3 ms·
At the risk of being overly confrontational, the things that make humanities people believe that they are capable of critical thinking (in contrast to STEM type
by ForHackernews 12y ago
At the risk of being overly confrontational, the things that make humanities people believe that they are capable of critical thinking (in contrast to STEM types) are comments like yours.
> Just at the beginning of the article he states that humanities are only good for rich students to pass their time
Where in the article does the author state or imply this? The section beginning "When I first came to Oxford 30 years earlier..." is obviously written to be tongue-in-cheek.
A close reading (humanities skill!) of this article might highlight the following passage as the central thesis:
Universities, which in Britain have an 800-year history, have traditionally been derided as ivory towers, and there was always some truth in the accusation. Yet the distance they established between themselves and society at large could prove enabling as well as disabling, allowing them to reflect on the values, goals, and interests of a social order too frenetically bound up in its own short-term practical pursuits to be capable of much self-criticism. Across the globe, that critical distance is now being diminished almost to nothing, as the institutions that produced Erasmus and John Milton, Einstein and Monty Python, capitulate to the hard-faced priorities of global capitalism.
> Locking themselves in a room, nostalgically talking with like-minded people without ever doing anything leads nowhere.
Again, where in the article does the author suggest this course of action? If anything, he seems to be suggesting the opposite, that the humanities should be returned to their traditional place in the public square, questioning and criticizing the prevailing ideologies of the day:
It would also seek to restore the honorable lineage of the university as one of the few arenas in modern society (another is the arts) in which prevailing ideologies can be submitted to some rigorous scrutiny. What if the value of the humanities lies not in the way they conform to such dominant notions, but in the fact that they don't?
- marcosdumay 12y ago> If anything, he seems to be suggesting the opposite, that the humanities should be returned to their traditional place in the public square, questioning and criticizing the prevailing ideologies of the day Yes, he want to be nostalgically talking with like-minded people in an open space. That's my fault, I've misread it. A bit of self criticism from his part would certainly lead to the conclusion that such kind of study does never lead to any actionable result. Anyway, there's no problem inherent in that. The only problems he faces is that he wants to do those things on the taxpayer money, and wants to sell it to students as some incredibly useful skill. People are stopping to accept that.
- tenementfunster 12y agoHumanities major spotted.
- arcosdev 12y agoThank you for this comment...I thought I was going insane for a minute reading the others.
- paganel 12y ago> Universities, which in Britain have an 800-year history, have traditionally been derided as ivory towers, and there was always some truth in the accusation. (...) Across the globe, that critical distance is now being diminished almost to nothing, as the institutions that produced Erasmus and John Milton, Einstein and Monty Python, capitulate to the hard-faced priorities of global capitalism. I never looked at Oxford people with the same eyes again after reading Giordano Bruno's works and about how the professors in there treated him. From his wiki page (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giordano_Bruno#England.2C_1583.E2.80.931585 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giordano_Bruno#England.2C_1583...): > His views were controversial, notably with John Underhill, Rector of Lincoln College and subsequently bishop of Oxford, and George Abbot, who later became Archbishop of Canterbury. Abbot mocked Bruno for supporting "the opinion of Copernicus that the earth did go round, and the heavens did stand still; whereas in truth it was his own head which rather did run round, and his brains did not stand still",[23] and reports accusations that Bruno plagiarized Ficino's work. I've recently read a book by French historian Jacques Le Goff who was saying something along the lines of: "the University as we know it was born around year 1,000 and flourished for the next couple of centuries, only to become more segregated and focused on itself starting with the 14th century, so much so that the Renaissance happened outside of its sphere of influence". So I will keep my hopes up. This downfall of the University as an institution has happened before but we still managed to create and produce great things outside of it.
- grayclhn 12y ago> I never looked at Oxford people with the same eyes again after reading Giordano Bruno's works and about how the professors in there treated him. Dude, you are going to be bummed when you find out how the rest of humanity has treated everyone
- paganel 12y agoI now that, after all I'm a subscriber on /r/syriancivilwar , is that when you're a professor at a place like Oxford supposedly you don't actively fight against science.
- eli_gottlieb 12y ago>Again, where in the article does the author suggest this course of action? If anything, he seems to be suggesting the opposite, that the humanities should be returned to their traditional place in the public square, questioning and criticizing the prevailing ideologies of the day: Ok. Questioning and criticizing on which grounds? Either there's a right thing to do, and anyone informed can point out that the public is ignoring it (in which case, universities are useful for such), or, as the humanities academics tend to say these days, there is no right answer, in which case they really have given up grounds for criticism. What I'm bloody fed up with their doing is claiming the sole ground to make normative claims, and then asserting no such claims at all!
- qu4z-2 12y agoThank you for this comment.