10 ms·
Interestingly I see a lot of comments saying we need more women in tech, but none saying we need more black people in tech. I have worked with a number of women
by collyw 12y ago
Interestingly I see a lot of comments saying we need more women in tech, but none saying we need more black people in tech. I have worked with a number of women, and only ever seen one consultant come in who was black. Are we more racist than sexist? (I see plenty of Indians however, maybe a disproportionate amount compared to the general population?).
I am based in Europe, and I do think there is less of a cultural division amongst races here. People appear to pigeonhole themselves into categories more in the US in my opinion, be it on race, job, music tastes or whatever.
- draugadrotten 12y ago> Interestingly I see a lot of comments saying we need more women in tech, but none saying we need more black people in tech. Let's assume California needs more black people in tech. Does China need more white people in tech?
- heldrida 12y agoEven better, in the US why don't we see more native Americans in Tech ? In Australia why don't we see more aboriginal in Tech ? Why in America, police shoot black people all the time ? Why is there so many poor black people, homeless black people ? The same for aboriginal people in Australia. It's not hard to figure out where all this is coming from.
- ivanca 12y agoWhite people in China accounts for 0.8%, black people accounts for 13% of the US, meaning statistically one in every 10 techies should be black but they are not and financial opportunities are also statistically low in that racial group (probably not for white people in China) I also believe segregating help is not the best idea in the world but lets face that is not so clear cut.
- enupten 12y agoYes, but only in an alternate world where China smuggled white slaves, repressed them for 400 years, and who then went on to become naturalised citizens. The stupidity!
- peterfirefly 12y agoYou should perhaps look a little bit into the history of slavery. It was not white against black or Europeans against Africans. It was everybody against everybody else. The Muslim history of slavery is quite interesting, for example. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthony_Johnson_(colonist) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthony_Johnson_(colonist) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_slave_trade http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_slave_trade http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_China http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_China
- douche 12y agoThe better analogy would be saying that China needs more Manchus, or Hakkas, or Uyghurs in tech.
- cauterized 12y agoPoor analogy. 10-15% of CA's population is black. Something like 1% of Silicon Valley tech employees are black. The percentage of white people in China is vanishingly small. And AFAIK China doesn't claim to be a land of equal opportunity.
- heldrida 12y agoWe don't need more women, black, latino, white, red, green people in tech, we need talented people, regardless of how they look like. We need less bullshit, people who produce sane code and go home early to work on what matters about us, our communities, our families, our education! I'm full stack dev living in London, I'm black, huge afro, piercings, english is not my first language, skateboarder, into punk music, etc.
- tormeh 12y agoWhat is your first language?
- heldrida 12y agoMy first language is Portuguese.
- collyw 12y agoActually I completely agree. It was a subtle way of saying that without getting the usual down votes when you mention that sort of thing on here.
- yardie 12y agoYes, we do need more black people in tech. And you get more black people in tech by having black people in tech. Going out to recruit, mentor, and support black tech candidates and workers. Seriously, the latest black YC candidate was a prison messaging service. More power to them but for a lot of blacks in the US the 2 paths that earn the most publicity are sports and criminal activity. Even when I was a teenager and had a mentor it took me 2 hours by bus in the Miami heat to meet him just 1x per week. Some of my fellow, richer, friends had cars of their own and would drive to meet their mentors or join them for lunch. And it's those small barriers that create the giant hurdle. At the moment, I'm mentoring my younger siblings, nieces, and nephews who are on their way to college. Being the first in my family to attend university I'm hoping to help them avoid the pitfalls that I encountered when going to university.
