6 ms·
Are master’s degrees on their way out? Alternatives grow as enrollment fades
- HarryHirsch 12y agoIn my experience, masters degrees serve as a waiting pattern to get into medical schoool and also get around immigration restrictions, especially the Master's cap. They serve these purposes rather well, the question whether anyone taking these degrees actually learns anything useful is not relevant at all.
- EliRivers 12y agoAnecdata; I've just finished a Masters in Maths and my mathematical ability has massively improved. Nobody doing this alongside me is going to medical school. My first masters was in physics. I don't know of anyone there going to medical school either, but it's been a few years; maybe some have.
- glesica 12y agoI have two masters degrees (well, one and writing a thesis for the second one) and I found them both enlightening, valuable experiences. It is, of course, important to note that I didn't pay for either of them (except in the form of opportunity costs). If I'd had to go deeply into debt I might feel differently.
- Rapzid 12y agoIt's a shame you need a bachelor's degree to undertake a master's program. It might be fun to do a comp-sci program at Georgia Tech, and I believe I would find it enlightening and valuable. There is just no way I'd go through the trouble of getting a bachelor's degree first.
- pdiddy 12y agoGood shout bringing up Georgia Tech. Their new online master's in Comp Sci seems to be really shaking things up. It seems like a major omission from this article, especially because it is a collaboration between Udacity and GT.
- jonkiddy 12y agoI'm wrapping up my second semester this week in Georgia Tech's OMSCS program. It's fantastic. The courses are packed full of CS fundamentals, algorithms, data structures, etc. I finished my bachelor's in 2004 and find this MS program challenging probably due to being out of school for a decade.
- symfoniq 12y agoThis. I'm in my 30s with a wife, kids, and a successful career. The Georgia Tech program looks great, but there's no way I'm going to go back and finish my bachelor's degree at this point in my life. Useless general education coursework and the absurd cost of online degree programs from reputable brick and mortar schools makes it a nonstarter. If there were an affordable online B.A./B.S. program from a reputable institution, which was tailored to worldly-wise people for whom high school was half a lifetime ago, I might reconsider. But I haven't found it yet.
- lrm242 12y agoI don't know how far along you and the parent are in your bachelors, but there are BS completion programs that you might consider. I'm now 35 and I left my undergrad EE BS in my senior year to start a software company. Thankfully it worked out, but I have at times wished to be able to get a masters degree and have found the bachelors requirement troublesome. Last year I enrolled at UT Arlington to get a BS in University Studies via the Finish@UT program (http://www.finishatut.org/ http://www.finishatut.org/). I am specifically planning on finishing a CS masters via the Georgia Tech program. To finish my bachelors I will need to finish 4 semesters of part-time coursework, essentially picking up where I left off in my undergrad EE at UT Austin, but of course not getting a EE degree, but still getting a BS degree. Anyway, as a means to an end, I can stomach 4 semesters of undergrad online coursework to (a) finish my degree as an example for my daughters and fulfil a promise to my father; and, (b) enable for me the option to get a masters in CS for personal fulfilment reasons.
- Spooky23 12y agoThere are a few options. Check out Excelsior College, which is a SUNY school intended to provide educational options for employed people... they've been doing this for many years. You can get credit for work experience as well -- I think up to 70. There are other options as well, many of these programs were setup originally to support nursing programs and military families. Just stick to non-profits.
- Rapzid 12y agoI'm in much the same boat less the kids though. Just into my 30s and started my career a bit late but already making good money and have really good experience on my resume. A 4 year program with all the extraneous drawn out learning would present a huge potential opportunity cost for me. I already try to be a bit of a Renaissance man, and I'm constantly expanding my IT/comp-sci knowledge outside of work. I'm never asked about my education when applying for jobs.. I guess it's Coursera for me then :) @lrm242 So far away. I barely have a semester worth of credits from TCC(Tarrant County) earned a decade ago.
