5 ms·
> Create a website for free (you have to pay for certificates to use HTTPS) No you don't. You can get free certificates. But even if that was true, it's still
by mike_hearn 12y ago
> Create a website for free (you have to pay for certificates to use HTTPS)
No you don't. You can get free certificates.
But even if that was true, it's still a misleading argument. You can only make a website for free if you are OK with your website not having a domain name and running it off your personal laptop with electricity paid for by your roommates/parents. For any actual website, there are already a multitude of real costs of which a certificate is just one more.
> Report sensor data from small embedded devices with extremely limited CPU
If your CPU is really so limited then why are you using HTTP at all? Use a custom binary protocol with or without encryption as appropriate.
> Your JS can talk to APIs that don't yet support HTTPS (e.g. NextBus).
Then those APIs suck - avoid them and/or ask the providers to get with the program.
> Transfer large files at gigabit speeds on consumer-grade hardware
AES-NI can decrypt at 3.5 cycles per byte. With modern consumer grade hardware you will not find symmetric streaming crypto to be a serious bottleneck.
- ciupicri 12y agoFrom where can one get free certificates? Not everyone has modern hardware. My hosting provider doesn't have AES-NI for example.
- blowski 12y ago> From where can one get free certificates? e.g. https://www.startssl.com/?app=1 https://www.startssl.com/?app=1 Also, if HTTPS became a requirement, then demand would increase for free HTTPS certificates in exchange for, say, advertising.
- ciupicri 12y agoIf I remember correctly there were some issues with StartSSL, but I don't have the details right now.
- pfg 12y agoThey charge for certificate revocation, which became a bit of an issue during the Heartbleed massacre.
- tomjen3 12y agoIt is only an issue if you actually care about security. If all you want is a checkmark or the ability to show up in browser then that is more than good enough.
- blowski 12y agoTheir customer service is appalling, but you pay for what you get. The original point was that requiring HTTPS would mean free-to-host HTTP services would go out of business as it was impossible to provide free HTTPS certificates, and in that sense, StartSSL proves them wrong.
- yellowapple 12y agoNot if those free-to-host HTTP services are commercial entities; StartSSL's free certificates can't be used commercially per their terms of service. And if StartSSL is the only option, then I'm sticking to HTTP. They're a nightmare to deal with even for non-commercial use, let alone commercial.
- mappu 12y agoIt's a TOS violation to use their free certificates in a commercial project.
- unimpressive 12y ago>Also, if HTTPS became a requirement, then demand would increase for free HTTPS certificates in exchange for, say, advertising. Any plan that puts more advertising on the web is going to get a big fat thumbs down from me.
- cbhl 12y ago> You can only make a website for free if you are OK with your website not having a domain name and running it off your personal laptop with electricity paid for by your roommates/parents. Many online free hosting sites that give you a subdomain are HTTP only because wildcard HTTPS certs are expensive. Many of those services would go away or turn paid-only in an HTTPS-only world. The children of the future have already lost Geocities and dial-in BBSes that we grew up with; how will they manage if their Internet isn't exactly like ours? /s > If your CPU is really so limited then why are you using HTTP at all? Use a custom binary protocol with or without encryption as appropriate. I might not want to write the client for said custom binary protocol. Like it or not, a lot of embedded devices (Arduino, Spark Core) provide libraries for serving JSON over unencrypted HTTP. Restricting yourself to devices that are more powerful (say, Raspberry Pi 2) would require you to use a bigger form factor for the hardware, and/or would cost more.
- MichaelGG 12y agoI highly doubt a company that's running OK today will get shut down by a the $30/month expense equivalent that is a wildcard cert.
- yellowapple 12y agoNo, but prices will go up. Free tiers will be significantly reduced or outright eliminated. Cheap tiers won't be as cheap anymore. A lot of individuals and small businesses will now suddenly be faced with more costs, and while $30/month might seem small to you, that adds up considerably over several years. Not everyone on the internet is a multi-millionare YCombinator alumnus.
