13 ms·
Peak car
- jgrahamc 12y agoI'm part of this phenomenon. I don't own a car but instead cycle to work, use public transport a lot, taxis, and, on the rare occasions I need to drive myself, Zipcar. There are a lot of things I like about Zipcar but I'll point out two that are not directly economic: I don't need to worry about the car once I've finished with it (a real concern in a big city with vandalism, theft) and I can rent different size cars (5 seater for normal times, 7 seater if I have lots of guests).
- mod 12y agoI'm part of it, not because I don't own a car, but rather because I drive it very little. I work from home and I'm a bit of a recluse--but even those places I do travel with any frequency are all within probably 3 miles. I think I probably average about 20 miles per week.
- more_original 12y agoI live in Europe and have never even considered getting a car. In cities the bike is the fastest mode of transport anyway, and for longer distances it's quite convenient to take the train.
- pkorzeniewski 12y agoI live in Europe and I can't imagine not owning a car. My city has quite good public transportation, but the flexbility and independence of car wins all the time. Using bus+train it takes me 1h to get to work one way, while by car it takes me 15m, additionally I do grocery shopping and other things on the way home. Time saving isn't however the major reason, but the feeling that I can go whenever I want, wherever I want.
- more_original 12y agoFair enough. What you describe sounds much like I feel about bikes. Taking the bus and train to work takes over 30 minutes, while the bike ride is just 10 minutes. Going by car would certainly take more than 10 minutes here. Someone once said to me that he feels amputated without a bike, which really hits the nail on the head.
- atirip 12y agoI live in Europe and i own a car, but don't use it to commute. It takes 10 minutes by bus and 15+ by car. Plus it takes min 10 EUR a day to park my car in the city. And the bus is free.
- barrkel 12y agoIt's hard to beat a motorcycle over longer city distances, however. IMO a scooter is the best city transportation. I can pretty much get anywhere from anywhere in London in under 30 minutes. My commute from Victoria Park to Clerkenwell is 13 minutes. Google suggests 20 minutes to cycle; I reckon an athlete who ignored red lights could just about keep up, but they'd be sprinting in between the places they'd have to give way.
- lancewiggs 12y agoElectric bikes make that sprinting easy - so easy it feels like walking. I walk, (e)bike, motorbike and drive my car. Short trips are almost all bike now, car is for transport of large things and motorbike for longer trips.
- peatmoss 12y agoAs an urban planner (well, PhD student now), the utility of electric bikes strikes me as obscenely high. We know that the vast majority of urban trips are < 3 miles--with a goodly portion under 1. Yet, so many people make these trips by car. A bike is very much more efficient, and often much faster if there is any congestion. Electric bikes remove one major barrier people have, namely the arrive sweaty after a hill climb factor. I hear other bicyclists claim that this is less karmic because of exercise, but I view it differently. We know that, controlling for type of infrastructure, the prevalence of bicycling is strongly correlated with improved safety. The plausible explanation I subscribe to is that, with increased numbers, drivers are more accustomed to looking for bicyclists, and that bicyclists are better able to establish good group norms about how to ride safely. And of course increased numbers also mean that there is more political will to add more bicycling infrastructure, which in turn generates more bicycling. Electric assist bikes help with all aspects of this, with the exception of getting the maximum amount of exercise on every trip. I'd love to see a business model that figures out how to 1. create a desirable electric bike brand 2. Have a low-barrier-to-entry rental or lease mode 3. Handles maintenance in a frictionless, reassuring way--perhaps with roadside emergency support 4. Has great on boarding for how to ride safely and confidently, perhaps coordinating with local bike clubs for instruction and personalized route planning.
- nawitus 12y agoI live in Europe and while I can get around without a car, owning a car improves my standard of living quite a lot. I guess the point is "I live in Europe" says nothing about how easy it's to get by without owning a car.
- more_original 12y agoYes, that was poorly worded. Europe is big. I meant to say that there are places (specifically in Europe), where it's perfectly possible to go through one's whole life without a owning car and without missing out.
