4 ms·
Otherwise, what’s the point of having a countdown signal? It tells people currently on the crossing how long they have. If they're infirm, they may be better o
by vacri 12y ago
Otherwise, what’s the point of having a countdown signal?
It tells people currently on the crossing how long they have. If they're infirm, they may be better off waiting at a traffic island than trying to rush across. The red hand is pretty clear - it means "don't start crossing", not "start crossing if you're confident you can make it in time" (though that is the way the countdown is used).
$200 is a ridiculous fine, though - that's over 20 hours work at the minimum wage.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoAgreed; this isn't at all ambiguous. If you were allowed to cross, it would be a walk signal with countdown.
- cozzyd 12y agoNo other place treats it that way (and most police departments have better things to do than to target pedestrians).
- JoshTriplett 12y agoTo the best of my knowledge, that's the meaning it has in Portland, and many other cities. (Now, on the other hand, I don't think that's vigorously enforced.)
- danhak 12y agoNot if you take the walk signal to mean "it's safe to cross right now," which is not the case if you're on the curb and there's one second left. You also clearly haven't spent much time in L.A...many of these signs flash the walk signal for literally 2 or 3 seconds before beginning the 20 second red countdown.
- sukilot 12y agoWhat's wrong with 2-3sec? That's plenty of time to start walking if you are paying attention in traffic.
- _asummers 12y agoSome intersections I cross in Chicago have the walking man for literally one to two seconds before it starts the blinking hand or countdown (typically in the 10-15 sec range). This is barely enough time to enter the intersection, even if the individual is paying complete attention. Given this, I'd never even considered that it could be a fineable offense to begin crossing when the countdown was happening.
- Cymen 12y agoThat is a joke -- people walk at different speeds. Walking in carland is enough punishment. The worst are burbias where the walk signal never comes on if you don't press a button.
- vacri 12y agoWalking in carland is enough punishment LA was the only place I've ever been crossing the road with the valid pedestrian signal and had to stop walking or I'd literally walk into the car turning across my path (to the right, with the same green light I'm crossing with). It happened a couple of times, and I was only there for one week.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoYou have never been to china before. Here crossing the street is a game of frogger.
- anigbrowl 12y agoNo it wouldn't. Around here I know of many intersections that only display the walk signal for a second or two before going into the countdown, such a short time that you can miss it if you briefly glance away. I pay attention to crosswalk signals and spent months training my dog to do the same so that he sits when we arrive at a crosswalk. When the city is setting up the lights so that they change in the time it takes to walk a single step then your interpretation isn't reasonable.
- MichaelGG 12y agoYet the countdowns are also at intersections that have no middle place. In such cases, it's a binary decision, made for people of all ability ranges. The countdown provides no useful information to act upon and should thus be removed. Though I agree - there should be some way to indicate "do not attempt crossing, even if you think you're so fast." Perhaps adjust the countdown and keep the hand for several seconds more than it is currently.
- cauterized 12y agoWhat does a median have to do with it? The countdown allows me to choose to cross if there are 20 sec left (enough time for me to get across anything less than an 8-lane highway) or not to cross till the next light if there are only 3 sec left when I reach the curb. With old-school flashing lights all I know is that the light will change soon, but gives me no idea HOW soon. In pedestrian friendly cities generally people will cross if it's flashing (esp. on a narrower street) because they have right of way. Heck, most of us will cross a one-way street AGAINST the light if the nearest oncoming car is a third of the way down the block. That's not the least bit dangerous and doesn't interrupt the flow of traffic.
- MichaelGG 12y agoBut the countdown occurs while the hand for no crossing is showing and that's jaywalking. Unless the point is to say "don't cross, unless you're fast". After the hand goes up, it should be just don't cross. Otherwise people will mostly try to outrun the light, especially in the US as there is little fear of a stopped driver hitting you (vs, say, Latin American countries).
- cauterized 12y agoYes, the flashing hand (countdown or not) has always been a warning that the light's about to change (like a yellow light for cars). Before the countdown clocks, it was meant to say "don't start crossing" but in most cities people didn't interpret it that way and would start crossing if they were fast walkers. Even if they didn't know how much longer it'd be flashing. The countdown clocks add that information so they can make an informed decision. I agree that LA shouldn't have bothered with the countdowns if they're going to consider starting across the intersection after the countdown has begun to be jaywalking.