- MichaelGG 12y ago... Please. You're talking about the difference of a single paid plan or something. There's no viable product or company out there now where $30 a month is even make anyone blink.
- 12y ago
- mariusz79 12y ago> If your CPU is really so limited then why are you using HTTP at all? Because it does not require user to install any other software and still have access to the device (PLCs and other embedded controllers)?
- dragonwriter 12y ago> You can only make a website for free if you are OK with your website not having a domain name and running it off your personal laptop with electricity paid for by your roommates/parents. Actually, if you are willing to do without your own second-level domain name and just have a third- or fourth-level domain name, there are plenty of services where you can have a free web site (or app) running of over HTTP. E.g., any number of free (or free-within-limited-quota) static site hosting services, or even Google App Engine. Of course, in the Google App Engine case, you also get HTTPS for free (within usage quota), as long as you are willing to have an <app>.appspot.com domain name, so the "create a website for free" isn't really a "with HTTP, but not HTTPS" thing.
- dheera 12y agoSure, although GAE is blocked in China. AWS works, and has a free tier that will get by for a year, but doesn't give you free certificates. Also, for a lot of newbies, installing SSL certificates is a PITA. 0. You realize you need a SSL certificate. You're presented with a dizzying variety of options and already lost. Are you supposed to get Positive SSL, Negative SSL, Essential SSL, Comodo SSL, Start SSL, Wildcard SSL, EV SSL, Rapid SSL, Slow SSL, or EV SSL aux Mille Truffles et Champignons? Most newbies ask, "Why isn't there a simple [click here to get HTTPS certificate] button?" 1. You get your certificates by e-mail, but you still can't install them directly. Your webserver wants a .pem file, so you Google "How do I create a PEM file". The top 10 tutorials tell you to concatenate THREE files: your_domain_name.crt, DigiCertCA.crt, and TrustedRoot.crt in that order. What you received by e-mail was FOUR files: AddTrustExternalCARoot.crt, COMODORSAAddTrustCA.crt, COMODORSADomainValidationSecureServerCA.crt, and your_domain_name.crt. You're lost, no tutorial is helping with what to do with FOUR files instead of THREE, in what order to concatenate them, and StackOverflow bans your question. You're fed up, quit, and use HTTP. (Not me; I'm describing an actual case of observing someone else's frustration trying to set up HTTPS.) The only way HTTPS will gain popularity is if we can get rid of the certificate-issuing economy and make it easy for newcomers. The majority of content creators unfortunately do not understand the basics of security nor can we expect them to have the patience to learn it.
- Hello71 12y ago
- mschuster91 12y ago> AES-NI can decrypt at 3.5 cycles per byte. With modern consumer grade hardware you will not find symmetric streaming crypto to be a serious bottleneck. The "old style" Raspberry Pi and, iirc, also the B2, don't carry crypto accelerators, and these are the first choice for people doing embedded linux prototyping. Same for most other mobile chipsets.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 12y agoThey also don't have gigabit ports.
- mschuster91 12y agoI wouldn't exactly count on this. Chinese "pi alternative boards" already include gigabit ethernet, Android apparently also includes support for wired LAN (but somehow the manufacturer of my tablet went broke before they could sell the adapter cable)...
- yellowapple 12y ago> No you don't. You can get free certificates. The only free certificate authority that actually exists right now that I'm aware of is StartSSL, which I've at least found to be pretty damn horrendous to work with, and which only supports non-commercial uses of certificates, meaning that small businesses are still forced to pay up. And no, Let's Encrypt doesn't count, seeing as it's not operational yet. > For any actual website, there are already a multitude of real costs of which a certificate is just one more. That's one more that can mean the difference between a mom-and-pop shop having a website and said shop not having a website because it's too expensive. Just because plenty of factories dump industrial waste into rivers doesn't mean that I'm not an asshole if I dump a bottle of OxiClean down a storm drain.