12 ms·
> The black women left behind find that potential partners of the same race are scarce, while men, who face an abundant supply of potential mates, don’t need to
by dmix 12y ago
> The black women left behind find that potential partners of the same race are scarce, while men, who face an abundant supply of potential mates, don’t need to compete as hard to find one. As a result, Mr. Charles said, “men seem less likely to commit to romantic relationships, or to work hard to maintain them.”
Interesting, I never thought about this side-effect of mass incarceration. Another aggravating factor in a repeating cycle?
I remember reading a hypothesis of why many middle eastern countries generate so many young angry jihadists is that most of the young men had never had a stable interactions with women in their youth. Most grew up in socially conservative environments and missed out on the stabilizing effect of having relationships with women, not having a sexual output, not having reasons to stay alive for a girl at home, or even missing out on having a female perspective on things (women are arguably less war-prone than men).
Middle eastern young males obviously experience a different social environment than black men do but I'm curious if stable relationships with women really do lead to less violence/crime by males? Or is that merely hopeful thinking by social conservatives?
- dccoolgai 12y agoThis dynamic has always frightened me about China's "one child" generation coming of age. Instead of a group of disaffected Jihadists, you have a large and influential political force in an increasingly belligerent and powerful nation.
- Someone1234 12y ago> increasingly belligerent I'd argue that China's belligerence is lower now than it has been. They've moved from a very communist that strongly distrusted and arguably even hated the West, to a semi-capitalist one who mostly just wants to compete with the West (and makes oodles of $$$ selling to us). The US has been drum-beating against China a lot recently, but frankly that seems more about the US losing in the "trade wars" than anything specific China did.
- Dirlewanger 12y agoI think (may not be) he's talking about the fact that China's male-to-female ratio is just under 1.2, which is insane for a country their size. Lots and lots of single unhappy men in a society where one is pressured to marry ASAP does not make for a happy society.
- Someone1234 12y agoHe was. He also suggested that China was: > an increasingly belligerent and powerful nation Powerful is of course true. Increasingly belligerent was the point I was responding to. If you look at China's recent history, they're a lot more West-friendly now than at any point since WWII.
- megaman22 12y agoIt's not been a good look for China historically either. Particularly around the fall of the Ming dynasty, there was a large male-female imbalance, and low and behold, in some of the places where that ratio was worst, there were some of the most destructive of the peasant rebellions.
- adventured 12y agoChina's neighbors would likely disagree about China only wanting to trade. They're very aggressively laying claim to large swaths of sea around the Philippines, Vietnam, and Malaysia that clearly do not belong to them. Annexing water territory that does not belong to them, is no different than China taking Tibet by force on the basis that they proclaim it belongs to them. As such it's clear that plenty of their extreme belligerence is still intact.
- yichi 12y agoIn what way would you say those terroritories do not belong to China, or any other country in the region? Or better yet, what makes even places like Canton, Shanghai even belong to China? (Keep in mind I'm not saying these lands do or do not actually belong to China, but I'm merely asking under what grouds do you make these claims)
- ggchappell 12y agoExcept they're not "coming of age"; they already have. Enforcement of the one-child policy started in 1980. The first children born under it are turning 35 these days. I think your worry is a very reasonable one, but it has not become a reality. I wonder why not.
- eru 12y agoThe one child policy has not always and everywhere been enforce with full power. You get a certain buffer effect from men getting a younger female companion: measured in person years, you'll have more single-men-years than single-women-years this way.
- crazygringo 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_women_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_women_of_China
- Dirlewanger 12y agoYet another reason why a society only is as stable and wholesome as its average nuclear family unit.
- erickhill 12y agoI know this is treading off-topic, but interestingly, "lefty wacko uber-progressive" Seattle (I put that in quotes as it's not my thoughts, but some of the commenters found on The Seattle Times would likely describe it as such) has the highest percentage of nuclear families in the 50 largest cities in the U.S. Source: http://blogs.seattletimes.com/fyi-guy/2014/12/28/end-of-the-nuclear-family-not-in-seattle/ http://blogs.seattletimes.com/fyi-guy/2014/12/28/end-of-the-...
- foldr 12y agoThe burden of proof should really be on the OP, who didn't provide any evidence to back the hypothesis up.
