38 ms·
Illegal drugs: The wars don’t work
- ThomPete 12y agoIn 100 years from now the war on drugs is going to be seen as one of the most absurd, inhuman, draconian and misguided ways to deal with the problem.
- crusso 12y agoWe look at the Prohibition of alcohol as a huge mistake yet societally we continue to repeat the basic pattern.
- transfire 12y agoThey are working just fine for the people that profit from them, drug cartels and the law-prison complex. Thanks!
- RegW 12y agoThere was an interesting talk on Radio 4's Fourthought recently by an ex-cop. "Peter Bleksley, a former undercover policeman fighting drugs crime and an ex-drug addict, argues that the only answer in the so-called "war on drugs" is to legalise and license them." However, he was against simply putting the supply into the hands of pharmaceutical companies instead of criminals. He was calling for an affordable, state controlled supply to remove the incentive to build a business based on pushing the crap. http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b05r3zby http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b05r3zby http://www.amazon.com/Gangbuster-Peter-Bleksley/dp/1903402913 http://www.amazon.com/Gangbuster-Peter-Bleksley/dp/190340291...
- Nursie 12y agoHe's probably right. I'm very pro-legalisation myself. I also think it would be amazing if we could point our pharmaceutical research facilities at recreational drugs and say "Hey! Go find drugs people like that are less addictive and less harmful!". But given the nature of markets we'd end up optimising for the most addictive substance, because you want repeat customers, right? And the last thing I want to see is aspirational drug advertising of the sort we've had forever with tobacco and alcohol. "I don't often take cocaine, but when I do it's Old-style ultra-crack, because I'm a young go-getting executive type with lots of cash and a hot girlfriend..." (Please snort responsibly. This message brought to you by the cocaine producers alliance)
- nidieunimaitre 12y agoMakes me wonder if the US (or Uruguay?) will start seeing TV commercials or magazine ads for marijuana brands soon.
- Osiris 12y agoWhile I do not condone the use of mind altering substances, I believe that the externalities of the illegal drug trade are far worse than what the drugs do to the users (e.g., the number of murders is Mexico is currently unknown and is somewhere between 20k and 250k a year). A second argument in favor of regulation over an outright ban is personal liberty. Our social contract is about protecting ourselves from each other, not from ourselves. Drug use that negatively impacts the lives of someone other than the user should be illegal, much like banning second-hand smoke. Outside of that restriction, we should value personal liberty and freedom to make choices about ourselves.
- sneak 12y agoWho are you to condone what others do or don't do to their own bodies and minds? That's like not condoning execution-altering software. It's none of your business what I do with my hardware.
- Osiris 12y agoIt doesn't sound like you read the second part of my post. My point was exactly that while I hold a personal belief about the use and effects of the use of certain substances, that doesn't mean that I have a right to enforce that belief on others.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- phaemon 12y agoI think the problem is with your use of the word "condone". I'm sure you meant it in the sense of "like", but it sounds as though you meant "give permission". I suspect the reply is basically saying, "I didn't ask your permission for anything." :-)
- Osiris 12y agoMerrian-Webster defines "condone" as "to regard or treat (something bad or blameworthy) as acceptable". That's exactly how I meant it.
- tilsammans 12y agoI just finished Chasing the Scream: The First and Last Days of the War on Drugs by Johann Hari. I highly recommend reading it if you're interested to know more about this topic.
- Synaesthesia 12y agoIt is a brilliant, sometimes harrowing first hand account of the effects of the drug war.
- ctolsen 12y agoAnyone interested in the topic should read the LSE report on the Economics of Drug Policy. The facts are staggering, especially on the human and fiscal cost of internal displacement. I bet not many know that Colombia just a few years ago was only beat by Sudan in terms of internal refugees, and it's all due to the drug war. It also gives some perspective to the Western debate – we talk about decriminalisation and healthcare. That is a good step, but it won't help the atrocities committed in the rest of the world. We need to talk about legalisation. http://www.lse.ac.uk/IDEAS/Projects/IDPP/The-Expert-Group-on-the-Economics-of-Drug-Policy.aspx http://www.lse.ac.uk/IDEAS/Projects/IDPP/The-Expert-Group-on...
