7 ms·
The Serotonin Levels-Depression Link Is a 'Marketing Myth,' Psychiatrist Claims
- joosters 12y agoIt's worth reading http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/05/chemical-imbalance/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/05/chemical-imbalance/ for a more balanced take on this issue IMO.
- Alex3917 12y agoThis entire article is based on a complete mischaracterization of Robert Whitaker's book/article. How exactly is that balanced?
- FeepingCreature 12y ago[See also this follow-up.](http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/18/polemical-imbalance/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/18/polemical-imbalance/)
- Alex3917 12y agoIt's still a complete mischaracterization. What RW is saying, to vastly simplify, is that pharma companies and psychiatrists are selling drugs that haven't been proven to work by using the monoamine hypothesis, which is a largely discredited theory. What this blog is saying is that when psychiatrists talk about a chemical imbalance, they are merely saying that brain chemicals are involved in depression in some way, rather than that a lack of serotonin causes depression. The latter has literally nothing to do with what Robert Whitaker is actually talking about. It's just nonsense pharma propaganda designed to trick people who haven't actually read the original book, which sadly is the vast majority of people.
- thedufer 12y agoHow can it be a mischaracterization? RW explicitly argued against the blog post in question here: http://www.madinamerica.com/2015/04/psychiatrists-still-promoting-low-serotonin-theory-depression/ http://www.madinamerica.com/2015/04/psychiatrists-still-prom... If he was being mischaracterized, wouldn't he have said that instead of repeating exactly what he was claimed to be saying? > pharma companies and psychiatrists are selling drugs that haven't been proven to work by using the monoamine hypothesis Where's your evidence here? SSRIs do work (I assume this is the class of drug we're talking about). For sure, they don't work for some people (or some types of depression; hard to say which is the issue at this point). But they still beat placebo on average. In fact, the monoamine hypothesis was _based_ on the fact that SSRIs work. The cause/effect is the opposite of what it would have to be for your claim to make sense.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ap22213 12y agoI can't speak for the depression remedy, but SSRIs have certainly helped my anxiety issues. A few years ago, I started having incapacitating panic attacks. They were so pronounced that I'd end up in the hospital ER several times a month. Eventually, I was prescribed an SSRI, and the anxiety attacks went away completely. Maybe it's placebo, but when I tried to stop taking them, the anxiety attacks came back. (reverse placebo?) I'm not a big fan of big-pharma, but for me, SSRIs were a literal lifesaver. It's easy to criticize, but unless one has an alternative solution, it's best to let things be until better treatments come along.
- jfb 12y agoI have almost exactly the same experience. Given that the science isn't settled, and that the mechanisms are imperfectly understood, and that talk therapy has worked or not for largely the same population since 1910, I'll take the placebo effect.
- Ollinson 12y agoSame here. I used to have panic attacks from any unusual physical stimulation (too hot, too cold, hungover, hungry, ate too much). These would happen weekly and many times put me in the ER. I have not had a single panic attack since I've been on my SSRI.
- dholowiski 12y agoPretty much the same here. Its easy to downplay depression or anxiety, but SSRIs are a literal lifesaver for many people, myself included.
- letstryagain 12y agoI've been taking SSRIs for more than a decade. In the last few years I've learned that they don't seem to work much better than placebos. That may be true but it does not matter. They work for me and the side effects are minimal so I will keep taking them. SSRIs have made a huge difference to my quality of life. I don't care if I'm just taking a placebo at this point, as long as I'm getting the results I need.
- 12y ago
- fsk 12y agoThere were several drugs I tried where I couldn't stand the side-effects, and only one that I actually liked. As a patient, if you feel the drugs aren't helping, you should be prepared to fire your doctor or even stop taking them. (I know that's a big medical no-no, but I never would have found someone competent if I didn't fire several psychiatrists and refuse to take drugs that had harsh side-effects. My first psychiatrist was so incompetent that I believed that they all were incompetent and all the drugs were harmful.)
