9 ms·
Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency
- junto 12y agoWas the police officer in the original story sued or prosecuted out of interest? Because he should be. I'd be so angry if one of my family members died because a cop thought he was a more qualified paramedic than a trained paramedic.
- tomjen3 12y agoFrankly I am flabgastered as to why the EMT in the story convinced the jury too. You don't go against medical advice. Arrest the guy in the hospital if need be.
- JeremyMorgan 12y agoI'm an EMS professional and am very fortunate to work in an area where the local culture prevents much of this from happening. While it's primarily rural, we do mutual aid in the larger nearby cities ( around 10-90k people in each) and the culture is the same there. The cops respect the opinions of the EMS and Fire professionals in every case I can remember, and at the same time we rely on them for safety and respect their opinion in that regard. This is still fantastic advice however.
- rmxt 12y agoI immediately thought..."you must work in Vermont, Oregon, or a blue part of the Midwest, or some place like that." Judging from your profile, looks like I was right. I wish this mentality and culture were more pervasive across the United States. EDIT: My point above was less about a specific "culture of respect for EMS workers", and more about a "culture of respect for non-law enforcement" in general that law enforcement does not always seem to have in the United States. Rethinking, it might not be the red/blue state divide as responders have pointed out. I still do think that there's a geographic component to law enforcement culture. I completely agree that urban areas, though a blue general population, regularly show instances of oppressive police culture. With the above, I was more trying to point out that in those areas there are generally less reports of oppressive and abusive police behavior. However, maybe the effect that I am trying to point out is an illusion of sample size. Either way, I think we would all be in a better place could we extrapolate the small-town police vibe to large urban areas. Yes, it's idealistic, but removing the adversarial relationship between big city PDs and their populations is something worth striving for. https://xkcd.com/1138/ https://xkcd.com/1138/
- JshWright 12y agoWhy would that be geographically variable? I'm a paramedic in New York, outside of stories that very occasionally hit the various EMS news sites (like this one), I have never heard of a cop questioning a paramedic's authority to do what's in the best interest of the patient.
- protomyth 12y ago"blue part of the Midwest" I'm in a red part of the Midwest and the cops I know (many friends from HS or cycling in as security at the local workplaces) know when an EMT says "transport", thats it. It helps that some of the EMT's are former cops, but they know the story.
- msandford 12y agoHilarious that rmxt thinks the police could only be professional in a liberal-leaning area. You know, like the extremely professional folks in Seattle PD, which is also in a blue city in a blue state. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_and_politics_of_Seattle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_and_politics_of_Seat... Oh wait, I was completely wrong about that. http://www.seattlepi.com/local/article/Feds-findings-in-Seattle-Police-abuse-2407378.php http://www.seattlepi.com/local/article/Feds-findings-in-Seat... That's not to say that all the people who work for Seattle PD are bad apples that need to be fired. But I'm sure a few of them are, if the whole department is getting investigated by the Justice Department.
- swdunlop 12y agoThat Seattle PI article is from 2011; so if the justice department is still investigating.. They need to hurry the hell up. Also, Washington is only a blue state because of Seattle. It would be a swing state at best. You can see the evidence in its state legislature, where it has been in a near state of paralysis for years trying to figure out a budget that will satisfy "starve the beast" conservatives and Seattle's infrastructure needs.
- rmxt 12y ago
- ericcumbee 12y agoI had always assumed that EMT/LEO was like Star Trek. Where the Captain might have final say in most matters, in regards to medical/health matters the Chief Medical Officer can override the Captain.
- JeremyMorgan 12y agoIn our area we have a medical director who oversees the entire county, and is surprisingly available for matters like this. If a problem like this were to reach him I am certain a local police department or even police chief wouldn't be able to override him.
- Domenic_S 12y agoWell... literally speaking police have the guns, so they can do whatever they want. That's the point. When minutes matter (like in the case of a stroke) I don't want cops & EMTs fighting with each other. Probably doubtful the police chief would want to get into a media brawl with the county medical director though.
- JshWright 12y agoIt's complicated... The ranking medical provider on scene is in charge of all aspects of patient care. That seems pretty simple, but then you have to consider the matter of consent... I can't do anything without the informed consent of the patient. When a patient is in police custody, suddenly the state has some say in what that patient can and can't consent to (and the cop is an agent of the state). However... I can't think of a conceivable scenario where a cop would want to assume the liability of disregarding my advice.
