5 ms·
Don't underestimate philosophy's power to change the world. Marx's critique of capitalism had a dramatic effect, for example.
by barrkel 12y ago
Don't underestimate philosophy's power to change the world. Marx's critique of capitalism had a dramatic effect, for example.
- czzarr 12y agoKant's, Hegel's and Nietszche's too
- taylorscollon 12y agoAristotle gave us logic, which is the basis for rational inquiry in all fields. Also an important contribution.
- hueving 12y agoBecause people couldn't think before Aristotle? Formalizing something is very different than 'giving it to humanity'.
- taylorscollon 12y agoGravity exerted force before Newton formalized its effect. I think Newton's contribution was still valuable.
- hueving 12y agoRight, but we didn't pretend like there wasn't something that brought you back down when you jumped until newton's work.
- dhfromkorea 12y agoIn Asia, the key ideas of Confucius, Mencius, Laotzu, Zhuangzi and the like are still alive at the hearts of many.
- Symmetry 12y agoI suppose Marx is a good example of why philosophy can be more useful than it looks. Much as in AI, whenever a philosopher ends up making an important contribution it starts a new type of academic research (political economy in Marx's case) and is no longer considered to be philosophy.
- javert 12y agoMarx is a good example of why philosophy can be very dangerous. Marx's ideas have literally caused the deaths of millions in Soviet Russia, Communist China, Vietnam, North Korea, Cambodia, Cuba, and probably others. Besides keeping people desperately impoverished in places like Venezuela. I'm not saying we sholdn't do philosophy because it can be dangerous. Philosophy can also be very good. In fact, we need the good ideas to prove the bad ideas wrong. I am a big fan of philosophy. But not at the point of a gun (i.e., not on the taxpayer's dime). Philosophers used to be self-funded or funded by patrons. As an aside, since philosophers have become primarily funded by governments and guns, we have a 10,000 fold increase in the number of philosophers, and no increase in the quality of output.
- barrkel 12y agoHave you read Marx?
- javert 12y agoYes.
- hueving 12y agoWhat does that have to do with the impact of Marx's philosophy?
- javert 12y agoHe wants to defend Marx but there is no defense, so he does something to attack me instead. It's a classic disinformation tactic. I don't know that for certain, maybe he's just actually curious, that's why I just answered his question instead of saying this to him.
- dhfromkorea 12y agoI totally agree. We should remember pretty much every major academic field we are studying has its root in philosophy. It is true philosophy seems barely standing on its own nowadays as it has branched out to many different fields over the past centuries. Standing on the shoulders' of giants? The biggest giant we have seen so far is philosophy.
- ninguem2 12y agoMuch as Marx, whose contributions are controversial, the work of Peter Singer has also (to a lesser extent) changed the world.