- GabrielF00 12y agoIf you choose to stop taking an anti-depressant, please be careful and consult a physician. If you don't taper off the drugs, you can feel some really nasty effects. This seems to be particularly problematic with Cymbalta. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antidepressant_discontinuation_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antidepressant_discontinuation...
- alejohausner 12y agoYou bring up an important point. If you STOP taking an SSRI, you will feel depressed, because your serotonin levels will drop. What's happening is that the SSRI has been fighting your body, pushing up your serotonin levels, and your body has been fighting back. When the SSRI is cut off, your body's fight continues for a while, pushing levels down. Often patients feel suicidal at this point. Healy and Whittaker point out that the clinical studies initially used to justify the use of SSRIs cleverly took advantage of this effect. Patients on SSRIs were compared to those who had just been cut off the drug. Of course the latter group, perversely included as "placebo", fared worse than the ones taking the drug.
- DanBC 12y agoDiscontinuation effects are not "feeling more depressed".
- bayesianhorse 12y ago
- teammatters 12y agoFor me and others close to me anti-depressants proved to be a joke/a placebo. I was on five to six different drugs to cure an odd social anxiety, that went away as I got older and grew more comfortable in my skin. How in the world can a drug cure an odd internal social behavior that leads one to feel anxious/uncomfortable? Answer for me is .. it can't. Another example being my g/f. We started dating six years ago and up until a year ago she had been on 4 different anti-depressants each year. Her doctors would say oh that one isn't working lets try this one and so on. Finally she realized this stuff isn't helpful, what's the point? For those it has helped that's good to hear, but for me, my g/f and many others I know... these drugs are just lining the pockets of the drug companies.
- gordaco 12y agoAnti-depressants didn't ever do anything for me, either. Although I suspect that the only anxiety attack I've ever had could very well have been caused by them. In his awesome book Bad Pharma, Ben Goldacre also hints that the link between depression and serotonin levels is not very well established. For those of you that don't know, Ben Goldacre is not some quack that pretends that science is wrong or something like that; in fact, what he asks for is precisely more rigorous science (specifically, more rigorous medical trials, all made public). On the other hand, apparently there are a lot of people who have had a measurable level of benefit. My non-educated hypothesis is that there are several causes of depression and serotonin levels may be only one of them.
- teammatters 12y agoI agree if it's helping people great, but for me it, you and many others I know it's hocus pocus. The brain is an incredibly complex organ!
- pyre 12y agoIt's probably best to view depression as a symptom. It could have several immediate causes (i.e. the physical processes that make you feel that way) as well as many other root causes (i.e. what leads your body to be in the state that is causing you to feel depressed).
- electronvolt 12y agoI think it's important to note that although studies of serotonin levels don't show a connection with depression (i.e. lower serotonin levels = depression), that doesn't mean that drugs which decrease reuptake/increase (by proxy) serotonin levels won't improve mood. It's sort of a red herring to say "Depression isn't caused by a serotonin deficiency, therefore SSRIs are bunk", which is what this article seems to veer towards. SSRIs could affect a completely different body system as long as they wind up showing a statistically significant effect over placebo in a double blind study, then they are acceptable forms of treatment by our current scientific/medical standards. (Which apparently they do for most patients--so I wouldn't rule them out.).
- gburt 12y agoThe fatal error in his reasoning is fundamentally units vs. integration. The "comprehensive" studies still show that SSRIs are effective [0], the mechanism of action is just not likely to be "because you didn't have enough serotonin." [0] Cochrane Review: http://www.cochrane.org/CD007954/DEPRESSN_antidepressants-versus-placebo-for-depression-in-primary-care http://www.cochrane.org/CD007954/DEPRESSN_antidepressants-ve...
- Alex3917 12y ago> The "comprehensive" studies still show that SSRIs are effective From the article: "Most of the studies were supported by funds from pharmaceutical companies and were of short duration." In other words, what they are saying is that the published research papers show efficacy for SSRIs, which is completely different from saying that the research shows that SSRIs are effective.
