11 ms·
The charging confuses me. Of course you pay to get gas at the pump, don't you pay to get electricity? I've always wondered that, seeing cars charge on the stre
by lucb1e 12y ago
The charging confuses me. Of course you pay to get gas at the pump, don't you pay to get electricity?
I've always wondered that, seeing cars charge on the street or in parking lots, how does the system know whom to charge... or is it government-sponsored to promote electric cars?
Edit: Relevant section
> The seller looked very puzzled at us and explained that it is not possible to refuel gasoline cars at home, and there are no free gas stations. We tried to explain our questions, in case he had misunderstood, but he insisted that you can not. Apparently you have to several times a month drive to the gas station to recharge your petrol car at extortionate prices – there are no alternatives!
Edit 2: I should clarify, I'm from the Netherlands (Europe).
- raverbashing 12y agoYou don't pay at Tesla stations
- lucb1e 12y agoI guess those must have a Tesla logo? I've never seen any of those (I live in the Netherlands). Edit: Those? http://www.teslamotors.com/supercharger http://www.teslamotors.com/supercharger I guess we don't have these, I would surely have recognized them.
- raverbashing 12y agohttp://www.teslamotors.com/supercharger http://www.teslamotors.com/supercharger Not sure if it's going to be in Europe
- toomuchtodo 12y agoIf you scroll down, and click Europe, you see that almost all of western europe is already awash in Superchargers, and Tesla continues to push east over the next 6-18 months.
- raverbashing 12y agoThanks, it shows the US for me in the map, and it can't be dragged
- toomuchtodo 12y agoEurope Superchargers: Today: https://i.imgur.com/229ZJIg.png https://i.imgur.com/229ZJIg.png By End Of 2015: https://i.imgur.com/p5D3K0w.png https://i.imgur.com/p5D3K0w.png 2016: https://i.imgur.com/0Q9nKzp.png https://i.imgur.com/0Q9nKzp.png Interactive Europe Map: http://www.teslamotors.com/findus#/bounds/65,55,34,-11?search=supercharger&name=europe http://www.teslamotors.com/findus#/bounds/65,55,34,-11?searc...
- jaxbot 12y agoThere's quite a few in Germany and the Netherlands, according to the map
- timoth 12y agoThe superchargers arrived in Norway almost 2 years ago: http://www.teslamotors.com/blog/tesla-motors-brings-revolutionary-supercharger-europe-launch-across-norway http://www.teslamotors.com/blog/tesla-motors-brings-revoluti... You see a lot of Teslas around in Norway, relatively speaking. The favourable tax (discount) helps I imagine, given the punitive tax on private IC vehicles.
- Navarr 12y agohttp://www.teslamotors.com/findus#/bounds/53.6756,7.227140500000019,50.7503837,3.3315999999999804,d?search=supercharger&name=netherlands http://www.teslamotors.com/findus#/bounds/53.6756,7.22714050...
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>You don't pay at Tesla stations Tesla is a money losing company and its cars and its own funding are subsidized by the US taxpayer. $108m in losses last quarter. Yeah, its neat they can pull this trick, but its meaningless as its clearly non-sustainable. Show me profitability, especially when they're off corporate welfare from my tax dollars. Why are the working poor and middle class families being taxed to make luxury $100,000 cars cheaper for the top 10%? I'm getting a little sick of paying for a rich person's tax break on a $100,000 car. The reality, regardless of hysterical fanboy HN downvotes, is that EV's make no economic sense for the average car buyer. The market is choosing against them for a reason, and not because everyone else in the world, but you the EV enthusiast, is ignorant. Personally, I think Lithium-Ion just isn't there from a cost/capacity perspective and will never get there. ICE alternatives are still forming and we'll probably look back at the crazy Tesla days the same way we look back at other oddball cars like the Delorean. Middle-aged millenials will be fixing them up in 20+ years and enjoying their kitschy value. Heck, even if we get cost down to ICE levels (and we wont) we still have major wear issues to worry about: The results of an Idaho National Laboratory study released in March found that the test LEAFs lost 22-26% of their initial capacity after just 40,000 miles. http://www.torquenews.com/2250/how-long-will-electric-vehicle-batteries-last-tesla-s-roadster-could-be-guide http://www.torquenews.com/2250/how-long-will-electric-vehicl... So on a hot day with the AC on, what am I getting in range from a $30,000+ EV with 40,000 miles? 30-40 miles maybe? There's a reason no one is buying these things. tldr; ICE will die someday, but it wont be lithium-ion that kills it.