- jrs235 12y ago"I can't think of a conceivable scenario where a cop would want to assume the liability of disregarding my advice." What [personal] liability does a cop take on by disregarding your advice? It seems that cops have strong immunity to liability. It also seems that when a cop is found liable that the state/municipality pays the price. Perhaps if police [officers] had to be individually bonded and insured then at least "costly" police would lose their capacity to be officers through market means (insurance and bonding is no longer cost effective).
- JshWright 12y agoI'm a paramedic. The scenario described in the article is pretty rare... There are certainly various anecdotes to be shared, but this is not some systemic issue. Cops generally see EMS (and, by and large, Fire/Rescue) as being 'on the same team'. I have never once had a cop question my judgement... I would be completely flabbergasted if it ever happened.
- pragone 12y agoI was just going to say... in ten years on the streets, I don't think I've ever had an interaction like this. If anything, I'd say they are more likely to refuse to take a "suspect" and have us take him or her as a "patient", regardless of presence or absence of existing or suspected medical problems.
- ludicast 12y agoI agree. I'm a fireman with the FDNY and cops absolutely are on our side (and the same side as EMS as well). In the past 12 years there only was one time where I even witnessed tension between us and them (an elevator emergency with victims, where ESU (New York's SWAT equivalent) and FDNY had overlapping jurisdictions). The bench-clearing hockey game brawls are the stuff of TV. Cops are by and large professionals, who get shot in the face while protecting the same community that vilifies them for a few bad apples.
- Domenic_S 12y ago> vilifies them for a few bad apples. What is that saying about "a few bad apples" again?
- mikeash 12y agoFor those who are unfamiliar what this is referring to, the full saying is "A few bad apples spoils the bunch." This refers to the fact that overly ripe apples give off a chemical that speeds the ripening process of other apples, so a few bad apples among many good ones can destroy them all. The same thing can apply to people. The fact that there are bad police out there is only to be expected, just like you'd expect to find a few rotten apples in a large bunch of them. But just like the apples, you have to remove them, or the rot will spread. Bad police don't seem to get removed nearly often enough.
- tfigueroa 12y agoThat's a sad story, but a very interesting case I hadn't considered. The techniques are useful here in software, too: build a report, don't always go head-to-head, bring in an outside authority, etc. Technical types tend to approach things in technical ways that non-technical types cannot appreciate.
- tgokh 12y agoI volunteer in EMS and I've only once encountered a similar situation where the police officer disagreed with our judgment to transport a patient, but before I could even grab my medic, the cop got chewed out by his sergeant. I have run across a couple police officers wanting to clear lanes of traffic on the highway faster than we were comfortable with (when responding to a car accident), but our first responders (fire department, usually dispatched to most car accidents to provide initial medical care, extrication, scene protection etc) have always been good with maintaining scene safety.
- copsarebastards 12y ago> Police officers are trained to be aggressive, assertive, controlling, and correct in all situations. Well maybe this should change. I am a night owl and sometimes take walks at night. I don't drink, I'm completely sober. Nevertheless I've been stopped and patted down a few times. Once I was illegally searched because the officer "smelled weed" (I favor legalization, but I haven't smoked since college--I don't like how it makes me feel). And I'm a white guy in my late 20s who dresses like a businessy nerd--if I weren't who knows whether I'd be in jail for some made-up charge by now. Cops in the US have a combative relationship with the people they serve and that has to change. They work for us--we need to get them under control. Stopping medical professionals from doing their jobs puts the lives of civilians in danger. Cops should be required to defer to medical professionals unequivocally.
- cesarbs 12y agoMy wife and I have been in the US for 2.5 years and we had a surreal experience while taking a walk at night once. I must say, we were walking around late at night because we love being in a safe area were we can finally do that - back in our home country, we simply couldn't do that because of the absurd crime rate. So we're walking around downtown just enjoying a nice summer night, when a police car shows up in a corner. No big deal, it's actually nice to see them around. We walk a block and there's the police car again... and it was like that for basically every block we walked until we got home. Fortunately we were not stopped, but we were definitely being followed and watched. We come from Latin America but we're both white (German ancestry). I can't help but think the experience would likely have been a little worse if we had more typical Latino looks.
- sjtgraham 12y agoWhat was it about your experience that made you assume negative intent? Have you considered that maybe their presence had nothing to do with you, or perhaps couples had been targeted by robbers in the area that night and they were merely ensuring you didn't become another crime statistic? I dislike authority and cops more than most, but I also like evidence and I don't feel like this supports the implied harassment.