- Kluny 12y agoI think you and your parent comment may be using two different definitions of "nuclear" though. One definition is the traditional mom-dad-2.3 kids arrangement, but a broader and equally valid definition can include polygamy, gay parents with a surrogate, lesbian parents with a sperm donor, couples where the mom and dad have split and started new families but still have kids in common, and a million other combinations. The most important positive factor seems to be stability, which is easier to maintain when your peer group is accepting of whatever weird arrangement you have. That acceptance is a strengthening factor for the traditional nuclear family as well as the non-traditional combinations.
- panglott 12y ago"Nuclear" should mean that newly married couples form a new household rather than integrating into the household of the extended family. Why the nuclear rather than the extended family would be considered important for social stability is anyone's guess. We live in an incredibly atomized society that values personal freedom and autonomy over interdependence and social connection, but that doesn't mean "stability".
- guelo 12y agoThat middle eastern hypothesis is wrong, offensive and off topic.
- cloakandswagger 12y agoI think it's an interesting point. Even more interesting is your attempt to shut down the conversation because it offends you.
- DanBC 12y agoPeople don't trn and shut down these conversations because they're offensive. They try and sht them down because they're toxic. Try wandering into any programming thread and talking nonsense about eg static typing then complaining about people trying to shut down the conversation.
- hackuser 12y ago> Even more interesting is your attempt to shut down the conversation because it offends you. That brings up an interesting issue for me. It's a somewhat popular trope, that there is an equivalence between Amy offending people and Bob asking her to stop. It's really a rhetorical tactic -- an attempt to disrupt Bob by forcing him to philsophically justify what is obviously and intuitively true to everyone. There may be a question of whether something is offensive or otherwise does harm to others, of course. But absolutely if someone finds something offensive, they should stand up and say so -- and not be shut down by the new political correctness (i.e., the frequent knee-jerk reaction to people who point out issues of race, gender, etc.).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- fredgrott 12y agothe other aspect not to be missed as it lines up gang studies is that there is big lack father time with both sons and daughters..in ME its a culture of multiple wives..different from gangs with single moms..but same effects angry young men
- hemantv 12y agoI think similar dynamics applies in India too. It has been changing a lot in recent time.
- soheil 12y agoHow does this belong in HN? And have you looked at what those countries been put through by us? It's easy to believe media propaganda, but are you doing yourself or the world a favor by willfully ignoring the real geo-political reasons that caused so many crises in those regions?
- at-fates-hands 12y agoI'm pretty sure no geo-political reasons cause many middle eastern societies to treat woman lower than dogs and cats. Those my friend, are religious and cultural norms put in place by their own people. No amount of external pressure has ceased the ungodly treatment of woman, homosexuals and other "miscreants" as they are deemed in much of the middle east.
- hackuser 12y ago> I'm pretty sure no geo-political reasons cause many middle eastern societies to treat woman lower than dogs and cats. The U.S. and western powers keep the conservative Middle Eastern dictatorships in place, preventing any social and political reform. That is, in fact, a major cause of resentment by people of the Middle East toward the West. In fact, Al Qaeda's goal is to overthrow the Middle Eastern dictatorships (and inflict their own oppressive dictatorship on the people there). They targeted the U.S. because they believed that American support is the reason those governments are stable, and that they first have to drive the U.S. out of the Arabian Penninsula. The people in most Middle Eastern countries have no choice in the matter, and geopolitics is a major reason why.
- hindsightbias 12y agoIt's a major cause of resentment, but that doesn't mean they've thought it out. I'd argue that the US has been a socially moderating force, not that that was intentional or a US goal. I don't think there's any evidence Iraq, Libya, Egypt (under Morsi), Syria (under whatever remains) and eventually KSA are going to end up with better treatment for women when all their political reform is over. Iraq under Saddam was more secular - women's rights to vote, education and political office went back to the 70's. In some areas, they may be holding on, but overall I doubt they'll end up being better off. Egypt had a huge social/political change, and democracy meant a MB majority. Now they're back with Mubarak-lite (and they all blame the US for abandoning Egypt to the MB).
- fossuser 12y agoI remember reading somewhere (probably here) that the same effect is shown in areas with heavily skewed male/female ratios in general. That in places with a lot more men than women both men and women converge on wanting a long term relationship, but in places with a lot more women than men - men would typically prefer not having a relationship i.e. more single mothers in NYC than on the west coast. There was also a subtext idea about women (in general) being competitive and 'slut shaming' as an evolved mechanism to collude with each other and push the sexual availability/access down in order force men to have to invest more time/effort/resources into a relationship. I'll try and see if I can find whatever it was - the idea was cool (if not obvious) and the unintentional collusion part didn't occur to me. There's probably a lot at play though it's hard to make any real statements about evolved behavior outside of cultural pressure and without a lot of time to look at things.
