6 ms·
Rules Change on I.R.S. Seizures, Too Late for Some
- mikerichards 12y agoThere's absolutely no accountability by the government. Nobody is ever prosecuted, reprimanded for these thefts from American citizens. These agency representatives (Lerner) have no fear of congress and thus the checks and balances that would typically be in effect are meaningless. Until these agencies have their budgets severely slashed (like someone would get a fine for breaking the law), there's no hope that these bureaucratic thugs will change their ways.
- jqm 12y agoA few criminal prosecutions for abuse of office and forfeiture of pensions would do even more. But you are right. Many government bureaucrats feel completely unaccountable to the populace, and this needs to change.
- fennecfoxen 12y ago"Your client needs to resolve this or litigate it," Mr. West wrote. "But publicity about it doesn’t help. It just ratchets up feelings in the agency." yep
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kabdib 12y ago"He [Steve West, a prosecutor] concluded with a settlement offer in which the government would keep half the money." How do these people sleep at night?
- 300bps 12y agoThey start out with the "guilty until proven innocent" maxim that civil forfeiture operates under and then convince themselves they're doing you a favor by taking all your money and returning half of it.
- loceng 12y agoAnd then your lawyer likely recommends you take the settlement.
- adventured 12y agoSome of them are simply crooks, using their positions for pre-planned theft: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/10/us/police-use-department-wish-list-when-deciding-which-assets-to-seize.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/10/us/police-use-department-w...
- a3n 12y agoThe war on drugs didn't work, so now they're trying the war on citizens.
- tomohawk 12y agoIt's too bad the president is only lukewarm at best on this issue, as shown by his nomination of Lynch. http://www.forbes.com/sites/georgeleef/2014/11/25/loretta-lynch-has-no-problem-with-civil-asset-forfeiture-and-thats-a-problem/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/georgeleef/2014/11/25/loretta-ly...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoIt really doesn't matter whether or not the President nominated Lynch. The sad reality is the Senate was too chickenshit to "just say no". In the President's defense, the USA has a long and sordid history of bad Attorney's General. I'm sure that Lynch is nowhere near the bottom of that list.
- imaginenore 12y agoI don't get why he can't simply sue the government. It's a decent sum of money, and it seems like a pretty easy case to win.
- adamnemecek 12y agoWatch this John Oliver segment https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEpZWGgJks&t=12m44s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEpZWGgJks&t=12m44s
- fennecfoxen 12y agoWell, he can try to sue, but it's complicated because the case isn't against him, it's a case against the money, and probably named something like "United States vs $107,702.66". He's a third-party claimant. If you're thinking that this sounds an awful lot like "guilty until proven innocent" then you can find loads of really fun reading over with our libertarian friends at http://reason.com/tags/asset-forfeiture http://reason.com/tags/asset-forfeiture where they've been raising alarms about the trend since 1989 (long before its abuse in places like Ferguson, MO made talking about it cool) Postscript: Oh, I think I was spot on about the name; thanks Google. https://www.docketalarm.com/cases/North_Carolina_Eastern_District_Court/7--14-cv-00295/United_States_of_America_v._$107702.66_in_U._S._Currency/ https://www.docketalarm.com/cases/North_Carolina_Eastern_Dis...
- jkestner 12y ago> It's a case against the money Not only are corporations people, money is people, my friend. This means that money has free speech, which probably has recursive implications for campaign fundraising. Seriously - has the idea of an object without will being named a defendant ever been challenged in the courts? Don't tell me that the person who owned the money has no standing - they certainly had property taken from them.
