6 ms·
I don't like what this Florida Police Officer is doing. But focusing on a single poorly spoken sentence is absurd. I understand that police sheriffs are politi
by dragontamer 12y ago
I don't like what this Florida Police Officer is doing.
But focusing on a single poorly spoken sentence is absurd. I understand that police sheriffs are politicians, so this is generally considered "fair game" in American Politics. But this is an obviously bad, off-the-cuff remark that Chris Nocco shouldn't have said.
But the amount of focus that has been given to this absurd statement is ridiculous. It is a demonstration of our short-attention span and love of "gotcha" catchphrases that are destroying American Politics.
Lets do this rationally. Lets start by looking for a written official statement from this Officer before making fun of his views.
---------------------------
Here's a better quote from this officer.
"I think, unfortunately, when the story's being told in other (publications), they're not talking about the fact that he committed this crime previously," Nocco said Monday. "We enforce the law. And if we don't enforce the law, nobody else will."
Knowing that this guy is a repeat offender changes the calculus significantly. I think everyone can get a free pass once. The 2nd pass, maybe the officer is just showing the kid that he really has the power to prosecute him (without necessarily going forward with the intent on actually doing so).
The kid's lawyer likely contacted the eff / press to make the officer back off a bit. In the end, the kid is going to get off with a slap on the wrist and a bit of disdain for the officers of this country.
- emodendroket 12y agoHow many people posting on HN have not, at several times in their lives, in some way used computer systems in an "unauthorized" way?
- dragontamer 12y agoHow many people on HN have been caught using a computer system in an "unauthorized" way, and then decided to do it again less than a few months later? Remember, this kid is a repeat offender. He got caught, officially, at least once by the Police. We don't know how many times his teachers caught him before putting something onto his permanent record either. ---------------- EDIT: "Green was released on Wednesday from Land O'Lakes Detention Center into the custody of his mother. He'll likely be granted pretrial intervention by a judge, sheriff's detective Anthony Bossone said." The Sheriff Detective doesn't even expect this kid to have any serious harm on his record. They're trying to scare the kid without really putting anything on his record. Unfortunately, the freaking newspapers are releasing this guy's name. What the flying *!@#! guys? Does not Florida have laws against releasing the names of 14-year old minors?
- lawnchair_larry 12y agoIt's a setting on a computer. Get a grip. This is pure insanity.
- dragontamer 12y ago> [redacted] said that on the morning in question, he accessed the computer that stored the FCAT files and, realizing that computer didn't have a camera, found another. > "So I logged out of that computer and logged into a different one and I logged into a teacher's computer who I didn't like and tried putting inappropriate pictures onto his computer to annoy him," [redacted] said. Erm... the kid was looking for cameras so that he'd spy on his classmates using administrative privileges. BTW: The real problem here... is that the press is extremely dumb how they're handling this. I shouldn't be able to find this information... the press should have editorial discretion to protect this kid from this sort of analysis I'm doing. It's not right to take apart an 8th-grader's argument like this... but I think I have to to prove a point to yall. I'm gonna redact his name at least, unlike the press.
- judk 12y agoIt reads like he put a picturr of his own butt on the computer, not spy on anyone
- nogridbag 12y agoNow that I look back on it, I've done this numerous times. If I was born 5-10 years later, I would probably be in jail. When I was in elementary school, I inputted an expletive into the school's hangman game - I thought it was amusing. The school staff did not. In middle school, I wrote a simple basic program that would run in the background and speak() interesting phrases throughout the day. In middle/high school I received detention for goofing off when I was supposed to be researching in the library. I was using Google.com - which the staff had never heard of. When we first had internet at home, I sent a fake email to my parents from billclinton@whitehouse.gov. On an internship, I remotely changed the wallpaper of a coworkers PC (we played pranks on each other all the time). But I accidentally targeted a machine in our conference room which was being used by a high ranking military officer... In college, I attempted to add the school president as a friend on thefacebook.com, since many users at the time had fake accounts as friends like George Bush, Arnold Schwarzenegger, etc. But I needed a valid college email to signup. So I created a forwarding email alias: hisname@myschool.edu but for some reason I could not receive email using that alias so I went to sleep. I spent the following couple of days being interrogated by the police and various school officials. I didn't find out until some point later, but apparently this was the school president's actual forwarding email address and due to some bug in the school mail system, I registered a dup account which made all his incoming emails bounce. But I was treated as a hacker, threatened with being expelled and charged with a two-page list of crimes such as identity theft, unauthorized access, etc. I got off with being put on school probation, community service, and writing some papers.
