6 ms·
Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?
Amazon seems a big consumer of open source technology.
Does it give much cash in support to open source projects?
Does it contribute much in other ways?
- zo1 12y agohttp://www.quora.com/Did-Amazon-ever-open-source-any-of-its-software http://www.quora.com/Did-Amazon-ever-open-source-any-of-its-...
- gaius 12y agohttp://www.quora.com/Does-Amazon-actively-avoid-contributing-to-open-source-software-projects http://www.quora.com/Does-Amazon-actively-avoid-contributing...
- henningschuster 12y agoAmazon doesn't contribute much to the open source community. Most of their contributions happened around the XEN project which they use to power EC2.
- Rapzid 12y agoEven there though, isn't it mostly bug fixes? Has Amazon contributed any major functionality back? They do a ton of custom stuff and I don't really see any of that showing up like you do with say, Google and cgroups.
- cperciva 12y agoIt's really hard to guess at Amazon's code contributions; I don't know what weird corporate anti-pattern causes this, but I've received patches from Amazon in emails which say "here's a bug fix but don't tell anyone that this came from Amazon", and I know other people who have received similar contributions. In a more financial sense, they have been generous in supporting my work on FreeBSD/EC2 -- not with cash, but lots of free EC2 usage for development and testing.
- vertoc 12y agoYeah there's a weird internal thing where Amazon employees are not supposed to publicly contribute to open source projects but I don't know the reasoning behind that...
- dudleydoright 12y agoFormer Amazonian here. When I was employed: To do ANY FOSS work as an individual unrelated to the company (And I mean ANY: private projects that may be on Github, projects with nothing to do with Amazon) required a one-off application for permission. To actually contribute something to some FOSS project that is in use at Amazon (For example, to fix a bug) requires even more special permissions (I think it is once per submission but cannot remember). This is to "protect Amazon IP"; you can imagine why people try and skip the hassle.
- atopuzov 12y agoSame rules apply now.
- LamaOfRuin 12y agoIs this in your contract / some IP agreement you sign? I wonder if they would drop this as fast as they dropped the warehouse employee anti-compete agreement if it was publicized. It would also be interesting to hear from a lawyer with relevant expertise if that is actually enforceable for most employees.
- GeneralMayhem 12y agoIANAL. It's in pretty much every employment contract in the software industry. Washington has code 49.44.140 which makes such terms unenforceable unless: >(a) the invention relates > (i) directly to the business of the employer, or > (ii) to the employer's actual or demonstrably anticipated research or development, >or (b) the invention results from any work performed by the employee for the employer California has section 2870, which is almost identical. The problem is that those terms are vague enough that they can be construed to apply to pretty much any software. The big companies have varied enough business that (a) is hard to get away from, especially if it's Web based and you work for Amazon/Google/Facebook, and software techniques are generalizable that they could probably claim (b) as well. As a result, all of those companies have various internal processes to request that the company either release IP for side projects or allow it to be open sourced with the company as the copyright holder but the employee listed as the author.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- markuman 12y agoAmazon has assume the Linux Kernel developers (~20) from AMD in Dresden/Germany a few Yeats ago and is still hiring Kernel Developers in Germany.
- hackercurious 12y agoRichard Stallman's personal site has lots of information about Amazon. https://stallman.org/amazon.html https://stallman.org/amazon.html
- jeorgun 12y agoYes, but that doesn't really answer the question. His site also has a lot of information on Apple, Google, and Microsoft, but none of it is about their considerable open source contributions.
- mizzao 12y agoApple's considerable open source contributions?
- tzs 12y agoWebKit and clang, for example. For WebKit, they started with a fork of KHTMP, which is under LGPL, and some have tried to say that this means it does not count since they were forced to open source it, but that is not correct. They were only required to open source a subset of it. They could have made the rest closed. Instead, they opened it all.
- raverbashing 12y agoRichard Stallman's website (which is ironic, because he doesn't use a web browser) is full of extremist opinion about lots of things, most of which are irrelevant to this discussion
- _delirium 12y agoStallman does use a web browser, just locally. His workflow is that he works offline, but when he runs across mentions of webpages that he might find useful, he queues them up to be wgetted via a proxy, then later points his browser at them. So it doesn't seem too ironic to me that he might put up web pages that others can retrieve (and indeed he's been doing so since the early days of the web). If he had some kind of crazy AJAXy webapp that can't be viewed offline, that might be inconsistent, but he doesn't. However, I agree that page doesn't much have to do with whether Amazon contributes to free software.
- mgkimsal 12y agoOn the 'liability' angle... Was the legal team really ready to bring lawsuits against any other open source project that was used internally that may have broken or caused a problem (like anything from Apache, for example)? If not, why would they think they'd be sued as well?
- K0nserv 12y agoOne of the things that I am aware of them Open Sourcing are their chef cookbooks used for opsworks(https://github.com/aws/opsworks-cookbooks https://github.com/aws/opsworks-cookbooks). Unfortunately the activity on the repository is a sad read. A lot of issues and PRs created that solve real problems for users of opsworks and in some cases fixes security issues. Most of these sits ignored and unmerged and some, such as one of mine(https://github.com/aws/opsworks-cookbooks/pull/231 https://github.com/aws/opsworks-cookbooks/pull/231), have been rejected elsewhere(on Twitter in this case). There are in fact many PRs dealing with SSLv3 and POODLE besides mine for example https://github.com/aws/opsworks-cookbooks/pull/291 https://github.com/aws/opsworks-cookbooks/pull/291 and https://github.com/aws/opsworks-cookbooks/pull/281 https://github.com/aws/opsworks-cookbooks/pull/281. So while these cookbooks might be open source they are nothing but a read only representation as PRs are very rarely accepted.
- courseeplus 12y agoWe www.courseeplus.com opensource social learning platform which offers Instructor led online courses with certification. Check and signup now
- andrewstuart 12y agoSounds like "not much". Amazon is an open source leech.
- mixologic 12y agoI know that in an effort to provide SDK's for their services, they have also produced some greate high quality supporting Libraries. Guzzle, an http library for PHP came out of their PHP SDK: https://github.com/mtdowling https://github.com/mtdowling is the author, and participates in the php framework interop group on behalf of Guzzle.
- srean 12y agoI have heard both good and bad things about Flipkart, the obvious Amazon competitor in India, but something that makes them quite attractive to me is their healthy open source portfolio https://github.com/Flipkart https://github.com/Flipkart From what I have heard from people working at the place is that it isnt any well thought out strategic decision to attract developers, just something that felt right to them because they use quite a bit of open source stuff. If anyone knows more I will be quite interested to learn.
- thebiglebrewski 12y agoWhen the Echo came out, I created a proxy to add functionality (http://alexaho.me http://alexaho.me). One of those functionalities was a Hue integration, which Amazon integrated natively this week. All of my code was open sourced. I never received any credit or compensation from Amazon for my idea or code, if they happened to look at it and frankly, I wouldn't try to fight them. Who would try to fight a company with such a large legal team? Even a thank you for my idea would've been nice...
- caseysoftware 12y agoThey integrated your code or the idea?
- thebiglebrewski 12y agoHonestly, I have no way of knowing.
- vanessa98 12y agoThey don't. They're classic free riders.
- runT1ME 12y agoThis sounds like a great argument for AGPL.