- jmspring 12y agoMy in-laws live in a village a bit outside Nuremberg. In the 11+ years visiting them on a regular basis, I've seen the closing of small markets in favor of US style supermarkets. These stores are often further outside the town/city center. What was walkable becomes less so. I've seen a similar trend where my brother-in-law lives outside Munich as well as some other towns where friends are. For things like commuting, the train can make some sense, but for short trips to a market that is no longer walkable? A car may be more desirable.
- kleiba 12y agoI used to be part of this phenomenon. First, I lived in the city center where owning/using a car is just a drag. Then I moved to the suburbs and still resisted buying one as a matter of principle. But a little less than two years ago, I made the transition and now I happily own a car. The reason? 1) Public transport in my city sucks. 2) The shopping infrastructure has moved out of the center of my community to the edges. And it's not like I didn't try. As I said above, for quite a number of years I refused to use a car even after I moved out of the city center because I was convinced that individual car usage just isn't sustainable. But as I get older, I feel my spare time becoming more and more valuable. And in my particular case, going to and from work takes >1h each way, while with the car it's a good 20 minutes drive, saving me about 1h20 per day. This is because my work is in another suburb which by public transport you can only get to by first going into the city center and then out again. With the car, you can circumvent the city completely. (Unfortunately, the part of town where my work is is not a very nice place to live, or else I could probably bike.) The second part is shopping. When I was younger, I would just walk to the next store and buy the few items I would need that day. But I was single back then. Now, there aren't any stores in walking distance any more, but my partner and I also require more stuff than when I lived alone. I still believe it's a bad idea that every household owns more than one car on average. And I've always wondered: of all of the privately owned cars in this country, how many are actually moving at any given point in versus how many are parked? But I have kind of given up hope that broad acceptance of public transport would become the norm "automatically", simply because people should realize that individual traffic is unsustainable. Now I think the only way this will ever become a reality is through force -- namely, governmental regulation. Of course, this is not on anybody's agenda at this point (anybody in power, I mean) and will not be in any foreseeable time. I don't believe individual car use will experience a measurable reduction in my life time, sadly.
- johansch 12y ago> how many are actually moving at any given point in versus how many are parked? Doesn't most (like >80% in normal usage) of the depreciation cost incur while the car is moving, as opposed to being parked?
- deleted 12y ago
- djthorpe 12y agoI fear we are part of a small self-selecting group that has chosen the convenience to living in densely populated, well connected cities and are relatively well-off. I doubt you'll hear a lot about "peak car" outside these small groups or areas. For many, I suspect the car represents a great deal of freedom in exactly the same way that not owning a car means to this self-selecting group: making a decent living, access and comfort, etc. The real aim to force the decline of car use is sustainability, efficiency and equality. It's not going to happen without huge investments and will affect the whole economy negatively for decades, which is why Governments shy away from doing anything very serious about it. In the meantime, I'm also happy to not own a car, cycle to work, etc. But if I lived outside central London I would get one immediately.
- more_original 12y agoYou're absolutely right. I understand "peak car" as trying to get away from unreasonable car use. Like in the US where one has to use a car for trips that one could easily walk, if only there were sidewalks.
- lotharbot 12y agoI think one of the major causes of "peak car" is that, as cars become saturated, alternatives begin to come online as cities try to relieve pressure -- and once those alternatives (sidewalks, public transportation, bike lanes, etc.) have a critical mass of users, they enter the public consciousness as acceptable alternatives, and they begin to have more resources poured into them. When your area gets adequate sidewalks, you can get away from unreasonable car use, and your use of the new sidewalks encourages more sidewalk construction, etc.
- more_original 12y agoI think you're right that this is a factor. What it doesn't quite explain is the decline of car usage in European cities that have always had sidewalks and good public transportation and where cycling isn't much easier now than it was 30 years ago. There seems to be a cultural change in attitude too. Cars are not as cool anymore as they used to be.
