6 ms·
Police chief: “Paying the Bitcoin ransom was the last resort”
- toxicFork 12y agoI'm not an expert of CryptoLocker but at this point I would just format the computer and assume all data is stolen and gone already, then deal with the consequences and train my employees about computer security a bit more. It's not like someone has a physical thing in their hands and are willing to give it back if the ransom is paid. That is a bad situation as well, of course; but I find this to be worse.
- joopxiv 12y agoThe damage would be a lot worse than $500.
- toxicFork 12y agoSure but do you really expect them to actually decrypt the files and then walk away? If they do I think they would be more honourable than some non-criminals!
- MichaelGG 12y agoUh, yes? Because if they behave well, then word spreads and people know they can trust the ransom. If they kill the hostage each time, then no one pays. It's not like they make more money if they defect. Yeah, they could try to ransom again, but a: the success rate might be lower since right after ransom people are likely to have made a backup and b: word spreads that paying just results in more extortion, leading to less payments.
- toxicFork 12y agoThat's a good point.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoYes, CryptoLocker does actually decrypt your files if you pay the ransom. At first, there was an expiration date; you had 10 days or something like that to pay the ransom, and then your files were gone forever. More recently, it changed so that you can pay a ransom at any time to retrieve your files, but the ransom goes up after the initial 10 day period (or whatever it is now). The developers are savvy business people and CryptoLocker is very well done.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- thaumaturgy 12y agoI think we'll have to agree to disagree. I follow the "respect your enemy" school of thought, and I dislike the kind of us-vs-them hyperbole that passes for political debate these days. It should be clear from my comments that I'm opposed to CryptoLocker. You'd have to assume the worst of me to imagine that I'm encouraging it at all. But it's factually correct to say that CryptoLocker is well-written and well-executed and is making good money, and that's exactly the argument I use to convince people that they need to have backups.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 12y agoPeople writing aggressive malware aren't tipping back and forth based on the language they see in message board comments. Their default state is no shits given. Imagine them having an interview where they say they were going to give it all up, but then they saw that one guy remark that their software was effective at doing what it does, and they were so chuffed that they went on to scam thousands and thousands dollars more out of people. It's preposterous.
- thaumaturgy 12y ago
- kbart 12y agoYou can't simply delete police records, it's not your home computer with cat pics. According to the article, these files were pretty important: "the infected computer contained a significant amount of police data, including its "Computer Aided Dispatch, records management, arrest logs, calls for service, [and] motor vehicle matters"
- rmc 12y agoIn some cases "deal with the consequences" can be very costly. Imagine some record the police need for a court case is part of that data. You've just deleted it. A drug dealer walks free. You've just let a drug dealer go free all for $500. Good luck at your performance review.
- notahacker 12y agoI can imagine a drug dealer's defence lawyer having fun questioning the admissibility of evidence that had been "corrupted by Russian hackers" in front of a non-technical judge and jury though...
- rmc 12y agoThe alternative of "the police have lost the files" means they'd probably certainly walk.
- rodgerd 12y agoI am more disturbed that they don't have access to rolling snapshots and backups that would let them restore and ignore.
- toxicFork 12y agoFrom what I have seen in most countries I have been in, it is very safe to assume that most of the offices (including government or small businesses) do not have very good practices nor training regarding digital content or software security.
- patio11 12y agoYep. This is also true about large companies and software startups. Pick any group of savvy technologists you want, then on the morning of their A round take the CEO's Macbook and throw it into the river. That should be a non-event. It is not.
- toxicFork 12y agoAh yes, the river factor. The sister of the bus factor.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoAnd even people that think they're covered sometimes turn out not to be. "But I have a NAS with two hard drives and all my files are on it. That's my backup." "Yeah, the company that set it up did it wrong. Your files were spread across both drives, instead of copied to each drive. When one of the drives failed, all of your files went with it." "..." True story.
- mnw21cam 12y agoRepeat after me: RAID is not backup.
- thaumaturgy 12y ago
- laurencei 12y agoThis raises so many questions. The 3 major ones that come to my mind are; 1. How is security on a police server so bad it can be infected with malware in the first place 2. It sounds like they didnt have (good enough) backups, where they could just format the server and restore the data 3. Doesnt this mean that all the data on the police server is effectively compromised? i.e. the hackers could have made a copy before encrypting - so it is likely the data is breached?
- fletchowns 12y agoIt's a small town police department. They just don't have the resources to properly address those aspects of IT. I worked IT helpdesk for an affluent city of 70,000, you would be surprised at all the ancient equipment they were still using.
- icebraining 12y agoWhich raises the question: why are they handling their own servers? Can't it be centralized within the county or state?
- fletchowns 12y agoIn theory, maybe. In practice, not even close. The current state of information sharing between different levels of government is really, really bad.
- Spearchucker 12y agoCan't they sell one of their armoured personnel carriers or assault vehicles to pay for modern IT equipment? Decent opsec and backups strike me as more useful than militarizing the police.
