8 ms·
David Simon on Baltimore’s Anguish
- nrao123 12y agoDavid Simon is a national treasure. The Wire had lots of scenes on how metrics & incentives screwed up Baltimore city. Here is a great scene talking about metrics/stats from The Wire - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xH_6_8NOfwI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xH_6_8NOfwI Article also refers to Martin Malley's ambition to be Maryland's governor that really screwed up the incentives and cooking of the books. "How do you reward cops? Two ways: promotion and cash. That's what rewards a cop. If you want to pay overtime pay for having police fill the jails with loitering arrests or simple drug possession or failure to yield, if you want to spend your municipal treasure rewarding that, well the cop who’s going to court 7 or 8 days a month — and court is always overtime pay — you're going to damn near double your salary every month. On the other hand, the guy who actually goes to his post and investigates who's burglarizing the homes, at the end of the month maybe he’s made one arrest. It may be the right arrest and one that makes his post safer, but he's going to court one day and he's out in two hours. So you fail to reward the cop who actually does police work. But worse, it’s time to make new sergeants or lieutenants, and so you look at the computer and say: Who's doing the most work? And they say, man, this guy had 80 arrests last month, and this other guy’s only got one. Who do you think gets made sergeant? And then who trains the next generation of cops in how not to do police work? I’ve just described for you the culture of the Baltimore police department amid the deluge of the drug war, where actual investigation goes unrewarded and where rounding up bodies for street dealing, drug possession, loitering such – the easiest and most self-evident arrests a cop can make – is nonetheless the path to enlightenment and promotion and some additional pay. That’s what the drug war built, and that’s what Martin O’Malley affirmed when he sent so much of inner city Baltimore into the police wagons on a regular basis. "When you say, end the drug war, you mean basically decriminalize or stop enforcing? Medicalize the problem, decriminalize — I don't need drugs to be declared legal, but if a Baltimore State’s Attorney told all his assistant state’s attorneys today, from this moment on, we are not signing overtime slips for court pay for possession, for simple loitering in a drug-free zone, for loitering, for failure to obey, we’re not signing slips for that: Nobody gets paid for that bullshit, go out and do real police work. If that were to happen, then all at once, the standards for what constitutes a worthy arrest in Baltimore would significantly improve. Take away the actual incentive to do bad or useless police work, which is what the drug war has become.
- jokoon 12y agoYeah, legalizing heroin is not going to fix the problem, medicalizing it might cost a lot, and you won't be able to compete with drugs dealers. Users might buy from dealers anyway. If you want to remove the dealer's profits, you have to compete with drug dealers, but it has to be healthy, you have to treat users and remove the incentive to use drugs, and it's a very tricky thing to do. I really don't know how to do this, but it boils down to the same problem of unemployment and crime. How do you integrate people into a healthy social model ? Poverty and economic opportunity is still at the root of the problem.
- soylentcola 12y agoAt the very least, I feel like not throwing someone in jail for being a drug addict or smalltime dealer would be a good start. Too many people resort to drugs to escape despair (if only temporarily) or poverty (through working the only business that seems to be "hiring" in your town). Addressing the root causes of this is indeed difficult, but you exacerbate the problem when those same people who need solutions are saddled with criminal records for life.
- ryandrake 12y agoMeasuring a police officer's performance by number of arrests is like measuring a developer's performance by number of lines of code.
