14 ms·
The Medical Bill Mystery
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoI just received a bill for some SEO that I never ordered. I explained to my mother that it was a common scam, then pitched it into the recycling bin. If my company were larger than just myself, that bill would have gone to Accounts Payable, with a good chance that it would get paid. Accounts Payable staff at big companies don't have the headspace to chase down whether someone really ordered $85.00 worth of SEO service; such a small amount would not require managerial signoff.
- DanBC 12y agoI worked for a company that bought about £100,000 of electronic components (plus other stuff) per month. They knew where every single item was - down to the paperclips. I'm kind of surprised to hear that tech companies might not know where their money is going, especially when it's $85. See also "Cuckoos Egg" where a few cents difference in billing leads to uncovering hackers intruding on the network.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoI expect your former employer was quite successful. Many aren't. My full name is Michael David Crawford. I had a classmate in high school named Michael Dwayne Crawford who often skipped out of school. High school truancy before the age of sixteen is a criminal offense in California. Whenever Mike Dwayne would skip out, the police department's truant office would call my father at work, who then had to take leave from his important work of fighting the cold war then ride his motorcycle twenty miles - sometimes in the driving rain - then visit the principal, all to say "This is not my son". This because the school's MIS system only recorded our middle initials.
- triangleman 12y agoWhere is the startup helping me to decode my medical bills?
- tapp 12y agoHere: https://www.copatient.com https://www.copatient.com I have no affiliation with the company; I'm just a fan of their work.
- DigitalSea 12y agoExactly what I was thinking. It could be a simple app that you take a photo of your itemised medical bill and it decodes it for you. Although after reading this, I think an app that does this automatically would fail as itemised bills do not seem to be the norm and even when you ask for one, nothing makes sense and there appears to be a lack of standardisation. I think insurance companies should offer this as a value-add. A broken down, item-by-item explanation of what you were charged for and what it means.
- Aloha 12y agoI don't think its that simple, the myriad of billing formats would be problematic. That said, a credit karma like service to connect with your insurance company could be a lot less problematic IMO to implement.
- biot 12y agoIt's because the myriad formats are problematic that this would make for a good startup. And you could initially schlep it: as new formats come in, do just-in-time research to figure it all out.
- oomkiller 12y agoHow would knowing the meaning and even the average cost for a given code change your behavior? It's still basically impossible to get even an estimate of cost for even the most basic medical procedures before having one. Also, the bills are much more complicated than what they print out and mail to you. The amounts can vary based on many different factors, such as BMI, alcohol/nicotine dependency, and other risk factors that make you more risky to provide care for.
- mirimir 12y agoThere's one simple fact that can save patients real money: network providers generally can't go after patients for fees that aren't covered by insurers. Forgoing that right is typically part of their deals with insurers. They often go ahead and bill patients anyway. But they back off when challenged, saying that they billed in error.
- maxerickson 12y agoCan you explain further what you mean? I recently had an x-ray that was not covered by my insurance, and the hospital submitted it to my insurance to ensure that it would apply to my deductible. I guess you mean a fee that is uncovered in the sense that it would not apply against the deductible. (It's total BS, the price I paid was 5x the medicare reimbursement rate, like 15x the medicaid reimbursement rate and I would speculate at least 2x what the insurance company would pay (based on researching the 'typical cost' of the particular x-ray on the internets).)
- cbr 12y agoWas this in-network? Typically if something is in-network but applied to your deductible then the rate you pay is your insurance company's "allowed amount", the rate they "negotiated" with the hospital for the service, and exactly "what the insurance company would pay".
- maxerickson 12y agoIt was in network. I don't believe it though. I did say I was speculating, because I don't have any evidence. I would love to see what they actually pay, assertions that they must pay the allowed amount don't really make me any less skeptical about it.
- mirimir 12y agoI was specifically referring to stuff that's covered, and where the provider bills the patient for it's cash-price fee, less what the insurer paid. Network providers generally can't do that. But out-of-network providers certainly can, and those fees can be huge. In your case, I'm guessing that your insurance doesn't cover outpatient services (or perhaps just imaging) at hospitals. Even if the hospital is in network. If that's the case, make sure to have that stuff done at stand-alone clinics, where it should be covered.
- twic 12y agoOne minor, pathetic quibble: > “The baby boomers have tolerated the current system,” she said. “But 20-somethings and millennials are not used to this and they won’t.” So as a Generation Xer, what am I, chopped liver?
