8 ms·
Japan to open first hotel entirely operated by robots
- datamatt 12y ago> "No need to tip the staff at this hotel." In Japan it is rude to tip, so this opening sentence is completely invalid.
- josteink 12y agoFor those who doubt this statement or find it odd, I can offer an explanation. First of all, tipping someone implicitly puts them in a servile position and says you're off better than them. Secondly, and this is probably the killer, it says that you don't think they would manage without your help. Which just goes to show that everywhere you go, you learn something new which can be different ;)
- damian2000 12y agoI've tipped taxi drivers in Tokyo before and they're pretty appreciative, so maybe they just got used to foreign tourists tipping them and put up with it.
- staunch 12y agoThere's no truth to the idea that it is considered offensive in anyway.
- josteink 12y agoI don't know. Before I was made aware of this, I tried tipping while in Japan. Several places people were very dismissive about it. Eventually I just stopped, because it seemed like people didn't want tips.
- staunch 12y agoIt's correct to say that in Japan one should not tip. It's not correct to say that it's considered offensive. To seriously offend some Japanese people you'll have to do something crazy like stick your chopsticks straight up in your rice bowl. Then you'll see them really wince ;-)
- 6t6t6 12y agoPeople in Japan know that Americans do tip and they will not be so surprised. Specially if you look like a "gaijin" tourist. Some will even consider it fun to be tipped for first time in their life, others will find it offensive and will think that you are looking down to them. But, in any case, tipping is a faux pas in Japan.
- staunch 12y agoHave you ever actually experienced this or are you repeating the same myth? No one will be offended unless you're some kind of jerk about it. "Do as the Romans do" is always the correct behavior, but in this case the potential for offense is entirely overblown.
- 6t6t6 12y agoI live in Japan and my wife is Japanese. Also, I had this conversation with several Japanese people. I can tell you that most Japanese I know hate the concept of tipping and it makes them uncomfortable. They also hate giving tips. Not because of the money, but because they think that tipping is a way of looking down the other person. Of course, when I say offensive I don't mean that they will curse and hate you forever. But probably some will think: "I already have a salary, I don't need you give me your coins". If there's an scale of socially awkward situations, I guess tipping would be slightly under asking ketchup for your sashimi. But definitely not as bad as going into someone's house with your shoes on.
- kristofferR 12y agoI've never heard about anyone tipping taxi drivers before, seems like a weird thing to do. Is that actually common in the US?
- idiot900 12y agoVery common. In NYC for example there is a social institution that taxi drivers are tipped.
- DominikR 12y agoIn Austria (Europe) this is common too.
- tormeh 12y agoBut not in Germany, though. In norway, tipping is something you only do at restaurants (not in taxis or other places).
- syntheticnature 12y agoInteresting. I had a taxi driver in Hamburg bitch at me for the whole ride that Americans don't tip and why don't they tip? So, that was the one taxi ride in Germany I took and didn't tip. (It was not the first taxi ride in Germany.)
- tormeh 12y agoMaybe there's an east-west divide? My experience is with Berlin.
- syntheticnature 12y agoLooking at a few sites this morning, it sounds like it's typical to round up to the next Euro in Germany, and that tipping more than 10% might be seen as offensive (unless of course you are hoping to get some extra from an American).
- 6t6t6 12y agoAdd that people working as waiters (and Serving Workers in general) do have an actual salary.
- solicode 12y agoIt's good knowledge to have before going to Japan, but encountering a Japanese person who would actually be offended if you were to offer a tip would be quite rare, I think. They're well aware tipping exists in other cultures. And they don't expect you to know the Japanese way of doing things. It could be interesting to see how they react if a Japanese person were to attempt it though. :) Also, you could say a form of tipping does exist in Japan (kokorozuke), though it's quite different than what we usually think of tipping. The biggest differences being: 1. It's sort of a way of saying, "Sorry for the trouble" rather than "rating" their service. 2. You give the "tip" beforehand rather than afterwards. And it's likely you'll have to insist that they take it. You can see this custom in high-end ryokans for example, but even then, it's not required or anything.
