4 ms·
Seriously? The whole story is about search and ads, and thus the Economist concludes with: > But rather than trying to rein in American firms, European politic
by skrebbel 12y ago
Seriously? The whole story is about search and ads, and thus the Economist concludes with:
> But rather than trying to rein in American firms, European politicians should focus on fixing what is holding back the old world’s most promising platforms: the lack of a common digital market. Today only 15% of consumers shop online across borders within the EU.
So to fix a monopolist in search abusing its position, the EU needs to make it easier for me to buy shoes from Poland with simpler VAT laws. How are those related at all? There's probably plenty of reasons why no European PhD dropouts started a successful search company, but cross border e-commerce isn't one of them.
- blfr 12y agoLacklustre cross border commerce is among the reasons why successful companies in one European country have trouble scaling up and competing with American giants who by default start in a market with over 300M people. Google's internal response[1] covers it inadvertently. They show stats for various European markets with competition in the shopping category, mostly with other American companies. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9377951 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9377951
- skrebbel 12y ago> Lacklustre cross border commerce is among the reasons why successful companies in one European country have trouble scaling up and competing with American giants who by default start in a market with over 300M people. Yes, but search is very low on the list of industries where that matters. Plenty European internet companies have trouble getting outside their founding country, sure, but the trouble is language, culture, lack of a unified media landscape, etc, not VAT rules. Anybody who tells you different is just trying to find a scapegoat for their inability to execute cross-culture. This indeed makes Europe a more difficult starting point, but good luck fixing that with politics.
- blfr 12y agoThe whole started with Google's addition of shopping results to their regular search results and later expanded to Android, I think.
- skrebbel 12y agoYep, and this article recommends that Europe improve cross-border internet shopping rules to somehow "fix" the fact that the monopolist in search is not from Europe.
- blfr 12y agoYes. Large European platforms wouldn't need Google. You would just go straight to your favourite when looking to buy something. Like many Americans go to Amazon.
- makomk 12y agoTheir biggest competitor, who filed the anti-trust complaint in question and are the most likely winner from all this, is Microsoft. They're also not from Europe.
- makeitsuckless 12y agoYeah, because that's what Google, Twitter, Facebook and all do "cross border commerce"... Not to mention the fact that before the digital age, when all international commerce actually involve moving physical goods across physical borders, Europe had no problem scaling up to multinational corporations.
- blfr 12y agoLook through that linked article. Ebay and Amazon dominated German and British markets. Their business includes getting physical goods to customers. European giants are largely hold-outs from a different age[1] (full article[2]). The decline didn't start with the Internet. [1] https://media.economist.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/290-width/images/print-edition/20120728_FBC674.png https://media.economist.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/2... [2] http://www.economist.com/node/21559618 http://www.economist.com/node/21559618
- rbehrends 12y ago> Lacklustre cross border commerce is among the reasons why successful companies in one European country have trouble scaling up and competing with American giants who by default start in a market with over 300M people. While it would be nice to get the VAT problems sorted out, this is second to the problem of there being a couple dozen different languages being used in the EU. People shop domestically because they can use websites in their native language and when they have problems, can talk to customer service representatives in a language they understand. It is really, really hard to get your service localized in couple dozen different languages (let alone provide actual customer service in all of them). Even Amazon handles only a part of Europe, and if Amazon can't do that, what companies can? There are a few, but not all that many, and for many it isn't worth it, because your economies of scale quickly disappear when you have to build and maintain a separate presence in up to 28 different countries that mostly speak different languages. (That includes American companies, too, by the way, many of which simply choose to ignore Estonia or even Sweden and Portugal.)
- rjtavares 12y agoIf the problem was the need to maintain a specific presence, then they would let me use the english language version of the website. But they don't. I'm tired of "This content isn't available in your country" and "we can't ship x item to your country" messages...
- musername 12y agolocalization has to deal with differing laws, too. Differing customs in general.
- noir_lord 12y agoNot to mention Germany has 85 million, United Kingdom 65 million, France 65 million etc. That is a big enough user base to have a successful business for most general retail without requiring cross borders. If you look Amazon is most active in foreign countries with English as a first language, that's not a co-incidence it's simple cheaper to do business.
- 12y ago
- magicalist 12y agoIt's kind of the basis of the article. The European Commission is focusing on shopping as the core of the case right now, so that's what the article is about. It's arguing that if you want to improve competitiveness of European shopping sites, there's much that could be done to make sure they aren't hobbled in the first place.
