3 ms·
I'm a vegan who's motivated by opposition to animal agriculture, so I enthusiastically support research like this (and think it's the most promising path I've h
by schoen 12y ago
I'm a vegan who's motivated by opposition to animal agriculture, so I enthusiastically support research like this (and think it's the most promising path I've heard of to a vegan human future). I went to a vegan advocacy organization event a few months ago where this topic came up, and other attendees shared my enthusiasm for this kind of research, but the diversity of views and motivations in the vegan community makes me wary of claiming that that means this is mainstream.
To answer your correlation question, probably yes -- but vegans' attitudes toward "tampering with nature" vary widely from the view that it's the worst possible thing humanity can do, on through to the view that it's the best possible thing humanity can do (e.g., David Pearce), with a broad spectrum in between. (I don't have an ideal example of the former group in mind, but I could mention Sea Shepherd's Paul Watson, who advocates deep ecology and opposes GMOs.)
I think we will see sharper divisions between environmentalist vegans (especially advocates of deep ecology) and animal rights/animal welfare vegans over time. I don't know how the population breaks down in the west today, or how many people have even had to think about it that much.
- rboyd 12y agoYour last sentence is pretty interesting to me. After months of prodding from my girlfriend to go vegan, the book 'Abundance' and the chapter on the water inefficiency of factory farming is what finally turned me. It was reasonably easy for me to justify carnivorism as naturally occurring, harder to justify water waste with so many humans going thirsty. Without even starting down the emissions road. That said, looking at it now (and especially once synthetic meats come online, out of cost efficiency if nothing else), I think our children might look back on the practice of animal slaughter as being pretty horrifically barbaric.
- hollerith 12y ago>with so many humans going thirsty Where are there humans going thirsty? Honest question.
- Swizec 12y agoIn places where they don't have water purification plants. Also in places that are becoming uninhabitable to humans. Think expanding deserts and such.
- jklein11 12y agoIsn't that an infrastructure problem? If we use less water in California that doesn't mean less people will be thirsty in South America.
- Swizec 12y agoExactly. California's drought has literally zero effect on anybody else. Maybe a bit on people downstream of California's rivers and such. So the consideration that "people are going thirsty" should have zero effect on how Californians deal with their problem. It serves nothing more than as an emotional device to make people feel bad.
- Dylan16807 12y agoI'm not convinced by the water argument as a large-scale issue, for two reasons. First, water transport is expensive, in a relative sense. This means that as long as you're not farming in direct competition with people that lack water, stopping the farming won't help them. Second, the price of meat is high enough, and the price of desalination low enough, that all else equal we could easily feed cows by using infinite salt water.
- schoen 12y agoIn California water is a little bit fungible because of the California Aqueduct (and other aqueducts in the California water system), and because of some farmers' water rights claims over particular sources that might otherwise have been available to other users for other uses. But it's not completely fungible by any stretch of the imagination. I don't know enough about the water system and the patterns of shortages to understand the prevalence of direct competition between sets of users. Of course a weird thing is that municipalities may have locked in particular sources, so there may not be anyone in competition with us at all (for example, we in San Francisco have near-exclusive access to Hetch Hetchy, so water demand from farmers elsewhere in the state isn't likely to threaten our municipal water supply, at least not very directly). I guess I need to learn more about the extent to which different users actually compete with one another. Clearly livestock farmers in the Central Valley are in competition with crop farmers there for the same water resources, but their competition with city dwellers for sources of what might have been human drinking water is a thornier question.
- sologoub 12y agoCalifornia water issues are very complex as you state, but one big issue is going somewhat unaddressed by government - use of non-renewable underground sources. Currently, farmers are able to even increase production in the drought, but few know how long they'll be able to keep this up because underground water is not unlimited. California could go the desalination route, but so far that progress is painfully slow and the methods being selected may result in significant harm to local marine ecosystems: http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/04/15/us-usa-desalination-california-idUSKBN0N601V20150415 http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/04/15/us-usa-desalinatio.... Something like this would be much better: http://waterfx.co/ http://waterfx.co/. Unfortunately, last update in their blog is a year ago...
- sukilot 12y agoChildren already think animal slaughter is horrific. Then they get greedy about meat.
- tracker1 12y agoIsn't agriculture (crop farming) the biggest reason of the water problems in California right now... it seems to me wasteful water usage applies to plant growth as much as animal farming.
- schoen 12y agoMost modern styles of animal farming just use more water (per kg or kcal of resulting human food), especially those that are growing human-edible crops like corn and soy in order to feed them to farm animals.
- sukilot 12y agoSome vegans are anti-GMO, like some Ohioans are. But "Vegan" has no relation to "GMO"
- ptaipale 12y agoJust a feeling, but I think there is quite some correlation between veganism and being anti-GMO, although there are certainly also vegans who are expressly pro-GMO. Would there be any research on the subject?
- schoen 12y agoIt looks like people are studying it quite a bit, but the nutrition and diet literature is less open-access than the math and CS literature. I searched on Google Scholar for "vegan attitudes GMO" and found several articles, often in the journal Appetite, that seemed relevant but were behind a paywall. The first result is "Attitudes towards genetically modified and organic foods", by Saher, Lindeman, and Hursti. I also did a Google web search for the same terms and found, among other things, several articles by pro-GMO vegans complaining that it was common for other vegans to be anti-GMO (based on their personal experience, not studies). The former felt that widespread vegan opposition to GMOs was unfortunate because it would make it less appealing for people to go vegan (for example because the range of available foods would appear more restricted), or because it could make vegans appear indifferent or hostile to scientific progress, among other concerns.