- hobs 12y agoYep, sounds like we should definitely throw children in prison because they keep changing that dang wallpaper. "We enforce the law, especially when it is an outmoded reaction to children, if we dont have ridiculous reactions to things, nobody else will." Police officers have the power to scare without having to prosecute, this is just giving an officer a free pass for something that (if needed) should have ended with a kid in the back of a squad car driven home, not with an national press release from the eff.
- dragontamer 12y ago> Police officers have the power to scare without having to prosecute, this is just giving an officer a free pass for something that (if needed) should have ended with a kid in the back of a squad car driven home, not with an national press release from the eff. And since the officer seems to have already done that last October, and the kid continues to access the computer... What should the officer do then?
- trcollinson 12y agoMaybe the officer should suggest that the school and district have a better systems security policy? And that youth who seem to get passwords should be suspended from class? Or expelled for repeat offenders? Or possibly have a community service program for these sorts of cases? Why did the police need to be called at all? This is the centeral question in this case. Are we trying to say at this point schools and districts and parents can't punish for minor offenses like pranking a teach?
- dragontamer 12y agoThe kid already was suspended in October. Which means the kid has already shown disdain against the teachers. They're escalating the issue very naturally. And the Police seem like they're working in such a way to prevent any permanent damage on the kid's record. A felony charge is a very scary proposition to go through. But ultimately, its a slap on the wrist (its a charge, they haven't actually written anything to his permanent record yet), and the sheriff detectives have made it clear that they expect the kid to be let go during the pre-trial process. So far, there isn't any permanent harm to the kid's record. So... what's the problem exactly?
- omegaham 12y ago> The kid's lawyer likely contacted the eff / press to make the officer back off a bit. In the end, the kid is going to get off with a slap on the wrist and a bit of disdain for the officers of this country. I think this is both appropriate and what will happen. If the kid is a repeat offender, it's time to bring out the justice system and hit him with the stick. Charging him with a felony is pretty ridiculous, but odds are that it's going to be pled down to a misdemeanor, which will result in a couple months of probation and some community service. In addition, a misdemeanor can be sealed once he turns 18, which means that he won't ruin his life over something as stupid as this. If he offends again, fuck him.
- dragontamer 12y agoThe Sheriff's Detective actually expects him to be let go through pretrial intervention. "Green was released on Wednesday from Land O'Lakes Detention Center into the custody of his mother. He'll likely be granted pretrial intervention by a judge, sheriff's detective Anthony Bossone said." The real crime is the freaking newspapers that are publishing the kid's name. THERE'S A REASON WHY ITS LOOKED DOWN UPON YOU IDIOTS. This would have been a scare tactic by police to show the kid that he's in serious trouble. They would have let him go pretrial, put minor marks on his junivile record which would have been wiped away. Now his name is all over the freaking internet thanks to the illegitimate press who don't understand how this system is supposed to work. Thanks press for &@#$ing this kid over in his ass.
- sarciszewski 12y agoYeah, having your name dragged through the mud before you even enter high school isn't going to help your employment prospects later in life.
- judk 12y agoI dunno, the employers seem to like people who don't tale stupid for an answer. And maybe a kid who won't sit down for buklshit will become an entrleneur.
