14 ms·
Secret Shuts Down
- kra34 12y agoHow much do Unicorn horns fetch on the black market?
- xrange 12y agoPound for pound, about the same as black swan foie gras.
- sharkweek 12y agoFor the curious, pulled their deal history from PitchBook: Secret raised their B last July at a post valuation just over 130M (http://i.imgur.com/jNXw5PZ.png http://i.imgur.com/jNXw5PZ.png). They had some major investors backing them up, and then the hype train just... stopped. I remember so many people being so high on it when it launched, with several friends all raving about how fun/addicting it was, then just poof it disappeared from conversation. Hearing that the founders got some cash off the table (article from last summer - http://www.businessinsider.com/secret-founders-pocket-6-million-in-25-million-fundraise-2014-7 http://www.businessinsider.com/secret-founders-pocket-6-mill...). While I always thought that seems like a good thing, I can't help but let my mind wander a bit as I know if I were given a nice chunk of change like that so early, it might be kind of hard to keep focus.
- petercooper 12y agoI remember so many people being so high on it when it launched, with several friends all raving about how fun/addicting it was, then just poof it disappeared from conversation. Pure speculation, but I think trolls/frauds took it over. I say this as a Secret troll myself. I knew the odds of the data (linked to my FB account) becoming public was too high to post real secrets, so I used to just experiment with what got people liking or leaving comments instead. Which was amusing.. until I could tell a lot of people had started doing the same. So I stopped using it.
- pjc50 12y agoDid it always have the FB login? Could that have been what killed it?
- petercooper 12y agoI could be wrong, but when I signed up (not early but around the time it first hit the headlines) I thought it was the only way to sign up, or at least the only useful way (since you needed friends and friends-of-friends to see secrets from).
- SandersAK 12y agoInvestors (and the team) were looking at the wrong numbers. In apps, it's basically all down to having meteoric growth week over week. It can't be based on spikes as this was. Taking money off the table in a B makes sense for the founders, and I can't blame them for leveraging their situation. Ultimately this falls on the investors for biting on hype, and not having a deeper understanding of the product (and it's potential)or the founders (and their potential). edited for clarity.
- sharkweek 12y agoTotally makes sense - but I also completely get why the investors would bite on hype - missing the next billion dollar company is way worse than incorrectly picking a few duds.
- untog 12y agoA $35m dud, though. That's not small fry.
- erichmond 12y agoExactly right, this is a very important message here that should be taken away by future (and current) entrepreneurs.
- josu 12y agoI don't know, at a 130m valuation, a 100x exit was no longer possible, and even a 10x didn't even seem that likely.
- look_lookatme 12y agoCrunchbase says they have 11-25 employees... how did they burn through all of that money? Is it possible they are pivoting or returning money to investors?
- ascorbic 12y agoThey haven't. The article says they're returning the money.
- krschultz 12y agoFrom the article it doesn't sound like they ran out of money, sounds like the growth has stalled and key talent has left. I bet the money goes back to investors, it doesn't sound like the team is still in place to pivot.
- cwilson 12y agoVery likely returning money to investors.
- emp_ 12y agoNoobie question: what happens with the off the table cash?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nulltype 12y agoI'm guessing it remains firmly off the table.
- downandout 12y ago>http://i.imgur.com/jNXw5PZ.png http://i.imgur.com/jNXw5PZ.png Here was the intended use of the $25M: "The funding will be used to implement two new features, a Facebook login and the ability to follow posts on a certain topic". This is what is wrong with Silicon Valley today. An afternoon project for a single developer gets $25M from investors. Please, someone give me just $10M....I've already implemented Facebook login for my apps.
- GCA10 12y agoThat's hilarious! In Web 1.0, people raised $7 million to buy a domain name. Needing $12.5 million to implement a Facebook login ($25/2 projects) is even more ridiculous.
- smt88 12y agoBox paid 7 figures for the Box.com domain name, so I wouldn't say that raising money to buy domains is dead yet.
- billmalarky 12y agoBox bought box.com roughly 6 years after they launched, they were already wildly successful (as box.net).
- blumkvist 12y agoHas box had a profitable quarter yet?