- noonespecial 12y agoThe most important thing I've learned is that the "bill" is not like the bill that comes at the end of the meal at a restaurant. Medical bills are more like the first offer in a long negotiation process. Unfortunately for the uninsured who get serious illnesses these days, it often just amounts to an impossible demand that is then graciously negotiated down to merely everything they have.
- acveilleux 12y agoBasically, Oracle pricing.
- GabrielF00 12y agoIt's not just the billing codes that are insane, it's also the differences in prices. I recently filled a prescription at CVS. CVS billed my insurance company nearly $200 for 90 days. I found out that you can get the same prescription at Target for $10 for 90 days. (I'm not sure that the insurance company will actually pay $200 - I'll have to wait to see what the claim says).
- tomohawk 12y agoAs someone who has recently gone through a property purchase and had to deal with the forms mandated by the new "reform" laws mentioned in the article, it's pretty clear that the laws have made things much more confusing. I've purchased property before, and this time around the forms were much more confusing, and downright misleading at times. Talking with the pros involved in the purchase, they unanimously agreed - they were constantly having to explain what the forms meant to seasoned home buyers. It's clear that gov't bureaucrats should not be trusted to specify forms that are intended to make any sense. This article is a good sign that now that high deductible plans are becoming the norm, people are actually interested in what's being billed and in controlling costs. Hopefully this will lead to a reform where health insurance is more like other insurances (purchased by the person needing it instead of employer, purchasable across state lines, ...). I know that one of the reasons I keep my car insurance company is that the mechanics of doing business with them is nearly frictionless.
- bachmeier 12y agoI had surgery last year. There was a steady stream of bills, some duplicates, some not, and I had no idea how much I needed to pay (to say nothing about what the charges were for). My wife went to the hospital to clear things up and they couldn't even tell her how much they wanted me to pay - and this was months after the surgery. Finally, after a couple weeks had passed, they decided what I was supposed to pay. Good chance someone just wrote down a number.
- fluidcruft 12y agoMy feeling is that the experience could be improved dramatically right now if instead of ever directly paying providers, we instead always paid the delta to the insurance company. My experience with provider billing offices is that they actively weasel and trick you into overpaying the negotiated rates and hope you don't go over the bill. And then they stall and "forget" to refund. Nothing ever makes sense until the explanation of benefits document is generated. In other words--if we're not going to do single-payer, then it should at least be single-payer-per-patient.
- pcurve 12y agoI guess insurance companies don't want be involved in the collection business. So much so that, my dental insurance company (Delta dental, funny enough) cuts me the reimbursement check. And I have to pay my dentist.
- fluidcruft 12y agoOf course they don't. Everyone wants to externalize the unpleasent parts of business.
- PaulHoule 12y agoSometimes I wonder if I sent an incomprehensible bill to the hospital for services rendered if they would pay it.
- venomsnake 12y ago> 1. 25030731 HC RT OXYGEN DAILY CHARGE — $2,132.25.”; >The supplemental oxygen delivered into the nose after surgery, a routine precaution at many hospitals. What is wrong with US healthcare in one sentence. two thousand dollars for oxygen is beyond ludicrous. There is no way this cost could be justified.
- tomohawk 12y agoThis is a completely rational price given that none of the prices are published, and that the prices tend to be set more on who is doing the paying than anything related to the actual cost. Do an experiment sometime. Pretend that you need an MRI of your head. Call around to the various places that provide MRIs and see if you can get (a) the price, (b) a description of the equipment that will be used so that you will know if it will be a good MRI or an ancient one. It's pretty laughable that we just had a major "reform" of our health insurance system, with lots of lip service paid to cost, and yet there is still no information available to allow people to make decisions based on cost and quality, and this appears to be by design.
- genkaos 12y agosomewhat related: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=120545569 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1205455...
- mplscoder 12y ago"Your medical care would be paid for by others. And therefore you would gratefully accept, on bended knee, what was offered to you as a privilege. Your role being responsible for your own care would be diminished."
- michaelochurch 12y agoI've paid (either directly, or by an employer having paid money that otherwise could have gone to me) about $60,000 into the medical insurance system since leaving college. (That's 10 years times $500 per month, which is a low estimate.) I've also paid several hundred thousand dollars in taxes to a government that prioritized blowing up Iraq over protecting us from things that might actually kill us, like cancer and heart disease. Given the amount paid, I see health care as a right, not a privilege. We already have high taxes and high insurance premiums. Yet we live in a society where it's pretty much random whether your insurance even covers you when you get sick.