- jaxbot 12y agoIf you look at their strategy, they're aiming to make profit around 2020 when the Gigafactory is at full capacity and the Model 3 is shipping at full capacity. At that point, the government subsidy expires for Tesla (100,000 cars shipped by one manu) and they make full profits on their own dime. If they were really unsustainable, nobody would be investing in TSLA right now. The tax subsidy applies to all electric cars, and has made the Leaf and other cars in its class affordable for many Americans, which has pushed electric car adoption. Even in the case of Tesla, there are plenty of people who couldn't afford a Tesla if it weren't for the $7,500 tax credit. It seems silly, but it's a big chunk of money, and when you're stretching your budget to afford a nice, eco-friendly and American-produced car, the extra subsidy really helps. Tesla is opening the door for sustainable transit in the U.S., has pushed other car manufacturers to follow suit, and is creating a buttload of jobs with their domestic factory, the Gigafactory 1, their local service centers, and whatever comes next. It is frustrating to see tax money thrown at corporations, but hey, Tesla didn't take a multi-billion dollar bailout when they made poor business decisions and were going to cost America millions of jobs. Just something to put this in perspective.
- cpwright 12y agoYou don't pay at Tesla stations, because you've prepaid for the supercharging option. They may have recently eliminated it as a separate ~$2,000 option with the introduction of the 70D, but that just means it is rolled into the price of the car.
- wyldfire 12y ago> that just means it is rolled into the price of the car. True. But if there were an option for all-you-can-eat fossil fuel, a lot of the market would probably consider it very seriously, especially if it were less than 5% of the cost of the car.
- axx 12y agoI can't answer your question, but i can tell you that engery prices will rise, if more people need more electricity to charge their cars. Electricity cost is so "low" because most cars don't need this type of Engery. To solve this issue people need to charge their cars at home with solar power.
- exelius 12y agoWell, if energy prices rise a bit, solar becomes much more attractive economically. So it's a feedback loop that solves itself.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoI don't have a link offhand (my apologies), but there is a DOE report floating around out there from 1-2 years ago stating that almost 80% of the current light vehicle (cars) fleet in the US could be converted over to using the electric grid solely with existing generating capacity. Combined with the relentless expansion of solar and wind in the US, I disagree with your assertion that energy prices will rise long-term. You'll probably see peaks and troughs as demand increases and supply comes online, but there is a lot of land left for renewables to be deployed to.
- jpitz 12y agoGenerating capacity isn't the only concern. Distribution capacity is another issue. Thankfully, the vast majority of the projected 30% increase in consumption will not coincide with summertime peak ( air conditioning ) loads, but it may be enough to worry some utilities, especially in the congested Northeast corridor of the US.
- lucb1e 12y agoWhy would the prices rise? We will consume more, and then we pay more, but why would the price per kWh change? In general things become cheaper to produce at scale (though I guess the current energy consumption is already at a big scale).
- mikeash 12y agoElectricity costs are low because electricity is inherently cheaper to generate and distribute than gasoline. Big, centralized power plants enjoy economies of scale that allow them to be much more efficient and operate more cheaply. They can also use fuels that are impractical for mobile use (basically all of them). Cars don't use gasoline because it's cheap, cars use gasoline because it's dense. If you don't need density then you can use much cheaper stuff, like coal, natural gas, uranium, sunlight, water trapped in a big lake, etc. If everybody switched to electric cars tomorrow, electricity use would go up about 30%. This is far from trivial, but it's not the sort of thing that would cause prices to spike. Answering the grandparent, payment varies. At home, you obviously just pay it in your electric bill. When charging away from home, some chargers are free. Businesses often put them in to attract customers, and Tesla operates a vast network of chargers whose operating costs are covered by car sales. (These chargers only work on Teslas, and electricity costs are low enough that they can afford to provide lifetime charging for their customers.) Some chargers are paid, and that's typically done with an RFID card (either a regular credit card with RFID, or a card specifically for the charging network) or a smartphone app.
