5 ms·
"This is a fork of TextSecure that aims to keep the SMS encryption that TextSecure removed for a variety of reasons." Reason for the fork: https://whispersyste
by sschueller 12y ago
"This is a fork of TextSecure that aims to keep the SMS encryption that TextSecure removed for a variety of reasons."
Reason for the fork: https://whispersystems.org/blog/goodbye-encrypted-sms/ https://whispersystems.org/blog/goodbye-encrypted-sms/
- AlyssaRowan 12y agoThe underlying reasons are actually pretty sensible. Signal (as it will be) can't deliver encryption via SMS on iOS due to platform restrictions. Neither can tablets or computers normally send SMS messages. (To say nothing of metadata risks, although TextSecure cannot address that without a decoupling layer, like Tor, and in any case low-latency low-bandwidth mixnet messaging is very hard versus nation-state adversaries with traffic correlation abilities.) It's also clear that voice and video can't be delivered well or at all by SMS/MMS, and that MMS in particular is a huge pain in the arse. However, users who have limited/no data plans are up in arms. Whole bunch of 1-star reviews. Clearly quite a few vocal users (not necessarily users in regions you might expect) liked this feature, used it, seemingly needed it. I know that sometimes when travelling even I'm out of data service, but within SMS service. So it may be that a fork does make semantic sense here. Signal will eventually deliver cross-platform best-in-class secure messaging, group messaging, voice/video/etc - features which cannot be delivered by SMS - and SMSSecure could deliver encrypted SMS messages for users on the Android platform (only).
- hobarrera 12y ago> Neither can tablets or computers normally send SMS messages TextSecure is android-only, so I fail to see how this is an issue. Also, (please, correct me if I'm wrong), they also require that you have an SMS-capable line to use it, so I fail to see how that limitation would matter.
- psykovsky 12y agoIf they intend to be a messaging app then they should stop trying to be the default SMS application. They're just another messaging app.
- rand334 12y agoI've read almost all of the comments here and I'm so confused... So I'm not going to be able to text my non-TextSecure friends with it anymore? And, if my data connection drops right before I message a TextSecure user, will it get sent plaintext over SMS then?
- psykovsky 12y agoI guess not, at least if you want to keep your SMS's encrypted and use SMSSecure.
- AlyssaRowan 12y agoAgreed there: if Signal won't do SMS, they shouldn't be catching SMS intents, or they might get invoked when, for example, there's no data. (Of course, there's scope for disagreement here. SMS and particularly MMS are horrible, but sometimes horrible is all you've got.)
- sarciszewski 12y agoMaybe someone should suggest this to the team? They probably did that from the get go, but now no longer need to.
- detaro 12y agoThey said on Github that they are keeping it for a while, so that users still can receive encrypted SMS from users that haven't updated yet.
- sarciszewski 12y agoOkay, cool. Sounds like they're doing the right thing.
- thatcat 12y agoif your friend updates and you don't, the encryption still fails though
- wtbob 12y ago> in any case low-latency low-bandwidth mixnet messaging is very hard versus nation-state adversaries with traffic correlation abilities Indeed, The Pynchon Gate[1] paper indicates that intersection attacks can break any mixnet, to include high-latency mixnet. The authors' solution is high-latency, high-bandwidth private information retrieval. Sadly, I can't see a way to make this work efficiently with mobile devices. [1] http://freehaven.net/anonbib/cache/sassaman:wpes2005.pdf http://freehaven.net/anonbib/cache/sassaman:wpes2005.pdf