6 ms·
People who were legally in the US, were literally picked up off of American streets, blindfolded, put into secret CIA aircraft, flown to Egypt, Jordan, Morocco,
by Someone1234 12y ago
People who were legally in the US, were literally picked up off of American streets, blindfolded, put into secret CIA aircraft, flown to Egypt, Jordan, Morocco, and Uzbekistan, and then tortured [0].
Yet not a single person has gone to jail over this. The CIA hasn't been reformed structurally, and no additional oversights have been added. In fact the only difference between then and now is we have a different administration in the White House who are just choosing not to continue it...
Does this not disturb anyone? Isn't this exactly the type of stuff people used to joke about the USSR/KGB doing? Since when did the US constitution only apply to citizens and not residence?
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_rendition#21st_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_rendition#21st_c...
- hyperliner 12y agoThis is relevant: "Are Foreign Nationals Entitled to the Same Constitutional Rights As Citizens?" http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1302&context=facpub http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?ar...
- skwirl 12y agoThe answer is "NO" because the Supreme Court has ruled that they are not. Unfortunately the Constitution grants judicial powers to the Supreme Court and not to David Cole, Law Professor.
- hyperliner 12y agoActually, the Supreme Court has not offered an absolute rule. If you read the article I offered, you would have learned about the nuances that the Supreme Court has provided in terms of areas of protection to non citizens and areas of no protection.
- pdkl95 12y agoNo, it's not. The fact that the person being tortured isn't a US citizen doesn't make torture any less of a contemptible, barbaric act that is unfit for civilized society. If basic human decency is not convincing, I suggest reading 18 U.S. Code § 2340A, which says (a) Offense.— Whoever outside the United States commits or attempts to commit torture shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 20 years, or both, and if death results to any person from conduct prohibited by this subsection, shall be punished by death or imprisoned for any term of years or for life. (b) Jurisdiction.— There is jurisdiction over the activity prohibited in subsection (a) if— (1) the alleged offender is a national of the United States; or (2) the alleged offender is present in the United States, irrespective of the nationality of the victim or alleged offender. The nationality of the victim doesn't matter.
- hyperliner 12y agoDid you even read what I posted? Here is a copy-paste for you: Thus, there is little reasoned support for the widely held no- tion that noncitizens are entitled to substantially less constitu- tional protection than citizens. While not identically situated in all respects, foreign nationals should enjoy the same constitu- tional protections for fundamental rights and liberties as United States citizens. The areas of permissible differentiation - admis- sion, expUlsion, voting, and running for federal elective office - are much narrower than the areas of presumptive equality - due process, freedom of expression, association, and religion, privacy, and the rights of the criminally accused. When we balance liberty and security, in other words, we should respect the equal dignity and basic human rights of all persons. In the wake of September 11, we have failed to follow that mandate. When we spy on foreign nationals without proba- ble cause but not citizens, selectively target foreign nationals for registration, detention, and deportation based on their ethnic and religious identities, and lock up foreign nationals in secret or without any hearings at all, we have chosen the easy way out: sacrificing their rights for our purported security. In the end, the true test of justice in a democratic society is not how it treats those with political power, but how it treats those who have no voice in the democratic process. How we treat foreign nationals, the paradigmatic other in this time of crisis, ultimately tests our own humanity.
- maxerickson 12y agoThat Wikipedia article lists 1 person who was deported from US territory (prior to their clearing border control, so they were not legally in the country). Are you getting the "Hundreds of people who were legally in the US" from some other resource? I guess people won't really change their views on the practice just depending on whether it occurs in the US or not, but I also don't see any reason to add noise to the discussion.
- Someone1234 12y agoI misread Wikipedia. I have removed the "hundreds" wording which was clearly in error.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt also says nothing about anyone being picked up off of a US street. US persons (not just citizens, but people legally living in the US) tend to enjoy more US Constitutional protections than people outside the US, so I think you are still quite wrong in your characterization.
- xnull2guest 12y agoDo we have a proper source? We really shouldn't go on any number mentioned in Wikipedia unless it is comprehensive and well sourced. Following news over the past few years, just by the number of mentions in the media over that time, the distinct impression I have it that it is more than one. This article, from 2005 says that hundreds of people have been taken (from the streets) since a couple years prior. (http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/washington/2005-12-27-cia-renditions_x.htm http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/washington/2005-12-27-ci...)
- maxerickson 12y agoThe parent comment was very specific about saying "legally in the US" and "American streets". This is simply not the case, there are not hundreds of extraordinary renditions that started with a kidnapping on US soil. But sure, let's all get outraged about a blatant misunderstanding of reality, instead of discussing the still outrageous reality.
- CSMastermind 12y agoThe wikipedia article you posted doesn't support your claim. Where are you seeing these "Hundreds of people who were legally in the US, were literally picked up off of American streets"
- Lawtonfogle 12y ago>who are just choosing not to continue it Or so they claim. How many times in history has some group promised to stop some wrong doing only to continue, perhaps in a modified way?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 12y agoI don't see anything in there about people being "literally picked up off American streets." Yes, that's important. The Constitution grants civil rights to Americans and those on U.S. soil. Outside U.S. soil is the domain of the military and executive apparatus acting under the authority Congress gives them. What the military/CIA do abroad may be bad and maybe something they shouldn't do.[1] If the CIA is doing it on the streets of Milwaukee, that's illegal and something they can't do. [1] And I strongly agree we shouldn't be grabbing random people off the streets in foreign countries.
- fiatmoney 12y agoJose Padilla (although he was not rendered to a third country; they tortured him themselves).
- rayiner 12y agoJose Padilla was not kidnapped on the streets--he was arrested at customs in Chicago while returning to the U.S. It's also not clear whether he was "tortured." I don't want to get into a debate about enhanced interrogation, but this article describes what we know about his interrogation: http://content.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1565798,00.html http://content.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1565798,0... (solitary, sensory deprivation, extreme temperatures, stress positions). Padilla was clearly an example of the Bush administration overreaching. He's the only known example of the government holding a U.S. citizen as an enemy combatant without charge. But he was ultimately indicted, and the length of his detention would've been a lot shorter if his habeas petition hadn't been filed in the wrong jurisdiction in the first instance. The gears of justice sometimes grind slowly, but in that case checks and balances worked. If you're going to say "the government is picking Americans off the streets and torturing them" you shouldn't have to lawyer your way around each of the elements in the sentence.
- jacquesm 12y ago> I don't want to get into a debate about enhanced interrogation The words 'enhanced interrogation' leave me with a bad taste. Either it's interrogation or it is torture, let's keep it simple that way you won't have to debate where the line lies, you stay well away from that line to avoid doubt.