2 ms·
>"WTF did you expect to happen?!" // Often we all assume something and so no one really investigates it properly. Science must concern itself with things we th
by pbhjpbhj 12y ago
>"WTF did you expect to happen?!" //
Often we all assume something and so no one really investigates it properly. Science must concern itself with things we think we know are a priori truths in order to provide a solid basis for building on.
That said Goltz experiment seems quite reasonable to me, ~"do frogs have non-brain based reflexes that react to temperature?", ~"do frogs react to absolute temperatures or just changes in temperature".
https://archive.org/stream/studiesfrombiol00martgoog#page/n405/mode/2up https://archive.org/stream/studiesfrombiol00martgoog#page/n4... at p.389 suggests that the frog with "no cerebrum" is in some way alive in Goltz experiment - perhaps it is missing that point that makes you say WTF?
It seems the excitability of headless frogs in varying temperatures was quite a point of interest, see eg p.393 ibid.
- mikeash 12y agoIt's just a knee-jerk reaction, "Duh, of course the frog with no brain doesn't jump." The difference between intuition and reality is the humor here.