- michaelchisari 12y agoin places with a lot more men than women both men and women converge on wanting a long term relationship, but in places with a lot more women than men There's also the narrative that places where men outnumber women, men become increasingly competitive and violent towards women and each other. An example is any blue collar "boom" town like North Dakota's fracking industry.
- mc32 12y agoIn china where men outnumber women due to family preference for a male heir, it has resulted in straight men having to compete with each other on an economic status basis to attract women, what happens in north Dakota is not a universal phenomenon.
- Retric 12y agoThis is vastly overstated. Historically there are 1.05 male births per 1 female birth without any technical sex selection going on. Which for a population the size of China works out to an extra ~33 million men. Interestingly in the US and globally men of every age but ~10 years old die more frequently than men so older woman significantly out number older men. It's a fairly significant gap which is one of the reasons this chart looks so shocking. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db88_fig4.png http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db88_fig4.png Roughly stated the younger the population the more men you end up with. Generally this is balanced by woman having shorter 'breaks' between relationships until old age when women significantly out number men. See: 1950: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_China#/media/File:China_Sex_by_Age_1953_census.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_China#/media/Fi... vs: 2010 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_China#/media/File:China_Sex_By_Age_2010_census.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_China#/media/Fi... It's hard to read, but the gap actually looks smaller for 15 year olds now vs 1950.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Mizza 12y ago> women are arguably less war-prone than men I don't think are actually any studies that support this, unfortunately. War simply isn't a consequence of gender, it is a consequence of ideology and fear.
- joshuapants 12y ago> it is a consequence of ideology and fear ... and competition for resources
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- subsection1h 12y agoAll of the relevant poll results that I could find at PollingReport.com[1][2] indicate that women are less likely than men to support war. [1] http://www.pollingreport.com/iraq17.htm http://www.pollingreport.com/iraq17.htm [2] http://www.pollingreport.com/iraq18.htm http://www.pollingreport.com/iraq18.htm
- zurn 12y agoIt's not hard to find references to such studies. See eg "Scholars and polling organizations have also noted a consistent gender divide in public opinion on military action, beginning with World War II through the most recent U.S. wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, with men expressing higher levels of support for military action than women (Bendyna et al.,1996; Berinsky, 2009; Burris, 2008; Fite et al., 1990; Moore, 2002; Nincic and Nincic, 2002; Rohall et al., 2006; Shapiro and Mahajan, 1986; Smith, 1984; Wilcox et al., 1993)" (from https://www.academia.edu/1802567/Race_Gender_and_Attitudes_Toward_War_in_Chicago_An_Intersectional_Analysis https://www.academia.edu/1802567/Race_Gender_and_Attitudes_T... )
- gaius 12y agoIf you are English you grew up with the stories of Boudicca who battled the Romans, the notion of the warrior woman is pretty deeply embedded in our national psyche.
- mrxd 12y ago
- foldr 12y ago>many middle eastern countries I'd be careful of generalizing across such a diverse region. Isn't it actually a fairly small minority of countries in the Middle East that "generate [lots] of young angry jihadists"?
- dmix 12y agoMost of the 18 countries considered part of the middle east have outputted their share of young men - especially if you rank the countries by population. And a significant percentage of Al-Qaeda in Afghanistan and Pakistan were foreign fighters from middle eastern countries not central asia, particularly the leading figures. I believe most people on HN are aware extremists represent a small percentage of the total populations.
- foldr 12y agoThat's missing the point. The question is what percentage of the countries in the Middle East are producing significant numbers of "jihdists".
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dmix 12y agoI would rank these middle eastern countries as the origin nationality of most jihadists. High: Iran, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Syria, Palestine, Lebanon, Egypt (most members of the original Al-Qaeda and current leader were Egyptian, and then there are Sinai groups) Medium (mostly just financing since they have low populations and high income): United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Bahrain. Low: Turkey (?), Jordan, Kuwait, Oman, Israel, Cyprus. These are obviously based on nationalities of jihadists, not based on percentages of populations whom become jihadists - which I suspect you are confusing my comment as implying.
- discreteevent 12y agoIran high? I wasn't aware of that. Could I ask what you are basing that on. Do you mean Iranian militias which are effectively the army and doing things which could be said to protect their country (as with US soldiers in all kinds of places they probably shouldn't be). If so I don't think that comes under the heading "angry young jihadis"
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoGay suicide due probably to social pressures. Hopefully gay rights will lessen these problems. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_among_LGBT_youth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_among_LGBT_youth
- BHSPitMonkey 12y agoAre you citing suicide as a violent tendency?
