6 ms·
Atlas: Visual IDE for Cappuccino Applications
- jerome_etienne 17y agodont bother would be my advice 1. i clicked and failed to find any release. only a video and a mailing list. 2. only a beta will be released and you will have to pay 20$ to get it. To pay to debug their code? the offer is not that compelling. let hope those are just glitch during the launch
- geuis 17y agoI agree. I haven't been much of a fan of Cappucino since seeing a review at a Google JS meetup several months ago. I have just never been sure what the point of a language written on top of javascript is. The whole point of really knowing not only the core language but also the inconsistencies between IE and the rest of the browsers is that I want to build web apps that perform fast and robustly. Abstracting that away into yet another layer that runs moderately slowly on the 70% of common browsers just means that it runs that much more slowly. To be fair, I give all the credit in the world to the 280 North guys, but charging $15 for access to a beta program for an environment and language that really has no broad adoption is just not worth it.
- milestinsley 17y agoRemember that because Objective-J is a superset of Javascript you can still write native JS code in an app. This is the beauty of Cappuccino: it provides the benefits of a framework (consistency, robustness etc) with the flexibility to pretty much still do whatever you want. The 280 North guys are the first to admit that CP isn't for every web app, but it serves a specific need exceptionally well. And, personally, I think its' application and adoption will only broaden. I can't wait to part with my $20! They have to monetise somehow, and if this helps the next year of development - hell, make it $40!
- demallien 17y agoYup, I couldn't agree more. In fact, I've even got an internal webapp for my company that I have planned to build using Atlas, so as of tomorrow morning, I'll be signing up for the beta program. $20 really is peanuts for a professional development tool.
- jerome_etienne 17y agoyep $20 is nothing for a professional development tool. even 200$ is totally acceptable. But they only provide access to a beta version of a unproven tool... not my definition of professional. i dunno what the tool worth and i dont plan to pay 20$ to find out if i need this tool. i dont blame the product, just the moneytisation is broken. Ok to sell a tool, but first convinces potential buyers
- boucher 17y agoThat's fine. We're not looking to convince anyone. We are recognizing that we have something useful now, and that there are people who are willing to pay for it now. We are providing it to those people, and making it known that we believe the application is still not ready to be called 1.0. We happily admit that a paid beta program is a bit of an experiment, but it's hardly unprecedented. See Mac OS X Public Beta for an example. We do not want to set up the false expectation that Atlas is free. It isn't.
- icodestuff 17y agoWill there be a substantial discount on the final version for beta testers? If so, sign me up!
- jerome_etienne 17y agoanother marketing glitch: dont launch a professionnal tool on sunday. do it during a work day, say around 10am pst to maximize the effect.
- 17y ago
- nrr 17y ago"I agree. I haven't been much of a fan of the NeXTstep class library since seeing a review in [a prominent publication of the period] several months ago. I have just never been sure what the point of a language written on top of C is... "To be fair, I give all the credit in the world to the NeXT guys, but charging $3500 for a microcomputer without a vast application library and that really has no broad adoption is just not worth it." That said, here's how I see things. (1) 280 North took a broken environment and tried to apply a not-entirely-broken substrate atop it. Is it going to be slow? Sure, but consider also that Javascript is inherently slow to begin with. (Slow begets slower, blah blah, I don't want to hear it. I don't care.) (2) It's a start, and when it comes to 280 North's business practices, I'd be willing to bet that there might very well be a standalone compiler for Objective-J at some point if enough people ask for it. ... if I don't beat them to it first. It's getting close to the point where I'm considering just hacking something together in OCaml to scratch my own itch in this vein. (3) The 280 North guys are smart guys. They listen. Complain. Send them mail.
- boucher 17y agoOn point number 2, the compiler ships with the open source project. It's written in Javascript. It runs in the browser, or on the command line. We are planning on getting a new compiler in 2010, and it will still do all those things. It will also be more robust, introduce some sorely needed new features, and with any luck be faster to boot. With respect to point one, I'm not sure anyone commenting in this thread really understands the complexity of optimizing application performance in the browser. On an absolute level, message passing is slower than function calling. But taken in context, that's a small percentage of what happens in an application. Cappuccino, because its an application framework, can make certain assumptions to dramatically improve performance. Assumptions that can not be made here and there by individual app developers. For example, coalescing DOM updates and drawing events on the run loop. Combining timers together to minimize overhead. Delegating events from the document level to prevent unnecessary build up of event handlers. On the tools front, we can strip some dead code from projects, automate spriting of all app resources, target different code paths to different browsers automatically, and a slew of other things. Performance is complicated.