- DominikR 12y ago> "First of all, tipping someone implicitly puts them in a servile position and says you're off better than them. Secondly, and this is probably the killer, it says that you don't think they would manage without your help." How do you come to this conclusion? When I tip someone I express my gratitude for the good service to the specific employee of some company that did a great job. I never thought of it as the person receiving a tip is below me or anything like that and I doubt that this is how most people think about it. It might be true that people in Japan feel this way about tipping, but your statement was very general as if it is an observation about the very nature of tipping itself.
- _delirium 12y agoThat was traditionally the view in parts of Europe as well, although nowadays many people will be happy to accept a tip, especially since there are so many foreign tourists willing to offer one. Some people used to perceive it as an implication that you were in need of charity, i.e. that the reason you'd offer a tip to a waiter but not to an architect for rendering good service is that you didn't respect the waiter as a professional in the same sense that you respected the architect. Sometimes it's contextual, e.g. in Greece the traditional norms were that tipping young people working at a restaurant as employees was fine, but tipping an owner-operator of a family-run restaurant could offend them, being taken as an implication that you thought they couldn't manage as an independent businessman, and needed a gift. Instead if you particularly liked their service, the socially acceptable way to show it was to either order more things, or return for another meal later; that way you gave them more money but in the form of more business, rather than an outright gift. (Nowadays this is only really an issue if you're Greek, especially a Greek from the same town, where tips, especially large ones, might be taken as having some kind of odd social implication. If you're a foreigner, tips aren't going to offend anyone, and are perceived basically the way North Americans would expect, as a thank-you for particularly good service.)
- 6d0debc071 12y ago> How do you come to this conclusion? When I tip someone I express my gratitude for the good service to the specific employee of some company that did a great job. Maybe so, but presumably you don't tip your doctor regardless of how well they do their job.
- bitwize 12y agoIt's also unnecessary -- many Japanese establishments include a service fee in the bill. Conventions appear to be changing in some countries: I've seen restaurants and stands in Australia, well-known as a country where tipping is not done, put out tip cups with signs encouraging patrons to tip.
- shawnps 12y agoI haven't seen that (in my 2+ years living here). Recently though I've noticed a lot of stores showing 2 prices, one with tax and one without, but when I first moved here almost every store I went to only showed the price with tax included. I think the recent change is due to the sales tax increase.
- sleepyhead 12y agoIt's pretty much invalid everywhere except the US.
- codemac 12y ago$59 x 365 = $21535 x 1 yr = $1794 x 12 mo I'm excited about the idea of an entire condo building being constructed in a somewhat similar way. I'd love to live in a building where the HOA meetings were people presenting new ways we could live without having to ever wash dishes again.
- tokenizerrr 12y agoYou could get a dishwasher?
- SmellyGeekBoy 12y agoOr a dish washing robot
- shabble 12y agoOr just a robot arm with arbitrary dish-type manipulator to load & unload your dishwasher. Then it can take my usual pile-of-stuff on the countertop, and restack it nice and clean an hour later. Bonus if it can reach into my cupboards :)
- rtpg 12y agoI know this is off-topic, but ascribing a country as the "doer" for this sort of story frustrates me a lot. I'm sure people would be up in arms if "America builds Creationist museum" was a headline, so why should we do this for other places? It's not even hard to rewrite! "First hotel entirely operated by robots to open in Japan"
- jacquesm 12y ago> I'm sure people would be up in arms if "America builds Creationist museum" was a headline Why would they be up in arms, it's a solid fact: http://www.creationevidence.org/ http://www.creationevidence.org/
- rtpg 12y agobecause it's not America as whole who got together to do it, it's a couple people who live in the country who do it. At least that's how I see it. "America rejects Bush, elects Clinton" makes sense because it's talking about something the country as a whole did. But saying "America builds the creationist museum" can be read as "this was built with a non-minimal amount of popular support, is representative of how americans see things as a whole, and should be placed on the index card describing the country and its people"
- jacquesm 12y agoEvery news-item in every newspaper published starts off with 'City,' for national news and 'City, Country' for international news. That's so customary I highly doubt readers would interpret it as the whole country being complicit, it's just a geographic label, not a stand-in for the population.
