10 ms·
Some American Airlines planes are grounded because the pilots’ iPads crashed
- gremlinsinc 12y agoBetter their ipad, than their airplanes ;) (Sorry for the reddit-like comment, couldn't resist!)
- pmontra 12y agoCan anybody here estimate the money lost due to late flights, crews, etc? I don't know where to start from but I'd love to compare it with the costs of keep using paper.
- humanrebar 12y agoI'd like the estimate to include money and time lost by passengers, but that's probably hoping for too much.
- capnrefsmmat 12y agoThe DOT actually has estimates of the value of time lost by passengers, used for economic analyses of delays. See this PDF, page 19: http://www.dot.gov/sites/dot.dev/files/docs/vot_guidance_092811c.pdf http://www.dot.gov/sites/dot.dev/files/docs/vot_guidance_092... Your time is worth $45-57 an hour, depending on if your travel is personal or business-related.
- notahacker 12y agoSeems a tad generous considering a back-of-the-envelope calculation puts the average amount contributed to GDP per US citizen per hour at around $6. From an airline point of view, if their schedule is sufficiently flexible to accommodate the delays without flight cancellations and the delays are insufficiently long to require passengers to be compensated, the biggest costs will be additional fuel if the delays involve the aircraft being put in a holding pattern at the other end and additional time or penalty charges levied by the airports. Staffing isn't that big a deal even if they're on overtime.
- jackweirdy 12y agoThough if you’re travelling for business - you’re probably not doing "normal" work. Travelling to sign big deals, and so on. Even a few large deals would skew that number upwards.
- capnrefsmmat 12y agoThe DOT numbers are based on median hourly income of airline travelers, rather than their contribution to the economy. You can read the report I linked for their detailed methods.
- bgoers 12y agoAs a former iOS Developer for American I can say that while there is a rather large effect on the entire network, it pales in comparison to the savings gleaned from having the iPads. I couldn't give specific numbers on the lost revenue here. It could be anywhere from a few thousand to several hundred thousand dollars. But there are people at the airline who analyze the cost of delays and they can be pretty significant - more so if this occurred at fleet launch in the early morning (though that doesn't seem to be the case).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- CPLX 12y agoActually this seems extraordinarily unlikely. Your proposition is that a no-iOS zone was maliciously created in multiple highly secure and surveilled areas across the country (ie airports) but despite the fact that the hack should affect all iOS devices in range, there were no reports whatsoever of any passenger devices (nor the pilots iPhones for that matter) being disabled.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pyvpx 12y agowhile I fully agree with your last part, the first part of your argument is dubious at best. it would be trivial to get away with a malicious access point in an airport. they helpfully provide charging stations for your electronics, and all it takes is an identically sized and shaped power brick to drop in a malicious access point. see http://samy.pl/keysweeper/ http://samy.pl/keysweeper/ but modified with wifi instead of bluetooth and you get the idea.
- CPLX 12y agoIt would be trivial to get away with it in one airport. Doing it in multiple airports spread across the destinations where AA flies simultaneously would be significantly less trivial.
- Spooky23 12y agoWhy does it seem likely? I've observed in the wild a few issues where updates to MDM software or bugs in applications crash iPads. MDM/MAM control layers usually have problems right after iOS releases. AppStore apps can cause issues too. Chrome had an issue last year that crashed some of our iPad2s.
- nomercy400 12y agoDon't forget about the savings for American Airlines. No more paper maintenance manuals, saving lots of weight, on every flight. The ipad powering down will probably result in a claim to the supplier of the ipads. Of course it is embarrassing, but think of the environmental benefits of saving all that weight.
- stefantalpalaru 12y ago> all that weight A few hundred grams? A few Kg?
- coolnow 12y agoOver hundreds of thousands of miles on thousands of flights. It must add up.
