9 ms·
Peter Thiel on the Future of Innovation
- davidw 12y agoI'm reading Thiel's book right now, and have some mixed opinions on portions of it, but it's certainly an interesting read, and makes you think.
- yla92 12y agoAgree with that. I find it opinionated but I gotta say I like it. I find some of the ideas (such as his lecture from YC startup class 'Competitions is for losers') from the books are a bit hard to accept and makes me thing for a while.
- lukasm 12y agoIn the book he says "We Live Under A Power Law" I absolutely agree, people have hard time grokking exponential growth. In the last chapter, he says that AI is overrated and it's 22nd century threat. He underestimates Power Law.
- david927 12y agoHe does that a lot. Universities are irrelevant, unless you went to Stanford (his school), in which case you are awesome. It's clear that he wants to think critically but he's somehow not able to bring himself to his own conclusions.
- motters 12y agoAs far as I can tell from his Wikipedia bio, Thiel hasn't done anything significantly innovative since PayPal. It looks like he supplied money for some other things, but that's about it.
- return0 12y agoHe's the philosopher of silicon valley, philosophers dont do, they think.
- levlandau 12y agohttps://www.palantir.com/ https://www.palantir.com/ | http://graphics.wsj.com/billion-dollar-club/?co=Palantir http://graphics.wsj.com/billion-dollar-club/?co=Palantir
- yummyfajitas 12y agoHe also runs a hedge fund: https://www.clarium.com/ https://www.clarium.com/
- sgt101 12y agoThe comment about Nuclear Engineering is odd - I have a friend who is earning ~$1400 a day as a consultant disposing nuclear waste, he has work for his lifetime more or less guaranteed and tells me that the industry has a huge need for more qualified folk to help clear things up.
- restalis 12y ago"earning ~$1400 a day as a consultant disposing nuclear waste" "work for his lifetime more or less guaranteed" I don't want to sound sarcastic, but what kind of life span expectancy is implied in this kind of job?
- sgt101 12y agoWell he's the fella sitting in the office, so I don't think he's too concerned!
- nqureshi 12y agoThis is an incredibly smart observation, and not made often enough: "Often the smarter people are more prone to trendy, fashionable thinking because they can pick up on things, they can pick up on cues more easily, and so they’re even more trapped by it than people of average ability"
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rpedroso 12y agoLast published elo was 2199 [1]. In comparison, Magnus Carlsen is currently at 2863 [2]. [1] http://en.chessbase.com/post/busine-insider-24-executives-who-are-exceptional-at-che http://en.chessbase.com/post/busine-insider-24-executives-wh... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_FIDE_chess_world_number_ones http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_FIDE_chess_world_number...
- bantunes 12y agoI don't get it - why do people still listen to him (honest question)? Is it the money? Didn't he just luck out with Paypal? He clearly is all about the $$$, even advocates that you should actively pursue building a monopoly, since "competition is for losers" (his words). What gives? Because for me, he's part of the Valley problem.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- return0 12y agoTo me, the fact that he gets strongly polarized reviews means he 's interesting. Give me more like him.
- rayiner 12y agoMonopolies are great. Almost everything awesome in computing came from companies insulated in some way from market forces, either because of outright monopolies, network effects, first mover advantages, etc. Bell Labs and the ATT monopoly. Xerox PARC, which gave us the GUI, OOP, email, LAN, was bankrolled by the Xerox copier patent monopoly. Google continues to use its network effect advantage and above-perfect competition profits to bankroll stuff like self-driving cars. Perfect competition is the current PC industry. Lenovo and Acer and HP. Nobody innovates because they can't take any risks with their frighteningly narrow profit margins.
