4 ms·
I'd love to see your source about the "average" on 401k plans. I've worked under so many 401k regimes I can't count them any more and have seen some bad ones.
by kasey_junk 12y ago
I'd love to see your source about the "average" on 401k plans. I've worked under so many 401k regimes I can't count them any more and have seen some bad ones. That said, there is normally at least 1 passive fund/etf in the mix even in the worst plans.
Further, 401k plans are easy to change. Make your displeasure with them known to HR (who frequently don't understand that the plan they have put together is bad) or discount the benefit accordingly when evaluating your compensation and invest outside of the plan in the ways you want.
- Spooky23 12y agoI agree and disagree. I'm a reasonably savvy investor, this stuff isn't really an issue for me. But most people aren't, and there is no evidence that they magically become good disciplined investors in the foreseeable future. The point is the employees in general are poor at investing and planning, and the 401k lowers the resistance level and gets people to invest. A poorly structured plan isn't an issue for you and me, but it for many (I would argue the majority) workers.
- kasey_junk 12y agoBut there is also very little evidence (and quite a bit of counter evidence) that abdicating the investing and planning of these things to pension fund managers works out.
- tedunangst 12y agoDon't know about that. Leaving investments up to individuals results in a lot of individuals investing exactly $0 towards retirement. By providing an incentive to save, even a 401k that provides negative returns will leave them with a retirement fund greater than zero.
- Spooky23 12y agoIn cases where the investment fund is actually funded, and not raided by the business to meet cash shortfalls in the business or enrich corporate acquirers, things can work out well. For example, the NYS Employee Pension fund is typically 90+% funded during any given year. That's because the law requires (quite onerous) funding contributions that spike when markets underperform, and makes it difficult to take money out. That doesn't mean that NYS is perfect (far from perfect -- a few years ago the sole trustee of the fund was convicted of corruption relating to investments). But it is in a much better position than a state like Illinois, which is only 40-50% funded for future obligations, or New Jersey, where the budget is balanced by "skipping" annual contributions.
- kasey_junk 12y agoAnd If I want to move to a different school system to teach before I'm vested? How do they pay out?
- happytrails 12y agoTake a look at Paychexonline and let me know when you find a "good" passive ETF that isn't charging above 1.5-2%
- mahyarm 12y agoAt a place I've worked at, the expense ratio was x10 compared to equivalent funds on the market. For example VTI had a 0.05% expense ratio while their S&P500 fund, the lowest expense ratio fund they had, was %0.5. I asked HR multiple times if we could switch from 'great west retirement services' (now empower retirement) to something like schwab, fidelity or vanguard where the expense ratios are far lower. They never changed because it was cheaper for the company to stay on with GWRS than it would be with schwab for example. So these crappy 401k services offer a cheap price to the company so they can make it up + more through their high expense ratio through the employees.
- kasey_junk 12y agoI would never argue that there aren't bad 401k plans. But you are not forced to use them and the market offers alternatives. Those alternatives may be influenced by a lot of other factors such as regulatory environments (the 401k/IRA contribution difference is baffling) or your employers decisions. But you can price that into your benefit evaluation. "You have a bad 401k plan, normally I'd take X in salary compensation, but you need to provide me X+Y". You do this when comparing health benefits right? Why wouldn't you do this for retirement benefits? The op was claiming that he had no choice but to use high fee options, and he later qualified that with regulation based in Sweden which made that largely true. In the US, it is not true, for better or worse it can be inconvenient to use low cost providers, but you aren't forced into it.