- jmspring 12y agoI can't speak to the drugs or the study, but having had a significant other showing signs of depression and working with them to get them active (physically), outside more, and an additional avenue to focus on (in this case, something in common that happened to be outside activity) helped with the depression symptoms significantly. Not fully, but definite signs. Just an observation/data point.
- whoopdedo 12y agoIf I eat some bad sushi, the pain in my stomach is not caused by constricted blood vessels or an excess of COX enzyme. But if I take a Tylenol, a COX inhibitor, I feel better. Then a few hours later I'm "cured" in that I no longer have stomach pain, headache or fever. Did the Tylenol cure what was ailing me? Not at all. What it did is made me feel more comfortable while the root malady was being taken care of. If the pain persisted after one or two doses of Tylenol then I'd suspect something more serious than indigestion were at fault and I'd start looking for a reason. What I wouldn't do, and what I hope a doctor would be responsible enough not to do, is to keep taking Tylenol or a more serious pain medication to cover up the pain without considering the actual cause.
- sjg007 12y agoTylenol, interestingly, has an antidepressant effect.
- magic_beans 12y agoWould that have to do with its anti-inflammatory property?
- im3w1l 12y agoOne alternative (maybe fringish, I don't know) theory I've heard for the action of antidepressants, are that they work by being antimicrobial.
- refurb 12y agoThat would be pretty easy to test, no? Just put some anti-depressant on different bacterial cultures and see if they die.
- letstryagain 12y agoOh we know they are anti-microbial, we just don't know how that might affect your mood
- DanBC 12y agoDepression probably is not a single illness with a single cause The serotonin hypothesis is probably wrong There are problems with some of the studies used for SSRIs / SNRIs / etc, as with many drugs. Studies show stronger effectiveness of meds for more severe depression Fromt line treatment for depression and anxiety is not medication but is a talking therapy or a talking therapy and a medication combined. None of this is particularly new. IAPT (Improved access to psychologicl therapy) is the UK national health service programme to help local health providers implement NICE guidance on depression and anxiety disorders. IAPT started in 2006.
- zamalek 12y ago> The serotonin hypothesis is probably wrong The serotonin is one possible cause. It sounds like you are suggesting that SSRIs are incorrectly used as a universal treatment, which I'd agree with completely. I think it's important to distinguish between depression and sadness. I've noticed a very sharp increase in the amount of people (especially youth) who claim to be depressed. They go to a doctor, get a SSRI prescription and next thing you know their brain has a dependency on SSRIs to maintain normal serotonin levels (they are now actually depressed). This is why this is important: > talking therapy or a talking therapy and a medication combined. I was clinically depressed for the longest time. Turns out it wasn't caused by serotonin but instead a genetic mutation[1] that something like 80% of human samples have. It can results in a condition is called homocystinuria. In layman terms your body is unable to activate (turn into usable form) one of the forms of Vitamin B. Unsurprisingly the symptoms 5-MTHF (the activated Vitamin B) deficiency can be strikingly similar to depression. My fix for depression is to simply take a vitamin for the rest of my life. I'm just lucky that the doctors I went to cared enough to not default to the SSRI prescription. [1]: http://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/gene/MTHFR http://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/gene/MTHFR
- martin1975 12y agoI didn't even know I was depressive until my mid 30's...when apparently (according to stats from the shrink I visited) a lot of people manifest symptoms. Mine were sudden panic attacks, which when they happened first, I thought I was dying so I called 911 for nothing and was told there's nothing wrong w/my heart even though I felt chest pains/tightness (a common occurence w/MDD, but who'd know, right?)