8 ms·
I'm surprised they don't also cite the first war against drugs (actualy, a drug) - prohibition. Exactly the same scenario played out then as is, hopefully, comi
by simonh 12y ago
I'm surprised they don't also cite the first war against drugs (actualy, a drug) - prohibition. Exactly the same scenario played out then as is, hopefully, coming to it's inevitable conclusion now in the 'western hemisphere'. If the same thing is starting up again in the East, it's going to be a bloody and chaotic few decades to come before the same lesson gets learned the third time over.
Fortunately we do have a largely successful, bloodless war on a drug to learn from. Tobacco abuse is less than half what it was back in the early 70s in the US, and similar declines are seen in many European countries. Advertising campaigns, usage restrictions in public places and high taxes have been very effective, and also meant that the medical costs of treating the effects of tobacco abuse have been more than covered by tax revenues from it's sale in many countries.
While campaigns against alcohol abuse have not been as successful, mainly because they have not been as focused on reducing all usage, tax revenues have been high. Normalisation of low levels of use in appropriate circumstances and ammounts have also limited the harmful effects on most abusers and those around them.
- peteretep 12y ago> I'm surprised they don't also cite the first war > against drugs Being a British publication, presumably they'd consider the Opium Wars - where the Brits fought to be allowed to sell the Chinese junk - as the first drug war.
- chippy 12y agoThat was a war for drugs, rather than against them. It was also about fighting for another drug - tea. Tea and coffee also had quite a loud vocal support for prohibition against it in the UK.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoSeveral Asian countries very successfully waged "war" on opium usage, to the benefit of their societies. They killed you if you were caught with any. I'm not a prohibitionist, but we need to drop the lie that a war on drugs has even been tried in the West. Sentences for drug possession are typically avoidable and usually light. What has been done (same as back in alcohol prohibition days) is corrupt law enforcement rackets have been funded to pursue "dealers." Well, we know that doesn't work. What does work is very harsh and uniform punishment for users. Which, I reiterate, has not been tried in the West for over a century.
- wavefunction 12y agoI think you're not being accurate when you claim that a "war on drugs" has not been prosecuted in the West. The cost to minority populations in the US and in countries where the drugs are produced has been enormous. Maybe you don't personally know anyone who has faced societally-imposed hardships due to drugs but the reality faced by many poor and minority people is quite stark and different than what you allege. A young man here in Texas was facing LIFE in prison for selling marijuana infused brownies (as well as possession of cannabis oils). That's just one case. And this: >>What does work is very harsh and uniform punishment for users. Paints you as a complete fool like the rest of the drug warriors.
- peteretep 12y ago> That was a war for drugs Not for the Chinese it wasn't
- hackerboos 12y agoGrowing opium in India to sell to the Chinese. They objected to their citizens becoming addicts (rightly so) so the British empire and East India Trading company turned their gunships on them and seized Hong Kong under the Treaty of Nanking. The Chinese, outgunned, had to surrender the terms. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Opium_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Opium_War
- pstuart 12y agoAnd the British have demonstrated how well they handle alcohol these days. Edit: meow, oh the butthurt. Binge drinking apparently is a significant problem but is tolerated because "alcohol is not a drug" http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/10825449/Britains-binge-drinking-levels-are-among-the-highest-in-the-world.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/10825449/Britain...
- jahewson 12y agoI don't know about that; it was a war for a legalised drug trade rather than against it. It's notable that the Chinese tried to enforce a total ban on the trade and to execute domestic traders, which resembles modern (failing) drug policy. The similarities probably end there though, as modern drug cartels and the British Empire are very different entities. It's also worth remembering that America was selling opium to China too, and that John Quincy Adams spoke in favour of the opium wars from a "free trade" stance.
- cmdrfred 12y ago'Fortunately we do have a largely successful, bloodless war on a drug to learn from.' Successful maybe, bloodless not even close. http://www.cnn.com/2014/08/01/justice/new-york-choke-hold-death/ http://www.cnn.com/2014/08/01/justice/new-york-choke-hold-de...
- simonh 12y agoOh come on, the guy was an illegal street trader. That gets cracked down on regardless of what's being sold, in this case it just happened to be cigarettes. I've seen someone arrested for selling slingshot helicopter toys on the street. Trying to stretch that into a bloody 'war on tobacco' is really a bit much.
- simplexion 12y agoI don't understand why the campaigns against alcohol have been so unsuccessful. It is amazing that so many people have no issue with losing control mentally under the influence of alcohol and those same people think it is scary that I would like to try LSD.