- mtrimpe 12y agoIndeed; but that's because the premise of the article seems to be that the EU is doing this out of jealousy and spite. As much as US companies may despise it but outside of their own borders they simply need to adhere to different rules though. In the US a belligerent defiance coupled with some strong lobbying goes a long way but, like you're seeing with Uber now, that approach doesn't work as well across the pond. Likewise in this case is just about challenging Google's use of its dominance to compete unfairly in other markets (which is illegal.) That it happens to be about pushing domestic shopping sites down the rankings to favor their own results is rather incidental; at it's core this is just a shot across the bow to make it clear that if Google wants ad-money from Europe they must play by Europe's rules. I hope Google gets that because these are not relationships you want to become adversarial or else someone might just decide to close the little tax loophole that lets Google escape taxation of its EU revenue.
- atmosx 12y agoBlah, the economist doesn't make sense since 2008. I was a 6-year long subscriber but after the Crimean (Russian vs US) crisis was analyzed without even a hint of objectivity, I start noticing that the quality started deteriorating further and further... Until you see articles like this one or others regarding the EU crisis. The economist is a conservative, strongly pro-war (seriously, it supported fearsomely every major US/NATO war, last I remember was it's views on the need for USA to openly attack Syria. Disgraceful articles...), pseudo-liberal magazine. You see good articles every now and then, but since most of the times you can't even tell the author (since it has a very specific policy about them), you're not sure what you're reading... Bug generally speaking I stopped trusting the 'E' long time ago.
- neuronic 12y agoIf you don't mind me asking, have you found viable alternatives? What do you read?
- atmosx 12y agoTruth to be told I did not. I read everything from anywhere, but I didn't find anything to fill the gap. I tries "Newsweek", a 3-month trial subscription. It was horrendous, worse than the 'E'.
- rz2k 12y agoI've come to really appreciate Bloomberg Businessweek. However, I've always felt the The Economist was flawed. To me it has resembled the type of conversation I would imagine an economics 101 student having with a student further along in an economics curriculum.
- chestnut-tree 12y ago"There's probably plenty of reasons why no European PhD dropouts started a successful search company, but cross border e-commerce isn't one of them." For digital goods and services, cumbersome VAT rules do make cross-border e-commerce more difficult. The recent new rules on digital goods where VAT is applied based on the location of the buyer means merchants now have to deal with different VAT rates for 28 EU nations. I can see the rationale for such an approach, and it is meant be fairer...but in practice it's cumbersome and bureaucratic. Users now have to supply their address details for simply downloading software (in order for the merchant to confirm their location). There is no benefit to the user other than having to give more of their personal info away to merchants. Plus, now merchants have to retain all that personal data for many years for accounting and auditing purposes. Harmonising VAT on physical goods will probably never happen, but the EU could have proposed a single VAT rate for digital goods and services which might actually have gained traction. Did they ever pursue this? If not, why not? The people from the European Commission who are helping shape the "Digital Single Market" don't always inspire confidence even if they have the best of intentions: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/2014-2019/ansip/blog/euvat_en https://ec.europa.eu/commission/2014-2019/ansip/blog/euvat_e...
- musername 12y agolast time i ordered from swiss to germany, tax used to be paid on import and there is the possibility to file for tax return on export. So, this change only moves the responsibility of paying the tax back to the seller. Offering a billing adress for online shopping is standard in almost every case. They are just closing a schutzluecke (a gap, a lack of protection)
- vanderZwan 12y ago> Harmonising VAT on physical goods will probably never happen I wouldn't say that too quickly. People tend to paint the EU as some bureaucratic behemoth, but the whole point of the project was to vastly reduce administrative overhead for deploying to EU markets, and it has done so quite successfully. Compare "meet EU standards and it can be sold everywhere in the EU" to "have to double check the standards for every country we want to deploy to" - it's pretty obvious why the former is easier to deal with. In fact, one of the biggest problems it is currently facing is that it's running out of things to fix in that sense. When it was about standardizing, I don't know, legally allowed substances in perfume, the benefits of standardisation far outweighed the hassle of changing local regulation. Now that its doing all kinds of things that can't be summarized as "everyone will (begrudgingly) go along because even in the worst case it benefits every involved nation", it's much harder to reach a consensus this way (paraphrasing a few books on the EU from memory). Anyway, standardised VAT rules could fall under the old "benefits everyone"-category of projects, even for non-digital goods, so who knows?