5 ms·
I'm anti-GMO, anti-dairy, pro-cheese, and pro-beef (so Im not in the vegan crowd at all)... yet I'd at least try this especially if it produced high quality che
by DiabloD3 12y ago
I'm anti-GMO, anti-dairy, pro-cheese, and pro-beef (so Im not in the vegan crowd at all)... yet I'd at least try this especially if it produced high quality cheeses on par with the best unpasteurized cheeses I've had.
Why am I anti-diary? The pasteurization process produces denatured proteins (linked to cancer), contains hormones that are not biologically inert for humans (we are not baby cows), and contain huge amounts of lactose (a sugar that some people are allergic to, and is not a particularly good thing to have in our diets).
The production of most hard cheeses and some soft cheeses tends to remove a lot of the hormone and lactose content, as well as some of the denatured proteins. Cheese does not require pasteurized milk, nor does it benefit from it in any way, as cheese was the first viable method for long term storage of milk.
- maxerickson 12y agoLactose intolerance is not an allergy. (I'm not sure that is what you mean or not though, and some people do indeed have milk allergies.)
- Zancarius 12y agoIt could go both ways. I can't speak for the OP, but I can say that I've found it's sometimes easier to explain sensitivities as allergies to people who don't understand the differences. So, giving that poster the benefit of the doubt, I'll assume they either don't know the difference themselves, or they DO know but don't want to split hairs on the matter in case someone doesn't know. As a personal anecdote along these lines and since discovering my own sensitivities to canola (and rapeseed oils in general), I've learned that simply calling it a "sensitivity" doesn't always convey the need to avoid certain ingredients. So, sometimes I tell people instead to "think of it as a food allergy," which they usually understand. I think that at least part of the problem is that, to a layperson, sensitivity doesn't sound as urgent or at least is suggestive of "optional avoidance." For some people, chemical sensitivities are anything but optional avoidance...
- Dylan16807 12y agoDoes it even qualify as a sensitivity? The problem is that the body ignores the lactose.
- Zancarius 12y agoWho were you replying to? I didn't say anything about lactose. Did you mean to reply to your comment's sibling?
- Dylan16807 12y agoDiabloD3 said: lactose (a sugar that some people are allergic to maxerickson said: Lactose intolerance is not an allergy. You replied: I can't speak for the OP, but I can say that I've found it's sometimes easier to explain sensitivities as allergies to people who don't understand the differences. Then I suggested the idea that lactose intolerance was not even a chemical sensitivity. I definitely meant to reply to you. But it looks like the term "sensitivity" has been defined that way, no matter if it's misleading. A sensitivity defined by total lack of interaction, ugh. I guess I'm sensitive to breathing a bunch of argon, too.
- maxerickson 12y agoGiven the life threatening nature of many allergic reactions, I think people should be careful to not trample the definition. So calling the simple inability to digest a sugar that causes some digestive discomfort an allergy is pretty much entirely off the table. The situation with chemical sensitivities is harder, but I guess I still don't want people in general deciding for themselves what chemical sensitivities they have that are equivalent to allergies, they should talk to an allergist about it.
- Zancarius 12y ago> Given the life threatening nature of many allergic reactions, I think people should be careful to not trample the definition. Don't get me wrong: I agree, but it's sometimes counter-productive to resort to such pedantry if all you're doing is ordering a meal and wish to avoid a specific substance that causes discomfort (or worse). Further, allergies can present with such a broad spectrum of symptoms that it's almost pointless to suggest it shouldn't be used as an analogy for someone who doesn't understand why sensitivities may be problematic is somehow adulterating the definition. Though, sensitivities/intolerances are, AFAIK, never fatal. (Strictly speaking, allergies are a response to foreign proteins; it's important to note that the word itself doesn't convey the nature or severity of the reaction.) That said, if you're speaking with a layperson who might be providing some service in a capacity that it's important they understand you need/want/wish to avoid a particular ingredient because of the effects it has, using a term that's fairly readily understood (such as allergy) can be useful to avoid misinterpretation. And, speaking from personal experience, certain sensitivities don't necessarily require speaking with an allergist to determine whether or not they're somehow "equivalent," and I think a GP is better equipped to make the decision first regarding what type of specialist (if any) you should see if you do suffer from sensitivities. Of course, if you have a sensitivity and it's blindingly obvious both in terms of the cause and the symptoms it presents, it's easy enough to determine on your own how bad it is and to what extent you should avoid the substance that causes it. :)
- DiabloD3 12y agoIt is commonly, but incorrectly, listed as an allergy, even though it is not an immune response. Lactose intolerance is a syndrome stemming from lactase deficiency.
- maxerickson 12y agoI posted because I'd rather you did not exacerbate the confusion. Allergies are a serious issue for people. Confusing other things with allergies makes it harder for people that do have serious allergies.
- wyager 12y ago>I'm anti-GMO, Why? The overwhelming scientific consensus is that it's perfectly safe. >The pasteurization process produces denatured proteins (linked to cancer) I think someone may have been playing a joke on you when they told you this. Denaturing proteins is a critical part of the digestion process. Our body can't really do anything with proteins that maintain their secondary/tertiary/quaternary structure through digestion. > [lactose] is not a particularly good thing to have in our diets What makes you say this? Sure, some people don't produce lactase and can't digest it, but it's fine for the rest of us.
- DiabloD3 12y agoNo, the overwhelming scientific consensus is it must be proven safe first on a case by case basis, and that GMO in of itself is not good or bad. However, it is not the science I am worried about, it is the willingness of companies to put profit before human lives. Denaturation of proteins is, as you have said, removing the secondary/tertiary/quaternary structures. However, that doesn't mean that the pasteurization process produces the same resulting denatured proteins our body does. Lactose is a sugar, and we simply do not benefit from diets high in sugars and carbs.
- mrestko 12y agoProteins are digested to no larger than tripeptides prior to absorption in the intestine. Once absorbed, these oligopeptides are hydrolyzed to single amino acids before moving into circulation. Whether you eat raw milk or milk with denatured proteins makes no difference, you only absorb small protein fragments.
- jjoonathan 12y ago> it must be proven safe first on a case by case basis Do you hold "natural" foods to the same standard? On average they tend to have far more genetic variation away from "known good" genomes, yet I don't know anyone who thinks that clinical trials are warranted when Farmer Bob's corn cross-pollinates with Farmer Joe's corn. > that doesn't mean that the pasteurization process produces the same resulting denatured proteins our body does. It's possible that there's a significant difference, but assuming we process denatured proteins similarly a reasonable null hypothesis that one probably shouldn't reject merely on the basis of a single p=.049 study. Just how strong is the evidence that convinced you it causes cancer? https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/everything-we-eat-causes-cancer/ https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/everything-we-eat-cause... > Lactose is a sugar, and we simply do not benefit from diets high in sugars and carbs. Yeah but you didn't mention sugar and carbs in general, you mentioned lactose specifically. Why? Was it just an example (it didn't come across that way)? > contains hormones that are not biologically inert for humans (we are not baby cows) I remember looking up the concentration of the hormone in human milk for comparison and finding that it was 50x higher than what people were whining about in cow milk. Do you think human milk is dangerous too?