5 ms·
I imagine other people are like me and are curious about the actual usage numbers for Diaspora, so I will share the results of my 30 seconds of research on Goog
by slg 12y ago
I imagine other people are like me and are curious about the actual usage numbers for Diaspora, so I will share the results of my 30 seconds of research on Google. Although I have no idea how accurate these numbers are as the decentralized design of Diaspora makes it hard to capture everything.
Rough estimates look to be about 1.2 million accounts with 81,550 active in the last 6 months and 20,207 active in the last month. There have been a little under 4 million total posts. [1] For sake of comparison, it takes Twitter roughly 10 minutes to accumulate that many Tweets.
[1] - http://pods.jasonrobinson.me/ http://pods.jasonrobinson.me/
- unicornporn 12y agoI'm not sure size is always an advantage when it comes to communities. There's always a certain vibe to places with limited users that I'm really hooked too. Generally, I think we should give up the idea of gathering everyone at a single point/protocol (federated or not). People will always chose different ways to communicate. But the ones that really matters will, eventually, be were you are.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoAren't we already gathered at IP?
- glesica 12y agoI agree. I think the interesting next step would be to ask if there are any communities that have adopted Diaspora heavily. Anecdotes from anyone whose social group uses it regularly would also be interesting.
- hngiszmo 12y agoA good product should support small and large groups and being a part of a small group can be valuable but I disagree that you can coin the adoption numbers of diaspora in any sense as a success. Diaspora might be a success on the software side and might maybe even be successful with users in the future, but for now it has not 1% of the value of facebook or even G+ to society in large.
- eellpp 12y ago> For sake of comparison, it takes Twitter roughly 10 minutes to accumulate that many Tweets. That is not a fair comparison at all. You could as well compare twitter to number of google queries (or number of some other number that dwarfs it). It should also not be compared against early stage of facebook as well (a private enterprise with slush funds for marketing , pr, buzz and developers). May be compare it against the early stage of popular GNU tools or other free/open source community projects that are dealing with tough problems to crack. Given the nature of problem involved, diaspora may be the first step to the next few steps in realising the goal of distributed social network. It needs to be pursued to that end.
- dredmorbius 12y agoIt's more than fair. Diaspora's been up and active for years -- it launched in November, 2010. Let's say that a Tweet conveys only 1/1000th the meaning or significance of a Diaspora post. You're still looking at the fact that the lifetime volume of Diaspora is a week's worth of Twitter traffic. I'm on Diaspora. Been there for years. Hardly use it, for a number of reasons -- chief among them that there's very little of interest for me there, no search, and I keep seeing content from idiots I'd really prefer not to deal with. I've got enough noise in my life. I'm also active on Ello, which, similarly, has quite a small (though enthusiastic) community. And G+.One criticism which applies equally well to each of these networks is that it's insanity to go up against Facebook on the social graph. Facebook owns that graph, to the tune of 2.5 billion people, a large portion of whom are monthly actives. Google has 2.2 billion profiles but cannot convince more than 0.27% to participate with public posts monthly. Now, a fraction of a percent of 2.2 billion is still a large number, about 6 million users. But it's a small fraction of Facebook's activity. The alternative is to pursue the interest graph. That's effectively what HN does (startups / tech interests), reddit (multiple subreddits), Pinterest (it's in the name), etc. See Michel E. Pearl's critique of Ello: https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/s-IsrNuI5ODCJqnUJ8KoEA https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/s-IsrNuI5ODCJqnUJ8KoEA Another is to consider social networking from the "problems solved" perspective. A shockingly large part of that is : 1. Where can I post my photos online? Kids love this, yes, but parents and grandparents even more. 2. How can I post updates and content online. Effectively microblogging. Sometimes more than micro. 3. Spam and access controls. Not everything I post need be commented on by everyone, or even be visible to them. From the ground up, HTML and HTTP make all of this difficult, and tools for mitigating spam, trolls, cross-scripting attacks, and other abuse are actually an underappreciated aspect of centrally-provided services. 4. Promotion. I recently discovered that there's actually a tremendous amount of activity and discussion on Wordpress, as compared to G+, Facebook, or reddit. But it's hard to get engagement on blogs. If blogs can sort out how to provide content recommendations and engagement, and the authentication / reputation issue for comments, they'll take away much of the benefit of social networking sites.