11 ms·
People aren't paying for content. But extrapolating that to say that they're unwilling to pay for content is a bit of a stretch, given the unwillingness of cont
by wtallis 12y ago
People aren't paying for content. But extrapolating that to say that they're unwilling to pay for content is a bit of a stretch, given the unwillingness of content producers to offer ad-free access at a fair market price, and the lack of an easy payments system to process such small transactions.
- manigandham 12y agoI work in the online advertising space. Unwilling is probably an understatement. Although "people" shell out tons of money on casual/social Facebook games and such, they are incredibly price sensitive to content like news or videos. They also use AdBlock to basically steal content without letting publishers recoup the production costs and other investments. I've spoken to and worked with several major publisher networks over the years that have tried various solutions with subscriptions but every attempt has led to a massive backlash or drop in traffic as users would rather go elsewhere then pay to read. Just look at how much negative feelings there are towards paywalls or any site that requires membership. There have been trials already by Google to solve for this but the original idea with Google Wallet [1] failed and they're now trying out the Contributor program [2] but still having trouble. [1] http://www.digitaltrends.com/web/google-launches-micropayments-for-web-content/ http://www.digitaltrends.com/web/google-launches-micropaymen... [2] https://www.google.com/contributor/welcome/ https://www.google.com/contributor/welcome/
- megablast 12y ago> Although "people" shell out tons of money on casual/social Facebook games and such, they are incredibly price sensitive to content like news or videos. Most of the money made in these causal games are by big whales, you will not get that in media.
- taspeotis 12y ago> They also use AdBlock to basically steal content I'm a thief for protecting my PC from malware? From here [0]: > Some Huffington Post readers fell victim to malicious advertisements spread through Google's DoubleClick network [0] http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/04/faked-flash-based-ads-on-huffpo-other-sites-downloaded-extortionware/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/04/faked-flash-based-ad...
- manigandham 12y agoThat's a small rationalization. Yes there are lots of shady ad networks out there because it can be so easy to start one that's used by all the long-tail small sites. There are also several high quality ad networks that don't do this and the entire industry is doing it's best to fight back against ad fraud, but it's not an easy problem. If someone mailed you something you didnt want, do you blame the post office? There are only so many checks that are possible and we're doing our best. I'm sorry you experienced this and but you're blaming the wrong party and depriving the publisher of their revenue.
- xorcist 12y agoLabel them "shady" if you want but all the big ad networks have linked to malware at some time.
- anonymousab 12y ago>and the entire industry is doing it's best to fight back against ad fraud This includes fighting back against the tracking of users across multiple sites, right? That's one of the more direct ways that people categorize 'good' and 'bad' ad networks.
- manigandham 12y agoTracking is necessary to show you better ads and is also anonymized. Most networks don't track anything about you but rather general things you might be interested in. Visiting a travel site might put you in the "interested in travel" bucket for about 30 days but that's it. The social networks and Google know far more about you then the other ad companies.
- tomjen3 12y agoActually yeah I do blame the post office for sending me spam. Who wouldn't? And as you have just demonstrated this is a problem even with the top tier ad networks. Mind you I would have blocked ads anyway because with the exception of Twitter the ads aren't worth reading (Twitters ads are split about 75%/25% ads I need/want to read and junk which is astonishingly high). Instead of whining about implicit deals (no such thing among strangers) and the difficulty of doing your job, make the ads worth actually seeing and your problems will tend to go away.
- techsupporter 12y ago> They also use AdBlock to basically steal content without letting publishers recoup the production costs and other investments. I feel like we've had the adblock vs. no adblock debate so many times that no one will change her position. So, I won't. Until I am 99% certain that the ad delivery networks used by content providers will not do any of the following, I will use a blanket adblock: - Autoplay video with sound or, really, any sound at all - Move on the page (movement within the ad is fine with me) - Pop up over the page like those absolutely horrendous "survey" or "give us your e-mail" modals do - Carry malicious or infecting payloads It also drives me nuts that I pay the New York Times for access and I still get ads on the mobile client.
- empressplay 12y agoDon't forget about tracking!