- logfromblammo 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synecdoche http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synecdoche http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metonymy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metonymy This sort of construct is well-established in English. When the headline reads "America Walks on Moon", the metonymic expansion is understood to be "[at least one person from] America Walks on Moon". In this case, I need no additional context to interpret the headline as the hotel being built somewhere within the geographical region called Japan.
- cstuder 12y agoI would love to see details on how they are cleaning the room with robots. The rooms* don't look too mechanical to me. * = Pictures/renderings on their homepage: http://www.h-n-h.jp/en/ http://www.h-n-h.jp/en/
- damian2000 12y agoThe reception desk robot reaching to get keys is bizarre, surely all door locks would be keyless (access via an app for example) and any other information could be provided digitally.
- _delirium 12y agoYeah, fully staffless check-in/out is already pretty common in Europe, and doesn't require anything as movie-like as robots grabbing keys off a rack. When you book you're given a code, and you use it to retrieve your key or keycard from a vending-machine-like box at the entrance. Then you drop it off when you leave. This is one chain that does that in Finland, and has no staff on premises most of the time (only cleaning staff come in for a few hours in the middle of the day): http://www.omenahotels.com/about-us/ http://www.omenahotels.com/about-us/
- ghaff 12y agoThe aforementioned Yotel in New York also has check-in machine at the entrance. (There's a check-in desk upstairs in the lobby but you don't routinely have to use it.) The business traveler chains in the US are also starting to focus more on check-in kiosks.
- samsaga2 12y agoI don't believe it. It is not yet possible make something as simple as a robot to make your bed or a robot to do the maintenance or the other robots and herself.
- icebraining 12y agoIt is not yet possible make something as simple as a robot to make your bed Sure it is, as long as you don't refuse to consider the idea that you can adapt the bed to the robots.
- Animats 12y agoIt's not all robotic. It's mostly robotic. It will be interesting to see how this works out. Except for handling linens, most hotel jobs could be automated in a hotel designed for that. It's time for someone to build an effective institutional bathroom cleaning robot. Even if you have to design a robot-compatible bathroom.
- kefka 12y agoI always thought that having a self cleaning bathroom would be better. Think something like a car-wash. Combine key activation with motion sensors, and I'd think it would be a great idea.
- _delirium 12y agoThat already exists with public toilets: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanisette https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanisette Not sure if the levels of cleanliness it gets to are up to hotel standards, though; people's standards for a public toilet are much lower.
- hiharryhere 12y agoI think the handling linens issue goes away when you rethink the bed, linens and machinery as a whole. What if the sheets were more of a pillow case style and the bed changed itself. Perhaps some machinery would lift the mattress, and the sheets could be slipped off and back on again by some arms within the bed frame. Those linens could then be dispensed through internal chutes into a laundry room. Someone further up this discussion thread said it really well, they suggested that we should think of the hotel as a complete machine, rather than machines operating inside a hotel.
- universaltest 12y agoI have seen a competition in Japan where the robot can recognize successfully what kind of drink is requested and bring it to guest . I feel optimistic about this concept.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ghshephard 12y agoWe're about 10-15 years (at least) from the point at which room cleaning can be done robotically. It's actually an incredibly complex task, which requires a lot more in terms of executive skills/dexterity that just aren't on the near-term roadmap for robotics or their control systems. Even doing something simple, and highly constrained like changing the linens on the bed, is still 5 years out (at least). Now, what they might have done, is constrain the environment, such that the tasks can all be automated. I.E. designing the bed/linens, restricting what/where things can be left in the room, or alternatively, restricting what types of cleanup work will be done. That would be an interesting approach, but far from the much more challenging task of creating a generalized robotic solution to hotel automation.
- chinathrow 12y agoHave you got any insights to share on your suggested timeframes, e.g. changing linens "still 5 years"? How did you come up with those figures?
- tim333 12y agoYou can guesstimate these things a bit by the Kurzweil type technique of projecting Moore's laws type improvements in computation and comparing them to animal neural systems as in one of his graphs: http://cdn.singularityhub.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/exponential-growth-of-computing-1.jpg http://cdn.singularityhub.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/exp...
- LunaSea 12y agoI would take anything that Kurzweil says with a mountain of salt.