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoTwo issues. First, the point could be: I'm curious if stable relationships with the gender they find attractive really do lead to less violence/crime by males?. Second, there are significant differences in the brains of heterosexual and homosexual men (one of the points made by those saying it was not a choice). These could mean that the above point only applies to heterosexual men.
- learnstats2 12y agoWait, what? Are you claiming that gay men don't have stable relationships?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- learnstats2 12y agoNot usually, I guess. [Sorry for my poor assumption there, thanks for clarifying :)]
- dghf 12y ago> Is there a gay crime wave? I haven't noticed one. I can think of two possible, orthogonal answers why that (sort of) fit the hypothesis: - the key is not 'stable relationships with women' but 'stable sexual relationships'; - many gay men do have stable relationships with women, in the form of strong, non-sexual friendships. [Edit: I neither support nor reject the hypothesis; I just don't think gay men are necessarily a good control group for it.]
- steamy 12y agoI think Osama Bin Laden had so many life-stabilizers i.e. women throughout his lifetime and yet he pursued the terrorist career with vengeance till the last breath.
- pyre 12y agoYou can't take a single person as proof or disproof of anything (except maybe absolute statements, which the OP didn't make).
- fecklessyouth 12y agoThe idea that boys need exposure to women before adulthood, with the exception of their mother, is a relatively modern one. The extent to which the modern west mixes the sexes through education and other social activities is unprecedented, so the Middle East is not nearly alone in this respect. Of course, things change in adulthood, and if young Middle Eastern men who would normally be entering stable relationships with women are prevented from doing so, I can imagine how that would enable angry jihadists. But at that age, the blame probably lies with other social/economic factors and less with their family unit. And the effect that marriage has on the behavior of men is fairly well-known: http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/inspired-life/wp/2015/04/02/dont-be-a-bachelor-why-married-men-work-harder-and-smarter-and-make-more-money/?postshare=3351429127355739 http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/inspired-life/wp/2015/04/...
- hackuser 12y ago> The idea that boys need exposure to women before adulthood, with the exception of their mother, is a relatively modern one. The extent to which the modern west mixes the sexes through education and other social activities is unprecedented, so the Middle East is not nearly alone in this respect. That's true, but if the prosperity and peace of the modern west also are relatively modern and unusual, perhaps the exposure to women has a positive effect.
- hbhakhra 12y agoThere have been so many factors that have changed in relatively modern times, that this is one time to say correlation doesn't equal causation.
- Ntrails 12y agoBut we certainly shouldn't discount the possibility that there is a causal link.
- panglott 12y agoAt the same time, it seems like marriage is much more costly and difficult for men to achieve in much of the Middle East/South Asia. So you still have a larger population of unmarried men without many marriage prospects.
- roymurdock 12y agoIn my experience, having a stable girlfriend for the past 3 years has been like looking in a mirror every month or so. She calls me out on things that I do habitually or without thinking, usually because they are selfish and hurt her or our relationship in some way. These are habits or personality traits that my close friends and family wouldn't be aware of, but that my girlfriend has exclusive access to as the one with whom I share the most intimate details of my life. She forces me to reflect on why I am the way that I am; sometimes directly when we fight, but often indirectly through her questions and observations. I'd like to think that our relationship has made us more empathetic and introspective. I don't think it has made me any less extreme in my ideals though. My personal view is that extremism is generally bred by a low standard of living and a high degree of economic inequality that is forced onto a united group of people that feel like they deserve more than the system has given them. The uniting factor could be race, religion, age - anything, it doesn't really matter. I've recently been struggling with the notion that, as a 22-year old who is about to graduate, I am to enter an economy and a system set up and controlled entirely by the captains of finance and government who allowed the financial crisis of 2007 to occur, and who have been unable to "fix" the economy through monetary and fiscal reform. This has pushed me towards the study of Bitcoin, a "radical" tool that traditional economists are quick to dismiss as a libertarian/anarchist fantasy. I don't subscribe to any political viewpoint - I simply see a broken system that has destroyed the lives of many of the constituents that it was created to serve through corruption and negligence. Bitcoin is just another tool, such as Quantitative Easing and Interest rate manipulation, that we could possibly implement to reduce the volatility of the financial system and remove some of its susceptibility to greed and corruption. My interest in Bitcoin nothing compared to ISIS, the PLO, the Black Panthers, or any other minority group that was oppressed and decided to try and change a system that it found unfair and stacked against it. The difference is that these "extremist" groups use violence to fight their battles, because they see the alternative life of dying poor and oppressed as a non-option. If we were to advance every civilization to a point where the standard of living was high enough and the measure of inequality was low enough, I think we could eradicate most forms of physically violent extremism. Mental "extremism" in the form of thought-experiments pushing the boundaries of the current system would continue, but to the benefit of society in general. Will this ever happen? Probably not.
