4 ms·
This is totally ridiculous. The man is a veteran software architect. When you're a veteran software architect, you don't NEED the source code. The only thing it
by lordnacho 12y ago
This is totally ridiculous. The man is a veteran software architect. When you're a veteran software architect, you don't NEED the source code. The only thing it tells you is a few syntactical idiosyncrasies of whatever language/framework you happened to implement it in, and it saves you time in typing it out.
Ask anyone who is familiar with GS's code base whether they would rather start fresh or have GS's code base. I've done this, and you can tell from my tone what they said.
I've also been on the other side of such a case; someone copied some code I'd written. Guess what, they couldn't get it to work because they didn't understand how it worked.
I suspect the jury is composed of people who are easily talked into a "cooking recipe" view of how software works. Well, just as I'm not going to be a Michelin chef from copying a recipe, you are also not going to know how to design an HFT system if you don't have a deeper understanding of how it works. Or maybe more to the point: there are plenty of people who copy recipes and make tasty food (my parents are quite good at this, actually). They don't get paid what a Michelin chef gets paid, because a Michelin chef is not a guy who just mixes some ingredients according to a formula.
- mfisher87 12y ago>Ask anyone who is familiar with GS's code base whether they would rather start fresh or have GS's code base. I've done this, and you can tell from my tone what they said. I think that's a false dichotomy -- no one can remember every minute detail of every problem solved by a large application. To re-do the research would be a large commitment, hence I'm convinced the wisest choice would be "both," legality aside.
- rubiquity 12y agoIf we use your logic that it's hard to use other people's code, then the entire premise of open source is a failure. Clearly that isn't the case so I question your logic.
- nulltype 12y agoClearly.
- tedunangst 12y agoIf he didn't need it, why did he take it?
- dmix 12y agoThe big issue is why did he hide his tracks after taking it. The criminal intent thing is always the primary question.
- infecto 12y agoLets assume what you say is true. Then why risk taking any code at all? It was an incredibly stupid move on his part. Cooking and programming are horrible comparisons too.
- BWStearns 12y ago> Cooking and programming are horrible comparisons too. I think that was part of their point
- whyaduck 12y ago> Guess what, they couldn't get it to work because they didn't understand how it worked. This isn't necessarily a good sign.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tracker1 12y agoHow timely... two-three years ago I had trudged through a pretty dated codebase to track down all the tables that contained relevant data to implement a new search system. Since then features were added, bolted on, and changes made (I had left the company for a year and a half in the middle). Now, I'm migrating said data into a green solution that will replace the whole thing. It took a surprising amount of time to track it all down again, even with my old code and additional data. The new solutions data structures are a bit different than even the old search-only solution. Even when you have the code, and even when you wrote it, that doesn't mean it's going to save you all the time... it's a little bit of a shortcut and reference, sure, but imho even if it's technically a crime, in this case I doubt it's enough of an offense to justify more than a month in jail, which has probably already been served.
- Patient0 12y agoA lot of the high frequency trading code actually is very expensive to recreate, because it contains logic like (and I am paraphrasing here): if(bookPressure > 0.7 and alpha23signal<0.2) buyEurUsd() where constants like 0.7 and 0.2 were arrived at from looking at actual trade activity (and order book fill rates) conducted by the firm over a period of a few months. That can be incredibly expensive and or impossible to "recreate" from scratch. The exact original code is also useful if you wanted to write code to "detect" that some automated trading is being done by a Goldmans proprietary algorithm, and then anticipate what it's going to do next so you can trade ahead of it.
- tptacek 12y agoThis is an interesting point I hadn't seen made before. If it applies here, then what you're saying is that the structure of the code itself doesn't matter, so much as the parameters encoded into it --- those parameters being available only to people who can bankroll the trading desks that generate the information from which they're derived. In that scenario, the "code" itself (as we understand "code") is a red herring, right? I'm surprised if this is what actually happened; it's too reasonable-sounding.
- lordnacho 12y agoRight, so that's a parameter, isn't it? A mathematical number that fits into a model. In which case you need to understand the model.
- Patient0 12y agoRight but I don't see how this detracts from my point. Also, often the models are very simple - it's the calibration to a particular market that is very expensive (the constants - which are then often hard coded for best performance). This is because calibrating it requires access to data from actual trading activity (not just tick data, I mean also information on say the chance that your order will be filled in a particular situation: information you can only get by actually placing orders of size in the market and observing when they got filled).