- tomjen3 12y agoI am soon going to be out of this - I have more money now and while a car isn't required for daily transportation I have family outside the city that I want to be able to visit more often and moving larger purchases in a bus is a real pita.
- edw519 12y agoMe too. 1972 to 2014: 1 million miles driven. 2015: 0. Separately, my bicycle & public transport are poor alternatives. But combined, they are incredible. With my bike & a metro pass, I can get anywhere, sometimes more quickly than with a private car. And now I never worry about: going to the gym, car payments, insurance, maintenance, gas, parking, and most of all, other drivers on their cell phones.
- manmal 12y agoNo gym because you cycle, or because it's easy?
- gerad 12y agoYou should definitely worry about other drivers on their cell phones if you're on a bike. If another driver hits you while you're driving, it damages the car. If that driver hits you while you're biking, it damages you. I'm fortunate enough to be able to walk to work, and never drive, but also stopped biking because it is so dangerous. Not only do you need to be doubly wary of other drivers, you need to watch for people getting out of parked cars, other cyclists, and pedestrians only paying attention to their phones.
- lkbm 12y agoThing is, I should probably be most worried about heart disease, but because I bike to and from work, that's not a major risk factor for me. Traffic injuries/fatalities are more likely if you bike, cariovascular disease is less likely if you bike. I suspect my overall annual risk of mortality drops when I make the trade-off, as my bike commute isn't along any particularly dangerous roads.
- Zarel 12y agoAt least MMM agrees that your overall mortality risk drops when biking: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/06/13/bicycling-the-safest-form-of-transportation/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/06/13/bicycling-the-safe...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Aqwis 12y ago>The theory is disputed by the UK Department for Transport, which predicts that road traffic in the United Kingdom will grow by 50% over the coming 25 years Any insight as to why they would predict this if road traffic empirically has been flat since the nineties?
- fredley 12y agoBecause their budget is dependent on their own forecast of road traffic?
- arethuza 12y agoWorth noting that this is the same Department for Transport that is surprisingly keen on high speed rail links like HS2. [I'm in Scotland where good old low speed rail seems to having a resurgence the new (re-opened) line from Edinburgh down to the Borders looks fantastic - I'm kicking myself for not buying a house in Heriot a few years back].
- justincormack 12y agoNot as simple as that I don't think. Despite figures about decline in road traffic, there is a big division between London, where the traffic decline has been most (indeed, Wikipedia provides no ex-London numbers) and the rest of the country, where public transport is much worse. For example half the bus journeys in England took place in London. The UK currently buys more new cars than anywhere else in Europe as well, partly due to credit availability, but clearly there is demand, and there is a huge pro road pro motorist lobby, as is clear when fuel taxes are increased. So I think the DoT have ended up reflecting largely this pro car part of the UK.
- kjjw 12y agoI buy new cars in the uk using credit but don't drive them much. My baseline miles per week is 0. Occasionally we use our car at the weekend. Still, I buy a brand new expensive car every few years. I guess I just old enough to.be effected by the idea of the car as a status symbol, but young enough to be caught up in urbanism.
- Theodores 12y agoAlmost everyone gets a car when they have children, in the UK it is considered a necessity. However not so many people are starting families when compared to former times, they are starting later too. What this means is fewer purchases of family cars and all those journeys to shops and schools. We are also creatures of habit so we stick to the transport we know. What happens when previous generations literally clog up all the roads with their cars so there is no room for the cars that a new generation would potentially own? I think that this has happened, owning a car would be impossible in many parts of most city or town centres. If not actually impossible, just very expensive or a lot of hassle when it comes to parking. Why go through all of that when you can just hop on buses and trains, to catch up with games/reading/emails on the phone/tablet? Once you have a generation that have settled in to using public transport or cycling the barrier to entry for motoring is quite high and there is no peer pressure or real benefit to having a car - unless a family comes along. Whilst pockets of 'peak car' may exist in cities realising that the car is totally impracticable, there will be growth in more pointless journeys between pointless places beyond the realms of suburbia. Outside the cities there is universal belief that you have to learn to drive as soon as possible, getting a job would be impossible without an ability to drive there. Hence inexorable growth, a long way to 'peak car'.