- jamestnz 12y ago> Seriously - has the idea of an object without will being named a defendant ever been challenged in the courts? Don't tell me that the person who owned the money has no standing - they certainly had property taken from them. Funnily enough, the idea of suing the property is actually a well-established legal concept, at least generally [1]. It falls under the "in rem" jurisdiction of the court, which is its power over things, as opposed to power over people (which would be the more familiar "in personam", where a person is named in a suit or complaint). Where in rem jurisdiction gets problematic is its use in civil forfeitures, for the reasons you say: The presumptive owner of the seized property is in fact readily available (i.e. the person it was seized from), and so any complaint should rightly proceed against them in personam, not against the property in rem. Also note that the money isn't being named as a "defendant" as such -- a defendant is a party you'd find in a criminal case, and this is a civil forfeiture. In a civil forfeiture, since the complaint is indeed against the property, the owner of the property is a third-party to the case. At this point the government pretends that the true owner of the property is unknown, so to fight the seizure it's first necessary for you to (a) legally assert ownership, and (b) legally deny the allegations in the seizure complaint. And only THEN can you proceed to the long and costly litigation against the government in which you must actually prove these assertions/denials. If things go well, some months or years later you'll get your stuff back. If you're really lucky, the legal costs won't have exceeded the value involved in the first place. Meanwhile, in many civil cash seizures, the money has gone straight into the slush fund of the local police department that confiscated it... and the whole thing starts to look like one big end-run around due process and constitutional protection. BTW, the government/courts also perform criminal forfeitures, which might be what you're thinking of where a confiscation involves a named defendant. For example, a punitive forfeiture doled out to a guilty defendant in a criminal trial. [1] The legendary case of United States v. Article Consisting of 50,000 Cardboard Boxes More or Less, Each Containing One Pair of Clacker Balls provides an amusing example of the way these suits are styled.
- jMyles 12y ago"...law enforcement agencies get to keep forfeiture proceeds. Such a windfall, critics say, creates perverse incentives..." 'Critics' say? Is there anybody who doesn't concur with this assessment? It seems like a flat, unambiguous fact. This toxic style of perspective hijacking is a huge part of the problem. It's always, "[government interest] says sky is green; critics say blue. The facts remain elusive."
- hellbanner 12y agoJust as bad are "officials say"..
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- phoxic 12y agoI agree. Your post reminded me of the welcome post for a new blog started by First Look Media that was apparently created "...to tell the unofficial story, one that describes the reality of U.S. politics as accurately as we possibly can." https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/04/16/welcome-unofficial-sources/ https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/04/16/welcome-unoffi...
- guelo 12y agoI'm sure there are law enforcement officers that disagree that there are perverse incentives. So the reporter has to quote somebody, he can't just state it as fact.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> So the reporter has to quote somebody, he can't just state it as fact. Why not? Its economics 101 [1]. Incentives matter, and the existing rules create "perverse incentives." Or are we talking about offending law enforcement and government agencies? Because fact and ego are two different things. [1] http://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/10_Principles_of_Economics http://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/10_Principles_of_Economics
- drawkbox 12y agoCivil forfeiture law is one of the most despicable aspects to our current system. The echoes to monarchy and state power greater than individual rights is too much. If you are in the US, this is exactly what smarter people before us crossed the ocean to get away from.
- discardorama 12y ago> Civil forfeiture law is one of the most despicable aspects to our current system. And yet, under Democratic and Republican presidents; under Democratic and Republican House control; and under Democratic and Republican Senate control, the policy persists. Why is that? How much power do these agencies have over the elected officials?
- hurin 12y agoOne thing I never understood -- and these articles don't appear to cover, is how laws enabling civil forfeiture were never struck down as unconstitutional in the first place. Isn't this an obvious disregard for the fourth amendment?
- pmorici 12y agoThe economics of disputing it don't work for the person who's assets were seized most of the time. Either the amount that was seized is relatively small and it would take several times that amount to battle the government over years. On the other hand say that clean out your whole bank account then you have no assets to fight them even if they took your life savings and it would make sense to fight them.
- rhino369 12y agoThe way it is portrayed here (I'm not sure if it is portrayed accurately), it is not constitutional. But civil forfeiture is definitely constitutional as long as you get due process. The NYTimes is wrong in stating you have the burden of proof in these cases, the government does. It's just not as high as a criminal case. The civil burden is the same that govern all sorts of property issues.
- seansmccullough 12y agoHow was this legal in the first place?
- adventured 12y agoIt wasn't, and arguably is not in any way constitutional. This became a thing mostly after 9/11. Terrorism and drug laws were significantly expanded in scope. For years the public was looking the other way - distracted by fear - while the government began openly breaking or bending the law, almost without any concerns. During that time, many behaviors became routine (with or without actual laws backing the behavior up) that have extremely questionable legal standing, and typically zero moral standing.