- HarryHirsch 12y agoIt is, of course, important to note that I didn't pay for either of them That's the discriminant, right there. If they pay you it's because they need someone to get some work done, and the funds to pay you come from someone willing to pay them - NSF, NIH, industrial sponsor, whatever. But if you pay them they'll just make some advanced undergrad courses a requirement for your masters, and it's a farce throughout.
- maccard 12y agoI've got a masters degree, taken for self fullfilment reasons. Myself, and the majority of people who took the course with me all now work as software engineers, none of us took it for immigration reasons. Two people are doing PhD programmes now. Just because you don't see the value in it doesn't mean it has no value.
- erikb 12y agoI'm not sure if we have this feeling in Germany already, but I'm also sure that this is the trend and that it is correct that way. I visited one of the first online courses available and it was awesome. No more sitting for hours in boring presentations when you can just skim through the video, google the important information, do the homework and be done in half the time of a normal class. You can grab the knowledge of a whole semester in a week, if you work hard. And you can choose which time you do the learning. 5am, 1pm or 11pm? Sunday morning instead of Wednesday afternoon? All no problem with online courses.
- bane 12y agoI have an M.S. and work with a group of colleagues who mostly have M.S.s or PhDs. I'd say in general, the value of an M.S./M.A. is far below that of a B.S./B.A. It's more valuable than had I gone and gotten an A.S./A.A. even though the A.S./A.A. would have been more work. I can't say I regret getting it, because it checked some boxes for me that let me move up the corporate ladder without as much fuss. It's kind of like getting a "free" extra 2-3 years of work experience and tends to move you up a hair in seniority, but that's about it. I seem to get management tasks a little bit faster than my non-M.S./M.A. peers. It seems to be that the next most valuable degree is a PhD, but with few exceptions, it's not nearly as valuable in industry as one might think. I'm not even sure if it's really worth it in terms of ROI, whereas I'm highly confident that a B.S./B.A. will generally earn you more than without. So in that case an M.S./M.A. is just a stepping stone towards that. And that makes the PhD even harder to justify. The people I know who seem to do the best have both a PhD and and MBA, which aligns them well with executive and senior executive placement in high-tech industry. It doesn't really even seem to matter what the PhD is in. An alternative that also seems popular among executive recruiters is J.D. & M.B.A.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoA PhD is more of a life fulfillment thing, it's not about money. There are some jobs you can only get with a PhD, even if those jobs don't pay more than normal ones, the work can be more satisfying to those who aren't cut out for dev work. A PhD MBA sounds...very weird.
- eitally 12y agoIt does sound weird, but there are quite a few joint PhD/MBA programs out there at esteemed universities (Yale, Stanford, UVA, Harvard, MIT, ...), and this (concurrent achievement) is the only scenario where it may make sense.
- bane 12y agoYou see a lot of people with PhDs and MBAs on the side outside of the typical HN startups space. You might be surprised at how many PhDs also have an MBA, but just don't advertise it since their other credentials are more important. For example, it's not uncommon for a researcher to come up with some great idea at a lab somewhere, quit, form a company (with him as CEO) and license the tech away from his former employers. In order to give the investors more of a warm fuzzy feeling about the competency of the guy running the company, they'll often have him do an executive MBA program while the company is still early stages. In megacorp-land, PhDs for senior execs are reasonably common as well, and it's desired that they also have excellent business education -- so you'll see lots of MBAs in executive resumes that they picked up somewhere during their careers. I haven't usually seen it as part of the education progression, it's treated more like a specialized certificate or accreditation program when people are moving out of researchy roles and into business ones.
- tluyben2 12y agoFor practical work the online platforms are good, but for hard theoretical work like a master's at least should be, they are not. At least not in my experience. I have one and I would get another one and even a phd if I could now, but at the time I thought all that theoretical bullshit wouldn't do me much good in real life. It did not directly but of course it did form my brain to actually being able to solve problems and learn things I never saw before while a lot of people who 'studied online' find have problems getting into things they never saw before. I would not mind master's and phd's going back to the academic realm though; for people who want to do research and not 'get a high paying job' as it once was.