- userbinator 12y agoAccording to the link in the article: http://hub.aa.com/en/nr/pressrelease/american-airlines-completes-electronic-flight-bag-implementation http://hub.aa.com/en/nr/pressrelease/american-airlines-compl... 35 pounds, or around 16kg. That is rather heavy... I'm thinking that they should not all carry iPads, but have one iPad and one other device from a different manufacturer running different software but with the same information, for redundancy purposes. The weight of carrying an iPad and backup device is still tiny compared to what it replaced.
- pmelendez 12y ago> , but have one iPad and one other device from a different manufacturer running different software Exactly my thoughts. I am surprised they didn't have any contingency plan as backup.
- draugadrotten 12y ago> they didn't have any contingency plan as backup. Do you have any Source of your claim that there was no contingency plan? FAA regulations seems to indicate that there are plans: "(5) Procedural means. g. Procedural Mitigations. If one or more onboard EFBs fail, resulting in loss of function or the presentation of false or hazardously misleading information, a contingency plan or process will need to be in place to provide the required information." Page 23, http://www.faa.gov/documentlibrary/media/advisory_circular/ac%20120-76b.pdf http://www.faa.gov/documentlibrary/media/advisory_circular/a...
- learnstats2 12y agoI understood it was illegal to depend on electronic equipment in the air?
- Cthulhu_ 12y ago"Was" being the correct word; airlines have become more and more lenient with that, and I'm sure airplane manufacturers do better shielding and error correction.
- CPLX 12y agoPretty sure they use a couple transistors and integrated circuits in planes now. There may be a few requirements for testing and approval of electronics however.
- jagermo 12y agoI think that is for passengers during the critical phases (takeoff/landing) so that they are not distracted. A few airlines have switched over to digital maps for airports, since they offer some substantial advantages (less weight, more up to date, etc). If you want to have a look at one of these apps, its on the public app store (https://itunes.apple.com/de/app/lido-iroutemanual-aeronautical/id413078249?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/de/app/lido-iroutemanual-aeronautic...) - though I could not find a source that AA is using the LH Systems app (and if it was the source of the problem, I guess there would be several more stories about it. edit: Source: did some work for LH Systems, but not affiliated with them.
- manarth 12y agoFAA permitted "PED" use (Personal Electronic Devices) for passengers from late 2013: http://www.faa.gov/news/press_releases/news_story.cfm?cid=TW189&newsId=15254 http://www.faa.gov/news/press_releases/news_story.cfm?cid=TW... Other countries are slowly following suit.
- rpmcb 12y agoThis is not true. In fact, we've built our entire business on the fact that pilots can use iPads while flying. www.foreflight.com
- bvrlt 12y agoThanks for the better title on HN. If you look at most reports on the issue, the title mentions "An iPad glitch" making it sound the iPads are at fault rather than a software issue. http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/apr/29/apple-ipad-fail-grounds-few-dozen-american-airline-flights http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/apr/29/apple-ipad... http://qz.com/393909/american-airlines-planes-are-grounded-because-their-pilots-ipads-have-crashed/ http://qz.com/393909/american-airlines-planes-are-grounded-b... http://money.cnn.com/2015/04/29/technology/american-airlines-ipad/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2015/04/29/technology/american-airlines...
- _broody 12y agoYes, the app crashed. That was no doubt an app bug. The iPads also crashed. That's eyebrow-raising, and definitely an iPad glitch. The airline will fix the bug and it won't happen again. But relying on a closed, unauditable platform to keep any sort of safety-critical data in these conditions seems absolutely unconvincing to me.
- ifewalter32 12y agoI'm interested in a better solution/idea if you have any.
- arfar 12y agoPicking an open source platform you can audit, like Linux (Android) for example.
- skywhopper 12y agoThese enterprise apps aren't vetted by Apple, so they could very well be using unsafe APIs Apple doesn't recommend and would block during an App Store review process. And there are tons of ways to crash machines from userspace. Also, it's likely the iPads are running an old version of iOS. And for all we know, the iPads are jailbroken and all bets are off. Finally, it sounds like AA's software provider was able to deliver a patch, so I don't think it's just a matter of iOS being "unauditable". What OS would they be using that met your auditability standards? Even Android is not totally open.
