16 ms·
Retina Macbook 2015 Teardown
- lisper 12y agoThe submission to the original iFixit article only has five points: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9384791 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9384791 Something is badly broken here, and it's not just the fact that you can't repair the new MacBook. :-(
- dang 12y agoToo many submissions appear on HN for randomness not to be a leading if not dominant factor. That's why a small number of reposts are ok, if the article is good for HN and hasn't had attention yet. See https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html. We changed the URL on this submission from http://arstechnica.com/apple/2015/04/surprise-ifixit-says-you-cant-do-much-to-fix-or-upgrade-the-2015-macbook/ http://arstechnica.com/apple/2015/04/surprise-ifixit-says-yo... to the article it points to, as we normally do.
- lisper 12y agoBut now I am getting the submission credit that rightfully belongs to chaostheory, who originally submitted this link. (And to top off the irony, my comment is being downvoted into oblivion despite the fact that it's my own submission I'm criticizing!) Here's a constructive suggestion on how to fix the problem: 1. As long as the article is not on the front page, give the Nth upvoter K/N karma points, where K is the number of karma points the article eventually gets. 2. When an article not on the front page gets an upvote, put it back at the top of the New page (i.e. sort the New page based on most recent upvote, not submission time). This would provide an incentive for people to browse the new page and be early upvoters of quality articles. In order to prevent people from simply upvoting everything, you would need to: 3. Charge one karma point to upvote an article and in order to start everyone on a level playing field 4. Give everyone 100 free karma points (or allow karma to go down to -100 before users lose their upvoting privileges, at which point they can only redeem themselves by submissions) and to prevent submission spam: 5. Limit users with low karma to 1 submission per day or something like that I'll even offer to implement this for you if you think you might make this change.
- markild 12y ago"NXP 11U37 microcontroller; 128 kB flash, 10kB SRAM" [1] Does anyone have an idea of what this is used for? [1]: https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Retina+Macbook+2015+Teardown/39841#s89811 https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Retina+Macbook+2015+Teardown...
- platinum1 12y agoBased on location and size, I'm guessing it's used for the USB type C port - specifically implementing the CC sideband communication protocol.
- raverbashing 12y agoMaybe it is the SMC? (System management controller?)
- doe88 12y agoSeems that the major unknown is about the SSD controller [1] to know if it uses a custom controller or not. [1] http://www.anandtech.com/show/9173/more-pictures-of-2015-macbooks-applebuilt-ssd-controller http://www.anandtech.com/show/9173/more-pictures-of-2015-mac...
- ksec 12y agoLook at the size of it compared to the Intel CPU. That thing is huge. What are the usual node size SSD controller manufactured in? 28/40nm
- raverbashing 12y agoHere's something that might be surprising to some: package size is related to the number of pins mostly, not to the size of the silicon - and more pins if the consumption is higher (Usually bigger silicon has more pins, and vice versa, but not necessarily)
- std_throwaway 12y agoUsually yes. There is even a little PCB between the mainboard and the chip to get enough area for the thousands of pins. But this is not the case if they stack the flash chips with the controller chips. Then only a few external pins are needed for communication and power. But the flash chips actually need the silicon area for all those tiny flash cells.
- Kliment 12y agoIt's huge not because it needs to be but because it needs to fit the PoP bottom package to match the flash chip on top. The flash chip actually needs to be that size, so there you go.
- yagop 12y agoчитать в России!
- hahainternet 12y ago$1300, what an absolute joke.
- hahainternet 12y agoAaaand lovely proof that HN is broken. It's a $1300 netbook but this comment is not allowed to be seen.
- nazgob 12y agoIt adds little value.
- rsynnott 12y agoNetbooks typically used Atom (OEM price: ~$30). This uses a Core M (OEM price: $281). That's more expensive than most netbooks all on its own; it's a slightly different class.
- TEMPLEOS_DEV 12y agoHN IS FULL OF MACINTOSH FAGGOTS.
- KuchenKerze 12y agoI really appreciate the use of a NVM SSD Controller. I wonder if and when Apple will release Bootcamp driver for those.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- colinramsay 12y ago"Repairability" really means two things: 1) You can fiddle with the insides 2) You can fix it when it goes wrong Despite what you may read on places like HN and Reddit, no-one in the real world gives two hoots about #1, and if you make a product that has good reliability then #2 becomes moot.
- smoyer 12y agoI got my (mid-2012) rMBP about the same time as a friend got the equivalent MBP. I had to order mine with 16GB of RAM but he ordered his laptop with 8GB of RAM and installed a much cheaper 8GB to reach 16GB. There are a few things that it's nice to "fiddle with". Being able to swap out the SSD is another convenience.
- abroncs 12y ago> no-one in the real world gives two hoots about #1 That's not true at all. I have plenty of non-technical people who chose to upgrade their laptops as time goes on, even if they don't do it manually themselves. Same goes for desktops.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt's clear enough that users do not place a high priority on serviceability. It's harder to draw conclusions about how much absolute value is placed on it when it barely exists in a product category.