- burger_moon 12y agoIt doesn't look like it. https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ABOX&fstype=ii&ei=IQpCVdnxFozrsQfT0YHwDw https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ABOX&fstype=ii&ei=IQp...
- anonbanker 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bifrost 12y agonooooooooooooo
- robbiet480 12y agoI hope that Ping [0], a side project by the Secret team that has nothing to do with Secret itself, is going to stick around in some capacity. I loved the little knowledge bits that it sent me randomly. I just checked the app and other than a couple weather notifications, the last curated content was pushed to me 2 weeks ago :( [0]: http://iamping.com/ http://iamping.com/
- nedwin 12y agoThis is going to be used as a case study of why not to let founders take cash off the table in early rounds for years to come.
- tommoor 12y agoI believe it was highly criticized even at the time...
- dguaraglia 12y agoTo be honest, the investors knew what they were signing at the time. If they didn't do their due diligence to figure out how the application was going to make any money, they deserve what they had coming for them. That's the kind of shitty "let's throw money out the window, in case we hit one successful startup" attitude that'll get us in a bubble.
- Frondo 12y agoFounders acting in their own self-interest? That sounds like capitalism in action to me.
- CPLX 12y agoThis is hardly unprecedented, it has happened for oversubscribed companies that subsequently imploded multiple times in the last few years.
- joshstrange 12y agoWhile I have heard of Secret the majority of my friends who are still in college haven't and it's all about Yik Yak on campus right now.
- r0naa 12y agoSame here. I am curious as to what caused Secret to disappear so suddenly. I am not a power user of social networks but something that really struck me was the really poor UI of Secret relatively to the crystal clear interface of YikYak.
- cahoodle 12y agoYep agreed, same confusion here. TechCrunch seems to cite the slow response to Cyberbullying criticism as one of the reasons for Secret's downfall, but doesn't YikYak have the same problem, if not worse with college students?? What gives?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- danso 12y agoI would've never understood the appeal of these anonymous apps over something like Reddit (in which you can be as anonymous as you'd like) if I hadn't had a job on campus, where YikYak is well-frequented, and a far better source of breaking trivial news (i.e. what is all that yelling outside about?) than anything else...using YikYak periodically has made me realize again how easy it is to underestimate the appeal of less friction...including the friction of having to deal with users and their user histories. On the other hand, it's a shitshow when some topic like Greeks vs. non-Greeks or Middle East politics comes up...and having no way to filter the noise, either by user or by topic, ends up killing the enjoyment of the app. Yikyak is interesting because of its popularity on campus...but anywhere else, and it's not something I'm compelled to check at all. I imagine the same thing happened with Secret after it stopped being the gossip platform for Silicon Valley people
- ceejayoz 12y agoYikYak added muting by user just recently.
- arprocter 12y agoYeah, it's an option when you "report" something. Although assuming muted users continue to post controversial things, in the long run it may just lead to less reporting.
- denzil_correa 12y ago> I would've never understood the appeal of these anonymous apps over something like Reddit Recently, we did some analysis (sensitivity, type, potential audience and linguistic characterists) on the content posted on anonymous social media like Whisper [0]. Most of the posts were about Confessions, Relationships, Meetup and QnA/Advice. [0] http://socialnetworks.mpi-sws.org/papers/anonymity_shades.pdf http://socialnetworks.mpi-sws.org/papers/anonymity_shades.pd...
- rjaco31 12y agoI'm not sure I understood your point. You have all of this on reddit.
- xutopia 12y agoI stopped using it when they changed the app design to what it currently is. I loved it when it was a picture app.
- hiby007 12y agoWell in the last few months activities in the app was similar to omegle. People posting nude photos and stuff. I think the curation of content was a huge challenge for them., and also not to mention the new app design was not at all intuitive with lots and lots of bugs. But having said that, I had lot of hope in this app.
- minimaxir 12y agoHere's the official Medium post by the cofounder, in which there is confirmation that they are returning the money to investors: https://medium.com/secret-den/sunset-bc18450478d5 https://medium.com/secret-den/sunset-bc18450478d5 The post also includes the phrase "incredible journey" verbatim.