- manigandham 12y agoThat's not every ad platform. There are lots of crappy and shady networks that do this and also publishers who are willing to work with them, usually the smaller sites that want to put 50 ads on a page from the worst networks. This unfortunately makes the whole industry look bad and the top companies are trying their best to fight back against all these crappy formats and fraud. At the end though, the implicit deal is that you are reading content produced by the publisher, and it's accessible for free because you're exposed to ads. If you don't like the ads, please don't read the content. That's all there is to it. You're free to vote with your traffic and show publishers that their ad setup won't be tolerated, but adblock plugins are an easy way out that helps no one in the long term. EDIT: I can tell by the downvotes that people find this a touchy topic and would rather just install adblock then consider the realities.
- sliverstorm 12y agoAdblockers aren't undetectable. Publishers know how many visitors are adblocking. Or, at least that information is attainable if they decide they want it. There's also the issue of the simple time investment in curating ads. If I just somehow knew every website that depended on awful ads for the majority of their revenue, I'd happily avoid most of them, and everyone would be satisfied. But the volume is so tremendous, an adblocker for me is surrender. I would like to support good ads and avoid/punish bad ads. But there are just so many websites, so many ads, I cannot mentally catalog it all and remember "oh right I'm ideologically avoiding site <blerp>" as I skim Google. Given that, uBlock is the only thing keeping my old laptop from collapsing under the weight of the bad ads that appear from every direction. Actually it's a lot like spam blocking in some ways. Spam is such a voluminous problem, you are forced to implement blanket policies, leverage advanced technologies in heuristics, and maintain large networks of whitelists and blacklists, just to get on with life... that's what good ads and ad-free sites seem like, ham lost in a sea of spam.
- anonymousab 12y ago> "people" shell out tons of money on casual/social Facebook games and such The vast majority of the money in those are from a select minority of players with very deep pockets, addictive tendencies and mechanics that exploit those tendencies. And in some cases, ads. A strength of closed platforms, I guess. Not sure how you would translate that to online content of this sort. Nor that you would want to; how sustainable is such a model in the long term? >they are incredibly price sensitive to content like news or videos. When they can find almost the same content for free, often without ads? Yeah, they're not going to go out of their way to pay for it. Perhaps one simply can't expect to make money off of such content without the quality/product being vastly above and beyond what others will do for free. >They also use AdBlock to basically steal content I wasn't aware that Adblock actually deletes things off of servers now. Anyways, are impressions alone still worth that much? Or (reaching a lot here) is there some tacit acknowledgement of people clicking on ads they would have otherwise preferred not to see?
- manigandham 12y agoI worked on one of the top social Facebook games. Yes the majority of the money is from a small group, but there is a long-tail of low spenders who don't mind a few bucks a month. With content though, quality isn't cheap but the mainstream isn't interested in paying for quality. They would rather read crappy articles like BuzzFeed or the Daily Mail because its "good enough". In that case there's just not enough demand for high-quality content, and what demand there is doesn't understand the value enough to pay for it. Why is paying $4 for Starbucks nothing but $5 a month for a great site so much? Anyways, the basic agreement is you're reading content, produced at cost by the publisher, for free by agreeing to view ads along with the article. If you use AdBlock, you're removing your part of the deal while consuming for free, and declining to let publishers recover or make any money. If that's fair to you, fine, that's your personal thing. But it's a simple situation. And yes, impressions have value. Same way billboards or any advertising has value. You can test the results between a lack of ads and showing them and there's always a measurable difference. The industry isn't this big because it doesn't work.
- panglott 12y ago
- AreaGuy 12y agoI'd be willing to bet it's more ease of access than price. Both of my last jobs provided me with some subscriptions for free (i.e. Financial Times and some industry publications). Yet whenever I encountered their paywalls while browsing, I would always close the tab, since I didn't want to have to type in the password. It's embarrassing but true.
- manigandham 12y agoSo what's a good solution? Ad platforms and publishers are trying... but then maintaining your logged in status and showing you better ads requires tracking. And then people complain about being tracked.