- balabaster 12y agoSee, that's fair enough. He'd done it before and deserves to receive some penalty for his actions to show him that there are consequences for your actions and you need to consider the consequences before you commit the crime. But there is a generally accepted (and somewhat sane) process in academia. - Warning from the teacher & perhaps a letter/call home to the parents - Sent to the principal & perhaps another letter/call home to the parents, warning of suspension - Suspension - Expulsion - Police (& perhaps juvenile detention based on the crime) Kids are kids... Grade 8 is what? 13, 14 years old? I'm not saying that being a kid automatically gives you a walk, but kids make dumb decisions every day. Lord knows plenty of adults do too, but for kids that goes double. They don't have the smarts, foresight or experience to make good decisions yet, so they need to be taught. Hopefully the kid does get a slap on the wrist and hopefully he realizes that he got lucky and breathes a sigh of relief rather than taking the lesson that he can do what he wants and with the right lawyer he can get away with murder. Because who knows what he'll do if he learns a lesson like that... probably become the CEO of a bank or oil conglomerate or something.
- dragontamer 12y agoThe kid was already suspended in October. Which means the order that is going on right now is... - Warning from Teacher - Sent to the principal - 3-day Suspension <--- Happened in October - Police + 10-day Suspension - Expulsion Which frankly, doesn't sound that "unjust" to me at all.
- mordocai 12y agoPolice scaring the kid sounds fine, but a felony? Using a well-known password in a place with terrible security to do a mostly harmless prank results in a felony? That isn't justice.
- dragontamer 12y ago"He'll likely be granted pretrial intervention by a judge, sheriff's detective Anthony Bossone said." They aren't planning to put the felony on his record. They're gonna drop it pre-trial.
- maxerickson 12y agoThe most severe penalty that should attach to repeated unauthorized access of a school computer is expulsion. And that should take a while. If there was proof the kid was doing other harm using those computers, maybe that would be something where the legal system should get involved (depends on the harm), but the unauthorized access itself should stay a school matter.
- Roodgorf 12y agoI think the bigger takeaway is that the law as it is is much too broad. Certainly if this kid is a repeat offender for this there should be consequences for him, but a felony? If this really is as simple as using a known password then I think some amount of responsibility should fall on the shoulders of the school. Beyond that, if nothing truly crime-worthy was done, say, stealing private information, changing grades, etc., then it seems like this should be a matter handled by the school administration rather than the state.
- dragontamer 12y ago"He'll likely be granted pretrial intervention by a judge, sheriff's detective Anthony Bossone said." They're scaring the kid by charging him with a felony. Then the felony charge disappears during a pre-trial intervention, and the kid hopefully learns a little bit of respect afterwards. > stealing private information [Redacted] said that on the morning in question, he accessed the computer that stored the FCAT files and, realizing that computer didn't have a camera, found another. He was trying to spy on the other kids using the school cameras. Since his teacher's computer didn't have access to the cameras, he left a prank instead, and then looked for another computer.
- gtf21 12y agoIf you've found said written report it would be helpful to link to it. Even so: > he committed this crime previously What, the egregious crime of changing a background image? God knows what I would have been charged for as a kid, given the number of times I messed with a friend's computer to play pranks. A slap on the wrist, and then maybe detention and some slow escalation should perhaps be appropriate. Felony charges are an absurd reaction.
- dragontamer 12y ago> What, the egregious crime of changing a background image? Well... lets take a look, shall we? > [redacted] said that on the morning in question, he accessed the computer that stored the FCAT files and, realizing that computer didn't have a camera, found another. > "So I logged out of that computer and logged into a different one and I logged into a teacher's computer who I didn't like and tried putting inappropriate pictures onto his computer to annoy him," [redacted] said. The kid was using his unauthorized access to computer systems to find the school cameras so that he could spy on his classmates.
- sarciszewski 12y agoA friend of mine found all the social security numbers for every student with free and reduced lunch in our school's network, without ever touching his keyboard. Just by clicking.
- knd775 12y agoYou definitely misunderstood that. He was looking for a computer with a webcam.
