5 ms·
How to see everything you’ve Googled while logged in
- amelius 12y agoWhy does Google need to keep all of this data, when they could just classify (cluster) people based on their searches, and keep only that information? That approach would anonymize the data to a great extent. EDIT: In fact, perhaps users should be enabled to specify the amount of dimensions in the "cluster space" that Google is permitted to store. Or, alternatively, specify the "uniqueness" of the data. So, for example, if I specify that I want my data to be 100% unique, Google will retain all of my information. But if I specify that I want my data to be 1% unique, Google will only remember that I'm a programmer that likes Japanese movies (and not the details, such as specific programming languages I use and specific movies I watch). In fact, this could be enforced by allowing Google to only store N bits of information about me, where N is a user-defined constant. And this would not only be useful from the viewpoint of privacy, but also from the perspective of not getting trapped in a filter bubble. [1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filter_bubble http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filter_bubble
- hahainternet 12y ago> when they could just classify (cluster) people based on their searches, and keep only that information? That approach would anonymize the data to a great extent. Well I'm glad you've solved it. Better get on to Goog's Engineers to let them know!
- IanCal 12y ago> Why does Google need to keep all of this data, when they could just classify (cluster) people based on their searches, and keep only that information? That assumes you can take a pre-generated cluster and add information to it without having to recompute with all the original information. It also assumes there's nothing you can do with personal search histories to either target adverts more effectively or add features, which would absolutely amaze me.
- amelius 12y agoGood point. Please see my note about the uniqueness of the data that I just added to my comment.
- shaurz 12y agoI disabled web search history on my account a while ago, but they have re-enabled without notifying me.
- danielbln 12y agoYou might have accidentally clicked on one of the nag screens Google throws at you (in Google Now for example). I turned my search history off a long time ago and it's still disabled.
- jacquesm 12y agoI don't click 'accidentally' on anything and the same thing has happened to me.
- cmdrfred 12y ago"I don't click 'accidentally' on anything" number one thing users say to every person who works in IT.
- jacquesm 12y agoSure. But I'm very privacy conscious and am very sure that I did not give google permission to harvest my queries. Not that I have any illusion that changing that setting does anything concrete but I'm kind of surprised to see that the setting did not stay in its 'do not log' position. There are accidental clicks on ads and then there are accidental clicks on privacy violating features like these and since it's down a few menu options clicking it by accident is just about impossible.
- cmdrfred 12y agoThe point I believe the person above is making is that it isn't a few menus deep. They apparently (I've never seen it) use some dark ui patterns and pop up a little box "Do you want to turn search history on?" randomly. Unless someone has eidetic memory they can't really claim they haven't clicked something like that ever.
- danbruc 12y agoWhat happens when you disable the search history? A) Google no longer stores your search history. B) Google no longer lets you see or download your search history.
- SpaceInvader 12y agoThis is exactly the question I'm asking myself. I have search history disabled for last (at least) 5 years, but I am not sure if google isn't storing it anyways.
- realusername 12y agoI would probably bet for the second option. Google has a quite long history of keeping everything they can. The only option would be to deny the Google home page access to the Google account cookies and to add an addon to add random searches just in case.
- stinos 12y agoFor me it seems to be B: tried to download history as described in the linked blog post and it took me to a page asking if I want to enable search history. Clicked 'No thanks' and it just showed me the google start page, not even an error message or so. edit forget the above. I got an email "Your Google search history archive is ready" with a link to a Drive document. Which contained an html file saying basically "No Searches". I cannot tell if that is really correct though: I don't actively use the account let alone I remember if I turned of search history before doing any searches while logged in..
- coldpie 12y agoI have had Search History disabled for years, but not forever. I use my Google account all over the place, including at work and on my Android phone. I downloaded the search archive and it contained the same "No Searches" HTML file and nothing else. It's impossible to know whether they actually store this data, but at least as far as their direct user-facing interfaces are concerned, Google does not track my search history.
- pdkl95 12y ago
- eeZi 12y agoAll non-ASCII characters are missing from the JSON dump.
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoThe curiosity in me wishes I didn't have search history disabled.
- Joona 12y agoDon't worry - it's not THAT great. Mine went back to 2007, and taking a quick look it didn't really remind me of anything. Maybe I should disable it...
- sbate1987 12y agosomebody make a website or app that lets me Google as someone else.
- donkeyd 12y agoThis is why I (probably naively) often Google things in incognito mode.
- jacquesm 12y agoWhat really bugs me is that I switched this off in the past and now find that it is back on again!
- paulornothing 12y agoWell I think this is interesting when I try to turn off sharing my searches with Google. > Please note that even when this setting is paused, Google may still use searches you make within active sessions in order to improve the quality of your search results.
- benlower 12y agoI google things using Bing. How can I get this to work?
- marssaxman 12y agoAnd this is why I keep Google accounts quarantined in a separate browser (Safari), and never ever log in using Firefox.