3 ms·
> It’s natural to assume that service providers like Ancestry will be good custodians of our data, No, never. Not Ancestry or anybody else. In this very moment
by pmontra 12y ago
> It’s natural to assume that service providers like Ancestry will be good custodians of our data,
No, never. Not Ancestry or anybody else. In this very moment my computer is running my daily back up my Google Drive (customers write stuff there) to my USB disk (I know, I should need a better disaster recovery solution). Not that Google doesn't provide a good service, but I don't trust them to preserve all my data until I need it, possibly tens of years in the future. I better care about it myself.
I consider anything stored "on the cloud" as expendable. If I really care about it I back it up in multiple copies. I have a couple of servers where I send encrypted backups using duplicity.
Is this too much for the average computer/tablet user? Yes, but there won't be a market for proper consumer backup until enough people has been burned by this kind of things and all cloud services will start offering an export procedure.
Meanwhile I think it's worth using self hosted services. For my company I have a self hosted redmine with all the details of my projects.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoI think you're wrong if you're saying that "it's NOT natural to assume ...". For sure it's natural to assume a company whose sole preserve is digitisation and archive of family history -- which it has been doing for several years for millions of people -- is going to be a "good custodian". Is that the best way to proceed? Nope, abject paranoia seems like the only way to preserve data -- assuming there is a nuclear war, have you archived your data on a different continent, have you got a plan for retrieval!?!
- vgabios 12y agoA service's customer data must persist somewhere. "On the cloud" is a marketing abstraction to fool customers into a false sense of integrity. Just remember that most cloud services do not do backups, do not have a disaster recovery / BIA plan, do not use ECC memory in network, compute and storage systems. Users must take personal responsibility for ensuring their private data is safe, because wishing is not a winning strategy.
- yasth 12y agoAmazon uses ECC [1] (search ecc) MS Azure uses ECC [2] Rackspace uses ECC [3] While compute servers aren't backed up this is by design (use storage). Storage is indeed backed up and replicated. Also most assuredly there are extensive disaster recovery plans. The cloud isn't for everyone, but FUD doesn't help. [1] http://aws.amazon.com/ec2/faqs/ http://aws.amazon.com/ec2/faqs/ [2] http://azure.microsoft.com/blog/2015/03/16/microsoft-azure-uses-error-correcting-code-memory-for-enhanced-reliability-and-security/ http://azure.microsoft.com/blog/2015/03/16/microsoft-azure-u... [3] http://www.rackspace.com/cloud/servers/features http://www.rackspace.com/cloud/servers/features
- danieldk 12y agoWhile compute servers aren't backed up this is by design (use storage). Storage is indeed backed up and replicated. And yet, you are referring to pages about redundancy, not backup. Redundancy helps when a disk, server, or perhaps even data center fails. Backups help when your cloud storage provider makes an error and removes your data from redundant storage. There have been enough incidents to show that cloud computing alone cannot be trusted [1]. Unfortunately, most cloud services are data silos, so you couldn't even backup data if you wanted to. And then we haven't talked yet about data leaks. Some larger incident than last year's iCloud leak will probably happen sometime. Hopefully then people will realize that client-side encryption is important. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8440985 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8440985
- yasth 12y agoFor one the iCloud leaks had not one thing to do with cloud computing. Nor did the dropbox one you linked. Those were application level problems, and could well have occurred with on premises based storage (obviously with a public interface for an icloud issue). Let me assure you that bad synch algorithms have caused data loss before the cloud. Applications can fail to backup or record things. Also I provided only links to ECC proof.
- 12y ago
- acdha 12y ago> > It’s natural to assume that service providers like Ancestry will be good custodians of our data, > No, never. Not Ancestry or anybody else I respectfully disagree: it is natural for people to assume that companies won't callously discard their customers’ data. If it wasn't natural, we wouldn't need to have so much effort going towards education about the terms of service to watch out for and how to make your own copies. Too many people have a mental model for corporations which grossly exaggerates the level of stability and long-term planning.
- JoblessWonder 12y agoI agree. It is "natural" to assume that they will be good custodians but it isn't "correct" to assume that.
- pmontra 12y agoOk, you have a point. Trust is natural (think about the attitude of little children) and education goes like "don't trust strangers". Hoping for the best often is a sub optimal strategy. I was starting from that assumption.
- erroneousfunk 12y agoTrust isn't for "little children." Trust is what makes the world go round. I trust that my bank won't close overnight and steal all my money. I trust that the food I buy is safe for human consumption. I trust that random people on the street won't attack me because they feel like it. "Hoping for the best" (or perhaps "trusting that people won't screw me over") is actually an extremely good strategy -- far better than not trusting anyone with anything. I can hire third parties to cook my food, do my taxes, handle my banking, even babysit my children after a background check (where I have to trust the background checking company) and a brief interview. If I couldn't trust people, I simply wouldn't be able to function in the modern world. So I have a company, who I have paid to store my data. The company has been good so far, I use their services frequently, and I have every reason to trust them (they've had my credit card info, and my family's for years, haven't screwed me over, haven't lost any other data in all this time...) The company is shutting down, and they explicitly tell me that they will let me download all of my data, including text conversations. I download the data, only to open it weeks later and find that the company has failed to do what they said they would. In this one particular case, the strategy of "trust" has failed. However, in the long run, it's made my life a heck of a lot better.
- Istof 12y agoI like to backup my data to storage that I own too and I try to keep a copy of it on all my devices but while storage is getting cheaper everyday, hardware makers try to limit local storage on mobile devices every way they can to increase cloud business (even remove microSD card support), Google being a good example... You would think that by now a $650 phone would have a lot more then 32gb of storage.... But even if you have a phone that supports an external microSD card, Google makes it difficult to write to it using a 3rd party Android app (stating security as a reason). There should be a law that prevent companies from keeping root to themselves on devices that you own.