16 ms·
A man who was accidentally released from prison 88 years early
- hobarrera 12y agoGiven that the man had changed, and actually moved on to have a more civil life, can anybody explain the point of him going back to a correctional facility? What are they trying to correct?
- mastermojo 12y agoWhat was he incarcerated for? Edit: Two counts of first-degree burglary and three counts of aggravated robbery
- RadioAndrea 12y ago"Both men received two counts of first-degree burglary and three counts of aggravated robbery, for each of the three employees they made cooperate at the two stores... Then came the kidnapping charges: three counts of second-degree kidnapping, because they’d forced three employees in those two robberies to move from one part of a store to another." Edit: and edit ninja'd...
- basseq 12y agoI really dislike "stacked" charges. Maybe that's the best way to differentiate between "a burglary", "a burglary where an innocent person was involved", "a burglary where 3 innocent people were involved," and "a burglary where 3 innocent people were involved and made to do stuff beyond 'getting robbed'". But assuming "equal" charges, is involving three people 3x as bad as involving one? Is "forcing people to move" 2x as bad as just robbing them?
- gootdude 12y ago"... Two clerks were in the store, not just one. Lima-Marin and Clifton brought them both into a back room, forcing one onto the floor and the other to open the safe. “They put a gun to the back of my head and said, ‘This is where you’re going to die,’” one of the employees, Shane Ashurst, later recalled." https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/04/07/unfreed https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/04/07/unfreed A bit more than simply asking them to move to another room.
- basseq 12y agoThe "mov[ing] from one part of a store to another" was how the article characterized the kidnapping charge. I would imagine that forcing someone to the floor and threatening them with a gun would be part of the aggravated assault charge. Otherwise, what's the difference?
- mschuster91 12y agoTalk about cruel punishments, locking up someone for two fucking robberies without any deaths for nearly a century is unreasonable, cruel and defies everything our civilization stands for. But hey, private prison operators need to make money and police/DA/any part of the justice system profits from being "tough on crime"... Thank God I'm German, even if you end up killing someone you'll at most get 15 years (okay, there are some exceptions, but they're literally exceptions, not like US where exceptions tend to become standards).
- _dark_matter_ 12y agoIt's very similar to the drug problem. As soon as we label these people criminals, we just don't care what happens to them. Because they are now not people, the DA has no problem throwing every single possible crime against them. This means they are not prosecuted for much more than what they did. "Going easy" on criminals is not a good way to retain a position in government in the US, so we do the opposite. It is interesting to note that the judge made good comments about how unjust this seemed, but was unable to do anything about it. That says a lot about our judicial system.
- nashashmi 12y ago> As soon as we label these people criminals, we just don't care what happens to them. Probably because felons don't have the right to vote. So no politician or anyone else cares much.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt's highly variable: http://blogs.findlaw.com/blotter/2014/08/do-convicted-felons-have-voting-rights.html http://blogs.findlaw.com/blotter/2014/08/do-convicted-felons... In most states, voting rights are restored upon completion of the sentence. In Maine and Vermont, prisoners have the right to vote. Florida, Iowa, Kentucky and Virginia make the loss of the vote permanent.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Raphmedia 12y agoThis article was a very good read. If you are in America, you should try and contact that governor his family is lobbying. I would, but I'm not living in this country.
- kstenerud 12y ago> “Plainly said,” Orman wrote in his reply, “the Defendant had no business getting married and starting a family.” Wow. Just wow...
- S4M 12y agoI came here to say just that. I can't believe someone who is supposed to represent justice can dehumanize someone to this point. It's a very sad thing to read.
- bobowzki 12y agoReading this made me feel sick...
- qiqing 12y agoThe U.S. incarcerates more people than China. Not per capita, mind you. More total people. If ever there's a stellar example of the kind of disaster that can result from privatizing a government function, this is it. Private prisons have a strong profit motive to increase the number of people behind bars until we have the kind of situation we have today in the U.S. These are folks who can afford to pay lobbyists to create the kind of sentencing that leads to 98 years for 2 robberies, and criminalize non-violent or victimless 'crimes.' Here's a Last Week Tonight segment on the broken prison system in the U.S.: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Pz3syET3DY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Pz3syET3DY
- merpnderp 12y agoI don't know that you can directly compare the two judicial systems. Especially when China executes roughly 61 times as many prisoners - often for petty crimes from repeat offenders. That being said the US puts far too many people in jail, often for far too long of sentences.
- Zikes 12y agoI think that's sort of the idea behind the comparison. Even a country with a bar so low for punishment is far outpaced by our own judicial system.
- kpil 12y agoStill, I think there is something fundamentally flawed with a society where 40-50 % of all men have been arrested by the police by age 23. I tried to find some comparable statistics and I found that 5-10 % of all 15-20 year old males in Sweden have been -suspected- for a crime. I doubt that all of them were actually arrested.
- qiqing 12y agoAlso, prison contractors get more taxpayer dollars for lengthy sentences, whereas the state handles executions (that is, there's no profit in executions for the prison-industrial complex).
- mikeash 12y ago
- waterfowl 12y agoThe insanity of the charges/sentencing reminds me of a passage from The Hot House(which is excellent, Pete Earley somehow got permission to go mingle with prisoners at USP Leavenworth for a year and write about it). A Bank Robber, 45 'They originally charged me with murder, kidnapping, and bank robbery, but I'm really just a bank robber with really bad luck. You see, my buddy and me were robbing this bank, and when we come outside there is a cop waiting across the street and he starts shooting. He shoots my buddy, but I don't know he's dead so I pull him into the car and drive away. When they bust me, they charge me with murder, kidnapping, and the robbery. I ask my attorney, "How the hell can they do that? All I did was rob a bank" He says the law says if you are committing a felony and someone dies, a bank teller has a heart attack or something, you can be charged with murder. He tells me they charged me with murder because my buddy got killed. He says the law says when I pulled my buddy into the car and drove off, I kidnapped him because I was taking a body from the scene of a crime. That's how they got me for kidnapping. He says the law says that I can be charged with all three even though I didn't kill nobody and I didn't kidnap nobody. I say the law sucks.'
