6 ms·
Congress: Stop Trying to Limit EFF’s Ability to Challenge Patents
- Lord_Zero 12y ago"Okay, were sorry about that." - congress
- im3w1l 12y ago>Specifically, a few people have publicly challenged some important patents with the intent of making a quick buck by shorting the patent owner’s stock. Shouldn't that be against insider trading laws somehow?
- Someone1234 12y agoWhy would an external entity to a company be subject to insider trading allegations on that company's stock? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insider_trading#Definition_of_.22insider.22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insider_trading#Definition_of_...
- belorn 12y agoI would find it relevant since insider trading laws are intended to catch individuals with access to nonpublic information about a company and that then uses that information in a unfair way on the stock market. Even in countries that don't use civil law, intentions should still be relevant in discussing the law or its enforcement.
- wmeredith 12y agoIt's not insider trading, because the person challenging the patent is not an insider. It is, however, market manipulation and it is illegal in the US. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_manipulation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_manipulation
- tedunangst 12y agoIt's funny that page lists "bear raid" as an example. That's basically how shorting is done. You short a stock, then you tell the world why as loudly as possible.
- copsarebastards 12y agoNot insider trading laws, but yes, this is covered by existing legislation. If that's really a concern, they should fund the SEC better.
- amelius 12y agoI am sometimes wondering why we should not have software patents. Programming, mechanical engineering and medicine, etc. are all done behind a computer, so we should allow patents in all of these fields, or none of them. Also, more generally, of the two following people, who would you rather see having the biggest probability of making more money? 1. The person who has the most money. 2. The person who has the best ideas. Without (software) patents, it seems that 1 is more likely.
- tobylane 12y agoSoftware patents as an idea aren't terrible. It's the implementation which often permits trivial things that aren't new enough, other than the on-a-computer element of them, to earn a patent. I hear the US PTO is underfunded.
- bcg1 12y agoI completely disagree that patents protect "the little guy" with the best ideas from those with the most money. Patents make it illegal to implement ideas. So if you come up with the best ideas, you are the one that is the most restricted by patents. The notion that the patent system exists to protect inventors is a fairy tale that they used to sell the idea of such a ludicrous system of thought policing. Its origins go back centuries to when the King of England wanted to create a way for his cronies to get rich by monopolizing a certain color of dye that was profitable at the time, IIRC. And the "all or none" idea is not logical at all to me as well.
- ahallock 12y agoPeople seem to buy this idea of patents on FUD: "No one will invent things if they can't have a monopoly on their invention." But is that the case in reality? I'd like to see some empirical evidence that the amount of inventions goes down critically without patents. Even if the number of inventions went down, there are always upsides. Less time and money wasted on litigation and better products for consumers.
- Guvante 12y ago
- Balgair 12y agohttps://www.opencongress.org/people/zipcodelookup https://www.opencongress.org/people/zipcodelookup No matter how you feel about this issue, a quick phone call to your senator can help have your voice heard much louder than any HN comment. If you have not already, put your senators' and representative's phone number in your contacts list for easy access to democracy.
- lostinpoetics 12y agoCost. Cost is the biggest issue with post-grant proceedings. I don't know how many times I've seen people that have air-tight cases but they, understandably, won't, or can't, pay hundreds of thousands of dollars (filing fees and attorney's fees) to pull the trigger. The cost for these things is truly astronomical compared to quite literally every other aspect of the patent office. Even more astounding is that there is no reduction in fees for entity size (like almost every other fee). So a solo inventor and a Fortune 500 company pay exactly the same amount in filing fees, which is absurd and makes zero sense (even the older, reexamination route has fees based on entity size. e.g., large companies pay 12k, while "micro entities" pay 3k). I'm hoping, but not holding my breath, that eventually the fee structure will change; but given the popularity of post-grant proceedings, I can't imagine the PTO pulling the plug on a solid money maker for them. Here's a quick scatter plot of fees for micro entities, try and guess which are post-grant filing fees: http://i.imgur.com/F1Q2E1l.png http://i.imgur.com/F1Q2E1l.png
- rhino369 12y agoThe attorney's fees aren't the PTO's fault, that is just what good talent costs. The fees are large but an post grant proceeding isn't just a patent reexam. It's a mini-trial. There is a lot of manhours required on the USPTOs side of things.
