6 ms·
It's what has become of capitalism. First there were producers, they sold what they created themselves and made a profit. Then there were merchants who bought a
by bjourne 12y ago
It's what has become of capitalism. First there were producers, they sold what they created themselves and made a profit. Then there were merchants who bought and sold and made a profit on the difference. Then investors who invested in merchants and made a profit by collecting interest on lended money. Nowadays, it's the fourth level of capitalists, the fund owners, who takes peoples money and invest it into investors who then invests it into merchants.
A common scam is to email 10000 people betting picks. To half of them you predict that team A will win and to the other half that instead team B will win. Repeat the process with the ones who got the right picks and after a few iterations you have a small group of gullible people who think you have supernatural sport prediction abilities.
Fund managers do the same thing all the time. They have a portfolio of funds, some of which purely due to chance will not beat their market line and will then be folded into those who did. Then new funds are started to fill the void. This way, almost every fund can appear to beat the market average.
That's just one of the many tricks available to fund managers. Another is choosing the right index to compare your fund against and selecting which time period puts it in the most favorable light. Maybe the performance over the last three years were extra strong or maybe it had a dip so let's compare over the last seven years instead?
The worst thing is that you can't abstain from playing the game. Your retirement money is on the stock market and fund managers will take a big slice of it in fees whether you like it or not.
- slothario 12y agoResearch low-cost index funds. They're better than managed funds and much, much cheaper. In this day and age, the only person who you can trust managing your money is yourself - and turns out, if you're smart about it, it's not hard at all to do well. But that doesn't change the fact that there is a large segment of the population who are not educated or disciplined enough to avoid learning about that, and they have to live their whole lives with the anxiety of mismanaged funds.
- kasey_junk 12y ago> The worst thing is that you can't abstain from playing the game. Your retirement money is on the stock market and fund managers will take a big slice of it in fees whether you like it or not. What are you talking about? There has never been a time where investing was cheaper and there were more options to invest without a fund manager getting a slice. If you want to discount your pension benefit because you don't control the asset allocation (and I think you should, but that is an opinion) that is fine, but it isn't some sort of "rigged game" that you don't have options in.
- Spooky23 12y agoThe average 401k plan is a bag of crap, with lots of high cost, low performing investment options.
- kasey_junk 12y agoI'd love to see your source about the "average" on 401k plans. I've worked under so many 401k regimes I can't count them any more and have seen some bad ones. That said, there is normally at least 1 passive fund/etf in the mix even in the worst plans. Further, 401k plans are easy to change. Make your displeasure with them known to HR (who frequently don't understand that the plan they have put together is bad) or discount the benefit accordingly when evaluating your compensation and invest outside of the plan in the ways you want.
- Spooky23 12y agoI agree and disagree. I'm a reasonably savvy investor, this stuff isn't really an issue for me. But most people aren't, and there is no evidence that they magically become good disciplined investors in the foreseeable future. The point is the employees in general are poor at investing and planning, and the 401k lowers the resistance level and gets people to invest. A poorly structured plan isn't an issue for you and me, but it for many (I would argue the majority) workers.
- kasey_junk 12y agoBut there is also very little evidence (and quite a bit of counter evidence) that abdicating the investing and planning of these things to pension fund managers works out.
- tedunangst 12y agoDon't know about that. Leaving investments up to individuals results in a lot of individuals investing exactly $0 towards retirement. By providing an incentive to save, even a 401k that provides negative returns will leave them with a retirement fund greater than zero.
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>It's what has become of capitalism. How is this a problem with capitalism? The problem is with centrally controlled public sector employee pensions, which has ALWAYS been rife with fraud and corruption as unions and municipal politicians all want a cut of that pie. In a more "ownership society" solution, you take your 401k where you want to. You choose your investments, risk level, etc. Its certainly not perfect (sometimes some groups have high fees but you should be able to switch providers), but the larger issue here is how messed up big city pensions are. In Chicago, the city is going to go bankrupt next month if it can't find huge and new levels of funding/taxation. It has promised so much in pensions it can't remotely pay for via politicking and union corruption, that the taxpayers are shocked at how badly everything has been managed. The larger issue is that the 60's and 70's radical leftist politics have come to roost. We handed unions and public sector workers the keys to the kingdom and now we just can't pay for it as they retire. Its not just fees and its not just Chicago, its going to be a lot of municipalities where pensions are going to do serious damage.
- bjourne 12y agoCapitalism has become incredibly abstract. You make a deposit of €1000 to your retirement account containing €10000 and hopefully, in a few years, due to investments the number will be larger than €11000. But I don't think anyone can trace exactly what happens with the money or what chain of middle men they go through before they come back at you with some profit. Btw, "pension funds" are just an elaborate illusion. What you pay today funds this generation of pensioners. It's not money doing nothing in a bank account. We hope that the working generation coming after us will be nice enough to pay taxes to fund us after we have retired. Surplus tax income used to be used by governments to build infrastructure, schools and housing. Building highways is a form of safe, long-term, high-yield investments. It's almost always profitable but it may take many decades before it becomes so. Nowadays, much less of the surplus is used for that kind of direct investments and we are instead giving it to fund managers and hoping that they will work their magic and give us back more money in the future.
- pdeuchler 12y agoHedge funds are not about returns. They're about hedging risk. Thus, hedge funds. The original purpose of hedge funds was to allow investors to decouple themselves from traditional sources of risk (stock market plunges, housing market crashes, etc. etc.) and diversify their assets in a way that would normalize returns and make things at worst more predictable, and at best stable and predictable. This is also why they enjoy lax regulation, as they often don't invest in traditional methods or securities (or at least they did, things have changed somewhat). Granted, that hasn't been the MO of every hedge fund ever created, but that is the fundamental point of a hedge fund. Framing the debate by saying "they don't even beat index funds and get paid billions" ignores the reality that investing in a way that diversifies risk is an extremely difficult thing to do, and even if a fund loses money it can still technically succeed at it's purpose and have earned it's commission.
- imaginenore 12y agoI'm starting the fifth level: investing in the fund managers.