3 ms·
If a company wanted to provide aid and give away food, we don't claim that it is creating an unfair market for the local food industry. If Wikipedia want to gi
by belorn 12y ago
If a company wanted to provide aid and give away food, we don't claim that it is creating an unfair market for the local food industry.
If Wikipedia want to give away free access to information, suddenly its an unfair advantage in the market of free information?
- manish_gill 12y agoBecause the access to information is extremely constrained. The Internet is much bigger than just wikipedia. There have been studies which showed that people in such situations who used these so called "Free services" didn't even realize they were actually a part of the much bigger Internet, and just considered them standalone. I guess a similar situation would be people in the old days thinking AOL was synonymous with the Internet. Do you want to live in a world where your access to information is constrained to one site only?
- disgruntledphd2 12y agoGive the choice between that and no internet (Wikipedia alone could be transformative, conditional on literacy), then yes, I'd probably make that choice. Its not ideal, but marrying the commercial incentives of telcos to get people paying for data and the gateway drug of free access seems more likely to get more people connected faster than anything else.
- firasd 12y agoThe difficulty in analogies like this (and other arguments against net neutrality, such as saying partnerships between Facebook and network companies are the equivalent of promotional marketing or bundling) is that controlling the availability of specific sites or apps on a network inherently introduces bias in the network. So this is like an organization that gives away food creating roads that only they and their partners can use, given a government license to build roads (the same way network companies have a government license to build on the wireless spectrum and other channels.)
- keenerd 12y ago> If a company wanted to provide aid and give away food, we don't claim that it is creating an unfair market for the local food industry. Actually some do claim that: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/14/world/americas/14iht-food.4.7116855.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/14/world/americas/14iht-food.... edit: In case you are hit by the paywall, > Charity finds that U.S. food aid for Africa hurts instead of helps, Celia W. Dugger, 2007-08-14
- denzil_correa 12y agoThe company owns the food. Wikipedia doesn't own the Internet or the information.