- wtallis 12y agoA site specific cookie to drop the paywall is totally different from cross-domain tracking of browsing habits.
- AreaGuy 12y agoGreat question. I clear cookies after every session on my PC, but not my phone (yet), so maybe the changing mode of transmission may provide opportunities. Fingerprint scanning is also far more convenient than passwords. Honestly, though, the news one reads is very personal. You're reading politics, gossip, salacious stories... I don't want people to know what I'm reading, and I don't think increasing advertiser's ability to track you is the answer. There's no reason every consumer of media has to pay for media content though. It can be supported by the top 5% or 1% of subscribers. For example, perhaps people would pay for a membership/donation model for a higher price point -- for $500 or $900 a year, the local newspaper provides unlimited print/digital/podcasts, as well as discounted/free conferences, parties, meet & greets, social networks etc. Newspapers also add great credibility, so if there's a way to demonstrate that they've independently verified something (i.e. a 'media audit') there may be a way to monetize that.
- peteretep 12y ago> They also use AdBlock to basically steal content > without letting publishers recoup the production costs > and other investments. Pretty easy to block people wih AdBlock installed from viewing your content, but then they stop sharing it, too, and they're often the more tech savvy readers who would be willing to share. I bet the WSJ would see a net profit from making HN a non-paywall referrer.
- manigandham 12y agoIt's not "pretty easy". Adblock works at a network level by blocking specific requests, which makes it very hard to engineer around. If you can show a different message to people with AdBlock, then you can just show them ads in the first place.
- jamesbrownuhh 12y agoThere are sites which do display just such a message, so it's clearly not as hard as it might first sound. If you think about it, it can be as simple as just displaying a message 'underneath' an area of the screen where the blocked content would appear. Blocked content = displayed message.
- manigandham 12y agoI understand your example but for most publishers, it's not about blocking the content but rather blocking the user if they have adblock installed. The only way to do that is if you serve the content and then perhaps have a request to some ads or a resource that looks like an ad and will get blocked. When the request fails, you catch it and then "hide" the content from the user or only request the content in the first place after this check. This is fragile though since the plugins can just unblock that testing resource very easily, and some already do manipulate sites like this. Either way, this sounds easy but can require lots of tech resources, SEO workarounds, accessibility requirements, etc. Just not a turnkey option. PageFair is a company that tries to offer this but they been put into the various adblock rules and are now pretty much ineffective which shows the constant arms race... and this is a company working on this fulltime.
- kyllo 12y agoI work in the online advertising space. They also use AdBlock to basically steal content The whole problem with your industry is that you are still operating under the mistaken belief that "impressions" drive purchasing behavior. As if having some image forcibly burnt into my brain will influence my subconscious desires enough to cause me to make a purchase sometime later. This idea is and has always been pure snake oil. I don't want to see your ads, and I'm not going to click on them or buy what they are selling anyway. If anything I'm less likely to buy a product after I see it in a banner ad because they are annoying and I don't buy products that annoy me. You have no business telling me that it's "stealing" when I configure my browser client not to show me ads that I don't want to see. The implication is offensive. Do you think that running a spam e-mail filter is "basically stealing" too?
- manigandham 12y agoYou're conflating a lot of issues. 1) Spam is not the same, you didnt ask for it so you are rightly refusing and actively blocking it. 2) Content is not free. Someone had to create it, and they can either charge you directly or let you see it for free by also showing you ads. When you block those ads but still read the content, you're stealing the access/time/production/value of that content without letting the publisher recoup any of their investment or make any profit. 3) I'm not really sure where this anger comes from. Advertising is such a big and growing industry because it works. This is not some evil conspiracy nor are all the companies full of idiots. You will find regular people much like yourself working at all of the advertising agencies, networks and publishers. Impressions do work. It's not a "belief", it's a fact. Think of it like an empty road with a billboard and a store at the next exit. You can have a blank billboard and see how many people stop at the store. Then put up an ad and measure again. That delta is a significant and measurable difference and with digital advertising, it can be tracked to a very specific level to prove it works. There are also many different types and formats of ads which work in different stages of the sales conversion funnel. YOU might not think it works, but that's not what the massive amount of data and results show every day.