- lmm 12y agoNo, they get those on a "loan" from the agency that actually needs them, mainly as a way to shunt maintenance costs onto the police. But they can't sell them because they don't actually own them.
- rikkus 12y ago"The Tewksbury Police Department chief told its local newspaper, the Tewksbury Town Crier that those who infected the computers in early December 2014 were "terrorists."" None of the definitions of terrorism I can find would describe this. Exaction, perhaps? Is there a better term?
- crististm 12y agoThis sounds more like extortion.
- aikah 12y agoDidn't the Obama administration issue an executive order basically saying any hacking on any US government infrastructure is terrorism? Ransomware would be terrorism in that case (not that I agree).
- ppod 12y agoText of the patriot act definition below. As much as I hate the Patriot Act, its terrorism definitions do a pretty good job I think, but B(ii) seems a bit redundant given B(iii). Note that it's A && B, not A || B. ‘‘(5) the term ‘domestic terrorism’ means activities that— ‘‘(A) involve acts dangerous to human life that are a violation of the criminal laws of the United States or of any State; ‘‘(B) appear to be intended— ‘‘(i) to intimidate or coerce a civilian population; ‘‘(ii) to influence the policy of a government by intimidation or coercion; or ‘‘(iii) to affect the conduct of a government by mass destruction, assassination, or kidnapping; and ‘‘(C) occur primarily within the territorial jurisdiction of the United States.’’
- irascible 12y agoExtortionists.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- MichaelGG 12y agoCryptoLocker is amazing. I find the reactions to it so intriguing. Because before, viruses would just delete your data and let you know you were screwed. Game over. Now, they delete your data, but offer a quick time-rewind to undo the damage. $500 seems like a not-so-bad deal, and if the data was deleted instead of encrypted, I would imagine you'd pay more than $500 to send it to a recovery shop. So really, it's just doing a good job of teaching users about data loss, without actually forcing them to lose data, just a bit of money. That seems like an overwhelmingly good bargain, overall. Especially if it gets someone to make backups before they suffer a hardware failure that truly renders the data lost. And terrorists? Wikipedia indicates "Russian hackers". I suppose you can stretch terrorist to cover that but well, that's just being dramatic.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoMalware hasn't gone around deleting data in ... I'm not sure exactly when the last time is I saw anything like that, but it's been a very, very long time. The majority of malware now is a commercial effort, it's just trying to turn you into part of an obnoxious ad network, use your computer to send spam, pick up account information or credit card details that in aggregate are worth a little bit on some particular forums, that sort of thing. Cryptolocker is amazing because the developers didn't screw it up. It runs very quietly in the background. Most people never realize it's there. It comes in multiple pieces, so your AV software might disable the UI portion of Cryptolocker but all your files will still disappear (oldest files first). Each file is encrypted with a different key, and then a master key is used to encrypt all of those keys. It's basically, "the kind of malware tptacek would build if tptacek built malware." It's also been a huge boon for us in convincing people to get backups going finally, because the sort of people that are willing to gamble that their hard drive will never fail aren't also willing to gamble that they'll never click on the wrong thing online. I hate having to scare people into getting backups, but, that's how it is.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dagw 12y ago
- captainmuon 12y agoI wonder if there is a way to come down with the full force of the police & surveillance state on this. I mean it has to be good for something.... For example (and I'm just making this up): If the malware contacts a server, send a rapid response team there. Find out where the data goes next, repeat. If they make it a national security or terrorism issue, they would have the cooperation of many western/interpol states (at least Europe, Australia and Canada). I also can't imagine that its in the interest of the Russians to be a host to this kind of crime, so you might get them to cooperate, too. I realize that this is complicated through the bitcoin protocol (if the malware doesn't communicate back in any other way - although it has to get the key from somewhere). But in an age where the GHCQ can record all trafic in and out of the UK for a day, it shouldn't be beyond their technical reach to monitor all bitcoin transactions passing through their nets in realtime. A transaction from/to a tainted wallet was issued from your PC? Expect a SWAT team in 10 minutes at your door. Of course this would be grossly undemocratic, complete overkill, and create huge collateral damage. But I believe the capabilities for such a crackdown are almost there. And if criminals start targeting infrastructure and law enforcement (and don't just "accidentially" attack them), something like that might happen.
- kwhitefoot 12y agoIt should be illegal to pay.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoWouldn't that just pan out as a tax on payments - or do you propose imprisoning people who don't have backups and want their data back?
- kwhitefoot 12y agoPaying an extortionist only makes it easier for the extortionist to continue. The same with kidnapping. In some countries it is in fact illegal to pay a ransom.
- atYevP 12y agoYev from Backblaze here -> Isn't that crazy? I've written to blog posts about Cryptolocker, and how you can use a backup system to defeat it (just wipe the machine and restore from a backup). The cryptolocker virus is definitely pretty amazing from a virus perspective. It turned the virus world on its head a bit. Still defeated by having a good backup strategy though!