- bobwaycott 12y agoIn which you could learn a thing or two about how "policing" works in Baltimore. Or, in which you could learn who the other "thugs" are. Way too many people across the internet think they can accurately and justifiably levy blame on parents, kids, criminals, communities, rioters, etc., all the while granting massive, unquestioning benefit-of-the-doubt to the police. Decades of brutal and unconstitutional policing in Baltimore is just as much a part of the equation here. I'd run, too, if I lived in this shit show. I'd riot when the anger, fear, rage, and hate boiled to the surface after yet another man met his last day on earth at the hands of the authorities. I wouldn't tell my kids they have nothing to fear if they just obey the law. I wouldn't tell my spouse they have nothing to fear if they just comply with the police. I wouldn't feel safe and secure when I saw a cop. I wouldn't feel comfortable knowing I "have nothing to hide". I wouldn't judge the guy I see with a rap sheet when I know that rap sheet was built from arrests by cops who get paid overtime for arrests, who aren't subjected to any rigorous accountability, who get to invent "probable cause". I wouldn't sit around smugly thinking those who are victimized by abuses of power "must have deserved it". I certainly wouldn't dare judge with ignorant superiority people who live in a shit-hole where drugs and crime are how one survives. I would know the cops can't be trusted--I'd see it every day of my whole life. And yet few try to understand having to live like that. They judge from white skin on comfortable suburban couches and fancy phones in nice neighborhoods that have not been brutalized by badges for decades. Understand the way you see and experience life and the world around you has nothing at all to do with the way life is or even can be for anybody else. Understand that your experiences in life do not in any way translate to being actual, persistent properties of reality everywhere. Understand life in middle-class white America, and all the privilege that comes with it and protects you, doesn't in any way translate to the existence experienced by others elsewhere. Hell, it might not even translate to the existence of those in your own neighborhood. Or, you know, don't bother to understand it. That's your choice. But do the nation and the victims of these horrid conditions a solid, and just don't speak about what people who live in areas infested by unaccountable and tyrannical brutal cops should do when another person they know is arrested with a high probability of bogus "probable cause". Or charged with fabricated crimes to serve a political and social agenda. Or beaten and otherwise abused unnecessarily--but, of course, after the officer has yelled the appropriate ass-covering phrases that make all the white people think they couldn't possibly be bullshitting or abusing their power. Or killed. Or all of the above. Remember the 60s, when white people saw horrific violence on their TVs, and it shocked them out of their decades-long stupor and prompted them to get off their asses, and get into the streets with those who were being brutalized by badges? They didn't sit back and tell themselves the people on the bridge in Selma were asking for it. They didn't say the victims must have deserved it. They didn't excuse the police brutality. It sucks to say it, but that was a turning point moment that legitimized the civil rights struggle in the national consciousness in a way that had not been so before. The brutality was televised, and the people woke up. In a nation built on and for privilege, shit doesn't change much until those with privilege stand up. Another man died at the hands of the police. His life was extinguished by something they did. He's never going to draw another breath, while those responsible for his death still breathe. There are people who love him who will never see him again. Never hold him again. Never hug him. Never kiss him. Never pat him on the back. Never hear his thoughts. Our moral compasses are completely fucked when meaningless, inanimate, material shit being damaged and destroyed ranks as a higher concern more worthy of conversation and cameras than yet another man's life being taken with impunity by those with a badge.
- drawkbox 12y agoDavid Simon on why he created The Wire and set it in Baltimore: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYXNdELqCe4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYXNdELqCe4
- bshimmin 12y agoI love David Simon's writing (and "The Wire" is the best thing ever to be on TV, in my opinion), but I was unable to read this article because the secondary navigation ("Popular on Facebook" ... "Q&A", etc) which kept swooping in every time I scrolled up drove me utterly insane. The fact that the actual text was overly large and offset strangely to the right also did not help. Why do people have to ruin content in this way?!
- Singletoned 12y agoI agree with the first bit, but I use a JS blocker and had no problems reading it as none of those things happened. You should definitely try one if that really bothers you.
- humanrebar 12y agoI don't see the political monoculture mentioned in any analysis about Baltimore, New York, St. Louis, Detroit, etc. These cities have been basically one party rule for fifty years (or more). If the police become too brutal or incentives become perverse, the party is not thrown out of office. If the mayor or council members are shown to be corrupt, the party is not thrown out of office. There's no real accountability. To be clear, I don't think the problem is unique to big cities. Political monoculture certainly happens in rural areas, but the tragedies out there (even more extreme poverty, lack of opportunity, population decline, meth epidemic) aren't seen as acute for whatever reason. I do think the problem is that, at some level, you can't credibly say "You messed up -- the other party gets a shot at running things" in much (most?) of the country. To some degree, the problem is the two-party system. If the district is liberal (as is the case in Baltimore), there needs to be at least two credible liberal alternatives. Maybe it's time to consider making room for more parties, for the benefit of local communities if nothing else.
- brownbat 12y ago> the party is not thrown out of office Where I grew up, we had two radically oppositional factions that just happened to wear the same label during national elections. The number of viable parties isn't always a good measure of political diversity or the capacity for churn in government. Maybe they're correlated in Baltimore, though, I'm less sure there. City governments have fewer moving parts, so they can get captured by a strong network of insiders and the network can stay in power for decades.
- pjc50 12y agoThis would definitely help. The only way to a multiparty system is non-FPTP voting; one of the preferential schemes like STV. Local government is often bad in a lot of countries, but one of the things about America is that its sheer size makes it unlikely that the national or state government will take it upon itself to "fix" a broken regional or city government. And if it did it would be objected to on principle.
- maxerickson 12y ago