- arethuza 12y agoHowever, this is about car use rather than car ownership - I agree that owning a car is still regarded as normal for parents but I see a lot of people, including my own family, behaving in ways that reduces the amount we drive. There are a lot of factors in this including improving public transport (e.g. I rather like the trams here in Edinburgh even though the project to install them was a fiasco), greater use of cycles - including people taking young kids on bikes, very strict new drink driving laws here in Scotland, reduction of parking spaces in city centers, park and ride schemes round cities etc.
- baking 12y agoThis is based on old data, but when I was working in energy consulting the number of miles driven per registered vehicle did not change much from year to year except when there were supply disruptions. Also, miles driven was an estimate based on hard numbers like the number of registered vehicles so not a great indicator. Here is some recent info on US vehicle registration: http://usa.streetsblog.org/2013/06/21/has-america-already-hit-peak-car/ http://usa.streetsblog.org/2013/06/21/has-america-already-hi...
- kristopolous 12y agoHow does this theory affect the BRICS? (edit: The atlantic has an opinion here: http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/10/the-rich-worlds-peak-car-moment-car-sharing-carpooling-car-ignoring/263086/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/10/the-rich...)
- bornabox 12y agoIn Brasil, the nascent middle class consumes cares. It's a status symbol and a dream for many. It's a different culture. In the big cities (São Paulo, Rio, etc) the public transportation is miserable. Buses and Metro are overcrowded and Metro doesn't have a good penetration. So, no, in Brasil at least, no Peak-Car for quite some time.
- galfarragem 12y agoAs long as we have suburbs we cannot erradicate cars: suburbs lifestyle imply that we use cars. So the decline of cars proves the decline of suburbs. Thank god.
- Gorkys 12y agoNot necessarily - in America yes that is the way things work at the moment, but not all over the world. There are may suburbs with good public transport where having a car is less necessary.
- galfarragem 12y agoIt's very difficult to have sustainable/economical public transportation with the population density existent in the suburbs.
- mediascreen 12y agoThere are lots of high population density suburbs outside the United States. Two examples: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banlieue http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banlieue http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Million_Programme http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Million_Programme
- netcan 12y agoIt's not necessarily impossible. Some big Australian cities work reasonably well with 'cars optional' suburb. They have an overall feel and lifestyle that I imagine would be familiar and comfortable enough for most American suburb dwellers. For a quick and dirty snapshot: Suburbs are considered similar to small 'urban towns.' They typically have a train station (some Sydney suburbs have cool ferry stations) at the centres and the suburb stretches for a 1-2 mile radius from there. They are usually denser and have a more town center feel near the center. Inner city suburbs feel more urban. The really distant suburbs are more car centric and often have a semi-rural feel. Suburbs on the Dandenong foothills in Melbourne are a cool example of this. Basically the nearer the city centre and suburb centre you live, the less cars are necessary or convenient. It's not extreme though. Most people have cars everywhere but the level of use varies. I would estimate that >50% live someplace where car free living is possible without too many trade offs. Realistically though, the way to prevent cars is to make them unaffordable. That's an option, but I don't think you can call it a victory for quality of life by itself if it's achieved by making something people want unaffordable.
- ychantit 12y agoI think the peak is happening because it's a lot more expensive to own a car and people prefer to share or borrow one when they really need it. For instance parking ticket has skyrocket by 300% this year in paris, fr ! You don't want to have a car parked there ... http://www.metronews.fr/paris/stationnement-a-paris-les-tarifs-explosent-pour-les-riverains/mnln!baMJWQiXCTmws/ http://www.metronews.fr/paris/stationnement-a-paris-les-tari...