- Navarr 12y agoThere are a number of places currently where the government will subsidize electricity used for cars. In Bowling Green, Ohio for example city parking lots have a couple electric car chargers that are free. Park your car & pay the meter (the parking isn't free!), plug it in, and walk downtown for some eatery. http://bgsujournalism.com/j4200/bowling-green-grows-fond-of-electric-charging-stations-city-monitors-usage/ http://bgsujournalism.com/j4200/bowling-green-grows-fond-of-... http://www.bgsu.edu/campus-sustainability/transportation/electric-vehicle-charging-stations.html http://www.bgsu.edu/campus-sustainability/transportation/ele...
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>There are a number of places currently where the government will subsidize electricity used for cars. So both the car and electricity are subsidized by hard working tax payers? Well, that can't last forever, so what's the REAL cost here? I think when we remove the welfare the cutsey "OMG GAS COSTS MONEY" argument will be dismissed as hyperbolic nonsense it truly is. I think the "electric is cheaper" argument is complete bunk without government welfare. The real cost of that giant Lithium-Ion battery and energy is non-trivial. Lets remember we're talking about a $100,000 Tesla here. That's not affordable by most. Not to mention, the money vs time cost. When I take a roadtrip or a long drive I can drive 300+miles, no issue, and refill in a couple minutes. With an electric I need to stop often and spend god knows how long getting a full charge, then go again. Imagine the costs here associated with long range trucking, delivery vehicles, etc. Or just time cut from my precious vacation time. Unless there's a massive breakthrough in battery cost, you're actually paying a lot more than an ICE car for day to day driving. Gasoline is so energy dense, so plentiful, and so easy to work with, its going to be VERY difficult getting off it. I pity the electric guys. They know its a uphill battle and lodging themselves into the luxury high end for economic survival is very telling. The "low" end is still a $35k+ car with quarter the range of the Tesla, which is terrible from pretty much any rational metric.
- icebraining 12y agoAll energy forms receive massive subsidies: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_subsidies#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_subsidies#United_States
- jaxbot 12y agoI think the biggest difference, speaking from my experience as a Leaf owner, is that electricity is much cheaper than petrol, more predictable in price/not as volatile as petrol prices, and the car itself is much more efficient than a gas car would be thanks to aerodynamics, regenerative braking and otherwise high efficiency in electric motors when compared to internal combustion engines.
- hn_ 12y agoCost to operate the vehicle (gas) isn't the whole story. How much do these vehicles cost to insure and is it comparable with a gas car at a similar price point? (Not being snarky, just curious)
- mikeash 12y agoInsurance costs are pretty comparable, yes, from what I've heard. (I won't try to talk about my personal experience, since a single data point is just about pointless when discussing insurance, but it's comparable for me too.) The big problem for Model S insurance is that the body is aluminum, which is a lot more expensive to repair, especially since Tesla wants to exercise a great deal of control over the whole process. This seems to be compensated for by the excellent safety, which reduces potential medical costs.
- danielweber 12y agoIf you can amortize the battery cost over the miles driven, electric cars ought to be cheaper than gas cars. Less maintenance (no spark plugs or oil changes), less consumables, and the purchase price is about the same (see my first phrase). If Better Place had worked out, it would have let people shift the battery ownership elsewhere. But it didn't.
