3 ms·
But there is also very little evidence (and quite a bit of counter evidence) that abdicating the investing and planning of these things to pension fund managers
by kasey_junk 12y ago
But there is also very little evidence (and quite a bit of counter evidence) that abdicating the investing and planning of these things to pension fund managers works out.
- tedunangst 12y agoDon't know about that. Leaving investments up to individuals results in a lot of individuals investing exactly $0 towards retirement. By providing an incentive to save, even a 401k that provides negative returns will leave them with a retirement fund greater than zero.
- Spooky23 12y agoIn cases where the investment fund is actually funded, and not raided by the business to meet cash shortfalls in the business or enrich corporate acquirers, things can work out well. For example, the NYS Employee Pension fund is typically 90+% funded during any given year. That's because the law requires (quite onerous) funding contributions that spike when markets underperform, and makes it difficult to take money out. That doesn't mean that NYS is perfect (far from perfect -- a few years ago the sole trustee of the fund was convicted of corruption relating to investments). But it is in a much better position than a state like Illinois, which is only 40-50% funded for future obligations, or New Jersey, where the budget is balanced by "skipping" annual contributions.
- kasey_junk 12y agoAnd If I want to move to a different school system to teach before I'm vested? How do they pay out?