- oflordal 12y agoI have been thinking this will change as self driving cars becomes more prevalent. Commuting by car is very inefficient since all the time spent driving is wasted (compared to public transport were you can potentially work on the way to work, or cycling/walking were you get exercise). Self driving cars that are sufficiently good to handle the commute most days would change this and allow you to live further away from work in places that lack public transportation.
- davidiach 12y agoYou can listen to audiobooks/news etc. while you drive. I do it all the time.
- Toenex 12y agoIf you own a car today it spends most of it's life sat there waiting for you. Not so the self drive car which can be off doing errands - picking up those Amazon deliveries for instance - or working as a taxi for someone like Uber and making you some money by providing the individual, door to door, on demand public transport we want. This is gong to have a significant impact on how many of us own a vehicle I would imagine.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- peatmoss 12y agoWe still have geometric problems with everyone driving. Namely, cars take up space in two or three useful dimensions on roadways that are fixed in length, and have limited capacity to grow wider or higher. In short, self-driving cars won't handle peak demand and the accompanying congestion. Where I am more excited about self driving cars is in their potential to change vehicle ownership economics in slightly denser areas. A car2go that delivers itself makes it pretty hard to justify buying an expensive capital asset that sits idle an average of 95% of the time. In other words, a rental service that is able to utilize its vehicle fleet more fully, should be able to make a handy profit while reducing travel costs for many people. The opportunity frontier is enormous here. Once more people switch to user-fee based travel as opposed to all-you-can-eat-buffet travel, people all of a sudden start choosing how to travel rather than automatically hitting the default option. That opens the door to better public transit, which can handle peak demand, as well as more walking and bicycling. And, we should have room for more and better bicycle/pedestrian facilities, since we won't need so much land to store all our mostly-unused boxes of steel and plastic. I think self driving cars will be transformative for cities, but it won't be some Jetsons vision of the future where we simply upgrade suburbia with tech. That will probably happen too, but those changes will be rather less profound.
- netcan 12y agoI read an article by a good journalist and nonfiction writer about “Peak ___”. On one hand, I think it’s an interesting concept for annotating historical events that are likely to happen. On the other hand, i think the “peak oil” idea of an inevitable supply crisis was generally poorly explained and understood. On the positive side, if we start by identifying relevant historical Peak X points, we might get something useful. Cars are a technology. Does technology peak? Have we passed “Peak Agriculture?” Will there be a “Peak Literacy?” We need a better historical account of how things peak for this perspective to be useful for anything but long term business strategy. https://www.straight.com/news/818136/gwynne-dyer-forget-peak-oil-weve-reached-peak-everything https://www.straight.com/news/818136/gwynne-dyer-forget-peak...
- eru 12y agoWe are definitely way past peak employment in agriculture.
- netcan 12y agoThat’s a good argument in favour of complexity and nuance, rather than sloganized Big Ideas. To get anything usefully true out of it we need to break it down and itemise.
- rjsw 12y agoAre we ? I don't know either way but the countries with fastest population growth tend to be ones with lots of agriculture.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoOnly because they are the least developed. Each country has its own peak agri though e.g. China had its in the 70s.
- eru 12y agoLots of agriculture, yes. But as productivity improves, everyone needs less people working in agriculture. Here are some graphs over time: http://ourworldindata.org/data/food-agriculture/agricultural-employment/ http://ourworldindata.org/data/food-agriculture/agricultural...
- brianbreslin 12y agoThis doesn't really take into consideration the growing middle classes in developing nations who will soon be able to afford automobiles.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI was thinking this as well. Car use seems to grow with industrialization and spread, then apparently shrinks with automation and urbanization. And if you look at the population that is entering into more general industrialization you see growing market for cars.
