10 ms·
Why Do We Play Video Games That Feel Like Work?
- brownbat 12y agoBecause in games accomplishment is often easier than in real life, maybe because it's more structured and well defined, maybe just because each accomplishment happens faster. We then probably get some kind of chemical hit from accomplishing things, which doesn't discriminate very well based on the importance of the thing we accomplished.
- drawkbox 12y agoExactly, it is a game version of 'work' and it is designed strictly for your enjoyment and tuned to the psychology that brings those rewards. Work in a game and real-life can be fun if you are accomplishing things and moving in a general progression direction with some success. In the real world, you can accomplish things and move sideways or backdrift based on many other factors than what you put in as work or capital, in other words, not as fun all the time and not really specifically tuned as a game design for fun.
- jsilence 12y agoYeah, in work games you can actually get some work done. Without all the administrative overhead and hassle. And also: No meetings.
- anigbrowl 12y agoExactly - the rewards are relatively assured. When I used to play Eve there was a lot of tedious work in terms of resource management and repetitive tasks like heading off to shoot pirates or whatever, but as you fulfilled your goals you got new toys to play with and more choices became available. In many real jobs you master some task and you *might get a pat on the back or a promotion, but you might just as easily get stuck with more of the same or have a bunch of extra demands laid on you - especially true in low-wage jobs, which tend to be the least rewarding/interesting ones.
- nether 12y agoDovetails with https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9492110 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9492110 Why do backbreaking labor outside when one can sit comfortably in a cool office staring at a screen? Because meaningful labor is invigorating, even in simulation.
- visakanv 12y agoYes. I have often surprised myself with how much I enjoy seemingly menial things like cleaning my windows and restringing my guitars, once I get over the initial pain of starting. Making a real difference to yourself, your living environment, your context, your peers, etc– can be incredibly rewarding. The equivalent at work would be when you can see a very clear relationship between your actions and the benefit your actions have on your customers and the rest of your team.
- ctdonath 12y agoFor many, we do what we do for work because it's what we would do anyway for free if we could. We get paid for that work because of all the irritating crap that is a real and largely unavoidable part of doing what we live to do for real. I love programming, and would do it for free if I could; what I get paid for is sitting here past midnight waiting for remote systems to validate an app submission while I try to get three packages to work well together when they inexplicably decide not to because an update to one suddenly has an aversion to seeing "#!" in another's file, and circumstances require I fix it right now regardless of the hour. We play "labor games" for fun because they are the idealistic of what we really want to do but without that irritating intrusion of reality.
- lmz 12y agohttp://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2015/may/05/is-being-addicted-football-manager-medical-condition http://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2015/may/05/is-bein... Maybe somewhat related.
- jaryd 12y agoThe DFW quote is from the following Harper's article: http://harpers.org/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/HarpersMagazine-1996-01-0007859.pdf http://harpers.org/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/HarpersMagazin... A vacation is a respite from unpleasantness, and since consciousness of death and decay are unpleasant, it may seem weird that the ultimate American fantasy vacation involves being plunked down in an enormous primordial stew of death and decay. But on a 7NC Luxury Cruise, we are skillfully enabled in the construction of various fantasies of triumph over just this death and decay. One way to 'triumph' is via the rigors of self-improvement (diet, exercise, cosmetic surgery, Franklin Quest time- management seminars), to which the crew's amphetaminic upkeep of the [ship] is an unsubtle analogue. But there's another way out, too: not titivation but titillation; not hard work but hard play.
- ffn 12y agoMaybe it's just me, but I find work to only suck when there is a long commute time and it's 2015 and our stupid company is still running Ruby 1.8 on rails 2.3, there is no automated testing, the javascript is an unreadable pile or .rjs mess, and literally every bug is some variant of "undefined is not a function" happening at run-time (for which I get yelled at). In other words, work sucks primarily because it has been made to suck by a combination of extremely expensive real-estate in a down-town office and inattention toward the subject of how to make work fun. The article calls this "the realities of work" and that the inherent difficulties and uncertainties are natural to the problems of the "real world" and must be accepted. But I beg to differ, there are tons of games that are extremely hard to play well (e.g. Sim City, Devil May Cry, etc.), yet still incredibly fun and addictive. And if you consider online games where interacting with other player can produce just as much uncertainty as real life, games are no less "real" than reality... yet they are fun while real work isn't. Personally, I think corporations can take a page from video game design and analyze their own employees work flows and design it to be a more fun process.