- 12y ago
- lsiebert 12y agoConsider, the wealth gap for white women to white men largely begins with them. Whereas a median White household has 50 times the wealth of the median black household [1], and income and wealth are a great predictor of attending and graduating college[2]. So it's a lot more convenient to get more white and asian women into tech without having to deal with the greater systemic wealth and income disparities that effect black candidates. That's definitely not all of it, but even if you believe, as a number of people on HN seem to believe, that there is no more racism in hiring for qualified candidates, this is something you can't really deny, that systemic disadvantages in income and wealth mean that black people are going to be under represented among qualified candidates. In fact, I recall hearing that the wealth gap between whites and blacks is bigger than in south africa during apartheid [3]. [1] http://www.epi.org/publication/trends-median-wealth-race/ http://www.epi.org/publication/trends-median-wealth-race/ [2] http://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2012/05/02/poor-students-are-the-real-victims-of-college-discrimination/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2012/05/02/poor-stu... [3] http://www.blackagendareport.com/content/worse-apartheid-black-obama%E2%80%99s-america http://www.blackagendareport.com/content/worse-apartheid-bla...
- enupten 12y agoI don't think the "racism" faced by Indians is any less than Blacks. That said, I think given the task they're faced with, they tend to form very expansive support networks, which are useful for career-wise. See, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x3rqnUg_Myo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x3rqnUg_Myo Can we stop using words with demonic connotations like "sexism", "racism" ? People tend to naturally discriminate against people who are unlike them. The usual propaganda makes this all the worse. What we need is meta-education, which teaches people the limitations of their own biological selves, not Marxist "revolutions".
- digitalzombie 12y agoThere's no proof that women are systematically targeted to be ousted from the tech field. I haven't seen any research papers with any clear evidence of this other than that there are more boys than girls in a particular field. I'm sure there are other occupation with the same thing. There are too many Fillipino in Nurse career I don't see any body saying to diversify it. There are tons of Vietnamese in nails, my uncle and mother included. I don't see people saying that there should be other race within such jobs. You can argue that it's not a great jobs but what about nursing? We can encourage more women and minority within a field which is fine. But to make it seems like a problem is a problem. Because of this people such as women will use this as an excuse. Look at the CEO of Reddit, she used this and sexism as an excuse. So before we jump the gun and say such thing such as racist and sexist, we should carefully find the cause and not jump the gun. We do not know if this is intentional or an unintentional the consequences of culture. I mean hell there's a lot of Asian going to university and a lot of less other color such as Black. Is it because Asian are racist against other races? No, it's culture and the Pew report for Asian Americans have backed this up. That Asian American parent believe an education is important.
- random854 12y agoRead 'Unlocking the Clubhouse' (in regard to women.) It's dated but more recent research has similar conclusions. I can't speak personally about race issues in tech. What I do know is that the industry thrives on ideas, and as people themselves have diverse ideas, missing an entire group's is missing a lot. Why isn't the field more racially diverse? Are black people 'naturally not interested in tech'? Or do they face social barriers others don't? What I know leads me to believe the latter.
- jrs99 12y agowhy even bother with someone who claims they've never seen research that proves discrimination in tech? That there's no discrimination against blacks who want to open up small businesses? Or claims that no one wants to diversify nursing? Less than a minute on google and I've found research that concludes there is discrimination in tech, that blacks face discrimination from banks when starting small businesses, and a handful of articles about diversity in nursing just on the first page of google results for that topic.
- white-flame 12y agoFrom a shallow headline perspective, women seem to bring in different angles of thought, creativity, and productivity than men, which is beneficial when blended together. There doesn't seem to be that sort of distinction between men across different races, as there is across gender. Now, that's probably not the actual drive for the strong push for women in tech (equality, fairness, etc), but a case could be made for it.
- rickyc091 12y agoI work in the education system and the primary reason there's been a lot of push for women in tech is due to the negativity around technology / computers. Girl enjoy the use of technology, but they would never pursue it as a career since it's not the "cool" thing to do. You get labeled as a geek, a nerd, etc. You basically become an outsider. When you're young, it's all about reputation. This is why people are trying to get girls interested in technology at an early age and change their mindset.
- garmain 12y agoDoes this mean that tech is inherently the "cool" thing to do? Or that men are less likely to be labeled as a geek, a nerd etc? Or less susceptible for this? The way you put it, it seems to me like somehow these effects are less strong for men. Why would that be the case?