5 ms·
"Inventor of image only made popular by people widely copying and remixing it starts suing people over it now that it's popular." I half expected the post date
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
"Inventor of image only made popular by people widely copying and remixing it starts suing people over it now that it's popular."
I half expected the post date to be April 1 (it wasn't), or for the last line of the article to be "And if you believed a word of the above, here's an image for you:" (it wasn't).
- MattBearman 12y agoI don't see the problem with this, now the image is popular and recognisable, companies are profiting from his creation. Why shouldn't he get a licensing fee for that?
- Mahn 12y agoBecause he didn't distribute it as such. Do you think the image would have become half as popular if he had posted it as "here's a face I drew in mspaint, I intend to change royalties for its use if it get catches on, enjoy"? No, the reason it was used everywhere is because it was assumed to be license-free, and usually the people hit by this wouldn't have otherwise used it. I don't have anything against creators earning royalties from their work, but in my eyes this is akin to charging a user for a subscription without his knowledge.
- slazaro 12y agoIf I'm not mistaken, he's only asking for money from whoever is profiting from it and he's not bothering anybody that just uses the image in a non-commercial way. Still kind of weird because it more or less belongs to "the people" and everybody uses it, but if someone is profiting from it, I don't see a problem with him getting a share.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> the reason it was used everywhere is because it was assumed to be license-free, and usually the people hit by this wouldn't have otherwise used it. Exactly. An image that is free for non-commercial use requires you to think whether your use is really non-commercial in nature, which is too much of a cognitive burden, so you go and pick another one. Moreover, this image wouldn't actually be famous if not for the number of people who profited on it already - namely, all that image sharing sites that have ads on them.
- mikkom 12y ago> No, the reason it was used everywhere is because it was assumed to be license-free What does that even mean? No image or any art is "licence-free" unless author explicitly states so. That's the basis of copyright, your creations are yours (unless you give them away). Publishing your work doesn't change anything.
- comboy 12y agoHe posted it to 4chan. "The next day, though, Ramirez was merely pleased to see others sharing his one-off doodle. In the anonymous world of 4chan, having other people recognize your contribution felt good." He clearly didn't have any issue with that, and without any license posted, that was already a violation wasn't it? They shared his work without stating the author and without his permission. Yet he was happy about that, until he smelled some money. It's like if you would put a basket of candies, some people approach you and try to take it, and you're like "sure, take it, I'm glad you like it". And this keeps on for a while. And then some guy in a suite comes in and takes one candy like so many others. At which point you start running after him shouting "THIEF! He stole my candy!"
- mikkom 12y agoAs I already said, by publishing your own work you don't give your rights for the work away. Yes, he's suing people who are using his artwork to make money for themselves. Why do you think that is a problem and why do you think they shouldn't pay him a cut for using his artwork?
- comboy 12y agoIt goes along with how trademark laws in US work (I think), if you don't defend them, you lose rights. IANAL so this could be a bad example. Law is on his side, so they should pay. My problem is just with him changing his mind at some point. Not defending his rights from the start and even being happy about them being broken could suggest that he meant it to be free. And as others mentioned, there's no chance that it would have any value whatsoever if it wasn't. E.g. company X puts some small open source code online (yes, nowadays nobody would touch it without a license). People modify it, improve it, share it, build on top of it. Company X often tweets "awesome to see how our code spreads and all fantastic usages of it". And then after some time it sues. i.e. as others mentioned, this picture would have no value if it would not (assumed to) be in public domain and without all thousands comics and memes done on top of it.
- jeffbush 12y agoMy understanding from the article is that he posted a comic strip that contained the image and people cut that image out of it. This was not how he intended for it to be used. Furthermore, the article implies the people he's going after are making money off it. If you have a business (even a small one) that is making money, I think you have no excuse for not making sure you have rights to the material you are using. So, I don't think it's fair to blame Carlos because other people misused his copyrighted material without his consent.
- userbinator 12y agoHe posted it to 4chan, where remixing and reposting images others have posted is the norm. In fact that's why it got popular as a meme.
- anon4 12y agoHe didn't attach a license to it, so it gets the standard "creator owns copyright on this until Disney stops prolonging copyright terms" license. The fact that he didn't sue at first in now way implies that it's public domain.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- TillE 12y ago"Popularity" really isn't the point. He's going after people who are profiting off his copyrighted work. I know casual copyright infringement is the norm on the internet (eg, distributing images from god knows where), and maybe that's okay, but you've certainly crossed an ethical line when you've started selling it without permission.
- alistairjcbrown 12y agoThe irony being that even the article had an image from god knows where > Image Credit: Adam Sandler (Unknown, please let me know!)
- ajuc 12y agoIt's not illegal or evil, but it's bad style. The value of the image is 99.9% associations it aquired thanks to the "copyright is bad" culture using it under assumption that it is public domain. Changing it now is bad style, and it sets bad example for others that may take this further. I know slippery slope isn't a very strong argument, but it is still valid concern. I wonder if 4chan should adopt GPL-like licencing.
- girvo 12y agoI agree it's not evil, but in some cases it's definitely illegal. Whether that's a good or bad thing, I pass no judgement on.
- userbinator 12y agoNC-SA, which oddly enough doesn't actually exist as a real Creative Commons license, would be more similar to what 4chan users treat memes as - non-commercial and share-alike, but no attribution nor any other the other restrictions.
- ekianjo 12y ago> but you've certainly crossed an ethical line when you've started selling it without permission. The troll face would have NEVER become popular if it was not free to distribute in the first place. It's not this guy who made it popular by himself, it's the 4chan and subsequent communities who did - in that sense, what it became does not belong to him at all.
- Dylan16807 12y agoIt's not like he waited in the bushes for it to become popular. He just smacked down people who were trying to profit or particularly annoying.