- 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- teen 12y ago> I remember reading a hypothesis of why many middle eastern countries generate so many young angry jihadists is that most of the young men had never had a stable interactions with women in their youth. Most grew up in socially conservative environments and missed out on the stabilizing effect of having relationships with women, not having a sexual output, not having reasons to stay alive for a girl at home, or even missing out on having a female perspective on things (women are arguably less war-prone than men). This has been my experience in San Francisco, thanks to gender imbalances
- danielweber 12y agoMonogamy was an amazing invention, as it did something with all the surplus males with nothing to lose.
- brc 12y agoMany middle eastern countries practice polygamy which deprives many lower status men of the chance of having a partner and children. The high status men also enforce heavy penalties for adultery to ensure their collection of wives is not cuckolded by other men. Coupled with the inequality where women are treated as property and this indeed does remove the tempering influence of women. There is little doubt that the triggering of protective behaviour that comes with fatherhood is a benefit to any society.
- throwaway8198 12y agoThe main reason for disaffected middle eastern young men is: 1) lack of career prospects, especially for university graduates 2) because of #1, young men cannot afford a matrimonial house and ceremony, so can't get laid (adultery is a capital crime.) That's why 72 virgins in the afterlife is very appealing ... because they aren't getting any in this life.
- twic 12y agoI don't know if romantic relationships would prevent civilians becoming terrorists, but in at least one case, they were deliberately used to turn terrorists back into civilians: http://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/issues/2001/12/hoffman.htm http://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/issues/2001/12/hoffman....
- benjaminmhaley 12y ago> why many middle eastern countries generate so many young angry jihadists This is akin to wondering why Europeans generated so many young angry crusaders. The term jihadists denotes a religion and a region. Its associated with Middle Eastern countries by definition. Angry young militants from other religions and regions are given different names. If we look at objective measurements of violence, like murder rate by country [1], we can see that the Middle East is not particularly violent, rather its on par with America. It is harder to find meaningful information on militarism. We do know that the Middle East was host to 3 of the 4 world conflicts that killed more than 10,000 people in 2014 [2]. All of these conflicts have included significant foreign and local involvement. Their causes are complex. In my opinion, they are driven by a desire to control the world's most valuable resource (Oil!) not by cultural factors. Finally, it is worth noting that Americans use the word Jihad to mean holy war, but in the Middle East the word does not have the same violent meaning [3]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intention... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ongoing_armed_conflicts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ongoing_armed_conflict... [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jihad#Current_usage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jihad#Current_usage
- panglott 12y agoYes, but why Europe produced so many angry young crusaders is also an interesting question that touches on gender and family issues. IIRC the Norman practice of dividing an estate among all surviving sons led, after a few generations, to large populations of land-hungry armed horsemen on tiny estates. Thus the Normans exported mercenary and conquering armies all over Europe, starting with England through the Crusades.
- benjaminmhaley 12y agoI agree that it is interesting to wonder why certain cultures are more violent and militant than others. My points, more clearly: 1. That # of Jihadist does not indicate how violent and militant a culture is because it is not a cross-cultural term. 2. That cross cultural measures of murder rates do not indicate that the Middle East is home to particularly violent cultures. 3. That the Middle East is home to lots of military action, but that it is produced by foreign and local interests and can be explained by financial motives rather than cultural ones.
- selimthegrim 12y agoOn the list of modern ideas, you might also want to toss in the pile women being less war-prone, especially over there if nothing else.
- flatfilefan 12y agoFor the Middle East it can be much simpler than that. I read something like Middle East experiences a population boom with like 50% of population being younger than 25. (exact number may differ) With so many young men there is not enough land from parents for them to inherit. With no decent education to increase productivity and a rigid political structure there is a huge pressure in the society building up.
- caramel 12y ago> I remember reading a hypothesis of why many middle eastern countries generate so many young angry jihadists Maybe we don't need to look further than the psychological impact of enforced genital mutilation past the age of infancy.