- narsil 12y agoWas that a reference to this tumblr: http://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/ http://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/ Pretty appropriate.
- teraflop 12y agoTechnically, the curator of that Tumblr account created it to criticize acquihires, not shutdowns in general. From the "What is an incredible journey?" page: > Companies go broke all the time. It’s unfortunate and it may mean a service you love will close. But some things just don’t work out. [...] This is what is galling. A company that can afford to pay millions for some new staff but not for what those staff built. The people who used the service, and invested their belief and time in uploading photos, or forming friendships, or logging data, are left to find new virtual homes while their former hosts enjoy a nice (if possibly delayed) payday. -- http://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/post/89180616013/what-is-an-incredible-journey http://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/post/89180616013/what... Although admittedly, from an end-user's perspective, the effects are the same no matter the reason for the shutdown.
- rdl 12y agoIt seems kind of crazy to me that people talk about startups and try to apply completely the same model for everything to: 1) A social app like this, which is essentially hype-based and self reinforcing. Success seems entirely down to virality and adoption, followed by monetization. 2) Some very vertical market focused SAAS offering which can be developed with minimal outside capital, own a niche, and where capital can then be applied to expand to other verticals, accelerate the sales process, etc. (Say, a scheduling application for vets) 3) A capital intensive project in a well understood field (IAAS, hardware, lab stuff, etc.) 4) Entirely new technology deployment (not discovery, which tends to be hugeco or lab, but first commercialization) Clearly there are some commonalities, but there are a lot of areas like employee vesting periods, how you recruit, etc. which probably should be different in these different kinds of companies, but tend to be the same.
- DaniFong 12y agoSpot on. A lot of what's very challenging for today's web startups, like hiring, is easy for startups in cleantech, since there's so few funded startups. Conversely, it feels an order of magnitude more challenging to raise the money in clean tech...
- hkmurakami 12y ago"It rode the hype to massive funding, which allowed the two founders, David Byttow and Bader-Wechseler to each take $3 million off the table. They essentially traded stock for cash, putting money in their pockets though the business wasn’t earning any." Wow. I guess their round was oversubscribed so they were able to sell this to the vcs. This is the first case where I heard of where a startup failed recently after founders took significant money off the table. I wonder if vcs will be able to use this as an argument to combat founders wanting to do the same in the future. I have mixed feelings about the whole affair but I have to hand it to the founders. That was really smart of them to take life changing money when they could.
- carrotleads 12y agoVC's offer this deal only when they are desperate to have an entry. So yeah some VC's may use this argument but if the startup isn't desperate its the VC who will have to make the concession.
- abalone 12y ago"Secret will hand its remaining cash back to investors" Minus the $6M the founders took off the table? If they keep it.. if ever there were a case for blacklisting founders, this is it. It is definitely NOT cool to pull a move like that. You want to cash out early a little because you've been boostrapping, ok, but if you then bail on the company and shut it down within a year, then you start to look like a fraud who knew the company was in trouble and took advantage of investors.
- ucha 12y agoThe whole point of taking money off the table is to keep it when the company goes bust. What you're describing is more similar to a loan where the collateral would be a slice of equity.
- DaniFong 12y agoThat is absolutely not true. The much more sensible reason is to take enough off the table to align investors and the management by (a) making sure the management isn't worrying about personal cash day to day, and (b) allowing the managers to prefer a home run swing rather than an early acquisition. It's always controversial, and never more so in my memory than here.
- abalone 12y agoWhat? "The point" of selling equity for cash is to get liquidity. That is the justification for allowing founders to do it early, not to reward them when their company goes bust. In fact, when executives sell a bunch of stock right before public companies announce bad news or go bust it often warrants an insider trading investigation.
- jonknee 12y agoWhat else would you want that liquidity for? Paying off the founders lets investors worry less about them wanting to sell before the investors want to sell (the investors don't have 99% of their net worth in the startup like the founders likely do). It would be nuts to try and claw back that money. The founders surely had remaining equity which is now worthless, everyone is taking a hair cut. > In fact, when executives sell a bunch of stock right before public companies announce bad news or go bust it often warrants an insider trading investigation. They didn't just do this, the last round was in July 2014. It was a flash in the pan.