- Nursie 12y agoIt sorta sickens me that those on the pro-war side of this debate always ignore what happens in South America and parts of Africa. The rhetoric is always about preventing addiction at home, stopping a few American (or British or Australian or whatever) kids from getting hooked and having a tough life. Never mind the destabilised countries, the thousands slaughtered, that's far away and not our problem. Jim-bob having a reduced bank-balance, a hole in his septum or a heart condition from cocaine abuse is far worse, somehow. To the outside world our countries are schizophrenic or just plain hypocritical - buying massive quantities of drugs and at the same time sending out military and quasi-military forces around the world to stop them. The whole thing is crazy and pushes our demand-side problem out to the poorer places on the supply side.
- UweSchmidt 12y agoAgree 100%: War on Drugs is bad, instead legalize/ decriminalize/ provide medical care. The War on Drugs puts massive pressure on South-/Central American countries. End the War on Drugs and this pressure is relieved. HOWEVER, no one seems to spell out exactly who is hypocritical or schizophrenic: The actual people who buy drugs that originate from these countries. People need to actually stop giving their money directly to the Cartels, right?
- Nursie 12y ago
- _yosefk 12y ago"...the impossibility of winning the “war” against theft, burglary, robbery, and fraud has never been used as an argument that these categories of crime should be abandoned." (From Don't Legalize Drugs, http://www.city-journal.org/html/7_2_a1.html http://www.city-journal.org/html/7_2_a1.html)
- Nursie 12y agoWell given these are crimes against another person, rather than 'crimes' against oneself, that argument is a load of bollocks!
- mibbitirc 12y agoDrug usage goes hand in hand with theft. Once you're addicted to drugs, you have to steal to pay for that habit. It's hardly a victimless crime.
- tmp-20150107 12y ago> Once you're addicted to drugs, you have to steal to pay for that habit. Not at all. Of course, you could just get a job that pays enough to support your habit? Software Engineering works for me, for example, and has allowed me to maintain a twenty year heroin habit, almost.
- girvo 12y agoI did the same for six years, though I'm clean now. The people I used to run with were all well paid, too, though that's more a function of how expensive heroin is in Australia.
- girvo 12y agoWhat do you base that on? Because I think you'd be very surprised to see the number of people who take drugs, and the fact that most of them do not resort to theft for their habit.
- Nursie 12y ago
- simonh 12y agoI'm surprised they don't also cite the first war against drugs (actualy, a drug) - prohibition. Exactly the same scenario played out then as is, hopefully, coming to it's inevitable conclusion now in the 'western hemisphere'. If the same thing is starting up again in the East, it's going to be a bloody and chaotic few decades to come before the same lesson gets learned the third time over. Fortunately we do have a largely successful, bloodless war on a drug to learn from. Tobacco abuse is less than half what it was back in the early 70s in the US, and similar declines are seen in many European countries. Advertising campaigns, usage restrictions in public places and high taxes have been very effective, and also meant that the medical costs of treating the effects of tobacco abuse have been more than covered by tax revenues from it's sale in many countries. While campaigns against alcohol abuse have not been as successful, mainly because they have not been as focused on reducing all usage, tax revenues have been high. Normalisation of low levels of use in appropriate circumstances and ammounts have also limited the harmful effects on most abusers and those around them.
- peteretep 12y ago> I'm surprised they don't also cite the first war > against drugs Being a British publication, presumably they'd consider the Opium Wars - where the Brits fought to be allowed to sell the Chinese junk - as the first drug war.
- chippy 12y agoThat was a war for drugs, rather than against them. It was also about fighting for another drug - tea. Tea and coffee also had quite a loud vocal support for prohibition against it in the UK.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoSeveral Asian countries very successfully waged "war" on opium usage, to the benefit of their societies. They killed you if you were caught with any. I'm not a prohibitionist, but we need to drop the lie that a war on drugs has even been tried in the West. Sentences for drug possession are typically avoidable and usually light. What has been done (same as back in alcohol prohibition days) is corrupt law enforcement rackets have been funded to pursue "dealers." Well, we know that doesn't work. What does work is very harsh and uniform punishment for users. Which, I reiterate, has not been tried in the West for over a century.
- ukigumo 12y agoIt's not often that I have the opportunity to feel proud of the legislators in my home country, but Portugal has been on the leading edge of drug prevention and rehabilitation since we moved from a "war on drugs" to a program of health risk prevention and removed the weight of criminal charges and proceedings from the equation. Some interesting articles below: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/02/03/portugal-drug-decriminalization_n_6606056.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/02/03/portugal-drug-decri... http://www.tdpf.org.uk/blog/drug-decriminalisation-portugal-setting-record-straight http://www.tdpf.org.uk/blog/drug-decriminalisation-portugal-...
