5 ms·
So, the real question is if the target audience is against using actual cow's milk, don't they have a heavy correlation to the anti-gmo crowd?
by tracker1 12y ago
So, the real question is if the target audience is against using actual cow's milk, don't they have a heavy correlation to the anti-gmo crowd?
- moron4hire 12y agoThey are also not the most rational crowd.
- tracker1 12y agoTrue enough.. I just mean it seems to me their target market is self-destroying based on how the stuff is made. That said, I think it's hard enough to get cheese that is simply cheese, let alone crafted/aged cheeses that I'll keep with cow/goat based cheeses for the foreseeable future.
- mesh 12y agoThat is a pretty broad generalization.
- njohnson41 12y agoCorrelation, sure. But even as a non-vegetarian, I can understand the argument for not raising animals directly or indirectly for food, due to inefficiency. Vegans who believe that but don't really care about food being "natural" would still want this stuff; not all vegans are motivated to be vegan by the same things.
- jqm 12y agoIndeed. Ideological eaters are and probably always will be a minority. Economics based eaters on the other hand.....
- chc 12y agoI would expect there's a stronger-than-average correlation there — mainly because they have the common prerequisite of caring about what you eat — but my hunch is that most vegans wouldn't object to this. I can personally say I'd buy it.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoThere are plenty of anti-GMO vegans. But I'm sure there are plenty of vegans who'd be fine with it. After all, there is a scientific case for veganism too.
- chc 12y agoEven the ethical case for veganism doesn't have much to say about GMO. The idea that hurting animals is wrong doesn't in any way entail that creating genetically engineered plants or microorganisms is wrong.
- tracker1 12y agoI am speaking from personal experience, but most of my vegan friends are also vocally anti-gmo... it just seemed to me that man vegans are also anti-gmo so it might be a self-defeating effort to target a subset of a subset market.
- schoen 12y agoI'm a vegan who's motivated by opposition to animal agriculture, so I enthusiastically support research like this (and think it's the most promising path I've heard of to a vegan human future). I went to a vegan advocacy organization event a few months ago where this topic came up, and other attendees shared my enthusiasm for this kind of research, but the diversity of views and motivations in the vegan community makes me wary of claiming that that means this is mainstream. To answer your correlation question, probably yes -- but vegans' attitudes toward "tampering with nature" vary widely from the view that it's the worst possible thing humanity can do, on through to the view that it's the best possible thing humanity can do (e.g., David Pearce), with a broad spectrum in between. (I don't have an ideal example of the former group in mind, but I could mention Sea Shepherd's Paul Watson, who advocates deep ecology and opposes GMOs.) I think we will see sharper divisions between environmentalist vegans (especially advocates of deep ecology) and animal rights/animal welfare vegans over time. I don't know how the population breaks down in the west today, or how many people have even had to think about it that much.
- rboyd 12y agoYour last sentence is pretty interesting to me. After months of prodding from my girlfriend to go vegan, the book 'Abundance' and the chapter on the water inefficiency of factory farming is what finally turned me. It was reasonably easy for me to justify carnivorism as naturally occurring, harder to justify water waste with so many humans going thirsty. Without even starting down the emissions road. That said, looking at it now (and especially once synthetic meats come online, out of cost efficiency if nothing else), I think our children might look back on the practice of animal slaughter as being pretty horrifically barbaric.