- zerocrates 12y agoThe felony murder rule is somewhat controversial but nevertheless nearly universal in the United States.
- beamatronic 12y agoDoes it always override the Good Samaritan law? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Samaritan_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Samaritan_law "Good Samaritan laws offer legal protection to people who give reasonable assistance to those who are injured, ill, in peril, or otherwise incapacitated." Does the law allow you to act as a Good Samaritan in the course of committing a felony?
- ctdonath 12y agoIt might protect you from breaking the heart attack victim's ribs while delivering CPR, but it won't protect you from inducing a heart attack in the bank teller you tried to feloniously rob.
- downandout 12y agoThe worst part of this, IMO, is how the mistake was discovered. His former prosecutor was looking up his old cases on the state DOC's website, apparently to delight in the damage he had caused decades earlier. You would have to be a pretty depraved person to derive pleasure from unjustly taking away someone's life.
- joncp 12y agoI thought that too until the article implied later that they were looking for other clerical errors as a result of a really bad mixup.
- downandout 12y agoThe state was auditing some cases, but according to the article his didn't come up for an audit. This was just the DA reflecting on his handiwork.
- venomsnake 12y ago> and he shall have Power to grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offenses against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment. And why is he not rubberstamping such when the prison situation in US is cruel, sadly not unusual and definitely unjust.
- nknighthb 12y agoThe offenses were not against the United States. This man is in a Colorado prison for crimes under Colorado law. The President has no authority in this case.
- venomsnake 12y agoThere are enough federal inmates with good reasons for pardon. And mass pardons of federal prison could hint the governors about their power too.
- nknighthb 12y ago1) The governors have powers that vary from zilch to equal to the President's. This is determined state-by-state. 2) You are mistaken if you believe all or even a substantial minority of the governors would ever agree with your views in this matter.
- jessaustin 12y agoThe Colorado governor may pardon any Colorado conviction other than those for treason or impeachment. The entire point of this thread is that the governors are culpable for the injustice of the system. Their opinions don't absolve them of that.
- nknighthb 12y agoThe comment I responded to said "And mass pardons of federal prison could hint the governors about their power too.". This suggests two mistaken beliefs: 1) That governors as a whole have these powers. 2) That "hints about their power" would prompt them to act in the manner he wishes. The governors don't need hints about their power in this area, they are well aware of it. They don't fail to exercise it as he wants them to because they need a "hint", they fail to exercise it as he wants them to because they do not agree with him. I'm not addressing the thread as a whole. I'm addressing this little corner of it. I'm under no obligation to address the thread as a whole in every comment I make, and doing so would be both pointless and tiring.
- woodchuck64 12y agoSign the Petition: https://www.change.org/p/john-w-suthers-release-rene-lima-marin https://www.change.org/p/john-w-suthers-release-rene-lima-ma...
- barking 12y agoI would like to see clemency for this man but I don't view the european system as being necessarily superior to the USA. In my country there are a lot of avowedly unrepentant murderers walking the streets after 'life' sentences that in some cases lasted less than a decade. The state has decided to show compassion. It's easy to forgive someone when you're not the victim or one of those who loved a victim. Personally I feel that if you premeditatedly take another person's life you should have no expectation of ever being able to live outside a prison again.
- DangerousPie 12y agoIf this was really an issue, shouldn't the murder rates in European countries be a lot higher than in the US? According to Wikipedia [0] the "intentional homicide" rate in the US is 4.7, in the UK 1.0 and in Germany 0.8. Shouldn't those numbers be reversed if the European system was releasing "avowedly unrepentant murderers" back onto the streets? [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentiona...
- barking 12y agoI don't think that follows. You might as well infer that the european rate is lower because we release murderers. The statistics you quote don't support either view, I believe.
- jessaustin 12y agoEuropean nations should be compared to European nations. American nations should be compared to American nations. Actually just a glance at your wikipedia page makes this clear: different continents simply have different murder rates. I feel this phenomenon is rooted in historical colonization.
- unreal37 12y agoThere was an element of "pre-crime" to the original sentences. Not just this case, but the article alludes to an entire program to sentence young people who have multiple brushes with the law to life long periods. Taking young teenagers off the streets for the rest of their lives purely on the basis that they are likely to continue committing crimes if they were released again and not for actual crimes committed. The COP program was done away with, but someone should revisit those horrific sentences given to teens that effectively take their entire lives away. Guilty, yes. But 90+ years for a case where no one got hurt? Wow.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jpgvm 12y agoHeh, I found the most ironic part to be where he talks about the simplicity of prison life. Everything is paid for and he simply studies. Makes you start to think about what the proportionality of these sentences actually work out in the eyes of the victim of the crime. In some way the victim wants them awarded the biggest punishment possible, but at the same time that punishment comes out of their pocket in taxes that go to keep this person behind bars for an unreasonable amount of time. I don't know what the numbers are but that sounds awfully expensive to me and if I was an employee at a video store that got robbed I really don't think I would like all that additional burden on the economy as retribution for a few minutes of fear.
- erobbins 12y agoThis is nothing more or less than cruel and unusual punishment.
- vorg 12y agoIt's difficult to read stories about U.S. non-concurrent sentences, third strike system, plea bargaining replacing jury trials, and 1% lockup rate for adults, then listen to their people talk about "Freedom in America" and keep a straight face.