- baldfat 12y agoThis is my fear. The "War on Drug" really is a health issue, but most people I know that are against the war basically want to smoke more and more pot and/or Libertarians and the reply to stop the war is not and we can help more people.
- rayiner 12y agoMental illness is also a health issue, but our reaction to it is to criminalize homelessness, put people in prison, etc.
- dublinben 12y agoDoes it really matter why someone is against the current failed policies? There are any number of paths that could lead someone to desire change, and none is more legitimate than any other.
- coldpie 12y agoI think your parent commenter's point was, the implied other half to ending the drug war is replacing that policy with another one. What policy does it get replaced with? Just a free-for-all market that a crazy literal libertarian would like? Some sort of regulation similar to our current legal drug market? What about rehabilitation programs? How would those be implemented and what would they cost? Suddenly you've got fiscal conservatives on your back. Ending the drug war is good, but what do we replace it with?
- edward 12y agoUK political party, Cannabis is safer than alcohol (CISTA) is fielding candidates in the UK general election next month. http://cista.org/ http://cista.org/ Funded by one of the co-founders of Bebo, a social network.
- gadders 12y agoI hope they apply this to PEDs as well. They actually have health benefits (as well as drawbacks), rather than just altering your mental state.
- cpursley 12y agoLooks like Rand Paul, a Republican surprisingly, is the only candidate running from either side is taking the correct stance on the "War on Drugs". http://www.ontheissues.org/domestic/Rand_Paul_Drugs.htm http://www.ontheissues.org/domestic/Rand_Paul_Drugs.htm
- bonesmoses 12y agoTell that to Bernie Sanders: http://www.ontheissues.org/senate/bernie_sanders.htm http://www.ontheissues.org/senate/bernie_sanders.htm
- humanrebar 12y ago> Looks like Rand Paul, a Republican surprisingly Sounds like you need to get to know more Republicans.
- jqm 12y agoI'm against the drug war and for people's choice to decide what they want to put in their bodies. I'm also against waste, cruel treatment and general stupidity which are also reasons I oppose the drug war. That being said, I believe drug wars can work. China and opium a century ago and modern day Singapore come to mind. The reason the drug war isn't being won in the West is because it isn't being executed properly. So why not drop the pretense?
- Nursie 12y agoWhat's "properly"? I think (hope) the citizens of the USA and Europe would not put up with people being executed for what we currently consider quite minor offences. I guess in some ways you're right - if this was transformed to total warfare, with no mercy for anyone in any part of it, then it might be won, maybe. But the price is unacceptably high. (Oh, also, Singapore is one small island with one city on it and a comparatively huge security service, it's often considered a sham democracy and a police-state. Cure worse than disease, IMHO)
- jqm 12y agoJust responding to the title (which is not factual). I didn't even read the article. Unacceptable prices and value judgements aside, drug wars _can_ be won and they have before.
- crusso 12y agoIt's really hard to point the finger at just one source, such as the execution of the drug war itself. Maybe the citizens of the USA just aren't serious enough about eliminating drug use, which leads to the election of leaders who aren't serious, which leads to poor execution of the drug war.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Im_Talking 12y agoSo executing people year after year shows that the Singaporian system is working?? Doesn't it show the exact opposite since, you know, they have to continue to execute people? Wouldn't the success of their laws be validated if no one was executed showing that they had eradicated their drug problem?
- discardorama 12y ago"Doesn't work" ?!?! For whom?? It works swimmingly well for the people in power, and the people who love to have control over their citizens!
- joesmo 12y agoThe drug war is a civil war. It divides and breaks up society for horrific purposes. In the US, it's always been racism, a way for the government to put down people of races they could no longer legally murder or enslave. Some 'friendly casualties' in such a war will always be overlooked by any government. It's certainly no coincidence that the ramping up of the drug war by Nixon came only a few years after the passing of civil rights legislation. I'm not as familiar with the histories of countries like China or Russia, but I am curious as to what nefarious purposes their drug war serves. With such scummy, tyrannical regimes, it's easy to imagine a million reasons for the persecution they are and will cause their people. While some people say not to ascribe to evil what can be ascribed to stupidity, I disagree strongly. Evil is just as pervasive and I just cannot believe that this drug war in Asia comes simply from stupidity, especially given the tyrannical governments now perpetuating it. Well, at least the US is now in the proper company with other tyrants--just as our laws are changing. It's hard to estimate the power and money that governments can make when persecuting and oppressing any group of people deemed to be enemies, whether they're deemed so because of drug use, race, religion, etc.