- dublinben 12y agoThey certainly don't at the time of purchase, but many regret that decision when they need expensive repairs. There's a reason why large enterprises still issue Lenovo/Dell/HP business class notebooks. A field technician with minimal training can fully rebuild one in an hour. That's not possible with anything from Apple.
- 12y ago
- a_bonobo 12y agoWorth noting that this device, typical for Apple, gets the worst "repairability" score: >The MacBook 2015 Repairability Score: 1 out of 10 (10 is easiest to repair) There are several reasons why this happens; the optimist says that to save space Apple had to glue and solder so much, the pessimist says it's so that Apple can charge more for repairs/replacements. But I think both can agree that this generates more e-waste than necessary, and I wonder whether this may be an incentive for the EU to step in. They've already standardized mobile chargers - starting 2017, all mobile chargers in the EU have to be of the same standard to reduce electronic waste. I wonder whether a similar law for PC/laptop components could work and how it would look like...
- tim333 12y ago> generates more e-waste than necessary I'm not so sure. Apple have free recycling and even the most repairable equipment will end up being chucked eventually.
- pmjordan 12y agoLeaving aside upgrades and repairs, it makes disassembly for recycling purposes overly difficult, i.e. expensive, when everything is glued. This reduces the profitability and therefore likelihood of recycling each individual component to the maximum of its potential.
- chrisan 12y ago> Leaving aside upgrades and repairs, it makes disassembly for recycling purposes overly difficult, i.e. expensive, when everything is glued. A similar thing happened in the auto industry. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_recycling#Policies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_recycling#Policies
- Silhouette 12y agoIt also makes removing the data storage for secure destruction much more difficult. I'm very happy to recycle old devices rather than contributing to landfill or otherwise being wasteful, but if my HDD/SSD can't go for complete destruction separately then the entire unit is going for complete destruction instead. In this day and age, this is a practical minimum for safely retiring old gear as far as I'm concerned. For my businesses, it is also effectively a legal and/or regulatory requirement in many cases.
- jhull 12y agoFor New Yorkers reading this: interesting to hear about the New York Digital Right to Repair bill. Didn't realize that the support provided to non manufacturers was being stifled. Read more here: http://newyork.digitalrighttorepair.org/ http://newyork.digitalrighttorepair.org/
- keeran 12y agoI'm not sure why this is an issue any more. It was a nice ideal when laptops were just PCs put into smaller boxes, but as manufacturers put the effort and investment into satisfying our demands for smaller, faster, lighter, I don't think the expectation of poking around inside them is reasonable. We don't see people complaining about the repairability of their R-Pis, Chromecasts, SoC systems etc. That's the way hardware is going - because that's what we've asked for.
- masklinn 12y ago> It was a nice ideal when laptops were just PCs put into smaller boxes, but as manufacturers put the effort and investment into satisfying our demands for smaller, faster, lighter, I don't think the expectation of poking around inside them is reasonable. A big part of the annoyance with Apple is their tendency to explicitly take steps against repairs: insane amounts of glue, multiple "weird" screws (the macbook here uses pentalobe, torx, philips and tri-wing in a single machine), non-standard formats & connectors (I don't expect them to ever swap their non-soldered SSDs for M.2, even though they've altered the connector and format multiple times). Having the machine be "hard to repair" because it's highly integrated is one thing, taking decisions which deliberately hinder repairability and have basically no other advantage is quite another. > We don't see people complaining about the repairability of their R-Pis, Chromecasts, SoC systems etc. Nobody complains about the repairability of an RPi because no specific step to make it harder to repair for no value were undertaken.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 54mf 12y agoA laptop is meant to be portable, with a significant number of moving parts (keys, hinges, trackpad [until recently],) and ports that see frequent insertions/removals. These factors result in a device that can break down in many, many ways. If one tiny failure results in the entire device being unusable (or requiring replacement of many [working] parts at significant cost,) well, you're going to get complaints. :)
- 12y ago
- hollerith 12y ago>Apple has opted to transition from using a row of LEDs with a light guide panel, to installing individual LEDs beneath each key. That's progress. Now, Apple, please replace each LED with an infra-red or a visible-light sensor, so that someone can write software to put a representation of the keyboard onto the screen that shows which keys have a finger hovering over them, so that the user never has to look at the keyboard except when the keyboard needs cleaning.
- lstamour 12y agoI wonder if you could achieve that today with the webcam at the right angle? ;-) it'd be a lot cheaper...
- anonymfus 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3dUeGNIX4M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3dUeGNIX4M http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/typehoverswipe/ http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/typehoverswipe/
- s_kilk 12y ago> so that the user never has to look at the keyboard except when the keyboard needs cleaning. The user should learn to touch-type.
- hollerith 12y agoSo you can hit the - key or the ] key without looking at the keyboard as quickly as someone who is looking at the keyboard? You just reach over and press the key and you never press an adjacent key by mistake?