- BuildTheRobots 12y ago"they're not talking about the fact that he committed this crime previously," You've got to wonder if he used the same password both times. If he did then it strikes me that the teachers and school that should be raked over the coals for not putting even the most basic safegards in place to protect all that confidential data on the laptop -especially after already being shown up about it. "The teacher’s computer reportedly had sensitive encrypted information related to the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test (FCAT)." -The other thing jumping to mind is that if the sensitive data was all properly encrypted, then even with intent, the student wouldn't have been able to view or tamper with it. Edit: grammar; as->that
- dragontamer 12y agoVictim Blaming fallacy. Do I need to go further?
- astrodust 12y agoVictim blaming is when someone, through no fault of their own, suffers harm. In this case a reckless disregard for proper security practices was endangering students.
- dragontamer 12y ago> Victim blaming occurs when the victim of a crime or any wrongful act is held entirely or partially responsible for the harm that befell them. Teacher had his computer improperly accessed by a student. The student did the wrong (granted, it is a minor wrong), and yet you are blaming the teachers. You are victim blaming. Period.
- astrodust 12y agoThe teacher is responsible for picking a secure password, just as they're responsible for a number of other things. They failed in their responsibility. They are not 100% to blame here, but they are not a "victim" like you paint them to be.
- sosuke 12y agoThanks for bringing reason to the commentary. I/we often lambaste media for not highlighting the other side, or being reasonable, but even though this story comes from "our side" they have left out enough information to try and cultivate outrage. This tactic is abhorrent from any publication.
- dragontamer 12y agoIts an EFF publication. The EFF is a lobby group specifically catered towards our opinion. The EFF is doing their job. The important part is to recognize that bias is part of their job. And just as the EFF does a good job at recognizing "hacker culture" and representing us in the press, we have to look at other news sources to get the full picture.
- JediWing 12y agoIf the kid was a repeat offender, have you considered the other side of the coin? If he only logged in by using a well-know/shared password, and there really was sensitive/personal information, then shame on the school for REPEATEDLY failing to SECURE that information. IMO a better use of our criminal justice system would be prosecuting the school for some kind of criminal negligence (though that would also be an overreaction... just saying it would be a better use than this nonsense). "Fool me once..." and all that
- dragontamer 12y agoNope. I try not to victim blame.
- nbouscal 12y agoEven when the victim legitimately deserves the blame? If I jump in front of someone shooting a gun at target practice, are you going to support charging them with manslaughter? If I jump off a bridge, are you going to blame the bridge builder?
- dragontamer 12y ago> If I jump in front of someone shooting a gun at target practice, are you going to support charging them with manslaughter? Manslaughter: unintentional killing that results from recklessness or criminal negligence. Last time I checked, we didn't charge that little girl who shot the gun instructor in the head with an Uzi. Your understanding of the criminal system is poor, please read up on it before continuing this conversation.
- nbouscal 12y agoMy understanding of the criminal system is fine. Your ability to reason sensibly, rather than using the "victim blaming" semantic stop-sign, is more questionable. Your ability to carry on a polite conversation is quite obviously deficient.
- notahacker 12y agoI'd be more concerned with the fact the EFF press release wilfully ignored the kid's apparent record of multiple similar offences and escalating punishments than the fact that it highlighted a statement the officer really shouldn't have made. Omitting obviously relevant details about the nature of the alleged offences risks undermining the credibility of future EFF press releases in defence of genuinely inexplicably arrested people, and the problem is there's a pattern developing here: a couple of days ago an EFF press release was issued about a security consultant who "tweeted about airplane network security". From the EFF's press release, you'd have thought he was a persecuted whistleblower, but he instead turned out to be an idiot who tweeted the network security equivalent of a bomb threat. I'm not convinced that felony charges guilty of nondestructive pranks on teachers' computers are appropriate, but I'm also not convinced that accounts which omit the main reason why charges were brought particularly serve the cause of fighting against judicial overreach. You can cry wolf too many times.