- mc32 12y agoNo, I don't think it's a war of any kind. That's a label used by governments to get buy-in from the public. If it's war, it must be serious and we should fund it seriously. This campaign against drugs is not racist in essence, but it is coincidental with race in some places. However, you'll see the same attitudes toward drugs in homogeneous countries as well as Africa, Latin america and Asia. The policy against drugs comes from a fear it will make citizens beholden to something unproductive. That is drugged up people don't contribute to society and makes people lazy. It also means the government has less influence on these people. They provide unwanted drag. On the other hand, if you want a docile population, do drug them up like they did during the opium wars in Asia. I think any association with race is coincidental. That's to say we'd have had this policy in the US even if we had been 100% homogenous population. However, we do know the policies affected those population most susceptible to the effects of drug addiction. Poor people black and white. Appalachia is just as ravaged by drugs as any place in the us, trailer parks, etc. Poor people can't get treatment, they can't hide their addiction as easily, can't hire competent lawyers, etc. It was never a war though. It was a bad policy. Just like the one child policy in China. It was not a war on families, it was terrible policy.
- btbuildem 12y agoWell, if you consider it from the point of view of law enforcement, private prisons and weapon manufacturers, the wars are working splendidly - lots of jobs for everyone, and tons of profits to be made.
- paulhauggis 12y agoI'm all for drug legalization, however, this should also be a part of the laws: -Businesses should be able to fire someone for being under the influence of any mind-altering substance. The CA proposition a few years back had a clause in there that made it very difficult. Calling addiction a "medical issue" makes it even worse because the differences between recreational use and addiction aren't that easy to distinguish. -The individual should pay for all of their own issues, medical expenses, etc due to drug addiction. Many of the advocates not only want legalization (because it's their choice, their body) but none of the consequences that come along with it (medical bills due to addiction). It's unfair for me, as an individual that chooses not to put those drugs into my body to also have rising medical costs that pay for the people that willingly ingest drugs. -Tort reform. We all know heroin is addictive and will cause many deaths and ruin many lives. If a company sells it and you choose to take it and die, your family shouldn't be able to sue the company or the government. We still have cigarette lawsuits..and it's been known to cause cancer for 50+ years (it's even written on the box). I think my overall issue is that advocates want all of the benefits (ability to use illegal drugs legally) yet also want society to pay for any of the negative effects that come along with it (death, addiction). You should have the choice to legally put anything in your body....but be responsible for anything negative that comes along with it. If you don't have the resources to deal with the consequences, you probably shouldn't be doing it in the first place.
- reseur 12y ago>Businesses should be able to fire someone for being under the influence of any mind-altering substance. TIFU by drinking coffee in the morning...
- Nursie 12y ago>> -Businesses should be able to fire someone for being under the influence of any mind-altering substance. Pretty sure they already can, you do not come into work drunk, for example. >> -The individual should pay for all of their own issues, medical expenses, etc due to drug addiction. ... It's unfair for me ... You already pay lots and lots and lots and lots of money to drug-war enforcement efforts. The cost of health problems related to drugs would be minimal compared to this. Lots of conservatives seem to want all the benefits of drug legalisation (reduced tax bills) without any responsibility (helping out your fellow man). Further, those taxes help keep you safe. You want to be robbed by an addict or do you want to give a few cents to the free-heroin-for-addicts program that keeps them from committing crime and helps them become contributing members of society?
- zouhair 12y agoOf course it works. It all depend on what the goals are. If the goal is to stop people from using drugs, that'll never work. But if it is to make a lot of money for some, it sure works.
- simnim 12y agoFor the sake of sanity let's remember that sugar is at least as addictive as cocaine and heroin. http://www.forbes.com/sites/jacobsullum/2013/10/16/research-shows-cocaine-and-heroin-are-less-addictive-than-oreos/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jacobsullum/2013/10/16/research-... It's probably even more addictive if 94% of lab rats prefer sugar over cocaine. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17668074 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17668074 The majority of drug addicts are victims of abuse. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3051362 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3051362 They need medical / mental health benefits. Drug addiction is clearly a medical issue. Let's treat it as such. We didn't learn our lesson with Alcohol, so we repeated history with the war on drugs. Now we are failing to learn our lesson yet again. Logic, reason, and education are not the driving factors for making drugs illegal. Fear, lack of education, politics, and deep misunderstanding are the true drivers of this insane ideology.