- lukaslalinsky 12y agoI use my car almost exclusively for long distance trips, so it stays parked near my home most of the time. But I still want it parked there, because I can decide at any time to make a trip and just go. Not worry about rental pickup/return times, reservations, mileage limits, etc. I was getting a new car last year and there was about a month after I sold my old one and before I got the new one. Almost immediately after selling the old car I felt like one of my freedoms was taken from me.
- Tloewald 12y agoI hope this is true, but I suspect self-driving cars will cause an upward inflexion.
- praptak 12y agoWho knows, they might enable much better service levels in public transit too.
- Tloewald 12y agoAbsolutely — let's hope so. (Of course, there are plenty of public transport systems that could run automated but don't owing to regulations or unionization -- a relative of mine used to work as a driver on BART, which essentially involved reading and occasionally pressing a "deadman" button.) You can easily imagine the cost of taxi service going down to the marginal cost of fuel and vehicle wear-and-tear, which would be far cheaper than private ownership. But I suggest that will ALSO vastly increase passenger miles. (It might yet reduce the carbon footprint of car manufacture.) The biggest cost for driving is time (gas, etc., a distant second). Efficient taxis will lead to less car pooling, more trips (because they will be less expensive in money and time -- you can watch TV, read, or chat with friends while driving). It's hard to see how this can possibly reduce passenger miles. Also imagine the increase in drug abuse! Now a pub crawl can continue while driving, and on the way home.
- praptak 12y ago> vastly increase passenger miles Ok, this might break the "peak car" but I'm fine with increasing passenger miles as long as passenger-CO2 and passenger-congestion go down. A self-driving minibus that you can call like a taxi but share with other passengers is my equivalent of the flying car :-)
- zantana 12y agoThis why some people are so optimistic about Uber, seeing a future where there would be instant aws style provisioning of transportation, you could see car ownership going the way of physical server ownership, in that case. Taking it one step farther, you can see a melding of plugable container ship style passenger interiors which could be routed very efficiently like network packets, leading to tremendous efficiency which would make car driving/mass transit seem quaint.
- gregpilling 12y agoCar production continues to climb. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automotive_industry#World_motor_vehicle_production http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automotive_industry#World_motor... There was a slowdown in 08, 09, and then back to growth. Internationally, it is expected to keep growing according to the auto manufacturers. Growing markets will account for a lot of that, for example in India auto ownership is at 1/10th the US and expected to continue to grow for a long time.
- ScottWhigham 12y agoThis makes no sense unless the distribution between rural vs. urban populations changes. If most of the projected population growth (to 10bb people by 2083 [1]) happens in areas where there is mass transit, then great - this seems plausible. If the % of the population growth continues to be what it is today (close to 50/50 [2]), then this just cannot be plausible. 5bb people in 2083 is unlikely to be result in fewer than the number of drivers that there are on the roads right now (roughly 1bb) [3]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_growth http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_growth [2] http://www.un.org/en/development/desa/news/population/world-urbanization-prospects-2014.html http://www.un.org/en/development/desa/news/population/world-... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle
- phunge 12y agoMatt Yglesias's recent article on how car commuting is actually on the rise in the US: http://www.vox.com/2015/4/29/8505097/car-commuting http://www.vox.com/2015/4/29/8505097/car-commuting Was surprised when I read that. He also ascribed some of the misperception to a young urban journalist echo chamber effect.
- bane 12y agoIt's interesting that most of the countries with observed post-peak-car figures are relatively advanced countries, but most of which have had very good public mass-transit for a very long time. Yet the downturn didn't really occur until around 1994. It's important to realize that this peak has occurred not just after the construction of mass-transit systems, but after the widespread availability of the internet has allowed for telecommuting. I live in a not-super-well connected suburb mass-transit wise, but my whole area has Fios. Because of that I've basically worked from home for the last 5-6 years. My most recent job even has a corporate policy favoring telecommuting because it lets them keep facility costs low. We have to come in 2-3 days a week for face-to-face meetings and other coordinating activities, but they offer robust remote access solutions, BYOD, etc. and make it very welcoming and easy to telecommute. I've recently become surprised at how many of my neighbors work for places with similar policies.
