4 ms·
Your "trick" doesn't change any of the conservation of angular momentum considerations in the article. To "get rid of the remaining kinetic energy" would only
by joe_the_user 12y ago
Your "trick" doesn't change any of the conservation of angular momentum considerations in the article.
To "get rid of the remaining kinetic energy" would only result in the object getting escape velocity relative to earth. The object would never have "stopped" relative to it's orbit around the sun but even at it's further point would be traveling with fairly close to the same angular velocity as the earth (as described in the article etc).
- CompelTechnic 12y agoI'm about 80% sure leni536 is right, from playing Kerbal Space Program.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoLet me guess: the wonderful experience of putting a satellite orbiting in the precisely opposite direction to the one required by contract, noticing that your orbital velocity at apoapsis is like ~200m/s and realizing that you have enough delta-v to just turn around and reverse the orbit on the spot?
- jheriko 12y agoi think you are right based on a similar feeling from that game, but be careful with that intuition. how much delta-v do you spend lifting the orbit so that lowering the periapse is cheap?
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoFor large orbital changes, substantially less than the niave transfer.
- benjoffe 12y agoThat "trick" would indeed work and is a well known orbital manoeuvre: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bi-elliptic_transfer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bi-elliptic_transfer (without the final circularising burn). This manoeuvre would be preferable to the article's alternative (a Hohmann transfer reducing periapsis to the sun's radius without the final circularising burn) in all cases where the initial semi-major axis (relative to the sun) is roughly greater than 11.94 solar radii (ignoring minor factors that make this case slightly different to the wikipedia example). edit: to make it clear, I'm talking about a heliocentric bi-elliptic transfer after Earth escape, where the initial orbit is equivalent to Earth's orbit, and the final inner orbit can be imagined as one scraping the surface of the sun, but since the sun would destroy the craft, the final circularising burn is not required (in sloppy terms: hitting the sun on the edge would be easier than hitting it straight on).
- teraflop 12y agoThe downside, of course, is that your nuclear waste spends an awfully long time in an orbit that crosses, or at least passes very close to, Earth's. Better not lose control of your rocket, or you'll have a politically inconvenient situation on your hands.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoMore important than politically inconvenient: a technically inconvenient situation, as that waste could be on a trajectory back to earth. https://youtu.be/YIqXql6LLz0?t=6m50s https://youtu.be/YIqXql6LLz0?t=6m50s
- jheriko 12y agothats not how this manoeuvre works. the burn to fall into the sun happens way before any possible return to earth if that orbit were not altered... all that happens is that you start near the earth - thats unavoidable because the rocket comes form the earth. it will of course cross the earth's orbit on the way into the sun, but, with the exception of very small ranges of orbits the chance of hitting the earth on return is tiny, and easily avoided with some timing.
- teraflop 12y agoI'm aware of how a bielliptic transfer orbit works. See the long gap between burns 1 and 2 on the Wikipedia diagram? That interval is necessarily going to be more than half a year long, and potentially much, much longer. Spacecraft are pretty reliable once they're in space, but that's still a lot of time for something to malfunction. And if burn 2 doesn't happen, now you have tons of nuclear waste on an elliptical orbit that re-visits Earth's path every so often. At any given perihelion, the earth has only a small chance of being in the right part of its orbit, but eventually... I'm not saying it's a big risk; the chance of a catastrophic launch malfunction is probably a lot greater. But it's definitely a long-term potential hazard that needs to be accounted for.
- 12y ago