- larzang 12y agoA much larger and more frequent issue than police/emt conflict over the handling of medical emergencies is police being dispatched to medical emergencies as sole or first responders and handling it like... police. There have been dozens of cases in the past few years in which police have been sent to medical emergencies and responded with unwarranted and fatal violence towards the people they should have been helping. That's not even counting cases like Kenneth Chamberlain Sr, in which there was no emergency, officers were notified of this shortly after arriving, and they proceeded to assault and murder a man who had done nothing wrong in his own home anyway. Calling 911 for assistance for a mentally ill family member can literally be a death sentence, and that is an intolerable state of affairs.
- JshWright 12y agoI absolutely understand what you're saying, and this is not an attempt to justify the cases you've described. However... Attacks on EMS workers are also a real problem, and I am glad for the presence of law enforcement on the scene of my EMS calls on a very regular basis. It is also common practice for EMS to wait for police to arrive and 'secure' a scene if the nature of the call sounds like there is a chance the encounter could turn violent (or that we could be walking into an already violent encounter).
- copsarebastards 12y agoThat's absolutely a decision I would rather leave to EMS workers rather than cops.
- JshWright 12y agoIn most cases it's up to the dispatcher, or, more likely, the dispatching software (if the call meets XYZ criteria, dispatch police).
- ck2 12y ago> Police officers are trained to be aggressive, assertive, controlling, and correct in all situations No, not in all situations. When they see other cops doing clearly illegal things they don't do a damn thing. That needs to completely change.
- trhway 12y agogiven what they do in such situations involved people, it is no wonder when a police officer would not let owner to take his dog wounded by the police to the vet for an hour http://www.11alive.com/story/news/local/2014/07/25/police-shoot-dog-dekalb/13191011/ http://www.11alive.com/story/news/local/2014/07/25/police-sh...
- pXMzR2A 12y ago> After a long and complicated trial, the jury agreed that my client was not at fault. The client EMS is as much at fault as the police officer. He let someone whom he knew in his medical opinion to be having a serious medical problem go to jail because he was intimidated. If he's not at fault, no medic ever is at fault for anything, even those who are present and supervise torture and police brutality, because "oh I'm sorry I was intimidated."
- LordKano 12y agoThe police officer is 100% at fault here. The paramedic has medical equipment. The cop has weapons.
- pXMzR2A 12y ago> The police officer is 100% at fault here. The paramedic has medical equipment. The cop has weapons. This is not a zero-sum game. They can be (and, I think, are) 100% at fault. The paramedic has a medical responsibility to ensure the medical safety of the patient. He abandoned his job because he got afraid / didn't know better. These are not valid excuses.
- PebblesHD 12y agoYou talk like you'd have any chance at standing up to an _ARMED MAN_ when you have little other than a stethoscope. I doubt you've ever had any interaction with the police but I can assure you they are some of the least pleasant times of my life, and they can be _VERY_ intimidating, especially if you disagree with them. In this situation, the medic was opposing a trained, armed person who could not be convinced he was wrong, if he had not backed down the officer may have become violent endangering both the patient and the medic.
- LordKano 12y agoPrecisely. I suspect the previous commenter has never encountered such a police officer. I have seen how they behave when their authority is challenged. Right, wrong or otherwise; police officers won't admit to being wrong unless ordered to do so by a superior.
- andyl 12y agoI've worked EMS in lots of urban and rural areas. Have never experienced conflict between EMS and LE. Would not want provide EMS without Police involvement - the two roles go hand-in-hand.
- mpdehaan2 12y agoAll my interactions with law enforcement have been exceedingly positive and very polite (all in NC), modulo the local rural county where I grew up, where it was common for at least one of them to follow you driving home for 20 minutes home from school to see if you ever committed a traffic violation. I'm guessing that guy is retired now. Assuming the police are up to no good going into a situation will make things end badly, and creates a toxic culture. That being said, recent events make it clear that monitoring is a very good thing, and I think would be widely welcomed from both sides of the coin. I think it's fair to say there are bad apples, and I greatly support the body camera plan for dealing with it and making it possible to request review when someone thinks they are treated unfairly, and this also prevents them from being treated unfairly in false claims.
- CamperBob2 12y agoDon’t waste your breath telling them how much they don’t know or why they are wrong. Instead, calmly remind them of the liability they are inviting and accepting by not allowing you to do your job. What liability? We don't hold cops responsible for jack shit in America. Unless they are literally filmed in the act of murder, the worst consequence they'll ever see is a paid vacation.