- peteretep 12y agoNormal alcohol dosage doesn't lead to massive loss of control
- jpatokal 12y agoNeither does normal drug use. It's the alcoholics (read: alcohol drug abusers) who let things get out of hand.
- DanBC 12y agoSomeone who is alcoholic will be drinking vast quantities of alcohol everyday. A person can drink far far less than that and suffer ill effects because of alcohol.
- saiya-jin 12y agoAlcohol is drug like any other. I guess everybody seen some people get aggressive even on moderate alcohol high. Tobacco is probably the worst drug ever consumed by man, considering amount of death and suffering it causes... None of drugs are a blessing to mankind, but to consider A OK and even promote it, and destroy people's lives and promote drug cartels for B, where many times B is not more harmful then A is... stupid. And we as society want to evolve and get better, right?
- MichaelGG 12y ago> None of drugs are a blessing to mankind Great for you that you never needed medication. Meanwhile, millions of people do, and drugs, from mood stabilizers to opiates to psychedelics, directly and dramatically increase the quality of life for many people.
- rayiner 12y agoThe difference is that the vast majority of people use alcohol. That was really a situation where the minority managed to impose its social mores on the majority. Drug users are in contrast a distinct minority group.
- jmadsen 12y agoI question how genuinely accurate that is. Drug use _started_ as illegal, and so many who have experimented and might have continued to casually use instead later on shied away. Alcohol started as a perfectly normal thing (until modern times, beer was considered a safer drink than water and no one ever considered restricting it to _anyone_) So, I'm not saying you are wrong - only that "Drug users are in contrast a distinct minority group" is not painting a fully accurate picture of America, and so you _could_ be wrong.
- dalke 12y ago"Drug use _started_ as illegal" Sherlock Holmes was portrayed as a regular cocaine user, and occasional user of morphine. At the time in Britain these were legal. BTW, the "beer was considered a safer drink than water" appears to be a modern myth. See http://leslefts.blogspot.com/2013/11/the-great-medieval-water-myth.html http://leslefts.blogspot.com/2013/11/the-great-medieval-wate... for a summary. It may be that beer was considered more fortifying than water.
- Nursie 12y ago>> BTW, the "beer was considered a safer drink than water" appears to be a modern myth Huh. From what I understood previously it was more of a misapprehension than a myth - it didn't make you ill because the water was boiled as part of the process, it's just that nobody understood that.... perhaps I am wrong!
- jmadsen 12y agoAs I stated, I was using America as the context, as I thought the parent post was. Our history with drugs and alcohol does not match all places, in all times. More importantly, we are talking about people's _perceptions_ of these events and how they influence modern thought. Most of us are taught things like "the pilgrims served beer at the table instead of water". The reason for it, or whether or not it is even true, doesn't change that we all grow up thinking that "beer is no big deal - even the pilgrim's children drank it". You could even extend that to Sherlock Holmes - it is subtle in the stories, but no one checks or cares if it was actually legal. We _are_ all left with the negative impression that he was a secret drug addict, who often disappeared for periods of time to indulge.
- PaulAJ 12y agoI know its a side point, but I gather that smokers actually cost the UK NHS less than non-smokers, because smokers tend to die younger and faster than non-smokers. The people who cost the NHS a lot are the healthy, clean living people who survive into their 80s and 90s needing more and more healthcare as they go.
- magoghm 12y agoInteresting point. I hadn't looked at it that way. Do you know about any hard data that shows this clearly?
- DanBC 12y agoThis is how much money is earnt through tax and excise: http://www.the-tma.org.uk/tma-publications-research/facts-figures/tax-revenue-from-tobacco/ http://www.the-tma.org.uk/tma-publications-research/facts-fi... (about £10bn in 2005) This is how much smoking costs, maybe: £5bn But it's a bit more complicated than that.
- tmoullet 12y agoDo you know of any studies/articles that explore this idea? In the UK does any of taxes collected on the sale/manufacturing of cigarettes go back to funding the NHS?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jobu 12y agoThis appears to be what you're talking about: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9359212/Obese-and-smokers-less-of-a-burden-on-the-NHS-than-the-healthy-who-live-longer-report.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9359212/Obese-an... The research was done by a think-tank called The Institute of Economic Affairs ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institute_of_Economic_Affairs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institute_of_Economic_Affairs ). Unfortunately I can't find the actual research information behind their study, but I did find they were paid by tobacco companies for doing it - http://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/jun/01/thinktanks-big-tobacco-funds-smoking http://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/jun/01/thinktanks-bi...
- robotresearcher 12y ago> "tobacco abuse" Why use the word 'abuse' when referring to the designed use?