- Taek 12y agoIn an ideal world, the patent system and the legal system in general would be substantially simpler, and premium talent wouldn't be required. For really clear cut cases you wouldn't need an attorney at all. Same thing with the mini-trial. In an ideal world the system would be a lot more efficient and cheaper for everybody.
- trjordan 12y agoThis is a legitimate discussion. Another story on the front page right now talks about a class-action lawsuit against Google for age discrimination. The person that's put up to it has a pretty flimsy case, it appears ("they didn't like me after my phone screen! Age discrimination!"), but the class action may uncover something more real. Finding somebody who has a real complaint seems before starting litigation seems like a good solution, because it ensures that at least one person was harmed. On the other hand, the EFF has a good point here: most of the people harmed by this aren't going to spend the money to deal with it. I like the idea of EFF pushing back against unfair patents, but I don't like the idea of ambitious lawyers building spurious class-action lawsuits. I'll admit that I'm not fully informed about either of these cases, but there is real value in putting up barriers to spurious cases that cost real money.
- ScottBurson 12y agoI think you need to understand the situation a little better. EFF is not suing the patent holder; the patent holder has nothing to lose in these actions except a valid patent, and EFF has nothing to gain except insofar as invalidating the patent is in the public interest. The analogy to a class action lawsuit is not a good one.
- driverdan 12y ago> a few people have publicly challenged some important patents with the intent of making a quick buck by shorting the patent owner’s stock This is exactly the type of thing we should encourage. It gives companies a strong incentive to avoid filing frivolous patents.
- throwawaykf05 12y ago> We say “perceived” because, if a patent is bad, should it really matter who is challenging it? The problem with this premise, of course, is that these patents are not being challenged because they are "bad", they're challenged because somebody wants to make a quick buck. They may be bad patents, because to get an IPR approved you must show that you have a fair chance of invalidating at least one claim. And statistically claims are very likely to be invalidated when IPRs are granted. But these IPRs are filed in bad faith, so it is an abuse of the USPTO's already limited resources. So far most IPRs have been filed by parties that are actually involved in litigation and hence have strong motivation to see claims invalidated. It is yet to be seen whether the same statistics will apply for cases like these. There does need to be a way for the EFFs of this world to challenge patents that are actively being asserted because small entities cannot afford to do so. I'd say that representing the targeted parties should be enough to give standing to file IPRs.
- Animats 12y agoThe new post-grant patent challenge scheme has made it a lot harder to enforce patents. Now, an accused infringer can file a post-grant review request and tie things up for a year or two, even if they lose. During that period, it's almost impossible to license the patent. The patent holder has to defend against the post-grant review, which is expensive. There are few real "patent trolls". The EFF's list is very short.[1] Only one law firm, Farney Daniels, is listed as having sent out more than 3 demand letters. This isn't a big problem. You need to own intellectual property if, for example, you're writing for Apple's platform. If your idea is a success, Apple copies it and then turns off your platform access. Look what just happened to Pebble. [1] https://trollingeffects.org/lawfirms https://trollingeffects.org/lawfirms
- bougiefever 12y agoIt should be easier to get attorney's fees paid by the loser. That would cut down on a lot of these kinds of cases.
- anigbrowl 12y agoAnd further deter small plaintiffs or defendants from having their day in court, because a loss will inevitably result in bankruptcy. All sorts of solutions have great upside, but that's not the only thing you need to consider.
- EdSharkey 12y agoChris Coons is a Democrat. The article didn't mention that fact. Also, I'm not sure if this is an example of crony capitalism or not; I don't fully understand the stated motivation for the legislation. The motivation seems fishy at first blush.