- jackgavigan 12y ago> ..Lynda.com, which reaches more than 4 million people a year with its how-to tutorials online in everything from management skills to programming. Now we know where Dilbert's pointy-haired boss learns his new buzzwords from! In all seriousness, I can't help feeling that someone who, for example, learns how to program using a Lynda.com online course, is missing out on a lot of things (e.g. the underlying principles of computer science) that are taught as part of a full academic course of study (whether or not that course is taught in the traditional manner in lecture theatres, or online, using video lectures). Given I'm not a programmer, I'm interested in hearing others' thoughts on the matter.
- nkozyra 12y agoIt depends on the individual. There are plenty of driven people who want to know the absolute most they can, and won't stop once they're able to generate applications. There are then plenty of others who get something to "work" and call it a day. But that's not restricted to self-learners. You can do the absolute minimum in college, too. Not to mention all of the things that you learn but don't apply after graduation, if you're taking specific classes and don't work directly in OS design or algorithms, that fades pretty quickly. More importantly, CS programs don't spend a ton of time on the programming itself, so to some degree you have to be a self-learner even at a college-level CS program.
- wongarsu 12y agoAll other thing being equal, the CS grad is much more likely to know the advantages and disadvantages of using a heap than a self taught programmer. At least in my CS program you can't get away without getting a decent exposure to algorithm design and theoretical computer science. You can on the other hand easily learn programming without ever touching these subjects.
- dragonwriter 12y agoLots of people long before the age of web tutorials wee self taught programmers from books that didn't focus on academic computer science, or even -- especially in the 80s and earlier -- from particular product manuals. Many of these people have been gainfully employed using their programming skills. While academic computer science is certainly useful for programming in industry, and some parts of it are essential to some jobs, not everyone programming needs a computer science degree or equivalent coverage in less-formal education.
- eitally 12y agoI look at master's degrees as advanced vocational skills certifications. A lot of people go into an MS/MA/MEng/MFA program right out of undergrad, primarily because they think they either may want a PhD or because they don't want to leave the safety of university just yet, but many more people matriculate into masters programs years after graduation when their work experience illustrates clearly that they would be well served professionally to dive deeper into a given area of study. For example, I started undergrad as a physics major but switched to history in my second semester, while continuing personal study of my hobby interest of computing/programming. I ended up getting a job as a webdev when I graduated (1999), and gradually moved into management. In 2007 when my company laid off 20% of its technical workforce and the economy was starting to tank, I made a decision to go back to school for a masters in an area actually relevant to my desired work (manufacturing systems engineering). I did and I learned a ton of useful stuff. In these kinds of situations, it's hard to overestimate the value of a master's degree, because like others have said, besides the emerging MOOC opportunities, there aren't really any other places where someone can spend either 1-1.5yrs full time or 2-4 years part time earning an advanced credential that's globally recognized, in nearly any field.
- stuff4ben 12y agoAs I ponder going into management, I tend to wonder if I should get an MBA or even a masters in CS. There are numerous leadership style classes at the major universities around here that I was thinking about taking as well in lieu of a full masters degree.
- lectrick 12y agoWhen looked at from a pure cost/benefit standpoint (on a salary ruler), it doesn't make much sense. But perhaps there's still an intangible benefit.
- matt_morgan 12y agoThis article doesn't actually say anything convincing about master's-level enrollment fading. It cites one university's layoffs and that university's related press communications. Not a single number, no generalization or overall trends ... I don't doubt it is happening but come on. Do some reporting. Link somewhere. Or change the title of your piece.
- shubhamjain 12y agoAre there any numbers on how many of the enrollments are from students of foreign countries because many people see M.S, as an easier way to have "Green Card" in US.
- ben010783 12y agoYou don't get the same bang for buck out of a master's degree, but it's not clear that enrollment won't rise again when the economy slumps again. Getting a Master's Degree gets you classes, experience, connections, and it also gives you access to a lot of services, like Lynda.com. When you look at how many colleges offer free access to Lynda.com or how many colleges supply courses for Coursera, you realize that many of these services are trying to supplement college, rather than replace it entirely. Continuing education has been necessary long before the rise of online video. I think these services will have a bigger effect on the publishing industry than the Master's Degree programs.