- codegeek 12y agoThe entire medical bill and insurance system is insane. I say this after going through 2 pregnancies (with my wife) and now with 2 young kids. The process is that you go to the doctor, they will NOT tell you how much it costs out of pocket because that amount is probably insane anyway but you need insurance to "bill" that insane amount to the insurance company. The doctor will send say $1000 bill to insurance company for a simple checkup (yes, it can be that bad). THe insurance company then will say "no no sir, we only allow $200 for this specific item". Then insurance company will figure out how much you the patient ius supposed to pay out of that $200 (copay, co-insurance etc) and THEN they will pay the remainder to the doctor. See the issue here ? The price of a simple checkup is inflated from $200 (we can argue on this too) to $1000. This $1000 is just to scare you but really does not mean shit. Imagine that the doctor could bill you that $200 directly anyway or whatever amount they eventually get from insurance company. It will save their time, your time, their staff hours and probably save more for them in terms of resource usage. What we need is a system where not everything goes through insurance. This scare of having mandatory insurance is the root cause. Doctors/hospitals need to have transparent pricing just like other businesses and insurance should only bee needed for really catastrophic events like cancer, major accident etc. I would much rather pay $200 to a couple of visits instead of paying insrance $1000/month just to "insure" myself.
- acveilleux 12y agoOr you get a single payer and this charade goes away because the single payer's price list is fixed. This is how the rest of the world does it.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoWestern Europe != rest of the world. The Indian system is a 1 billion payer system. The single price is also fixed and usually written on the wall, or maybe in a big book of prices. You ask for a price quote, receive it, pay that much and get it done. If the price is too high you go elsewhere. It works nearly perfectly. For any medical conditions I have that permit flight, I'm voting for it with a plane ticket.
- 12y ago
- yummyfajitas 12y agoI had four surgeries last year. In all cases I was given a price quote plus a ballpark on the cost of incidentals (things purchased outside the hospital, e.g. antibiotics to consume at home). For example, I was told that my spine surgery would cost 1.4 lac only. The final bill: https://imgur.com/Dbkrmo7 https://imgur.com/Dbkrmo7 In all cases the final price agreed with my initial quote down to the rupee. The cost of the incidentals was also within the ballpark that I was told (and minor in any case - e.g. 1.4 lac for surgery and 2-3k for post surgery pills). One of the wonderful things about India is that the medical system is almost entirely consumer driven - you have a problem, you pay the doctor, and he does his thing. Customers choose a doctor based (in part) on price, resulting in price competition. Nonsense like refusing a price quote will result in customers walking away. Given a choice, I'll always choose to consume medicine in India. It's just a vastly superior system to anyplace else I've tried.
- solutionyogi 12y agoCouldn't agree more. I am an Indian and when I first came to US, my biggest surprise was that jobs would advertise 'health insurance' as a benefit. I never understood it till I had to obtain medical care. If you want to experience true free market health care, you must go to India. Whenever I visit India, I make sure to get my teeth cleaning done. Person in my home town has a choice to get teeth cleaning done from 500 INR (7$) to 3500 INR (55$). On the low end, you get a clinic which is not in the hip part of the town, equipment is not the latest and greatest and the waiting room will be non air conditioned. On the higher end, the clinic will be fully air conditioned, serve you tea/coffee and will use the latest equipment. On my last trip, a real dentist (not a hygienist) performed my teeth cleaning and they took my teeth x-ray using those new machines where you stand up and the machine takes 360 degree scan. After the cleaning, the doctor took me to her office and reviewed the x-ray with me and then gave me a CD with all the x-ray images so that I can use them with my next doctor in case I decide to go somewhere else.
- gkop 12y agoHow long did the dentist spend cleaning your teeth? My experience is hygienists spend more time and are more thorough because that's their one job. Also, several dentists over the years have recommended to me seeking a dentist that an employs a hygienist for this reason.
- geomark 12y agoThe comments from those in India are interesting. Here in Thailand it is similar. Prices for standard procedures are published and you get an estimate in advance if it is a complex procedure. This is true for private hospitals. It is also true for public hospitals that offer "special clinic hours" which is when foreigners must go since they are not covered by the national health insurance scheme. To top it off, quality of care is better here than what I experienced in the U.S. at a fraction of the price. It drives me nuts to be reminded of the U.S. health care mess.
- strathmeyer 12y agoThey always give me direct, flat prices beforehand, once I tell them that I don't have insurance, and after they pull out their "other" price chart.