- rosser 12y agoAsset forfeiture rates were actually significantly down in the years immediately following the September 11th attacks. It wasn't until 2006 that annual forfeiture recoveries reached the rates they did during the 90s (at which point, yes, they increased sharply — nearly quadrupling in just two years). [1] As for the constitutionality of asset forfeiture, you'll have to take that up with SCotUS, who've (unfortunately) rather consistently disagreed with you. [1]: http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/Forfeiture http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/Forfeiture
- norikki 12y agohttp://reason.com/blog/2015/05/01/irs-steals-107000-from-convenience-store http://reason.com/blog/2015/05/01/irs-steals-107000-from-con... The above article doesn't leave out the fact that this seizure was initiated two months after the policy change. Looks like the policy has only changed on paper. It also doesn't fail to mention that the justification for the gag order was to prevent tipping off the suspect, but it has already been established that McLellan committed no crime, so its explicitly being used to keep this from the public's attention. It's unfortunate that NYT is so bad at reporting the relevant facts.
- ScottBurson 12y ago“Your client needs to resolve this or litigate it,” [prosecutor Steve] West wrote. “But publicity about it doesn’t help. It just ratchets up feelings in the agency.” My jaw dropped when I read this. Dear Mr. West: your job isn't about your feelings. And it certainly isn't about your need to be right or your refusal to admit a mistake. You need to grow up -- and I also think you need a new job.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> and I also think you need a new job. How do I, as a citizen, convince my representative(s) to pursue Mr. West (and the case in question) for investigation?
- mentat 12y agoYes, this struck me too. I really don't care about "feelings" at the agency nor should he. His job should be to approach justice. If it's not, get the bum out.
- mattdeboard 12y agoYeah I was about to quote & comment on that same part. Who cares about your stupid feelings? This is a legal case, that's not how it's supposed to work.
- discardorama 12y agoWell, the fact that feelings are being hurt means that it's not purely a legal case.
- ams6110 12y agoI don't defend asset forfeiture for simply making large cash deposits, but on the other hand there is no way a guy selling sandwiches for $2.75 is taking in more than $10,000/day in cash. We aren't getting the full story here. Making a daily bank deposit is not "structuring" it's a common (and a best) practice. So if he was accumulating cash for a week or more and making large deposits, he was being stupid. Not that it justifies forfeiture, if that's all it was. But something isn't making sense here.
- pmorici 12y agoThat's the point. The guy _didn't_ make more than $10k in cash /day. His deposits each day were for less than $10k they said that because of that he was trying to evade the 10k reporting limit since he made regular deposits under the limit. ie: they are claiming if you made a daily deposit of say $3,000 that is suspicious and are seizing your money for structuring.
- ams6110 12y agoStill not buying. Every fast food restaurant makes at least one, if not several <$5,000 deposits every day of the week. It's completely normal for that type of business. He got flagged for some other reason that is not being disclosed.
- function_seven 12y agoWell for some truly bizarre reason, the government is keeping that "other reason" a secret, and not charging them with anything at all. That is not something the government should ever be allowed to do, at all, under any circumstance.
- appleflaxen 12y ago> But something isn't making sense here. So maybe the government should prove it. Like beyond a reasonable doubt or something.
- rosser 12y ago
- jkestner 12y ago"Don’t bother with jewelry (too hard to dispose of) and computers (“everybody’s got one already”), the experts counseled. Do go after flat screen TVs, cash and cars. Especially nice cars." Ugh. This language sounds similar to the language thieves use in hitting homes.
- Everlag 12y agoThis is the language being used by thieves to hit homes; these are just lawful thieves.
- fiatmoney 12y ago"the prosecutor on the case, Steve West, was unmoved. Notified of the hearing by Mr. McLellan’s lawyer at the time, he responded with concern that the seizure warrant in the case, filed under seal but later given to Mr. McLellan, had been handed over to a congressional committee... 'Your client needs to resolve this or litigate it,' Mr. West wrote. 'But publicity about it doesn’t help. It just ratchets up feelings in the agency.'" That's pretty breathtaking. He's admitting that complaining to one's elected representatives in government about what is admitted to be an abuse of government power will result in those agents retaliating against you. So shut up and pay us, peasant.