- cabinpark 12y agoCourse-work based masters perhaps, but definitely not thesis-based. My Master's degree was entirely paid for and I actually made money. I wrote a thesis that contained original research and published a paper with my supervisor on the research. This is awesome. It's a 'PhD-lite'. It showed me how to do research and whether or not I would want to continue on with a PhD.
- geebee 12y agoI still think a traditional, full time MS degree can be worth while, depending on how you go about it. You do need to be careful, though. An MS can be a good way to build a portfolio, gain some skills that are hard to develop while working full time, and explore interesting ideas and options that might turn into a startup or software application. It isn't the only way, of course, but it can be a good way. The ground rules: 1) don't go heavily into debt If you are pursuing an academic MS, you can often get a TA position that will reduce or eliminate your tuition while paying a stipend. Alternatively, consider a highly regarded public university with relatively low tuition - for complicated reasons I won't get into here, public graduate programs in CS/Engineering tend to rank far more highly than the general undergraduate programs. I want to emphasize the debt thing again here - if you go heavily into debt, none of this is worth it. I hear what I can only call horror stories about people going 100k into debt for an MS in things like religious studies. I'm not surprised some people are passionate about this field, and by all means, they should find a way to pursue it. But I'm amazed that the federal gov't created a special non-dischargable kind of debt that allows people to go 100K or more into debt for masters degrees with such limit career earning potential. By contrast, 10-20k of debt with a MS from a reputable engineering school is no big deal. Really, the loss of income eclipses this, since people who can apply to MS STEM programs are usually already capable of earning a decent salary. 2) choose a program with flexible requirements. If you get into a reputable MS program in a STEM field, odds are good you've already done mathematically rigorous and highly structured undergraduate degree. Your new program should allow you to choose courses that match your more specialized interests. 3) it's ok to take a relatively easy academic load and pursue side projects. Maybe even better. This is where I fell down a bit. At Berkeley, I could have taken Intellectual Property through the SIMS/Law schools, product development through the MBA/Engineering schools. Instead, I dropped those courses to keep up with advanced nonlinear optimization and integer programming. Those are great courses for people who plan to be research professors in those fields, but they weren't good courses for me. I would have enjoyed myself more and gotten more out of my coursework if I'd realized what I was really there to do. On the bright side, I did pursue a lot of side projects, mainly software applications inspired by things I was learning. If you're at a good university, there will be a lot of interesting speakers, seminars, students, projects, and other types of activities that are highly relevant to your field. Of course, it all depends on what you're there for, and if you are planning on advancing humanity's mathematical knowledge of integer optimization, this wouldn't be the right advice for you. But keep in mind, a university is actually fertile ground for interesting ideas that, oddly enough, don't really fit into something that will get you credit hours. Don't lock yourself down with coursework to the point where you can't tap into that, especially if you aren't PhD bound anyway. Plus, you may be able to convert one of these activities into a MS project. All in all, it's still up to you to decide whether it's worth the loss of a year or more of income. It can be difficult to pursue ideas like this if you're working full time, and what you do in an MS program may put you on a much more interesting and fulfilling path long term. It's hardly the only way. If so, it can be worth it. Just really, don't go deeply into debt. All those wonderful, interesting paths that opened up to you may not be possible if debt forces you a demanding, full time job that takes up all your time and mental energy.
- zedpm 12y agoI was the last student at my college to receive a master's degree in Computer Science; the program was eliminated. At the time, the movement was towards cross-discipline graduate programs, e.g. a Robotics and Intelligent Autonomous Systems degree that combined studies in AI, ML, Electrical Engineering, Mechanical Engineering, etc. At the time this seemed like a smart way to get a more practical focus while herding more students into fewer graduate programs. I wonder today if even that approach is viable, or if, as this article suggests, the new-model education will continue to take market share from traditional university programs.