- asgard1024 12y ago> Maybe it's just me, but I find work to only suck when there is a long commute time and it's 2015 and our stupid company is still running Ruby 1.8 on rails 2.3, there is no automated testing, the javascript is an unreadable pile or .rjs mess, and literally every bug is some variant of "undefined is not a function" happening at run-time (for which I get yelled at). That's why you come home and program in a perfect world of Haskell (or some other toy), just like the farmer chooses the virtual farm over the real one. > The article calls this "the realities of work" and that the inherent difficulties and uncertainties are natural to the problems of the "real world" and must be accepted. In a certain sense, you're correct - the challenges to overcome in a game can have the same magnitude. In other sense, you're not. At the end of the day, game is still a game. Maybe it is the responsibility that you feel that makes the difference. In the real world, the stakes are higher; cannot that be the ultimate reason why the work sucks?
- lmm 12y ago> In the real world, the stakes are higher; cannot that be the ultimate reason why the work sucks? It could be, but I don't think it is. Doing something that's actually important feels awesome.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- barbs 12y agoI've recently noticed that roguelikes, more than any other kind of game I play, give me the most satisfaction and pleasure. In particular, games like FTL and Nethack promote decision-making and improvisation - making the most out of what the game throws at you, taking stock of what's available and trying to prepare for future encounters in creative ways. I find this parallels quite well with my day-to-day software development job, although playing these games remove a lot of the mundane tasks of actual employment (meetings, repetitive tasks, reliance on others, communication issues etc). Both of these involve solving varied problems in different ways, though. I concluded that I was simply doing what I enjoy, creative problem solving, and that I was just lucky enough to do what I intrinsically enjoyed for a living. I didn't think that my choice of leisure-activity was influenced by society's apparent changing view of free-time as "potential work time".
- mpdehaan2 12y agoAlso in the randomly-generated area (which i wish they would do a port to current consoles) was "Spelunky" - super challenging and randomly generated levels too. All being said, I miss the grand era of 80s/90s 2D greatly.
- barbs 12y agoYou can get that game on Playstation 4 at least https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spelunky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spelunky. That game looks amazing, but I've been waiting for a linux port. I don't think I'll be holding my breath though. If I get a Playstation 4 I'll instantly buy it.
- calibraxis 12y agoDoes the author assume everyone's aware of David Graeber Utopia of Rules? Because he didn't seem to cite Graeber, and yet clearly the arguments and style have obvious similarities. (http://boingboing.net/2015/02/02/david-graebers-the-utopia-of.html http://boingboing.net/2015/02/02/david-graebers-the-utopia-o...)
- saraid216 12y agoHe didn't cite http://theoryoffun.com/ http://theoryoffun.com/ either.
- calibraxis 12y agoThank you, don't recall seeing that before!
- getsat 12y agoMy vice is the Demon's Souls/Dark Souls games. As one Steam review put it: >hours of "WHY DID I BUY THIS GAME?" >seconds of "I AM A GOD"
- ribs 12y agoI'm several paragraphs in and there is no sign of deep insight. "In simulators, work is efficient, productive, and fun; it is goal oriented, quantifiable, and successful; the player can always win." No kidding. We're on the second page the story already. Time to tell me something I don't already know.
- dyates 12y agoJane McGonigal's book on gamification, Reality is Broken, includes quite a bit of detail about this similarity between work and games. The basic idea is that humans enjoy work if certain conditions are met, and games are designed to meet these conditions. She defines a game as having four elements: * Goals to be achieved that give the player a sense of purpose. * Rules that limit how the player can achieve said goals. * Feedback on the player's progress towards the goals the proves them to be attainable and motivates the player. * Voluntary participation by players aware of the rules and goals. And then the further argument is that we can make the world a better place and people happier in general by bringing all of these game-style elements into work and everyday life. It's an interesting read, if a little one-sided. On the flip side, the Black Mirror episode "Fifteen Million Credits" features a dystopia in which most people spend their entire lives generating electricity by peddling on stationary bicycles to earn credits they can use to outfit a virtual persona. Let's hope that's not the logical conclusion of Farmville!
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoYou say dystopia, I say a solution for obesity, :p
- jmcqk6 12y agoThe point made in that book that stuck with me ever since I first read it is this (I think she was quoting someone else): The opposite of play is not work; it's depression. I think the key thing people do wrong through, is to take work and try to make it more like play by adding in superficial 'game mechanics' like achievements. Visual Studio had this for a while, and it had things like "use the debugger 100 times" or something like that. This is not how you make work into play. Those achievements are meaningless. Worse, they could provide incentive for using visual studio poorly. For a really deep look at how games can be used to improve real world tasks, I recommend the works of [James Gee](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Paul_Gee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Paul_Gee).