- kyllo 12y agoHere's a thought experiment: Imagine someone invented "smart" sunglasses that detected billboard ads and filtered them out so the wearer saw only a blank billboard instead of an ad. By driving down the road while wearing them and not seeing the billboards ads, would I therefore be "stealing" from ClearChannel? My anger comes from the fact that businesses are constantly trying to sell me things by harassing me. I have no problem with paying for things that I actually want, and I gladly pay for content if it will make the ads go away, but it normally doesn't. If you buy a subscription to a news site you still see ads. I pay plenty for content when I buy books, though. If people are not willing to pay for the content on a site like BuzzFeed, it just shows how little that content is worth. And advertising is really not a growing industry, at least not as a share of GDP. It's basically a zero-sum game. Online advertising spending is only growing to the extent that it is replacing spending on radio, TV and billboard advertising. Source: http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-03-03/advertisings-century-of-flat-line-growth http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-03-03/advertisings...
- SomeStupidPoint 12y agoI'll stop blocking ads when you stop serving bloatware and malware; deal?
- manigandham 12y agoPlease read all the other posts. Otherwise this is like getting a box full of dog poop mailed to you then complaining to Fedex that you got dog poop. Ad networks are just a delivery system and while they do their best to match sender/receiver as the right fit, the contents aren't always safe. Trying to infect you with malware doesnt make the networks any money and is not good for business... instead, why not be upset at the actual authors of malware who are constantly attacking everyone? They're the real problem.
- jamesbrownuhh 12y agoActually FedEx have specific rules against mailing dog poop to people, and if one of their customers were routinely doing so, I would indeed complain to FedEx and want them to do something about it. Ad networks saying "well, the contents aren't always safe, we're just a delivery system, not our problem" results in Ad Networks being Considered Harmful.
- manigandham 12y agoNetworks don't say that. We actively try to block malware and accounts and have rules on content as well. Some networks have no issue because they don't accept 3rd party content or all the ads are created in house. Other networks are self-serve and let advertisers upload their own assets and script tags. This is, understandably, much harder to guard against. My point is that content is offered for free in exchange for ads and the ad networks are enabling this trade of value, they are not actively trying to spread malware but a few bad actors do get through. Like they do anywhere.
- cauterized 12y agoAnd as long as those few bad actors are allowed through, users will be justified in their use of Adblock. Most people don't use Adblock because they think ad networks are actively malicious -- but not being able to be confident that NONE of the content they carry is malicious is a damn good reason to block ads.
- tbirdz 12y agoIs blocking all JavaScript (including the scripts used to load the ad) with a plugin like NoScript also stealing? What about using a browser that doesn't support JavaScript like netsurf? Or even browsing the web in a text only browser like w3m or elinks? What if the ads only were displayed properly in Chrome, would you be a thief for viewing them in Firefox?
- manigandham 12y agoAs with anything, it's never black/white and there are thousands of factors. I'm sure you already know the answer what you asked. But, for exposition: It mainly comes down to your intentions. 1) NoScript is tampering with how a website is presented. If that includes tampering with their ads, then possibly. Definitely so if you're using it for that purpose, like adblockers. 2) If you're using a client that cannot support javascript because that is all that's available to you or all that you are able to use, that might be considered fair but actively doing so to skirt advertisements would be stealing. 3) Not everything will work in every browser, and sure you can take advantage of that. This isn't stealing, it's just how compatibility works. Tying back to the other points, there are sites that use text-only messages as advertisements to still show up for people without javascript/using text-only. Some publishers don't feel this is worth it. That's for them to decide. Yes it might sound subjective but this is no different than going to a store and taking stuff... only there they can stop you before you take it. The internet by its nature is open and accessible, meaning there are very little controls to selectively stop people. For example: there's no easy way for a website to block NoScript users so they have no control. But just because they can stop you doesn't make it right.