- raverbashing 12y agoI'm not really sure about absolute price/J of energy comparison between electricity and gasoline However an electrical car is more efficient than a gasoline one (gas engines are inefficient, diesel not so much)
- lgbr 12y agoIn relative terms, charging an electric car from home is cheap. It is even negligible enough to where the companies that sell you electric cars will do so by comparing the purchase price of an electric car to the cost of a normal gasoline car plus the gasoline over the next several years. The charging stations on the street usually belong to a consortium with a membership card that unlocks the charging port or it may also belong to your local energy company. Subsidies may also apply to the energy supplied by them.
- danielweber 12y agoYes. When comparing electric cars to gasoline cars, just assume the electricity is free. The real money for the electric car is the depreciation of the battery pack. A penny or two per mile is a rounding error compared to that.
- sokoloff 12y agoI pay $0.21/kWh for electricity (electricity generation and distribution charges combined) and usually get between 3.0 and 3.6 miles/kWh (lower in winter; hope to be somewhat higher in summer). So, electricity is costing me 6-7 cents per mile before considering the inefficiencies of the charger, so likely 7-9 cents/mile at the meter. For a typical 12K miles/year driver, those costs are order of magnitude the same as the battery pack depletion (for my LEAF anyway).
- dghughes 12y agoYou could have a home distillery and use kitchen waste as the mash for the starter. Using kitchen waste to make fuel is so green not like those coal-fired electricty plants.
- engates 12y agoTesla pays for charging at any of their Tesla SuperCharger stations. So free to the Tesla owner.
- bradleyland 12y ago> Don't you pay to get electricity? That depends. For example, Tesla operates Supercharger (that's what they actually call them) stations where you can charge your car for free. There are other free options as well. However, most people will charge the car at home, so let's look at what it costs you to charge an electric car at home. I don't have this data for Europe, but I'm sure you can find it with some digging. In the US, the price of electricity is typically charged in kilowatt-hours (kWh), and varies based on your location. This table tells us the average cost per kWh by state: http://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.cfm?t=epmt_5_6_a http://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.cfm... I live in Florida, and in a market where the cost per kWh is particularly low. For off-peak times, I pay $0.09/kWh. While that's exciting for me, let's round-off the Florida average to $0.12/kWh and do some math with that. Some searching around on the internet tells me that a typical Tesla driver will get anywhere from 2.5 miles to 3.5 miles per kWh. Let's go with the median at a flat 3 miles/kWh. From here, most people jump straight to equating cost per kWh to miles per kWh, but charging is not 100% efficient. I found a reasonably well researched source [1] that puts efficiency at around 80%, which we'll factor in to the cost. Making some more assumptions, let's look at the cost to drive this theoretical electric car 12,000 miles per year: Calculate annual kWh: 12,000/3 (total miles/miles per kWh) => 4,000 kWh Factor in charging efficiency: 4,000/0.80 (annual kWh/charging efficiency): 5,000 kWh Calculate the cost of electricity at local rates: $0.12 x 5,000 kWh => $600 annually Monthly? $600/12 months => $50 Weekly? $600/52 weeks => $11.54 How does this compare to petrol powered cars? Calculate annual gallons of fuel: 12,000/30 (total miles/miles per gallon) => 400 gallons Calculate cost of petrol at local rates: $2.85 x 400 gallons => $1,140 Monthly? $1,140/12 => $95.00 Weekly? $1,140/52 => $21.92 So, do you pay? In most cases, yes. However, the monthly cost is lower by almost half. The value equation for electric cars is strongly dependent on the input factors. If you drive a lot more miles, or if you pay a lot more for petrol, your value equation changes significantly. I published this comparison as a Google Spreadsheet as well [2]. 1: http://www.teslarati.com/charging-tesla-model-s-cost-higher/ http://www.teslarati.com/charging-tesla-model-s-cost-higher/ 2: Published version: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15PbqSFB7ubis59AecCkVozfyh0s106eNCRLPjUAF22E/pubhtml https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15PbqSFB7ubis59AecCkV... Source (can be copied): https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15PbqSFB7ubis59AecCkVozfyh0s106eNCRLPjUAF22E/edit#gid=0 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15PbqSFB7ubis59AecCkV...