- ghshephard 12y agoMy timeframes are all minimum numbers - I.E. the dates by which I would give you 10 to 1 odds that they won't be beat. I don't have any insight into the maximum time frames - but anybody who spends a lot of time watching the growth curve in robotics would agree that we aren't advancing very quickly in optical/visual feedback dexterity See: http://newsoffice.mit.edu/2014/fingertip-sensor-gives-robot-dexterity-0919 http://newsoffice.mit.edu/2014/fingertip-sensor-gives-robot-... for what is considered to be state of the art. The dates regarding generalized cleaning, come from having done a n analysis of the higher-level thinking that takes place when cleaning a room - its very, very impressive the level of analysis that needs to take place for anything but the most straightforward cleanup job. What's interesting of course, is that anybody can make pretty good predictions as to what dates won't be beat, but it's hard to guess when they will be. Whats awesome to think about, is once we have technology to do things like clean up a room, the vast majority of other robotic tasks, are going to fall very quickly.
- funkyy 12y agoEvery year something operated mainly by robots opens in Japan. After initial news there is no more follow up about it. This sounds more like a marketing trick than real thing.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- uniclaude 12y agoSome love hotels in Tokyo already make sure you do not see a single human face in your stay. Room selection is done on a touch screen, door is opened with a code, and payment is done using a machine. It feels like this hotel is just the next step as (as a few mentioned in this thread) tasks like changing & cleaning sheets are probably still handled by humans, albeit hidden.
- chinathrow 12y ago"The hotel will also have facial recognition, which will allow hotel guests to enter their rooms without a key." Great, I'll be outside taking pictures of guests and trying to impersonate them.
- icebraining 12y agoFacial recognition has moved beyond that some time ago. It know can use 3D recognition (think Kinect-like).
- wingerlang 12y agoHow about 3D printers, they're getting better by the .. years .. it seems
- tshadwell 12y agoThough this might be possible, I've not seen it in practice and I very much doubt that this is what the hotel is planning to do.
- icebraining 12y agoIt's already sold as a commercial solution. As to whether this hotel will use it, I have no idea, for all I know the whole thing is just a PR piece.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- chinathrow 12y agoYeah, as we've seen with how Apple does it? ;)
- taylorling 12y agoSounds interesting, but for me, I think I would still prefer a more 'human' environment for hotel - robots might be highly efficient on some tasks, but they will never able to replace the 'human' part, which I thoroughly enjoy when I travel.
- xamuel 12y agoHumans make great bartenders, great phone support, great teachers. But when I'm in my room, typing away or something, the last thing I want is a stranger coming in to change the towels or whatever. Keep a human in the front lobby, I'll take the robotic maids any day, please.
- taylorling 12y agoThat's true, but that's where you have the door sign says 'DND', at least the hotels that I have stayed so far have this 'feature'.
- xamuel 12y agoSo under what circumstances are the human maids better? If you miss them because you're at the conference, then you don't care whether they're human, robot, or some sort of arsenic-based life-form as long as the room is cleaned. If it's casual smalltalk you want, a hotel maid isn't a very efficient way to deliver that.
- eng_monkey 12y agoWhy not write the news article when the hotel has actually opened? Otherwise it just sounds to vaporware.
- kreddor 12y agoWell, the bagage robot in the picture looks a lot like the one at Yotel in NYC: http://www.yotel.com/Hotels/New-York-City http://www.yotel.com/Hotels/New-York-City It broke last time I visited, but fun to watch when it's operational.
- JohnLen 12y agoThis is great. Wonder if the robots will be as efficient as humans at work.
- shawnps 12y agoFAQ for those who can read Japanese: http://www.h-n-h.jp/faq.pdf http://www.h-n-h.jp/faq.pdf It says if you stay between 2 and 5 nights there is a fee to have your bed made (#43). I wonder if this implies a human will be doing it. I don't see anything on there that mentions robots making the beds. Could just be that the robots do most of the cleaning and humans change the sheets or something.
- kinduff 12y agoMcDonald's should be managed entirely in this way and it's possible with the current technology.
- bhayden 12y agoWhen I'm bored I mentally plan out my on-demand hamburger factory food cart. Seems totally feasible in my head.