- lo_fye 12y ago"The issue was centered around an update that was pushed 4 days ago" - that's an app bug, not an iPad bug.
- SixSigma 12y ago> The pilot came on and said that his first mate’s iPad powered down unexpectedly, and his had too, and that the entire 737 fleet on American had experienced the same behavior. user mode programs causing power down is not an app bug
- raverbashing 12y ago"Going blank" is different from "Power down" (I suspect iPads are very rarely, if not never, powered down 100%) Of course, from the point of view of "can't be used" it is the same. Now, why would Jepessen be doing something "funny" and powering down iPads is the answer I want to hear.
- jsmthrowaway 12y agoYou've never heard a user say "power off" or "die" or "shut down" when an app crashed?
- draugadrotten 12y ago> that the entire 737 fleet on American had experienced the same behavior. That seems to be inaccurate. American Airlines confirms "several dozen flights" which is probably less. http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/apr/29/apple-ipad-fail-grounds-few-dozen-american-airline-flights http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/apr/29/apple-ipad... And the fix was available through nearest Wi-Fi. Leaving cockpit a few minutes. The horror! "In some cases, the flight has had to return to the gate to access a Wi-Fi connection to fix the issue. " http://www.theverge.com/2015/4/28/8511993/ipad-issue-grounds-american-airlines-737s http://www.theverge.com/2015/4/28/8511993/ipad-issue-grounds...
- duncanawoods 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- acd 12y agoMy iPAD and iPhone also crashes frequently since iOS 8.2+ They totally hang and then you need to reboot it by holding power and home. I'm switching to Android.
- pmelendez 12y ago> I'm switching to Android. That situation is not that much better on Android either.
- Kurtz79 12y agoMy anecdotal evidence against yours, I haven't experienced a single crash on my iPad(s) in three years.
- pmelendez 12y agoMy anecdotal evidence supports OP's and againts yours. My Ipad crashes more frequently with each iOS upgrade. My wife's Ipod touch is even more prone to crash that the Ipad. I just gave up with both iOS and Android (I gave the Ipad to my son). It turns out I only needed a phone and a kindle paperwhite after all.
- Kurtz79 12y agoThat's great! We already have three data points. A couple of thousand more and our anecdotal evidence could turn into a factual one.
- apalmer 12y agoKind of weird, there historically have been similar 'do it the old school way because its more reliable' fallbacks for other things in air transport. What happened to the planes that were mid flight when this bug occurred?
- donkeyd 12y agoAFAIK this is more of a regulatory thing than a direct safety issue. This has to work to be allowed to take off. When in flight though, they have no choice but to keep flying. The device not working could have become an issue if something unexpected happened though.
- ithingsnoway 12y agoIt is outrageous that flights could be stopped because of a reliance of shiny iThings and the software running on them. Paper versions do not run out of juice. There is a place for shiny tech, but the flight deck is not it. Paper worked, and we should go back to it.
- imglorp 12y agoPaper comprises an entire suitcase. Charts, airport docs, aircraft manuals, maint logs, regulations, etc etc. Updates are frequent and also paper. The fuel savings alone from not carrying the paper is substantial. As long as there's a backup tablet, it should be okay. If they get lost they can always call in for vectors. ref: http://news.delta.com/index.php?s=20295&item=124327 http://news.delta.com/index.php?s=20295&item=124327
- ithingsnoway 12y agoDidn't the backup tablet also experience issues in this case?
- CHY872 12y agoin which case they can call in for vectors
- 0x0 12y agoJust a wild guess: Could the enterprise in-house code signing certificate have expired? That would lock out the app. Imagine that happening mid-flight! (The iOS enterprise in-house code signing certificates, which only Apple can issue, always seem to come with 1-2 year hard expiration dates)
- ceejayoz 12y ago> Imagine that happening mid-flight! Not a problem, really. FAA regulations require all sorts of backups and emergency procedures. Even my dad's little four-seat general aviation plane has backups for every critical instrument. This issue prevents you from taking off (out of caution), but if it happened in-flight everyone'd know what to do.