- CPLX 12y agoPaging Michael O. Church to this discussion.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- austenallred 12y agoI thought secret was a really, really cool idea. I downloaded the app and played with it for a few days. After the hype died down, the app was almost 100% about sexual fantasies, coming out of the closet, and having been beaten/molested as a child. I can't be sure, but it seemed to me that the "upvote/like" mechanism boosting posts to the top (with no validity required) turned Secret into an enormous, "Who can say the most absurd clickbait thing" contest. It got tiring, and I deleted the app. Having talked with a few other people about Secret, they said the same thing.
- dguaraglia 12y agoThis was exactly my experience, even before the hype died down. 99% of the posts were from my gay friends (and friends of friends) talking about some sexual fantasy or sexual encounter. It was simply not compelling content, so about two weeks in I deleted it. I wonder if there was something in the marketing or the initial group of people that created some zeitgeist that eventually killed the idea? I'd be interested to know if they actively made some effort to try and get out of that rut.
- jgrahamc 12y agoWe curated one of the most amazingly talented teams... Curated! #help
- softbuilder 12y agoI hit a speedbump pretty fast when they wanted me to give up my address book. Yik Yak never asked for that. Yik Yak is still on my phone. Both are kind of crappy ideas, but if there was a clear winner it was the people that just let me use the damn app.
- beat 12y agoFrom my very limited perspective from outside Silicon Valley, Secret looked almost like an exercise in Silly Valley self-parody - like an elaborate joke that went too far. Did it implode? Yeah, sure. Did it ever make sense in the first place? Not really. pg says that great ideas often look like bad ideas. But I think it's also true that bad ideas often look like great ideas.
- suyash 12y agoI knew day one the idea and execution was going to fail.
- prezjordan 12y agoYou could say this about every single startup, and you'd be right 99.9% of the time. The other 0.1% you'd find a way to make yourself right. It's a really, really silly thing to say.
- notastartup 12y agoI certainly don't think this is the end. Was writing a comment but decided I will post it on my blog https://blog.scrape.it/secret-shutting-down-isnt-the-end https://blog.scrape.it/secret-shutting-down-isnt-the-end
- nlh 12y agoThis has been a fascinating story to watch unfold (and experience as a user.) When Secret came out, the addiction bug bit me hard too -- it was _extremely_ compelling. I posted. My friends posted. Everyone was checking Secret obsessively. People were "communicating" with their exes (or so they thought), people were guessing who was posting what. It was fun. It was interesting. It pulled some emotional heartstrings (I had a few interactions with "friends" who I was pretty certain I would never have spoken with in real life - i.e. bad breakups, etc.) Then it took a nasty turn. There was gossip, there were attacks. They didn't get too bad, but the tone changed. Then they released the Android app. More users signed up. It started to take on a high school feeling ("omg my crush winked at me"). It got more popular. Then, at least in SF, it started being almost entirely about gay sexual fantasies. Friends in my circle started using it less, so it got less interesting to me. Eventually I stopped using it when nobody I knew was posting. After that, I stopped following. They did some massive redesign which seemed terrible, and I didn't really pay attention after that. In the end, it was a niche fad that had particular appeal if you were a tech person in SF. All the gossip - as taboo as it was - was interesting and compelling (I admit it!). It was a fun, exciting, interesting fad, but it succumbed to the sort of thing fads usually succumb to -- time. The problem with these sorts of things - flash in the pan community-specific fads - is that they're _incredibly_ hard to sustain, and even harder to monetize as a business. I certainly understand the instinct of VCs to throw money at a hot app experiencing meteoric growth (and I doubly understand the response of the founders to take both the investment and the secondary $), but it was a longshot to start with. Frankly, I admire them for giving it a shot, recognizing the reality, and returning the leftover capital. Well and rationally played all around, me thinks.
- timr 12y ago"When Secret came out, the addiction bug bit me hard too -- it was _extremely_ compelling....Then it took a nasty turn. There was gossip, there were attacks. They didn't get too bad, but the tone changed." And all of that, from what I recall, in the course of maybe three months. It wasn't hard to predict the decline -- the Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory has been around since what, 2004? Maybe the investors who dump money into this kind of flash-in-the-pan stuff ought to wait a few minutes before signing the term sheets. But, oh yeah...because we're in a white-hot investment market, the Fear of Missing Out (aka Fear of the Greater Fool) doesn't let you stop to think.
