5 ms·
What's amazing/amusing to me is a hacky technical solution that solves the problem for "inspectors", instead of a solution that removes the need for any inspect
by scrollaway 12y ago
What's amazing/amusing to me is a hacky technical solution that solves the problem for "inspectors", instead of a solution that removes the need for any inspector to inspect the TV. A good administration system would make it easy to automatically check whether pub addresses use a business subscription.
- sopooneo 12y agoAre there pub proprietors that live over their pubs though, or beside them? If so, they could just snake the wire in from their homes.
- donatj 12y agoWell I think the idea might also be non-inspectors noticing and reporting establishments.
- Zenst 12y agoVery much so and case of being something joe-public can spot and report https://business.sky.com/fighting-fraud https://business.sky.com/fighting-fraud Now if they were to offer a token reward of even £50 then they would still be ahead as they would catch them all pretty much. Though imagine what would happen if traffic parking enforcement offered a commision to the public who reports such violations they see. Traffic wardens would be out of jobs and everybody would park much better in the long-run and many people without jobs and spare time would have a better quality of income.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoSo like HOAs for the road where soccer van moms can make money enforcing the most insignificant laws over and over again. Um... maybe let's not.
- mikeash 12y agoThe problem with HOAs isn't the soccer moms enforcing stupid rules, it's that stupid rules are in place to begin with. Likewise, the problem with parking enforcement isn't the enforcement, it's the stupid parking rules they enforce. Fix that, and citizen reporting is perfectly reasonable. (After all, we do it for all sorts of other crimes.) Don't fix that, and dedicated enforcement is also bad.
- inverba 12y agoThese laws already exist. http://gothamist.com/2015/03/10/cash_in_on_idling_vehicles.php http://gothamist.com/2015/03/10/cash_in_on_idling_vehicles.p...
- sambe 12y agoMost people want to watch their sports in their favourite environment. They're not going to report the pub and have that stop permanently.
- logfromblammo 12y agoPull the other one! I could fill a stadium with people who, if they saw a Time Warner or Comcast truck on fire in the street, would with great urgency and celerity rush past their fire extinguisher on the way to the bag of marshmallows. I'll report the guy who cheats the distribution channel the day after I see a monthly bill that I believe treats me fairly and respectfully.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- felixthehat 12y agoAlso amusing, these inspectors are paid to go to pubs to watch football matches. Not a bad job.
- JacobAldridge 12y agoI had a part-time job for a while inspecting cinema advertisements. The pay was minuscule (I did it on the side of my full time work), but all it involved was writing down the ads and previews in the order they were shown and noting any reaction from the crowd (positive, negative etc). My work was done when then feature started ... at which point, well, it would be rude to get up and leave wouldn't it? (We did have to get the manager's permission to stay for the show, but I was never once knocked back. I'd usually buy a frozen drink, so I guess they got something out of me.)
- YokoZar 12y agoDoesn't it defeat the purpose a bit if they know you're there? Why not cloak the inspection so you can catch the sort of fumbling of ads that happens when you're not aware you're being watched?
- ibmthrowaway218 12y agoThey're paid to visit lots of pubs during one particular match. Walk in, look at screen(s), walk out. You wouldn't get to see much of the game at all as most of the time you will be traveling between pubs.
- amelius 12y agoYes, but they get to tell a bunch of hooligans that the show they are watching is over.
- sveiss 12y agoSky is a satellite system, not cable; it's trivial to take the receiver and smartcard from one address to another and plug it into the dish there.
- jimktrains2 12y agoHow does the pint glass help with this and how doesn't this just strengthen gp's point?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sveiss 12y agoI expect that Sky broadcast multiple copies of the sports channels simultaneously (at a minimum, one with and one without the pint glass logo). Home subscribers are set up to tune[1] to the channel without the logo, the more expensive pub subscribers get the version with the pint glass logo. If a pub landlord subscribes at home, and then take their receiver/smartcard to the pub and plug it in there, the receiver will still display the home version of the channel without the logo. That's what the inspectors are looking for. (Alternatively, the smartcards used for pub subscription could insert the image into the decoded stream, but I'm not sure if they have enough processing power for that. The end result would be the same, though -- no expensive subscription, no logo.) [1] Yes, it's a digital system with multiple program streams per frequency, so 'tune' isn't quite the right word, but it's close enough.
- jimktrains2 12y agoA for some reason I thought you were talking about a COTS receiver and just pirating the business channel completely, not using an actual home receiver.
- sveiss 12y agoI think there's probably a perception issue at play too. Buying a pirate decoder card from a shady dealer is 'obviously' wrong, while using a subscription that you've already paid for in a different location is a different matter. I could see pub landlords being more comfortable doing the latter than the former. I don't know what the current state of the art for pirate decoders is, but if it still depends on extracting a keystream from a legitimate decoder in real time and sending it to the pirate receivers, limiting the number of legitimate receivers of the business channel to would also help cut down on piracy of the business channels by reducing the possible sources of key material. The high cost of a subscription and limiting subscribers to pub businesses only also reduces the number of potential key sources.
- petercooper 12y agoA good administration system would make it easy to automatically check whether pub addresses use a business subscription. That's what the TV licensing people do. There are people who've never bought a TV who've been hassled endlessly by TV Licensing simply because they can't believe there are any households who might choose not to own a television. The whole "detector van" thing is mostly a bogeyman to scare people.
- Robadob 12y agoThe whole "detector van" thing is mostly a bogeyman to scare people. The technology to remotely see what's showing on a CRT is Van Eck phreaking. Not sure over what distance it would be possible (and whether you could target a specific house accurately), also given the diversity in display technologies at current I can't see it being too effective. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Van_Eck_phreaking http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Van_Eck_phreaking
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI think you could do a pretty good job just by watching the pattern of lights changing in a room, and comparing it to what's currently being broadcast. No need for Van Eck hackery.
- DanBC 12y agoYes, van eck phreaking obviously works. But is it actually used in the UK to detect people without a license? Probably not, even though TVLA used to heavily advertise the use of detector vans. TVLA have the largest civillian database in the UK so mostly they just send letters and inspectors to addresses without a licence.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoThe detector vans are most likely smoke and mirrors. Even when they had the technology, you don't need to use it in most cases, the van's presence is enough to scare people.
- oh_sigh 12y agoYou still need to send someone out to confirm whether or not they are actually showing the TV to customers. For example, many pubs owners live over top their pubs, and their home may have the same address as the pub. Or, some pub owners might have a TV subscription to entertain their employees who are washing dishes in the back, but not actually show the TV to patrons.