- alanctgardner3 12y agoI'm pretty sure this is a rephrasing of a much older, well known principle in psychology (they cover it in undergrad), that work satisfaction is a function of: autonomy, feedback and variety. In other words: people want to control how they do work, and feel they have some flexibility. They want to recieve prompt feedback so they understand when they're doing well or badly. And they want to encounter a variety of challenges. Gamification is just building a tight feedback loop and providing sufficient variety. Autonomy is much harder to automate, because it seems to be the opposite of building an 'on-rails' experience guaranteed to please someone.
- mrxd 12y agoImplicit in all of this is a belief that true happiness is found in some kind of luxurious aristocratic passivity of nothing but rest, relaxation and comfort. That's great, if it suits you, but some of us need a bit more stimulation in life. The author also twists Adorno. Immediately before the quoted sentence ("the contraband of modes of behaviour proper in the domain of work… is being smuggled into the realm of free time"), Adorno says "free time must not resemble work in any way whatsoever, in order, presumably that one can work all the more effectively afterwards." Obviously work simulators try to very closely resemble work, and they don't try to hide this fact at all—no contraband smuggling here! That was written 50 years ago, maybe things have changed.
- whybroke 12y agoThe reward you get from a (well designed) game is both nearly immediate and directly related to the work you put into it. Additionally there is just enough randomness to create realism but critically not so much as to create the feeling of unfairness. Compensation from work is much more distantly related to performance. A salaried or hourly person gets the same pay per time period regardless of being more productive than average or not. Additionally that compensation is money which as at least one step removed from the actual reward. And sometimes that reward is using the money to buy time off which is apparently a contradiction and requires complex understanding to justify the whole point of work. Games don't have profound contradictions in this category. Also work compensation is sometime unfair paying inept or unproductive people who are good at office politics. Games obviously can't be unfair in this way. Sometimes the rewards are immensely remote such as retirement. Game rewards often occur within seconds or at most hours. Some rewards are just avoiding improbable miseries such as paying for an illness (if you have the misfortune to live in a society where this is a worry). Disasters in games are always no only unbelievable or impersonal but often humors eg minecraft's creeper or sim city's flood. No popular game has you grinding hard to save money just in case you become unemployable due to depression or cancer.
- parski 12y agoI think I have some degree of autism but I thought one of the most enjoyable parts of Shenmue was when you work as a forklift driver at the docks. Driving around moving crates was pretty zen and it got me thinking a lot. Very soothing.
- visakanv 12y agoThere are all sorts of real life "arrange things" tasks that can be really soothing, too. You may enjoy http://thingsorganizedneatly.tumblr.com/ http://thingsorganizedneatly.tumblr.com/
- emehrkay 12y agoThe reward were the after-work forklift races. Lol, spending that 15 minutes moving those crates from one place to another was torture. Good game though
- jokoon 12y agoI was talking to my psychiatrist recently. I was making the point that I can't manage to follow the rules I'm being given, that in general the rules of civilization are made up and don't make sense. She kinda made the argument that if I wanted to progress in life I could follow the rules (work to get this degree), and that it should stimulate me as much as diablo 3. It's true that in both cases, there are rules. Except I thought that life/society/civilization is not really a game. Maybe if you want to improve the economy, you can use bits of game theory to reduce the cost of regulation and corruption, but I doubt that it's sane to imply that all real life is like a game. Maybe I should try to play by the rules, but it would be very tempting to cheat, that's one reason to avoid playing, to avoid the temptation of playing. In video games the rules make sense, but in society it rarely does. Social stratification, social disintegration, my unemployment, etc. I don't think video games are much simpler, or that simplicity has something to do with it. But the rules never contradict themselves. There can be games with rules that are pretty complex too, and those games are much more interesting because there is a logic to it. Maybe an interesting game concept would be to make a game more realistic by introducing more contradictions inside it. Pollute the environment, increase poverty, deal drugs, corrupt politicians, etc, adding a "some people just like to see the world burn" aspect to it. GTA is already a little like that, except I don't see it going all the way through.
- asanagi 12y agoThe rules of real life don't contradict each other either. It's just that most of us were lied to when we were growing up. The way to the top involves scummy behavior: lying, cheating, and stealing. Bonus points for subjugating entire nations and cultures while you are at it. There is no such thing as sin and no such thing as justice.
