4 ms·
Hard call, but I think an occasional story related to politics may be ok if it is about some kind of major event that transcends politics-- just as a story abou
by pg 19y ago
Hard call, but I think an occasional story related to politics may be ok if it is about some kind of major event that transcends politics-- just as a story about technology might occasionally appear in a magazine about politics if it is an important enough story.
- run4yourlives 19y agoBut let's remember that Obama hasn't won anything. It's important when the US elects a president, or one dies, etc. Obama winning a primary is only important (outside of political circles) if a plane doesn't crash on the same day. I think every non-hacker story should be evaluated by the "plane crash beating" quality. :-)
- davidw 19y agoI would vote -1 on it too. There are 50 primaries and winners from both parties in each one, for a total of 100 victories. Sure, of course this one is more important, but still, you have to put it perspective (Bhutto's assassination wasn't mentioned here, for instance, and that was a pretty important event). I'm very wary of politics rearing their ugly head on this site. I'm sure we all have an interest and opinion in them, but I think that discussions about politics are only likely to damage this community.
- Tichy 19y agoI really don't care for news about crashing planes, unless they crash on my city. I hope to never read a plane crashing story on news.yc (which also implies I hope that there will never crash a plane on my city).
- run4yourlives 19y agoMy point is that a plane crash (killing hundreds) would be a top story around the world, even if it happened on the day Obama wins the Iowa primary, hence, Obama isn't plan crash important. If he won the presidency, that would possibly be plane crash important.
- Tichy 19y agoI suppose that win made top news in a lot of countries, though. It did in Germany, I know as much. The news item was actually interesting for me, because it was the first time I watched a video of Obama. Also, I think he is under special scrutiny, and his speech seems to refer a lot to that, doesn't it? At least I thought the "change" meant that there might be a black president of the US after all? Not trying to argue that it belongs on news.yc, but so far news.yc did a fine job filtering out the most interesting mainstream news (including the best xkcd cartoons, apparently).
- Zak 19y agoI agree, but this story doesn't transcend politics. The candidate who was leading in the polls in Iowa won Iowa. This is his victory speech, and its content is typical political victory speech content. The only thing remotely interesting here is the color of the candidate's skin, which shows we still have a problem with racism.
- mrtron 19y agoAh, so this is why YNews wants to avoid political points, the horrible comments. Obama's race is irrelevant, he is a very charismatic and thoughtful candidate. He seems to have the spark of greatness to him which I think is what makes this good enough to cross to hacker news. A lot of successful entrepreneurs also have great charisma.
- byrneseyeview 19y agoObama's race may be irrelevant to you, but it certainly mattered to him: he claims that his drug use was an effort to avoid thinking about race, he became a 'community organizer' working in low-income areas (in a neighborhood that is 97.8% black), his legal career focused on "community organizers, discrimination claims, and voting rights cases," and the subtitle of his autobiography is A Story of Race and Inheritance. If Obama matters to you, you'd better start thinking about his race, since it's been his obsession for decades. Edit: and don't forget his scary church: http://www.tucc.org/about.htm http://www.tucc.org/about.htm . It's as bad as Romney's church was thirty years ago.
- scooter53080 19y agoI think you have the makings of a good red state email forward .
- aswanson 19y agoDigressing, I'm not big on politics on this site either, but the mere idea of the absurdity of the last 8 years coming to a close is enough for me to be ok with this post.
- nickb 19y agoPolitics is so polarizing and so destructive for a community (since it involves hard divisions into camps) so I think that this is a wrong forum to consume and promote stories such as this. I do agree that political theory/philosophy articles are pertinent and good reads... if they offer some insight. But this video is blatant demagogy. Is that really worth wasting your time on? PS: This is exactly the type of stuff that caused reddit to degenerate so quickly.
- andreyf 19y agoPolitics is so polarizing and so destructive for a community That really depends on the community. I hate sounding un-democratic, but I sense there is a very clear division between people consumed by nationalism or screaming over rhetoric, and the people who want to understand the political process with the same motivation as understanding any complex system. I have a sense news.YC has much more of the latter.