- gcv 17y agoThe extra abstraction layer Cappuccino provides seems worth it to me. Much as I like jQuery et al., an MVC-style framework for writing desktop-like web apps, along with an Interface Builder clone, blows manipulating the DOM out of the water. IMO, of course.
- boucher 17y agoIt's $20 actually. But you're only paying for a development tool. The language, the framework, the runtime -- everything else is open source.
- nailer 17y agoRe 1: I suggest you read the title of the article you're commenting on.
- jhancock 17y agoI'm excited about atlas. However, posting a "watch this page" notice on HN is a bit out of place. How about posting the HN notice when it actually is available?
- boucher 17y agoAgreed. But it's live now. Sorry for making you wait. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943616 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943616
- aw3c2 17y agoWhat is Atlas? -> Atlas is a development tool for building Cappuccino applications. Is it some MacOS thing?
- swombat 17y agohttp://lmgtfy.com/?q=cappucino+applications http://lmgtfy.com/?q=cappucino+applications
- stephen 17y agoAs a professional programmer, I'm torn between the upside of open source software (primarily that I can use it without getting budget approval and a nightmare enterprise sales cycle involved) and the downside of it making it harder for programmers to make a living building software tools (although support contracts come close). I admit I'm just as guilty as the next for saying "I won't use X unless its open source" but I really do hope the 280north guys do well with Atlas. As a profession, I think it would be nice if they were able to build great tools and actually, you know, get paid for it. Case in point is Hibernate--I'm less of a fan of it than I used to be, but the insane number of projects using it for very real higher-productivity/lower-development-cost gains to me means its author, Gaven King, should be very well off right now, not just landing a nice salaried position at JBoss-now-Redhat. Co-workers and I have occasionally mused about how to help open source developers get income from their work in a non-invasive way. E.g. not having to pin your hopes on being the next SpringSource-type acquisition. Nothing ground breaking yet. Has anyone seen good approaches for this?
- emmett 17y agoThe hardest part is: if Hibernate came with a license that was not completely open and free, would it ever have been adopted as the standard? Probably not. So you can't really charge developers directly. What if companies that make money using open source software created an endowment that rewarded developers who produced widely used open source software?
- stephen 17y agoEndowment isn't bad. But then who decides where/who the money gets paid to? Does the money go to the copyright holder (e.g. the Apache organization for anything org.apache, JBoss/Redhat for anything org.jboss) or the individual developers? If individuals, how do you partition the money, by LOC, in-project voting/ranking of team member contributions?
- jerome_etienne 17y agowhat about a non-commercial use license for free, and a commercial use license for a fee ? - the software's author get money from his work and thus can go on provide good software to people - only the ones with money needs to pay - people without money get your product for free... you dont loose money as they wont buy your product anyway and they give you community and adverstissement for free. http://www.longtailvideo.com/ http://www.longtailvideo.com/ jw player seems to do well with this schema. am i missing something ?
- gommm 17y agoI'm currently developing an app in Cappucino and it's quite sweet... I'm not sure if I'll actually use the IDE, but I'll pay anyway because I want to support their work
- anshul 17y agoNo linux version... They talk of targeting windows in another month. Is a linux version planned? They should consider going the balsamiq route... ie provide that in-browser/git thingy he talks about in the dev video as a free demo possibly with limitations and with strategically placed upsells. This will allow non-mac people to use the app and provide for a try before you buy. They could of-course charge for this as a product or a service and/or beta charge for it. I am not a cappuccino or a cappuccino app user at this point. The user base I deal with does seem to react to loading times and loading perceptions quite a bit. The improvements promised by 0.8 mark the first point it seems it could be viable for me to do a mini-app in cappuccino (thanks mainly to the loading related improvements promised). Atlas seems interesting too. Would try if I could.
- boucher 17y agoLinux support should come with windows support, because of the way we're doing it.