- gsibble 12y agoI've never been more addicted to an app than when Secret first came out. It was all the rage in SF. I had to force myself to delete it after a few weeks in order to get back to productivity. I completely understand the hype. Personally, I feel this is a story about poor execution. They changed the nature of the app so significantly over time that it lost its appeal and never expanded successfully beyond the bay area. Shame.....it was so much fun and they are such a talented team.
- smt88 12y ago> never expanded successfully beyond the bay area This seems to be something of a meme. The Bay Area is a truly unique and bizarre place. People are incredibly busy and tech-savvy, and they're willing to spend way more on minor conveniences than people elsewhere. It seems like lots of companies raise on their explosive growth in and around the SV community. It may extend to people with similar demographics in other cities, but it's still a niche. I'm also thinking of all those gourmet snack-delivery companies, laundry-delivery, etc. Those might make a few million in revenue some day, but they're never going to have high margins or universal appeal.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dvirsky 12y agoIt went extremely viral in Israel about a year ago. At first with the start-up community that's very connected to SF used it for internal gossip and anonymous whining and dissing. Then it expanded naturally to young creative types (developers, designers, bloggers, journalists, etc) who are connected to the start-up scene, and became big in the gay community in Tel-Aviv, that highly overlaps both groups. And then the mainstream media started raving about it, and it exploded with the masses and especially teens. At this point it just became a cesspool of online bullying for teens, and I lost interest in following its path. There was even a proposed law banning it in Israel or something (http://pando.com/2014/08/28/israel-becomes-latest-country-to-try-to-ban-secret-bullying-app/ http://pando.com/2014/08/28/israel-becomes-latest-country-to...). But seeing this expansion graph over a period of 2-3 weeks last summer was fascinating.
- fredfoobar42 12y agoGood, and good riddance. Anyone who invested in Secret is a fucking moron. You can't monetize anonymous messaging, and no established company would buy technology they could build in an afternoon hackathon for the cost of a couple cases of Red Bull. If you need proof, 4chan's run at a loss for over a decade. Any investor in a VC fund that invested in Secret should sue their fund for mismanagement of money.
- denzil_correa 12y ago> You can't monetize anonymous messaging I have always been curious about this part. What are the reasons you think one can not monetize anonymous messaging?
- danieltillett 12y agoWhat the op is saying that nobody has yet worked out a way to monetise anonymous messaging. I can think of a few ways that it could be done (none ethical), but the major problem is that as the barrier to entry in this market is so low it is hard to prevent your user base defecting if you try. There is little network effect and no content ownership by the users to prevent them walking away.
- notahacker 12y agoYou can slap ads on anything. But the chance of slapping enough ads on a service to earn a multiple of a £130M valuation is pretty slim at the best of times, and when it's part of a trend of new "social" apps whose distinguishing feature is that they don't have network effects or targeting... VCs backing startups whose primary hope of a major return is to get enough eyeballs to make Facebook nervous enough to buy them deserve to take losses more than most.
- denzil_correa 12y ago> it's part of a trend of new "social" apps whose distinguishing feature is that they don't have network effects or targeting... May I indulge in a bit more? In these anonymous social apps, it is made explicitly clear that you are anonymous but traceable. It means that the service can identify your unique mobile device identity as it wishes to. You are ONLY anonymous in the eyes of the users of the app; in terms of the service provider there is NO difference.