- dennisgorelik 12y agoYes: the main driver in car usage decline is better software and networking. You already named remote work, but it does not end there. There are remote games, remote movies (Netflix, YouTube), remote shopping (Amazon), remote communities (HN), etc.
- contingencies 12y agoSince most people here are American, I figured I'd share my own story. I'm Australian and don't drive, except occasionally motorbikes in more liberal countries where a license is not required. Having lived in a few places and now having a child, I can tell you that in my experience not having a car is a pain in the ass outside of major city centers in Australia, New Zealand and most of the US. However, it is super easy in China and Europe. In China you use taxis and long distance trains/places/buses. In Europe things are often walkable and there are great train systems and many airports. To me it feels like the US, Australia and New Zealand bought too heavily in to the 1950s suburban dream and the car society around it, and now have a lot of catching up to do. Unfortunately, reclaiming streets from cars is difficult. Wisdom from India: The Highway and Automobile culture are symbols of totalitarian cultures which deny people more sustainable and equitable alternatives for mobility and transport. - Vandana Shiva, February 19, 2004. Another instance of "we out-capitalism'd you!" from China: China has the world's longest [high speed rail] network with over 16,000 km (9,900 mi) of track in service as of December 2014 which is more than the rest of the world's high speed rail tracks combined. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_China
- sukilot 12y agoThose are bizarre definitions of "totalitarinism" and "capitalism".
- contingencies 12y agoIt seems we have an ism-schism.
- yesbabyyes 12y agoThis is so relevant. In Sweden, there is currently (for the last 15 years or so) a big push to build new and bigger motorways. At the same time, Bil Sweden, the Swedish interest organization for motor traffic, publishes statistics on the share of the population having a driver's license.[1] Ever since I found this document I've been convinced of the decline of driving. The statistics are per age group, and the only age groups where the population share with a driver's license are still increasing are 67 years and up. All the rest seem to have peaked during the last 15 years. 18 year olds are the exception, where there is a small increase during the last few years. Still, it's at around 30% up from 25% ca 10 years ago, while it was 50% in 1989. Cars are so old school. And the explosion engine is just... Well it feels like steam punk to me. I just don't get the fascination. This is from a guy who's currently working to get a license, since I moved back out to my family's farm from the city. I still view it as good to have, not something that excites me at all. [1] http://www.bilsweden.se/statistik/korkort http://www.bilsweden.se/statistik/korkort
- burntsushi 12y ago> Cars are so old school. And the explosion engine is just... Well it feels like steam punk to me. I just don't get the fascination. A lot of people don't "get" my fascination with programming. Others don't "get" my fascination with American football. Others don't "get" my fascination for living in population sparse areas. There's nothing to "get" other than the fact that all have different likes and dislikes. Some people like cars for their freedom, for their solitude and/or for their speed. Maybe there are other reasons too!
- yesbabyyes 12y agoOf course, and that's ok with me. I guess I'm coming from a place where it was expected for a boy to be fascinated with mopeds, tractors, cars, cranes, anything with an engine. Not that there aren't many in my generation who, like me, never shared that fascination, but it was still expected, or it felt like that in a way, you get me? And to not like that, and not even get a driver's license (regardless of whether you really need it, or a car, having access to great public transport and communications and whatnot), making certain people - in your own family, even - disregard you automatically, like you're not actually a man, or you're not actually grown up. I've come to terms with all that now, and I understand it way better than when I was in my twenties and younger, but it still exists, and again, to me it's just weird. To clarify, I don't look down on e.g. my father for not "getting" computers and the Internet, even though I know it would be a great resource for him. I get the feeling that it's not mutual, though.
- mathattack 12y agoI'm curious what happens with driverless cars. Do people go more places without the hassle of actually driving? Do car miles go up because the cars drive in circles in lieu of parking? Or does it go down because we view driving as a variable cost more than fixed?