- ohjesusthatguy 12y agoIf you have content (not the entity using the handle "manigandham", of course, you "work in the online advertising space", so by definition you're not producing content I want to see) you can't afford to give away then make people pay for your content, period. It's a different world out there on the Internet, and it's not my job to tell you how to monetize your content. Back in the print age, most magazines made most of their money selling space to advertisers. That's fine; readers paid the cover price (sometimes far below the publisher's cost to produce) and received ads (the bulk of the publisher's income) in return. Of course I'm oversimplifying this, but I'm not wrong. Publishers today have access to essentially every eyeball on the planet for minimal cost; good for them! They can spread their messages to people who would have had no access to it 30 years ago (and 30 years ago, I was paying USD$12 to my local newsstand for a copy of Melody Maker; how much of that was to recoup the newstand's cost to get it from their distributor?). Their only need for advertising was to subsidize the cost of the content they actually produce. The consumers have spoken; they have no perceived need for advertising. Lots won't understand that advertising is what actually pays for the content they read, but (and I really do blame the newspapers for putting all their content on the web for free at the start) content producers appear to be giving away their content for free. They "can't" put up paywalls because then they won't reach the maximal audience to which advertisers can peddle product. That's not my problem. I, as a consumer, can consume whatever is available to me (that's the other edge of labeling us "consumers", we're not your "customers" anymore). Publishers can't have their cake and eat it too. If converting consumers to customers (possibly by cutting out their advertisers) is too expensive they're in the wrong business. I am indeed a user of Adblock Edge; I haven't purposefully clicked on an ad since 1997, have been disgusted by advertising since long before that, and now have a tool with which to remove that which I oppose. I've seen a number of sites that ask me to turn off my adblocker so they can make money; nope. I've seen a number of sites that refuse to serve me content until I turn it off; bye! You're in a global market; compete for my custom. Like I said, it's not up to me to tell you how.
- rodgerd 12y ago> But extrapolating that to say that they're unwilling to pay for content is a bit of a stretch Not to anyone who's watched it become axiomatic that musicians who expect to make money from their work are talentless hacks who should be pleased to work for free, that HBO Go is "too expensive", that gamers who plow $500+ into a video card "can't afford" $20 games, or indeed that people in creative industries in general should make money from something other than their main endeavour and that nicking their stuff and passing it on is "exposure" more valuable than mere money. No matter what writers, musicians, et al produce, their is a constant insistance that any price above $0 is brigandry.
- scrollaway 12y agoSo much of your post is just so disgustingly misinformed. For some people, HBO Go IS too expensive. For a lot of gamers, 20 dollar games ARE too expensive. Those gamers aren't the same ones spending 500 bucks in video cards - those guys buy 60 dollar games every time they want. You won't get anywhere near the same userbase if you offer your stuff for free, and if you offer it for 1 dollar. However, remember that advertising is at WELL BELOW $1/user. Advertising treats your userbase as if each individual is worth pennies - because they are. Don't expect your userbase to completely transit to a pay-for-content model without huge losses. But it doesn't mean you won't profit more in the end, it all depends on what you set the price to and what your userbase is (some markets are obviously better suited for pay-for-content models).
- paintrayne 12y agoThen why is Steam able to sell so many titles? Gamers are willing to pay, just not $50 a pop. Likewise with buying music. Not $20 for an album, but a $1 a song. Just because at one point the gates existed to extort customers into paying such high prices doesn't mean such prices should exist indefinitely. Change the pricing models and get rich, people do it all the time.
- te_chris 12y agoYou don't get to set the price to what you feel like, much as I wish that were true. I'd love to pay uniqlo prices for Saint Laurent.
- tomjen3 12y agoAgreed - people don't get their news from any one source and aren't going to subscribe for webaccess to twenty different newspapers. One pooled newspaper subscription might work. On the other hand, I personally probably wouldn't post those on Facebook or Twitter so you would need some new way to spread them.
- tormeh 12y agoA friend of mine used to never pay for games. Not because the money mattered, but because it was possible to get them for free. I imagined the rationale went like this: "See, if games are available for free, then only suckers will pay, right? And I'm not a sucker, so I won't pay. People with respect for themselves simply do not pay for games."