- nostrademons 12y agoThis shutdown - and some of the comments here that indicate how nasty Secret had become before it died - is quite interesting in light of the conversation surrounding Google's Real Names Only policy. Secret cofounders David Byttow and Chris Bader-Wechseler were both veterans of Google+. Byttow, in particular, I recall being quite well-respected as someone who got shit done, quietly and efficiently, by the rest of the G+ team. I didn't know him personally, but I had a few professional dealings with him where I found him to be a straight-shooter that was remarkably effective and helpful. When I heard of the product concept for Secret, my first thought was "Woah, somebody's finally decided to take the other side of the stupid Real Names policy and build a social network that's completely anonymous." Apparently that doesn't work either, and when you do that, people hate you just as much. My take-away from this is that social software is remarkably hard, and that whatever you do, people will hate you. The social sites that survive - like Reddit, Flickr, and Facebook - are those that very carefully balance everyone's competing desires, making just enough changes to keep everyone slightly disgruntled but not enough to leave the site. The ones that die - like Secret, G+, LiveJournal - are the ones that either do nothing to moderate or that introduce heavy-handed blanket policies. (4chan, as always, remains inexplicable; somehow it is still going strong despite being a cesspool. Maybe that's the whole point of it, though, to be the Internet's honey pot of bad behavior.)
- maxerickson 12y ago4chan isn't a cesspool though, that's just an image they project to push away people who would respond to such pushing (approximately, the olds). (There are certainly parts of it that are risky clicks though)
- zachalexander 12y agoUsually when people say "4chan" I assume they mean /b/.
- rtpg 12y ago/v/, /jp/, /pol/, and so many other boards are extremely toxic in behavior as well. There's some interesting stuff, but it's behind layers of "2edgy4u" behavior of people trying to out-insult each other.
- gtremper 12y agoI just opened secret for the first time in months(years?), and the first post was a very explicit dick pic... Seems like an appropriate send off.
- xnull6guest 12y agoCan we speculate as to the timing of this with the DoD marriage with VC firms and investment groups in Silicon Valley, or is that too conspiratorial?
- chx 12y agoCan we not link to TC please and use https://medium.com/secret-den/sunset-bc18450478d5 https://medium.com/secret-den/sunset-bc18450478d5 the official link?
- maceo 12y agoI've used Secret several times a week since they launched. Although the most recent redesign was panned from every corner, I found it to be the best anonymous messaging UI, by far. The friendly branding and overall feel of the design put it way ahead of its competitors, IMO. I discovered that their branding was actually outsourced to these guys: https://dribbble.com/shots/1854215-The-Secret-s-Out https://dribbble.com/shots/1854215-The-Secret-s-Out I would love to see their series A and B pitch decks -- how were they able to convince investors to hand over so much cash with no serious monetization strategy and nothing more than a temporary download spike? Add that to the fact that they were able to take 6m off the table. I can't see any rational investor thinking Secret for Business was actually going to bring in revenue? Props to Mr Byttow for raising the money, building out a great product, and returning the capital when he ran out of options... Can't wait to read the post-mortem.
- tuna 12y agoI wonder how long it will take to leak their data, spec those associated with facebook logins.Not surprised that they failed, it had plenty negative and offending posts and no cats/burgers/porn.
- onewaystreet 12y agoIt's hard to build a business on negativity when that negativity is directed at your own users. People like gossip but not when it's about them.
- shadytrees 12y agofeelings.blackfriday is still up though
- olivierkaisin 12y agoThe founder pretends that the investors have put money on the table to build a great team and a great product. If the problem resides in the product, I think pivoting is the least they can do in respect of their investors. Giving back the money is ridiculous, especially when they pretend to be guided by the motto "Innovation requires failure".
- pbiggar 12y agoIn the article, it says they made this decision after much discussion with the board. The board is the investors, so the investors are probably OK with this. It's likely the investors were investing in "the next big social network". When it became clear that this wasn't going to be successful, they were faced with the choice of get 80% of their money back, or to "invest" (as it were) that money in the remaining team. Maybe the remaining team had an idea, but the investor didnt want to invest in that idea. Or maybe the team was tired and didn't want to continue, and the investor would prefer their money back then try to force the team to continue.
- adamzerner 12y agoCan someone explain to me why people return money to investors? Legal reasons? Altruistic reasons? Selfish reasons (maybe that keeping it would hurt their reputation and make them feel guilty)?
- quizotic 12y agoOne reason is when the investors own > 50%, control the board, and decide to recoup 10 cents on their dollar. But I've known entrepreneurs who made the decision independently, feeling it was the right thing to do. And it is the right thing to do if the company has no other prospects or the team is falling apart. But even so, returning the balance just keeps some salt from the wound. It doesn't make anybody happy.