...which then got worse over time, despite what I did, exercise, vitamins, supplements, sleep, drinking, and other things I won't name, only because I (formerly) despised psychiatry as a profession and thought it was gobbledy gook. For reason I won't outline here, someone strongly suggested, after having fought this unsuccessfully for quite some time and needlessly suffering, that I visit a psychiatrist because in his view, I had MDD. This is someone I truly trusted and he apparently dealt with his MDD in the past, so I was like, ok, I'm at the end of my rope so I'll give the MD a shot. The best way to describe what happened few months down the road after a few trial/errors to see which SSRI fits me best (and that's how everyone finds out - trial/error, any doctor worth his salt will admit this- or they lie to your face if they say otherwise), is a persistent feeling developed, or I should say, resurrected only because I forgot how it felt to feel normal since I was a kid - of being lifted out of a deep hole that I seem to have been in for years, if not decades. All the b.s. about sexual dysfunction they petrify guys with - for me was not true, in fact, it was quite the opposite as I regained control over that aspect of my life, rather than desensitizing myself with some activities which may have eventually led to ED, despite some "logic" that was telling me that I was doing the "right thing" ... I could focus better at work, I was calmer in general with my wife, kids, and was more chipper and lit up overall. It's not a high or a dependency...to test it, I stopped, went through what one might call a "withdrawal", but then the MDD kicked back in in full force after a few months of being off it. Since then, I went back on and decided it is much more important to be productive and focused on an SSRI, than a panic-induced, anxious, crying fits, lost mess without it. So do SSRIs work? They worked for me - in conjunction with some therapy. Do they address the EXACT cause of depression? Unlikely. MDD is multi-causal, some nurtured by choice, some genetically inherited, no one really knows... but SSRIs treat it well enough in many cases. Don't dismiss anything out of hand - would be my advice. Depression (clinical, not just depression cause you lost your job or gf/bf - which tends to go away) is real and it is sucks big time. Mine was classified as MDD of moderate to severe character...and I asked the doc, what's really severe - his response was, curling up into a ball on the couch and not being able to function. Some are worse and potentially self-destructive...(i.e. suicide). There is help...SSRIs are just one of many ways to treat this. Point is to reach out for help when someone points it out to you - if you trust them, and you've struggled w/it long enough to the point of unmanageabiility. Study upon study show high causality between SSRI therapy and major reduction of MDD symptoms... good luck!
- scythe 12y agoThe editorial is here: http://www.bmj.com/content/350/bmj.h1771 http://www.bmj.com/content/350/bmj.h1771 Some of it I agree with, some I don't; I'm going to bed, but my primary objection relates to why the tricyclic antidepressants fell out of use. First of all, they're not gone; if you go to a psychiatrist and ask for amitryptyline or imipramine, you might just get it. But they're only used in depression which doesn't respond to SSRIs, because in some patients tricyclics can cause mania, hallucinations, and muscle twitching in addition to the infamous weight gain and sexual anhedonia seen on SSRIs. As such they were rarely prescribed even when they were the only drugs available. Otherwise I agree, but the question "why don't we use tricyclics?" has a lot of excellent answers.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoI compare this to giving a machine a hit with a wrench. So there is this cliché about machines which have hickups or stop working and then when you hit them hard enough, they work properly again. But that doesn't mean they were designed to only work under continous beatings. Same thing with serotonin: In depressed brains, SSRIs will "hit" the brain, and that works surprisingly often, but it doesn't mean the brain was supposed to only work with high serotonin levels.
- martin1975 12y agoECT hits it harder, and allegedly, in many cases, "reboots" it to a point of being normal (i.e. non-depressed), if the SSRI hits fail to work. Wanna hear something even trippier from my shrink's mouth? In cases where ECT failed - and not many at that - as an alternative, nicotine therapy broke the depression, restored feelings of normalcy. :) Obviously, they didn't have the patient take up smoking, since there are other ways to administer nicotine only without the 4000 byproducts of smoke, but it made sense, since I believe most of my family is depressed and the whole lot of them have been decades long smokers, to this day. Cool stuff huh? Grab that Camel pack now ;)
- Synaesthesia 12y agoWe do know that MDMA is an incredibly potent anti-depressant and serotonin releasing agent. It may be able to cure depression in a single dose. Unfortunately it was banned by the DEA under very controversial circumstances, against the recommendation of doctors and scientists, (who wanted it to be schedule 3) so a promising avenue of research was shut down. Of course it can be harmful, if abused, but if used correctly it's quite a benign substance. We also know from decades of studies that SSRI's don't work very well, often not at all, and that they also have paradoxical effects such as suicidal feelings and depression.