- deathanatos 12y agoThe article lists San Francisco as having total vehicle kilometers traveled as having declined "-4.8%"; but I would be more interested in seeing the suburbs, too; does it matter if local city centers are declining if the surrounding suburbs are all increasing? I work in SF, and I don't drive any miles in SF. But I drive ~35 miles daily to get to the public transport (CalTrain[1]). There's a less-driving-time public transit route to work, but it doubles to triples the commute time, which is unacceptable. That said, I also don't "commute solo" … the difference between the HOV and non-HOV lanes is too great. I also lived in Providence, RI, for a bit; there the transit system suffered two interesting "failures": 1. it was quicker for me to not take the bus that went right in front of my house; walking was routinely faster. This was mostly because… 2. the bus I was connecting from arrived 2 minutes after my connection had left. (and if you're going to encourage _more_ people to trade driving for public transit, CalTrain is going to need more capacity; trains are routinely full: i.e., there is so little room that it is difficult to board the train, let alone sit.)
- acdha 12y ago> 2. the bus I was connecting from arrived 2 minutes after my connection had left. This was basically 100% of the buses in San Diego. Most of the [quite large] county is theoretically transit accessible but they appeared to have used some sort of de-optimization program which ensured that every connection incurred the maximum wait.
- semi-extrinsic 12y agoIf your work is within walking/running/cycling distance I think those options essentially always win over anything else in densely populated areas. I recently spent half a year in central London, 6 km from home to work. I would run or longboard it in < 40 minutes one way, taking the tube or bus took > 60 minutes door-to-door, so even including a quick shower running was faster. If you count in the money saved on not taking the tube, not needing a gym membership, and the time saved by not having to do any workouts after you come home from work, it's a big win. I did have to limit myself to 3 days running a week (2 days longboarding), or my knees started complaining. Also, London: fix your goddamned pavements, they are un-bloody-skateboardable. We have invented concrete and asphalt, you don't need to use cobblestones everywhere.
- xasos 12y agoWith the advent of public transport, it looks like more people are moving to the city. This may also take into account people not needing to own cars, because of the ease of use of Lyft and Uber.
- stegosaurus 12y agoCross country, UK public transport is a shambles. As far as I can tell, it excels at two use cases - infrequent journeys and/or too poor to own a car, or so rich that the cost is irrelevant. A cross country train here essentially has to be booked in advance. Random example - London to York, ~200mi journey, £110 anytime single ticket one way. And that's for a single person. Add in a partner, friends or children and watch the fares explode into the stratosphere. This nonsense doesn't happen on the London Underground, or on a local bus. Basically, public transport turns life into a game of 'what will I do in x weeks time?'... the only people that really buy tickets for 'now' are business travellers and the elite. It bothers me that the only reason I really want a car is for the journeys that are actually the most trivial to solve. A train ticket from A to B should never cost more than fuel and depn that a car would use from A to B. Yet it does. eh. (If you book weeks in advance it's sort of OK. But that's not life. Not a life I want to live, anyway.) Heh. Just had a look at travelling to my hometown for a weekend. A few days out. Few hundred miles. 160GBP return. To me that's basically a troll fare. It's basically matching the fuel and depreciation on a new van, except one person can make the journey with a suitcase or two. Ace.
- bobbles 12y agoWhen I was travelling with my SO we ended up in Manchester and needed to get to London. I can't remember the exact fare but it was something like 150 pounds each for the one way train ride ($580 AUD total) vs a similar length trip in Australia which would have been about $110 AUD total. A complete rip-off IMO.
- stegosaurus 12y agoIt really is just hilariously broken. I do not understand it. Many people seem to hanker for re-nationalisation of the railways. I just want to see sensible business methods really. If you price railway tickets reasonably you have a potential market of millions. Perhaps even 10M+. If you price them as toys for the rich, everyone drives cars. What is going on here? Bonkers. I take budget coaches because they let me book at short notice, often at 1/5th the price or less.