- wodenokoto 12y agoMore over, isn't this just a manual? I mean, for most normal situations, the pilots know what to do, so even if the backup also died, chances are pretty good that they would land without problems, I imagine.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoI thought it was the flight plan.
- rpmcb 12y agoThe flight plan is programmed into the airplane's avionics, as well as on a printed hard copy in the cockpit. The app is supplemental. It can not be used as a primary navigation reference, per FAA regulations.
- blktiger 12y agoIt sounded to me like the pilot's couldn't input the flight plans into the cockpit avionics because they didn't have a paper copy of the flight plan.
- CaptG 12y agoIf you're curious, check out https://www.foreflight.com/ https://www.foreflight.com/, it's available from the app store and is marketed towards GA pilots. I've used it with some success on a domestic US flight with the inflight WIFI. EDIT: I just checked ForeFlight had a version update on 4/27. I doubt American is using the same software on their tablets, but then again you never know.
- ksherlock 12y agoThe article says the software was from Jeppesen/Boeing.
- rpmcb 12y agoAmerican Airlines does not use ForeFlight, though we are used by a variety of other large operators.
- ams6110 12y agoCertification for GA and large jet commercial passenger service are two different things. GA pilots can and often do use various portable navigational and other devices that are in some ways more sophisticated than what commercial airliners have, but they are not certified for commercial use.
- rpmcb 12y agoEh, yes and no. The FAA requires operators to get approval for iPad EFBs individually, and does not require GA pilots to do any such thing. "Certified," however, has a special meaning in aviation. iPads are not certified hardware, period. Pilots must still use their aircraft avionics (which are certified) as their primary means of navigation. iPads can be supplemental only, for both general aviation and commercial operations.
- nodata 12y ago"The software and data that powers American’s iPad-based flight kits are provided by Jeppesen, a unit of Boeing Digital Aviation." So not ForeFlight. Also see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9457945 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9457945.
- adim86 12y agoIs it me or is this headline misleading. As in AA for one reason or the other has a faulty app that refuses to launch or crashes the iPad. How is this Apple's fault if you want to be fair. This is like saying 7 bakerys had to close down for the week because their HP desktop crashed , when really they did not upgrade their software. What happened to investigative reporting rather than clickbait?
- xbryanx 12y agoThose flight plans sure look like XKCD comics from a distance.
- arikrak 12y agoI think I remember reading here that an airport was able to function even after there computers went down since they kept backup printouts of entire flight schedules. Seems like a pretty big contrast.
- birk5437 12y agoOne of the first things I was taught in a freshman CIT class was "Don't forget about paper! It has its place!" Not saying pilots should have to carry around heavy paper charts...but yeah.
- ericcumbee 12y agoWhile I am sure there are plenty of advantages to a full on app. I kind of wonder what the downside of a lot of that content being just PDFs is. Seems like there are less things to go wrong with that approach.
- Mikeb85 12y agoWhy on earth would you entrust anything critical to a proprietary, consumer-grade product? Seems like a bad idea from the get-go...
- mikhailt 12y agoBecause it is not mission-critical in the first place. If you think the flight plans on the iPad is the sole critical factor in the overall flight operation, you're mistaken. There are fallbacks, there are fallbacks even for the fallbacks and finally, the pilots themselves are trained in the event of total failures on all ends. In addition, it was a software glitch. We don't know what kind of glitch it was but if it was, it doesn't matter if they were using proper-graded billion dollar worth of products, software glitches exist everywhere.
- danans 12y agoPerhaps they chose too complex a platform, given the use case. Paper, while it has its own failure modes, is pretty failsafe, especially for information that doesn't change during the course of the flight. I wonder if there is an in-between solution that would provide the benefits of an electronic display without introducing as many failure modes as a device like an iPad which is designed primarily for consumer use.