5 ms·
On the backs of 1099 workers. Uber needs to be work on some social responsibility. Do we really want a country where the majority are struggling to serve the fe
by sschueller 12y ago
On the backs of 1099 workers. Uber needs to be work on some social responsibility. Do we really want a country where the majority are struggling to serve the few?
- RyanMcGreal 12y agoThe ingenious twist of American ideology is that so many of the many perceive themselves as aspiring members of the few, and hence oppose the kinds of policy that would improve conditions for the many.
- minthd 12y agoDefinetly ingenious. How did it got to that, pure coincidence ? or something more ?
- technofiend 12y ago"Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires." John Steinbeck
- dylanjermiah 12y agoThey're free to work for whoever they want. No one is forcing anyone to drive for Uber, they're doing it voluntarily. Why forcibly stop consensual behaviour?
- codecamper 12y agowhat is your point? you are saying that they are not forced into it and so therefore everything is A OK?
- dylanjermiah 12y agoIf people are consensually engaging in an activity and it is not harmful in anyway to others, it is perfectly fine.
- sschueller 12y agoThe problem is it is harmful to others. There is always someone who is willing to work for less or worse conditions which collectively affects everyone.
- tech_is_amoral 12y agoCompetition is what allows us to do more with fewer resources, which makes us all better off.
- codecamper 12y agothen theres that darn network effect. oops!
- tech_is_amoral 12y agoSorry it must be one of those days where I'm having trouble making the connection. Would you mind elaborating a little bit?
- toomuchtodo 12y agoReally? It appears that's not the case, and "competition" means those with leverage (both with capital and technology) are able to capture an ever increasing amount of wealth compared to the rest of the working class. Funny how "competition" is great as long as you're on the "winning" side.
- dhruvbird 12y agoIs prostitution perfectly fine?
- tech_is_amoral 12y agoAssuming there's no coercion occurring, I would say yes.
- mfringel 12y agoAssertion. Platitude, assertion. Rhetorical question.
- dpatru 12y agoPlease state your disagreement.
- mfringel 12y agoEmployers shifting externalities onto employees is something that labor law has been created to mitigate for decades. The fact that Uber has found a loophole (which is being closed quickly) does not make it "okay, because it's consensual". Also, I have issues with semantically null statements that could have been written by a Markov Chainer that's seeded with text from the Mises Institute, but that's a more personal problem.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 12y ago- competitors (aka normal delivery companies) pay benefits to their employees, so Uber has an unfair advantage because they don't. - because of pooling it is more efficient overall to force companies or governments to pay benefits than it is to have individuals self-insure
- ashark 12y agoFreedom of choice comes in degrees, with no sharp divide between free and not free. The freedom of an individual to negotiate with employers exists in a context of wild inequality in negotiating position, information asymmetry, and coordination problems among workers that lead to a race to the bottom (absent collective bargaining or government intervention). I don't know enough about Uber and their workers to comment on that in particular, but I don't think that "they could have not signed on, so it's OK" is necessarily a strong position from which to oppose collective intervention, governmental or otherwise, without qualification of the degree to which participants in an agreement were free to make their decisions, and what the consequences of thier decisions will be on the choices available to others. Since we're talking about low-wage workers and a giant company, my guess is that closer examination of those considerations won't aid an anti-intervention or pro-market (for common definitions of pro-market) argument.
- viscanti 12y agoIt doesn't seem an issue of workers negotiating with the individual business. You're redefining "freedom of choice" to mean freedom to negotiate with a company. It's clear that the parent meant freedom to choose when/where they work. If there were better alternatives, people would chose that over Uber. The fact that they aren't choosing other things shows that they're making an informed decision that they believe is best for them given their alternatives. We're free to wonder about if things could be even better for the people who made the choice to work for Uber, which is where some kind of negotiation between workers and Uber would come in, but that seems to miss the point completely. If there were better alternatives provided by any other company, most of the workers would go there.
- ashark 12y ago> You're redefining "freedom of choice" to mean freedom to negotiate with a company. It's clear that the parent meant freedom to choose when/where they work. Can't it be both? Really, I don't see how the two can be considered separately. The individual negotiation occurs in the context of the broader field of choices and consequences available, and of the relative power of the participants (which may, perhaps most relevantly, be considered as their ability to cope with any harm that results from saying "no" to a given offer). > The fact that they aren't choosing other things shows that they're making an informed decision that they believe is best for them given their alternatives. I don't agree that the fact of a choice having been made gives us any insight in to the degree to which it was "informed" but otherwise, sure. My point is: that someone said "yes" and that it was within their power to say "no", is a pretty poor metric for freedom per se, and a bit more than that is going to be needed to demonstrate that (say) government intervention would necessarily be inappropriate or harmful.
- ghaff 12y agoOne can simultaneously support allowing most consensual behavior such as matching buyers and sellers of services through technology while also being somewhat uncomfortable with the fact that many of the seller jobs being created are relatively low-paid contractors while the buyers are more often than not urban professionals. At some level, this is nothing new--dog walkers anyone?--but it's the focus of a lot of these new businesses. (All the while, trying to simply automate away as many of those jobs as possible.)