- VLM 12y agoasanagi got flag killed, probably for too many "trigger words" but the idea, expressed, phrased somewhat more politely, is people will lie to gain control and power and one thing to lie about is the rules. (edited to add and the most important rule to lie about is that "nobody is taught lies about the rules") So the bigger and more complicated a culture is (you know, like ours?), the more likely the rules as taught are lies vs the rules as how the world actually works. So unsurprisingly following the rules as taught isn't going to work very well for everyone. The folks who want to maintain control can fight that little problem by all manner of social engineering. Let people vote, but only between irrelevant decisions never the important stuff. Guilt trips. Threats (see religion and eternal damnation for all heretics). Anecdotal examples in the place of actual societal trends (the token xyz in a group, etc). Good ole fashioned bread and circuses, ya see the baseball game last night and how bout that game of thrones episode?
- dba7dba 12y agoI just want to say any work can be more fun than playing fun video games, if you enjoy your work.
- visakanv 12y agoI agree. I find video games less compelling now than I did as a teenager primarily because my work feels a lot more interesting and engaging than school did.
- sakri 12y agoI'm gonna make a game where you are an unemployed single mother, doing job interviews and cutting coupons. I'm gonna be rich!
- tauchunfall 12y ago>a game where you are an unemployed single mother, doing job interviews and cutting coupons Sounds a bit like Melanie Emberly from the indie game "Cart Life" (2013). >A recent divorcee who had to quit her job at her office as a result. Now, Melanie runs a Coffee Hut. Her goal is to amass a sum of one thousand dollars in sales by custody hearing on Monday whilst taking care of her daughter, Laura.
- visakanv 12y agohttp://playspent.org/ http://playspent.org/
- laurentsabbah 12y agoThe beauty of psychology, behavior and game-mechanics!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- anodari 12y agoI saw a joke who says that the most real life game was tetris because as in real life, no matter how much we work, always comes a new task faster and faster until we die.
- technomancy 12y ago"Tetris is a life lesson: your mistakes pile up and your accomplishments disappear."
- RankingMember 12y agoWow. I knew the game was Russian, but that is _so_ Russian.
- acmd 12y agoBut why? Because of the Dostoevsky leitmotif?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- thewarrior 12y agoMy room mate plays DoTA for 6 - 7 hours a day AFTER work. Now that has to be tiring but he does it everyday. I'm amazed at this level of obsession and dedication. If we could figure out how to turn this on or off for learning to code or figuring out math then everyone could do wonders.
- Shivetya 12y agoaccomplishment. plus in many cases it simply gives many something to do. never underestimate the number of people who have nothing to do and need an outlet its not much work if your not bored anymore
- visakanv 12y ago> never underestimate the number of people who have nothing to do and need an outlet The interesting thing is that people always have an endless amount of things to do. The problem is that we're usually really VAGUE about what we need to do. And vague todos don't get done a little bit less, or a little bit slower– they don't get done at all! This is pretty counterintuitive. I have a bookshelf of unread books, and an endless list of work, but it's easier to play a game (or reply to a HN comment!) because the task at hand is much more straightforward. Type, hit reply, get the dopamine. With the books, or with work, I have to pick something, decide what I want to do, decisions, decisions, decisions. Great video games lay out the decisions for you in a very clear "jump this gap", "pick up that weapon", "shoot that guy" sorta way. Real life is messier, and so we procrastinate more. The feedback is less immediate and clear (unless we deliberately design it to be so.)
- imgabe 12y agoVideo games offer a certainty of outcome you can't get in the real world. If you do X and Y, you'll get reward Z. X and Y might be difficult or tedious to do, but you know that Z is there around the corner. Work often has situations where the outcome is much less certain. We have a problem we don't know how to solve so we need to try various possibilities. This can be fun if there is room for experimentation and we can try some things that fail without failing overall, but in situations with tight deadlines and uncertain outcomes, where you have a limited chance to attempt something and you don't know whether it will work, this is a recipe for stress.
- erikb 12y agoIs that strange to some people? For me it's not strange at all. I'd love to do my job, after work hours, as a game. The good thing about games is that it is clear who wants something from you (you can name the NPC who gave you the quest), the result is clear, sometimes even the path to the result is clear, and success is rewarded(!!!!). In contrast in real life it is hard to find out who actually wants the result you are just tasked to do, nobody knows how it should look like in the end and everybody has complains about the result no matter how it looks. That's why work feels like work and the same thing as a game feels good.
- anon4 12y ago- You can stop playing any time you want, but at work you're bound by standard hours. - You need to work to make money to buy food to eat. That introduces unavoidable stress into your work in the form that you know, if you don't work well enough, you'll get fired and then you'll starve. Or get your power cut. Or be kicked out of your house. - You can always start again, no matter how badly you mess up. In a lot of workplaces, if you mess up a couple of times, you're fired and you can't try again. In short, real work is less like Farming Simulator 2013 and more like nethack, but you only have one life.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- s_kilk 12y agoSearched for "Eve Online" on the article page... was disappointed.
