5 ms·
The Tiger Woods Effect: Paralysis by Analysis
- raphar 17y agoI prefer the original article at the The Observer. It describes how you can focus (or refocus when you are already in a self-councious state). http://www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2009/jul/26/sports-psychology-choking http://www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2009/jul/26/sports-psycholog...
- dnewcome 17y agoThank you for posting this related link. I remember reading it a while back and wanted to find it, but it was not in my notes anywhere.
- amichail 17y agoWouldn't players want Woods to win all the time as this brings more money to their sport -- and probably also to them individually?
- harpastum 17y agoProbably not. As much as there are long-term benefits to increasing the popularity of the sport (larger purses in the future, etc.), golf tournaments are a zero-sum game. Everyone wants everyone else to do poorly, so they get a larger quantity of the available money.
- dkasper 17y agoIt wouldn't be interesting if Woods won all the time. In fact I might argue that underdog/Cinderella stories do as much for the sport as superstars.
- rjett 17y agoThose two sentences aren't mutually exclusive. In 2006-2007 when Tiger was on a 7 tournament win streak, golf ratings were up because a lot of people wanted to see Tiger extend his win streak. Complementary to that, a lot of people also tuned in to root for whoever was in contention to upset that streak.
- bmj 17y agoYou don't spend much time around athletes, do you? Athletes compete because they want to do well. Certainly, only a few at one time have a realistic chance of actually winning, but I reckon that most don't want one person/team to win continually. This is easiest to see in US football and baseball leagues--the fans and the league prefer some degree of parity so a single team doesn't dominate the sport.
- jackzombie 17y agoWhile I agree that most people don't want one person/team winning all the time, I believe that this does generate more interest, ie. Many people will take a vested interest in a baseball game so that they can cheer against the Yankees.
- gloob 17y agoCheering against the Yankees would be a waste of time if the Yankees literally won all the time. It would increase people's interest in the game the same way that a trick coin increases people's interest in betting on coin flips.
- idoh 17y agoThis could have a completely rational explanation: If you find yourself overmatched, then it pays to take risks. If I found myself playing golf against Tiger Woods, I'd try higher risk / higher reward shots, because if I stick to my typical game I'm surely going to lose. This would make my score worse on average, but who cares about that when once in a while the bet pays off and I win?
- redorb 17y agoin your example I might care because it would pay off 1: 1million that you beat tiger. I would rather play a decent game with tiger and would hope to shoot my best.
- tudorachim 17y agoThat does make sense, but the article is saying that people screwed up because they overthought their current strategies and played worse than normally, not because they overcorrected in the other direction and took more risks.
- idoh 17y agoThe only facts quoted in the article are: Tiger woods in dominant, and "[w]hen the superstar entered a tournament, every other golfer took, on average, 0.8 more strokes. This effect was even more pronounced when Woods was playing well." Based solely on the above they draw their conclusions. I'm just pointing out that there is a simpler and more rational conclusion one could draw.
- Dove 17y agoIndeed. This part constitutes the science: "When the superstar entered a tournament, every other golfer took, on average, 0.8 more strokes." The rest is speculation.
- neilc 17y agoIn fact, even that phrasing is slightly misleading, because it suggests causality -- I suspect the evidence only supports correlation. The article is a particularly idiotic example of uninformed speculation passing for science journalism.
- antimora 17y agoBtw, I highly recommend the author's (Jonah Lehrer) book "How We Decide". It's well written and informative.
- joe_the_user 17y agoWow, this give an experimental basis to the distinction between "conscious competence" and "unconscious competence". The thing I would be very curious about is whether other activities have the same dynamic or rather, in what activities is "thinking" more necessary in even when one achieves competence?
- wisty 17y agoGood golfers take risks. When Tiger Woods starts playing, they stop taking risks, so they end up being worse golfers. That's another explanation.
- tcskeptic 17y agoTony Schwartz talks about some of the things that seperates elite performers from the merely very good in his book The Power of Full Engagement (HBR article here: http://hbr.harvardbusiness.org/2001/01/the-making-of-a-corporate-athlete/ar/1 http://hbr.harvardbusiness.org/2001/01/the-making-of-a-corpo... ) One of the points he makes is that the very elite (he studied tennis players particularly) have rituals that they perform that allow them to reocover, refocus, and rest very efficiently. And that the more often an athlete stretches themselves physically or mentally beyond their own limits and relies on these rituals to help them succeed, the more powerful and effective the rituals become. So even without accounting for players changing their own playing style because of Tiger, they may suffer from impaired performance because they are simply not as practiced at performing at a high level within the crazy media and fan circus that surrounds Tiger Woods as Tiger Woods himself is. He clearly has developed and repeatedly stressed and practiced those rituals of performance within that environment far more than any one else has had chance to. Schwartz goes on to relate this to performance as a "Corporate Athlete" but his tips have far more applicability in my mind to the startup environment than to the typical corporate environment.