- adamzerner 12y ago> And it is the right thing to do if the company has no other prospects or the team is falling apart. Why do you say that? If for moral/altruistic reasons, that doesn't make sense to me - if you have $x million, do you really think the best place to donate it would be to VCs? I don't know anyone who donates to VCs, so I assume the answer is no. (sorry if I come off as harsh, I don't mean to - I just don't know how else to put it)
- lsc 12y agoyou don't have $x million. The company you founded, and no longer wholly own has $x million. It's a rather different thing. I mean, unless you are talking about the money for the personal shares the founders sold, the money, as it was said, that they "took off the table" - if that's the case, then I'm completely with you (but I didn't see any indication that they were giving that money back.)
- adamzerner 12y agoI was under the impression that someone had decided to give the money back to the investors. That they had a choice, presumably, to do what they want with it. Is that not true? To what extent were they restricted?
- AndrewKemendo 12y ago35 Million boggles my mind for what amounts to very simple technology. I'm a dinosaur though and compare everything to hardware start-up costs.
- Yadi 12y agoI've a question! Maybe totally unrelated, but isn't it always a bad sign when founders sell their shares before even reaching 1 year? Doesn't that put a red flag on how the investors should look into it? Or it's just the hype & hockey stick presentations that doesn't matter to some investors?
- diebir 12y agoSo, what can one develop using this beside "hello, world?" Can I build a cross platform GUI application? Is there a servlet container? How about an IDE?
- elmyraduff 12y agoI remember last year Techcrunch was publishing story over story about Secret, mostly as uninteresting as 'Secret app has an update and now it remembers where you left off'. And there was always someone commenting on the article 'Techcrunch stop trying to make Secret happen, it is not gonna happen.' That artificial media boost brought users and huge expectations, but users did not stick.
- rajatrocks 12y agoI still think there's a lot of room to do something interesting with social and mobile on the spectrum of Real Identity (Facebook) <-----> "Complete" Anonymity (Whisper). Yik Yak and After School have taken a small step to the left by focusing on specific geographic areas (schools) and that has worked well - a community centered around a shared context/life experience. Secret also took a step to the left with the "Friend" and "Friend of a Friend" concept - one which was ultimately unsuccessful, I think because it threatened to pierce the veil of anonymity, so many people didn't feel safe posting their real "scandalous" content. And of course with all of the anonymous apps you have the problem of bad behavior. So far we've seen community solutions to this (flagging, downvoting, karma - like here, Reddit, Yik Yak) and company solutions (moderating with 100 people in the Philippines, like Secret and Whisper - http://www.wired.com/2014/10/content-moderation/ http://www.wired.com/2014/10/content-moderation/). It would be interesting to think if there might be others. So the current "anonymish" apps have started from the right (anonymous by default) and either stayed there or moved to the left a bit. One of the things I've been thinking about recently is what would happen if you started from the left (Real Identity/FB) and moved to the right? Would the outcome be any better? I'm actually going to try it out and see with a new mobile app I've been working on - http://www.IAmOffTheClock.com http://www.IAmOffTheClock.com And as for them taking money off the table in their funding round - good for them. They weighed their offers and took one that eliminated their risk while giving the company enough cash to grow and still giving them a chance for a big payday. If Secret had hit it big, that would have been a very expensive $3M they took off the table. Investors wanted more stock, founders wanted some small amount of liquidity, and at the time everybody was happy, everyone believed, the graphs were all up and to the right, and nobody had a perfect crystal ball.
- dhruvbird 12y agoSecret is probably a very successful social experiment.
- nichochar 12y agoI've only ever heard bad things of that team. Arrogant, mean, shameless... I'm happy to see that this happens, when they cloned yik yak it was one of the most pathetic moves I have ever witnessed in the silicon valley
- mherdeg 12y agoWhat were some of the key contributions from Secret to wider culture? Was it — Julie Ann Horvath's decision to disclose big cultural problems at the company GitHub? Was there anything else?
- grahamg 12y agoDare I say it ...and nothing of value was lost