- cjslep 12y agoI agree. Anyone that wants to peer into the equivalence of work with video games that does not peer into the culture Eve Online has developed is missing a core part of the research, in my opinion. There is the literal "spreadsheets online" part of the "gameplay". I used to be one of them. I literally spent hours pouring over resource numbers and timing, and that's not even touching the in-game market that has complexities of the same magnitude as the real-world market. Then there is the "millionaire-turned-retired" myth persistent throughout the in-game culture. It was cited as a ha-ha-only-serious joke for whoever seemed to dump a ton of money-for-ISK into the game, but if there is a kernel of truth in humor then that is something that could always be more fleshed out. Then, of course, the entire premise of the game is built on top of the simple mechanic "when you get blown up, you lose everything with you". Loss is very real and requires real work to keep and maintain your in-game status quo. Whether it is having good allies or finding a less-crowded corner of the universe. Very many missed opportunities indeed.
- dkersten 12y agoI love programming. I find it to be a fun and enjoyable activity. However, when I have to do something, sometimes its not fun, but then if, later, I do the exact same thing when I want to, its fun again. I think its the same thing with games - some games I play do feel like work, but I still enjoy them and I think the reason is because I choose to play when I want to. If I were told "you have to play this game now", then I'd probably hate it, but if I can decide for myself, then I enjoy it. Which games I would choose to play in a given moment depends on the mood I'm in.
- bottled_poe 12y agoI see two obvious reasons - freedom of choice and having a stake in the outcome. Video games give the player total control over the outcome within the rules of the system. In my experience, workplaces typically define too many constraints and give the player very limited power over the process and next to zero share in the outcome.
- dennisgorelik 12y agoGames are based on simplified models and train us to do useful work. So we like to play, because it improves our skills.
- jebblue 12y agoYou want work in a game? Try 7 days To Die. Clear a newly found town of 50 to 100 zombies so you can maybe find a can of dog food in one of the cupboards. That's work and it's fun and I have no idea why.
- visakanv 12y agoKilling zombies is always its own reward. :-) I guess they represent the perfect "Other", you can completely hate them and enjoy killing them without feeling any remorse or doubt.
- crimsonalucard 12y agoYou guys ever heard of desert bus? Actual game. Possibly the most realistic "work" game ever made. "The goal of Desert Bus was to, quite simply, drive a bus from Tucson, Arizona to Las Vegas, Nevada; a very very boring drive, as those of us who have done it know. There were a couple catches, though: in the game, your bus could not go over 45 miles per hour. Also, it veered to the right, just ever so slightly, so you could not simply tape down the accelerator button on your Genesis pad and leave the game alone; you had to man the wheel at all times. Oh, and did we mention the trip takes eight hours, in real time?" “You saw nothing. It was just desert stuff going by, And there was a little green tree hanging from the rear-view mirror, one of those things that makes your car smell better? And it would just kind of drift in slowly to one corner of the screen. And you couldn’t take your hands off the controller, and if you did…it didn’t have a spectacular crash, it just slowly went into the sand, and then overheated and stopped, and then the game was you being towed backwards all the way back to Tucson.” “And when you went from Tucson to Vegas and did the full 8 hours, you had bus stops, and the bus stops…you could stop and open the door, but no one got on. No one’s ever waiting for you. And if you went by them you weren’t punished at all, because nobody was there. It meant nothing. And a bug hit your windshield five times during the eight hours, and that was the only animation. It was just road after road after road. Eight hours of desert bus. And then when you got in - and I love this - when you got into Vegas and pulled in and stopped, the counter - which was five zeros - went to 1. You got 1 point for an eight hour shift, and then a guy came in and said, ‘Do you want to pull a double shift, Mac?’ And then you could drive back to Tucson for another eight hours for another point.”
- crimsonalucard 12y agoI think it's not that these games simulate work per say. These games mostly try to simulate accomplishment while offering a minimal amount of work. Desert Bus illustrates what happens when the accomplishment is 1 point, and the work is 8 hours.
- wildpeaks 12y agoDesert Bus is kind of an exception because it was intended as a joke from Penn & Teller, mocking the argument that games need to be realistic. But if you want to see people suffer through that game for a whole week 24h/24, come watch the yearly "Desert Bus for Hope" charity marathon in November: http://desertbus.org/about/ http://desertbus.org/about/ :-)
- jarradhope 12y agogoat simulator.