- tew28 12y agoHis point about monopolies is widely misquoted and causing a lot of confusion. I think he should have been clearer about distinguishing creative monopolies and what we commonly consider monopolies, in the negative sense. There are nefarious monopolies like Comcast that are insulated from competition because of an unfair advantage. A more nuanced position should entail something like the following: - We want competition because it allows nefarious monopolies (and other companies) to be overtaken by better companies. - We don't want to discourage companies from attempting to obtain monopolies in their markets, since this gives them to opportunity to capture monopoly profits. Monopoly profits are not inherently bad. If a company becomes a monopoly, we want them to be a creative monopoly. - A competitive market in the sense of having low profit margins is very different from a competitive market in the sense of whether or not new entrants can come in and compete. - It is a bad thing if a company has monopoly power through something other than being a superior company, is capable of preventing new entrants, and is uncreative. We want to preserve the ability of new entrants to come into the market with superior products and overtake monopolies. (edit: formatting)
- grondilu 12y agoThiel seems to hope and expect technological progress to improve people's lives, and this seems to be the main drive for his interest in technology. But isn't it possible to be interested in technology for the sake of it, for the "wow" factor only? I mean, for instance he's very much into medicine, including anti-ageing medicine. And it seems that the slow pace of progress in this area, when compared to progress in IT, frustrates him. Me, I don't care much about medicine. Maybe it's because I'm relatively healthy, but I believe it's also because most people are healthy, so if suddenly everybody was, it would only be a quantitative change, not a qualitative one. A healthy human body is not something new. So, staying young and healthy until you reach say 100? Meh. If the goal is to improve life, there are other ways to do that rather than waiting for technological miracles. Money, for one. I mean, the life of a wealthy person nowadays is, I suppose, absolutely awesome, and it does not require very advanced tech to be so.
- LunaSea 12y agoJust don't forget that Peter Thiel is a co-founder of Palantir which is equivalent to a private-NSA that is currently funded at $1B.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoFor the record Palantir doesn't do any data collection or analysis on other people's data - which is what the NSA does (collection and analysis). Palantir simply makes overpriced software for groups to do complex network mapping and connection extraction from raw data - other companies then do analysis with on their own data sets with the software.
- LunaSea 12y agoThese groups being essentially the military and the alphabet soup agencies.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoTrue, however Palantir started with finance/wall street.
- mseebach 12y agoI heard the podcast a few days ago, but I struggled with understanding the point on globalisation "pulling back" and CA and TX being "inward-looking" vs. DC and NYC being centres of globalisation. What do Cowen and Thiel mean by this distinction? What does it mean to be "inward-looking" in this context, and how will it manifest itself in an edge over outward-looking/"leveraged to globalisation" places?
- dataker 12y agoThe shortest criticism is that globalisation doesn't spur scientific innovation, as it'd be just copying what works. Inward tech development would take 0->1 while outward would be taking 1 and spread across the world.
- santiagobasulto 12y agoI'm surprised by the amount of hate towards Peter Thiel. I consider him one of the bests. I think his class on How To Start a Startup was the best one, with really thoughtful insights. It's obvious he's going to be focused on the money, he's an investor.
- normloman 12y agoSurprised? The guy once said "Since 1920, the vast increase in welfare beneficiaries and the extension of the franchise to women—two constituencies that are notoriously tough for libertarians—have rendered the notion of 'capitalist democracy' into an oxymoron," The guy implies the world would be better off if women couldn't vote, and you're surprised people hate him?
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoWell, I for one read his statement as plain evidence that what we need to jettison is not democracy, but instead, of course, capitalism. I realize this is nowhere near his intended reading of his own statement, but if the shoe fits, wear it!
- happyscrappy 12y agoBeing opposed to capitalism is like being opposed to evolution, hell even the Communists are not crazy enough forgo capital markets.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agosigh http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalist_realism#Mark_Fisher http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalist_realism#Mark_Fisher A few simple questions: * If capitalism is as inevitable and natural as evolution, why did it take until the late 18th century and require the Enclosure and Poor Laws to appear? * If capitalism is good, such that even Communists need to ape it, why does it result in massive deflationary panics which leave entire nation-sized regions stripped of their wealth and utterly impoverished? * If capitalism is useful, why does it only seem to be working for manufactured-goods exporters and bankers? Why have growth rates dropped since the Bretton-Woods system and social democracy were abolished? Why has productivity growth been so terribly low despite the computer revolution? In short: if capitalism is so great, why all the problems we see in actually-existing capitalist countries?
- restalis 12y agoThiel views the area of self-driving cars as less regulated (next to biotech), but for some reason I think that to make it come true the challenge will be more than technical. The current state of affairs in the legal system is that there always has to be someone that may take the blame when something goes wrong. Verdicts ending in "accidents" are not accepted lightly, especially when human-made things are involved. The entire thing regarding the self-driving cars has something like a ticking bomb under it waiting to explode in terms of regulations!